C
Chiral
Guest
Quick logical recap here (entering late, sorry), can I restate the argument thus?
X is true. X is an event which takes place at T2, namely S picks a daisy (note, S does not have to be a person).
T1 is before (temporally) T2.
Truth is eternal, there for if X is true at T2, then X is also true at T1.
If this is the argument, then isn’t the question why X is true, in the causal sense as pointed out in the previous posts? In order for S to be a “free” individual, all that is required is that the alternative “not-X” also be presented to S at T2, and the argument doesn’t ask that…
Perhaps if we change the event to X = S chooses to pick a daisy, but that implies a choice regardless of its “logical” necessity, thus necessity does not necessarily omit choice. So my question becomes, is S the cause of X’s truth? And if so, could S have been the cause of not-X’s truth, say in an alternate timeline like T2(a)? Note, T2(a) does not have to be real, only logically possible, meaning “not-X” existed, which it did since all events X have their logical antithesis not-X (part of the law of bivalence you mentioned).
For every X that is true there exists (logically, not necessarily in reality) not-X which is false.
In a temporal situation, X’s truth, while existing from all eternity, is not actualized until T2, and it is only then (T2) that the alternative, not-X, is actualized as false. Therefore, prior to T2, the truth of X vs not-X was not established in temporal reality.
Now, to bring in God, the outside observer to whom T2 and all points after and before (including T1) are actualized, X is true, but it is only true because all events at T2 are actualized - this is why it is so important to understand God’s nature with regard to time. Now if to God T2 is actualized, then to S also is T2 actualized for S is the actor in the event X. The distinction between S and God is that, barring supernatural revelation, for S only the events leading up to and at TZ are actualized, where TZ represents what we here in time call the “present”.
To summarize, God knows that X is true at T2 because at T2 S also knows it is true for S chose X rather than not-X. Clear as mud?
X is true. X is an event which takes place at T2, namely S picks a daisy (note, S does not have to be a person).
T1 is before (temporally) T2.
Truth is eternal, there for if X is true at T2, then X is also true at T1.
If this is the argument, then isn’t the question why X is true, in the causal sense as pointed out in the previous posts? In order for S to be a “free” individual, all that is required is that the alternative “not-X” also be presented to S at T2, and the argument doesn’t ask that…
Perhaps if we change the event to X = S chooses to pick a daisy, but that implies a choice regardless of its “logical” necessity, thus necessity does not necessarily omit choice. So my question becomes, is S the cause of X’s truth? And if so, could S have been the cause of not-X’s truth, say in an alternate timeline like T2(a)? Note, T2(a) does not have to be real, only logically possible, meaning “not-X” existed, which it did since all events X have their logical antithesis not-X (part of the law of bivalence you mentioned).
For every X that is true there exists (logically, not necessarily in reality) not-X which is false.
In a temporal situation, X’s truth, while existing from all eternity, is not actualized until T2, and it is only then (T2) that the alternative, not-X, is actualized as false. Therefore, prior to T2, the truth of X vs not-X was not established in temporal reality.
Now, to bring in God, the outside observer to whom T2 and all points after and before (including T1) are actualized, X is true, but it is only true because all events at T2 are actualized - this is why it is so important to understand God’s nature with regard to time. Now if to God T2 is actualized, then to S also is T2 actualized for S is the actor in the event X. The distinction between S and God is that, barring supernatural revelation, for S only the events leading up to and at TZ are actualized, where TZ represents what we here in time call the “present”.
To summarize, God knows that X is true at T2 because at T2 S also knows it is true for S chose X rather than not-X. Clear as mud?