Haven’t quite read everything in this thread yet but here’s my two cents’ worth: much of the prejudice of the Roman Catholic Church against Freemasonry is foolish. particularly with regards to American and British Freemasonry. It is an astounding case of vindictive behavior some 200+ years ago being perpetuated for no apparent good reason except to keep an insititution from looking foolish.
John J. Robinson wrote two books on this subject, the first before he became a Freemason, the second just prior to his decision to join. He does as good a job as any in refuting the ‘Masonic Conspiracy’ notions which get tossed about by Protestants and (apparently) some Roman Catholics. I have begun to despair that citing books does any particular good: folks seem disinclined to read anything which might actually make them reflect upon the opinions they have always held. Nevertheless, I commend to anyone interested the books entitled “Born In Blood” and “A Pilgrim’s Path”, each by Robinson. Richard P. Thorne published another called “The Boy Who Cried Wolf”. I would also point out that by entering the word ‘Freemasonry’ into most search engines, one will uncover a goodly number of Masonic sites which will answer most of the anti-Masonic charges one picks up along the way. “Freemasonry 101” is one example; “Anti-Masonry: Points of View” is another. Finally: “Duncans’ Masonic Ritual and Monitor”
Some brief responses: One ordinarily “earns” the first three degrees of whatis called the “Blue Lodge” by memorization of three short catechisms. One is not obliged to join any other Masonic appendant organizations. Many do: the most popular choices are the York Rite, the Scottish Rite, and the Shriners. (At one time, it was obligatory to be a member of either the York or Scottish Rite to join the Shrine: this has not been the case for some years now, due to the sharp decline of all four Masonic organizations). One will acquire ALL of the ‘appendant’ degrees of any appendant organization one joins in one day, with no memorization required.
If one joins the Scottish Rite, one will attend an initiation as a Mater Mason (3rd Degree), and in about six hours, one will emerge a 32nd Degree Scottish Rite Mason. If one opts to join the Shrine at the same time, this will take an addtional hour or so. ALL DEGREES ABOVE THE 3RD DEGREE ARE HONORARY. One is no less a Freemason if one never joins an appendant organization. One is no more a Freemason if one joins five or six of them.