Gun violence - lest we forget

  • Thread starter Thread starter YourNameHere
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Nothing about the inner city culture. Nothing about the inner city gangs.
While the title is about “Gun violence”, the OP is about the terrorizing mass killings that are enabled by the ready availability of weapons suitable for carrying out such actions.

Proposals that would mitigate that access have been discussed.
Those proposals are not geared to gang violence that prevails in certain neighborhoods of some cities. I suspect if a thread on that appeared, people may make proposals on ways to deal with that problem. Likewise, if a thread on automobile safety were started, people might make proposals on that.

I am not sure why anyone sees it as a problem that the proposals advanced on this thread do not address gang violence, or, of that matter automobile safety.
 
I am not sure why anyone sees it as a problem that the proposals advanced on this thread do not address gang violence, or, of that matter automobile safety.
Palm, meet forehead.

This was supposed to be a general thread on gun violence. One in which all facets of gun violence should be open to discussion. Including the gang violence you so blithely dismiss.
 
Last edited:
This was supposed to be a general thread on gun violence
Was it? Here is the OP:
Events:
58 killed - October 1, 2017
- In Las Vegas, 64-year-old Stephen Paddock of Mesquite, Nevada, sprays gunfire on a crowd of 22,000 concertgoers from the 32nd floor of the Mandalay Bay Resort and Casino, killing 58 people and injuring almost 700. Witnesses say the gunshots last between 10 and 15 minutes. Officers breach Paddock’s hotel room to find him dead. Authorities believe Paddock killed himself and that he acted alone.

49 killed - June 12, 2016 - Omar Saddiqui Mateen, 29, opens fire inside Pulse, a gay nightclub, in Orlando. At least 49 people are killed and more than 50 are injured. Police shoot and kill Mateen during an operation to free hostages officials say he was holding at the club.

32 killed - April 16, 2007 - Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, Virginia. A gunman, 23-year-old student Seung-Hui Cho, goes on a shooting spree killing 32 people in two locations and wounding an undetermined number of others on campus. The shooter dies by suicide.

27 killed - December 14, 2012 - Sandy Hook Elementary School - Newtown, Connecticut. Adam Lanza, 20, guns down 20 children, ages six and seven, and six adults, school staff and faculty, before turning the gun on himself. Investigating police later find Nancy Lanza, Adam’s mother, dead from a gunshot wound.

25 and an unborn child killed - November 5, 2017 - A gunman opens fire on a small church in Sutherland Springs, Texas, killing 25 people and an unborn child and wounding 20 others. The shooter, identified by two law enforcement sources as Devin Patrick Kelley, is found dead after a brief chase, but it’s unclear if it was self-inflicted.

22 killed - August 3, 2019 - In El Paso, Texas 22 people are killed after a mass shooting at a Walmart store in a case that’s being treated as domestic terrorism. Police say they found an anti-immigrant document espousing white nationalist and racist views, which they believe was written by the suspect, 21-year-old Patrick Crusius. He may face hate crime charges in addition to capital murder charges.
 
It’s disingenuous to have a general title “Gun violence” and limit the discussion to mass shootings when there is considerably more gun violence out there than is seen in mass shootings. Why do you insist on limiting the discussion to mass shootings?
 
Last edited:
Mostly what I have seen here are attempts to criminalize the law abiders. Yes, criminalize.
No, they are attempts to establish laws that, if they are not obeyed, make one a criminal. That is always the case with new laws. It used to be legal hold slaves. Then those law abiders who held slaves were criminalized by making slavery illegal. But it only criminalized the behavior if they continued to do it after it became illegal.
Very very little about the War On Drugs. Very little about mental illness. Very little about how we help or don’t help the mentally ill.
Now you are getting back into whataboutism territory.

But let’s address one of those issues right now - mental health.

The fact is the mentally ill are more likely to be victims of gun violence than the general public, and they are less likely to be perpetrators than the general public. So claiming that the gun violence problem can be solved by confining or otherwise restricting the mentally ill is faulty at best and a deliberate distraction at worst.
Of course the pro gun control folks in this thread will deny that is the ultimate aim. But then again who could have imagined gay marriage 25 years ago?
“This thing is like that thing” cliche.
Further, there is an inordinate focus on rifles when they are actually a small percentage of overall gun homicides. Why is that?
I don’t think the focus is on rifles in general. It is only on high-powered semi-automatic rifles. And not because they cause deaths than handguns, but because they would be easier to restrict, politically. But you are right in saying the real problem is hand guns. It’s a harder job, but it might be worth doing.
 
Guns are not going to be banned imo.
You know this how?
The fact is the mentally ill are more likely to be victims of gun violence than the general public, and they are less likely to be perpetrators than the general public. So claiming that the gun violence problem can be solved by confining or otherwise restricting the mentally ill is faulty at best and a deliberate distraction at worst.
It’s disingenuous to say don’t do anything about the mentally ill. We’ve had many shooters who were being treated with psychoactive drugs that the makers warned had possible violent behavior effects in a small percentage of men under 25. That the possibility of violent conduct, while small, was definitely not zero. Hence those who get administered these drugs need to get them in a controlled environment which doesn’t exist now. The Aurora movie theater shooter, for instance. But nobody wants to discuss that, least of all you.

We’ve had existing laws about placing dangerous persons on a list. But those laws weren’t enforced for some shooters. The Texas shooter had a domestic violence conviction that should have resulted in his name being placed on a do-not-sell-to list. Why didn’t that happen?

Then we have existing laws about using guns as part of a crime. But the prosecutors are almost always dropping those charges in plea deals so there is effectively no punishment. Does no good to talk about “use a gun, go to prison” laws if the prosecutors aren’t going to use them very much.

In other words, we have a lot of existing laws that could be fully enforced. Right now. Today. But no, all we hear are is that existing laws will never be enough.

Take these background check laws for instance. Is someone going to go into the gang infested neighborhoods and enforce the laws there? Are prosecutors who don’t use the “use a gun, go to prison” laws against gangs suddenly going to use background check laws against them? If I’m not seeing efforts to enforce the laws where they actually matter, then I can only take this as an attack on the law abiders.
 
40.png
CradleRC58:
Guns are not going to be banned imo.
You know this how?
“imo” means “in my opinion”. Therefore it was not statement of firm knowledge, but a statement of opinion, which everyone is entitled to have. (as in “The Twins will win their next baseball game, imo”)
The fact is the mentally ill are more likely to be victims of gun violence than the general public, and they are less likely to be perpetrators than the general public. So claiming that the gun violence problem can be solved by confining or otherwise restricting the mentally ill is faulty at best and a deliberate distraction at worst.
It’s disingenuous to say don’t do anything about the mentally ill.
Except that I didn’t say that. What I was warning about was using the mentally ill as a scapegoat and subjecting them to even more social ostracization than they already endure. They need treatment. They don’t need to be treated like they are potential terrorists.
We’ve had many shooters who were being treated with psychoactive drugs that the makers warned had possible violent behavior effects in a small percentage of men under 25. That the possibility of violent conduct, while small, was definitely not zero. Hence those who get administered these drugs need to get them in a controlled environment which doesn’t exist now.
The question is not how many shooters were undergoing mental health treatment. The question is how many of those who are undergoing mental health treatment turn into shooters. As I said, statistics show that the mentally ill (in general) are less likely to commit gun violence than the general public. A few very specific kinds of mental illness are the exception, and we do take steps to prevent them from committing violence. But there are real problems with civil liberties to confine or otherwise restrict a mentally ill person without a very good reason.
We’ve had existing laws about placing dangerous persons on a list. But those laws weren’t enforced for some shooters. The Texas shooter had a domestic violence conviction that should have resulted in his name being placed on a do-not-sell-to list. Why didn’t that happen?
Are you sure he was convicted of domestic violence? I could find no record of it.

It’s always easy to say after the fact that someone should have been on a list. It is much harder to say ahead of time. (as in “The Twins won today! I knew they would!”)
Take these background check laws for instance. Is someone going to go into the gang infested neighborhoods and enforce the laws there?
Whataboutism.
 
Last edited:
Except that I didn’t say that. What I was warning about was using the mentally ill as a scapegoat and subjecting them to even more social ostracization than they already endure. They need treatment. They don’t need to be treated like they are potential terrorists.
I agree they need treatment. But a good part of that opinion results from the great number of them among the homeless population.
The question is how many of those who are undergoing mental health treatment turn into shooters. As I said, statistics show that the mentally ill (in general) are less likely to commit gun violence than the general public.
A bit disingenuous to make the case across the entire spectrum of mental health treatment when the specific focus of finding and counteracting potential shooters needs to be on young male recipients of certain psychoactive drugs about which the manufacturers have already warned have a small, but not zero, chance of turning violent. For every one who turns into a mass shooter, there are numerous cases of violence on a smaller scale. Hence requiring these particular recipients to be more closely monitored than they are now. But that’s not a discussion the drug makers are willing to have because then they would have to entertain discussions of liability as are happening with the opioids. So we’re not going to have that discussion thanks to crony capitalism. I’m in favor of targeting certain recipients of specific drugs based on manufacturers’ warnings as long as due process is honored. But we aren’t willing to discuss confinement either.
Are you sure he was convicted of domestic violence? I could find no record of it.
It was through the military court of justice. But the law required notification to civil authorities which didn’t happen. So that shooter slipped through the cracks because of a law that was already on the books, but not enforced.
Whataboutism
There you go once again, dismissing the inner cities.
 
But when too many people do what you say to “be better prepared”, I and others will be exposed to worse chances because of a world super-saturated with guns.
you can find data on both sides of this argument. i believe more guns make you safer. you can believe the opposite.
didn’t say that. I can see allowing AR-15s for those farmers and ranchers who need one to manage their farm.
but do the gun banners? did they the last time or will the Chicago argument win? the AR gun control in abc doesn’t work because AR’s are available in xyz
Background checks can reduce every single one of the sources listed.
no, they can’t

how do you regulate an illegal sale?

how do you stop a perp from taking a family members gun? family members that give criminals guns now are committing a crime.
 
Addressing the question of how background checks would affect illegal sales: When a criminal is caught using a gun in the commission of a crime, we find out where he got the gun. Trace it back to the one who owned it legally. That person bears the responsibility of selling the gun without a background check. With such a policy in effect, fewer legal gun owners will be willing to make that first sale into the criminal world.

As for AR-15s on the farm, I would propose that such uses be allowed, but only along with registration of that AR-15, so that if it does find its way into St. Louis and is used in a shooting, that farmer will be held responsible for letting his AR-15 out of his control.
 
Addressing the question of how background checks would affect illegal sales: When a criminal is caught using a gun in the commission of a crime, we find out where he got the gun. Trace it back to the one who owned it legally. That person bears the responsibility of selling the gun without a background check. With such a policy in effect, fewer legal gun owners will be willing to make that first sale into the criminal world.
if it is this easy why isn’t it done now? it is illegal to sell to a felon now. the person who sold it is guilty of a crime now.

the black market will fill the void. AR’s are easy to make in a garage.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
Addressing the question of how background checks would affect illegal sales: When a criminal is caught using a gun in the commission of a crime, we find out where he got the gun. Trace it back to the one who owned it legally. That person bears the responsibility of selling the gun without a background check. With such a policy in effect, fewer legal gun owners will be willing to make that first sale into the criminal world.
if it is this easy why isn’t it done now? it is illegal to sell to a felon now.
Not quite. Laws vary from state to state. But most states that prohibit sales to felons say “May not knowingly transfer a firearm to someone who has committed a state or federal felony”. The word “knowingly” is important, because it relieves the seller of any obligation of checking whether the buyer is a felon. Of course that is what a background check would do. But when background checks are not required for any private sales, all the seller has to do is be ignorant and he is within the law.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
Not quite.
Not true.
Most people know when their ‘friend’ is a repeat offender with a rap sheet longer than your arm.
That does not prevent someone from selling a gun to someone who is not their “friend”. People sell things all the time to others that are not their friends. It is quite common. And even if someone did “suspect” that the buyer was a felon, all he needs to do is claim he didn’t know. Unless the prosecutor can prove he did know, they have no case against him.
 
As for AR-15s on the farm, I would propose that such uses be allowed, but only along with registration of that AR-15, so that if it does find its way into St. Louis and is used in a shooting, that farmer will be held responsible for letting his AR-15 out of his control.
If I can own a 30.06 semi-automatic, why not a semiautomatic AR-15? And why should I be responsible if my gun is stolen and I don’t know it?
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
As for AR-15s on the farm, I would propose that such uses be allowed, but only along with registration of that AR-15, so that if it does find its way into St. Louis and is used in a shooting, that farmer will be held responsible for letting his AR-15 out of his control.
If I can own a 30.06 semi-automatic, why not a semiautomatic AR-15?
Being a rancher in southern Missouri I would think you could own both.
And why should I be responsible if my gun is stolen and I don’t know it?
Why shouldn’t you? There are already laws about the proper securing of guns. This is similar. If you leave any gun unsecured and a child gets a hold of it and shoots himself, in most states you will be held responsible for not securing your weapon. Why should securing against criminals be any different? Of course if you report it right away, that is a different story.
 
Addressing the question of how background checks would affect illegal sales: When a criminal is caught using a gun in the commission of a crime, we find out where he got the gun. Trace it back to the one who owned it legally. That person bears the responsibility of selling the gun without a background check. With such a policy in effect, fewer legal gun owners will be willing to make that first sale into the criminal world.
It needs to be done.

On May 27, 1999 Wayne LaPierre, executive vice president of the National Rifle Association (NRA), testified before the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime, saying: “We think it is reasonable to provide mandatory, instant criminal background checks for every sale at every gun show. No loopholes anywhere for anyone.”


That was 20 years ago. It’s baffling why lawmakers are not on top of this. By not addressing the issue, they are in fact enablers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top