Have you been born again?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mmmcounts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is going to come in 4 chunks. I can’t believe I wrote this much, but we’re looking at well over 20,000 characters. Definitely a new high for me.
How am I to know which of the information included in this document is reliable?
Well, for starters you can easily verify much of the useful information that he draws out of Scripture. You can check the references and look at an online interlinear Bible to check up on the Greek stuff. Or use some other resource to check up on the parallel passages cited in the document.
Whom should I trust? Which of these individuals can tell me the right way to be saved?
The right way to be saved is found in the Bible. You should not place that kind of trust in men- even studly men of God who have done a lot for Christianity. If in anything they have “rightly divided the Word of Truth,” you can call that what it is. No person is infallible though; only the Bible is, because it is of God.
So, am I born again? Can anyone, anywhere, ever challenge the personal assertion of one who claims to have been born again?
When I said “I can’t tell you one way or the other, you tell me,” I meant it. I don’t know you. If I did, I could make a better evaluation. You’d still be in a better position to say one way or the other, though. If you’re at all familiar with the Bible, you should be acquainted with the ways to know that you have eternal life. It’d be a little trickier for me to know (in the same way as you) that you have eternal life. The best I could do, without assistance, is make a probabilistic assumption. Or I could just ask and make sure you know what you’re talking about. If you do, I trust you. If you really have no clue where to start in terms of knowing (for yourself) that you have eternal life, I’d call it a toss-up. If you can’t tell me one way or the other, I’m certainly in no better position than you to decide that. I can only tell you how to know.
According to my Baptist friends the Catholic Church teaches false, man-made doctrines and is thus a perversion of true Christianity. They claim that nobody who’s truly born again would voluntarily convert to the Catholic Church, and by having done so, I’ve proven that I was never saved to begin with. Would you agree with them?
In general, no. They sound like mean people. Sorry that happened to you.
That’s interesting… I thought the Bible was supposed to be easily understood by anyone with the ability to read. Why should you need to explain this passage by making recourse to Greek? Did the translators of every single English-language version of the Bible mess up the translation here?
The knowledge of salvation is readily understood by regular unchurched lay people just by reading the Bible. It takes a little more work to understand all the nitpicky details that theologians go super in-depth about, but the important thing is that someone can read the Bible and understand how to be saved. As far as salvation goes, it’s not that hard.

This, however, is an issue of clarification when it comes to some of those nitpicky details. As far as John 3:5 goes, questions have been raised about a sacramental issue that is not actually mentioned in the conversation between Jesus and Nicodemus. Read on, though, and you see a plain-as-day description of how to be born again. (All the way at the end, though). Hopefully, we can knock both of these out.

Oh, and it’s good to remember that the Bible is the infallible Word of God, but if you’re wondering which English translation is infallible, it’s none of them. I sometimes joke that the ESV is the “extra special version” because it’s the divinely inspired translation, but I don’t really mean it. That’s why you go back to the ancient languages, analyze to your heart’s content, and remain blissfully unworried about stepping on the toes of a particular translation.

John 3:5- Jesus answered, `Verily, verily, I say to thee, If any one may not be born of water, and the Spirit, he is not able to enter into the reign of God.’ (literal trans.) Let’s work through some of this resource.

Born (and the uses of gevvaw). Stresses that birth is passive, both in actuality and in nearly all the grammatical uses of the word in John (including this verse). The birth spoken of is due to the agency of God, specifically the Holy Spirit. There is no specific reference to “total inability,” but it is hinted at.

Water ([h]udor)- Talks about its role in purification in the Old Testament, including for newborns. Also used figuratively in reference to renewal (Jer 2:13, 17:13) and to physical restoration (Ez 47:9; Zech 14:8). Elsewhere in John, the word’s used 21 times, both literally and metaphorically. Excluding this verse, 7 of them are metaphorical. In this case, it appears to be a descriptor of the “Spirit birth” referencing its cleansing quality.

Spirit (pneuma)- The Holy Spirit that produces eternal life. Consistent with how John usually uses the word.

Water and the Spirit coordination- should we take this as 2 separate births or 1 united idea? Either way, there’s multiple ways of looking at it. The words are used together a few times in the Old Testament, and the examples in Isaiah and Ezekiel are the ones Nicodemus would have been most familiar with. Isaiah 44:3-5 and Ezekiel 37:1-14 are examined (note that in Ezekiel, “wind” is another translation of “pneuma”). When you examine the context of Jesus’ words, consider the audience, and consider the way this is rooted in fulfilling Old Testament covenant theology, you see that it is most probable that “water and spirit” refers to a united concept of renewal and rebirth. But do you read “water baptism” into this? That is the question, and that is where people will differ even after agreeing to this point.
 
Oh, for more OT context, also see Ezekiel 36:25-27 (another OT reference mentioning both Water and Spirit that Nicodemus was familiar with). Does this condone baptism by sprinkling? Or does it mention water in a more metaphorical sense that refers to cleansing of sins, just as the reception of a new heart is metaphorical? I think it’s the latter. You probably do, too. All of this is intended to show how the mere mention of the word “water” need not indicate an actual baptism (and when Jesus speaks the word in the book of John, it never does. More on that later). My specific focus on Ezekiel 36:25-27 is my way of getting you to identify the metaphorical use of water in its cleansing sense when you see it. If you took that one literally, you’d have a decent argument for sprinkling. That’s probably not what you’re looking for.

Finally (as promised), we look at the other times Jesus uses the word “udor” (water) in the book of John (that is, the times the word comes from Jesus’ lips). There are just 3 in total. There is the one in 3:5, then later in 4:7-15 and in 7:38-39. If you don’t look up the last two references, please do not respond to this post. Also demonstrate in your post that you read them in a meaningful way that goes beyond saying “I read them.” In John 4, we see that spiritual rebirth via Jesus also involves living water- a fresh, bubbling spring within you. This is found in the chapter immediately following the one in question and certainly has relevance to what Jesus meant when he referred to water.
I think the last one is especially important for understanding the connection between water and the Spirit when Jesus happens to talk about the two together. Here, a parenthetical note from John clarifies the fact that when Jesus was talking about “living water,” he was speaking of the Spirit that would later be received by those who believed in Him. The thing to take away from that is the fact that living water is equated with the reception of the Holy Spirit from Jesus (they are the same thing), and earlier in John’s gospel Jesus tells Nicodemus he must be born of “water and the spirit.” Do you see the connection?

We find that the other two times Jesus uses the word “udor” in John, he is talking about “living water” and how it relates to inner renewal. On the other hand, whenever he’s talking about baptism, he uses the word “baptizw.” Is he referring to a literal water baptism in John 3:5? Well, he doesn’t use any form of “baptizw,” so apparently not. He’s describing new birth in Christ (birth “from above,” that is), specifies that it is the Spirit that does this, and mentions “water” (just once in the 5 parallel structures) because it relates to cleansing, purification, and the living water that he later equates with the Spirit. If he had meant to refer to baptism, he would have done so.

Ok, on to the literary context.

First, we examine the parallel expressions. There are 5 in the first few verses of John 3. In summary, one of them includes the word “water,” but all of them include the words “born” and “Spirit.” By looking at the repetition, we can see where the force of Jesus’ message is going. He’s talking about the same thing every single time, and I’m convinced that the inclusion of “water” refers neither to baptism nor to a separate event or process. It refers to purification and calls the mind to the concept of “living water.” Furthermore, Jesus tells Nicodemus very clearly how he can be “born of the Spirit” (or born from above, or born of water and the Spirit- it’s all the same thing). You know this chapter- Protestants have been quoting it at you for centuries. Nicodemus asks how this can be, and Jesus tells him how. Are you ready to start reading Jesus’ answer? You can skip the part where Jesus chastises Nicodemus for not knowing what he should have known, if you like. Start in verse 13 and go from there.

Next, we examine three possible interpretations of “avwthev” (pronounced anothen with a long emphasized o), referring to birth. (I wish Greek letters were possible on this forum…or if they are, that I could figure out how to include them). Oh, btw- we are now looking at the phrase usually translated “born again” in John 3:3.

Basically, “avwthev” is usually translated as “again,” but this is probably not the best translation. It’s probably best rendered as “from above,” and that’s the way it appears in every literal translation I’ve seen. These are the three perspectives mentioned.

One: This one is a “double meaning” compromise argument; it basically combines the latter two but still translates it as “again.” It kind of misses the force of Jesus’ teaching, though. (This is one example of something I wish was outlined better in this source).
Two: Another birth in a temporal sense. This one is handled badly by our friend named Robert McCabe. The argument would probably look like this: At the beginning of life, you are born physically. Then later in life, you need a different kind of birth. So you get born again. It’s stated pretty badly in this article.
Three: Instead of translating it as “born again,” we should translate it as “born from above” and emphasize its description as being “born of the Spirit,” which is the Holy Spirit, from God, given by Jesus who came from above, died, and went back to being “above” again. (While I do agree with this for a number of reasons, the way the opposing viewpoints were handled was pretty bad).
 
If we look at the other places in John where “avwthev” is used, it is always translated as “from above” in every single translation, and if you translated it as “again,” it would make no sense. These are the references. 3:31, 8:23, 19:11. The force of Jesus’ teaching is such that our birth of the Spirit is of God and is from above, and translating it as such is both consistent with the rest of John and more theologically clear.

To whoever was looking for a definition of what “born again” is defined as, there it is.

I initially included a bunch of stuff about Ek/Kai structures, water-Spirit vs. water-and-Spirit, and the way you translate anarthrous nouns, which is very handy to know when talking to a Jehovah’s Witness. But I cut it out. We need to move along. Read up on it if you want. If you don’t know any Greek, you probably won’t care anyway.

Next topic:

I think Matthew 3:11 is one that the Catholics had better hope not too many Protestants come across.

It says “He [Jesus] shall baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire.” Put this verse next to
John 3:5- “If any one may not be born of water and the Spirit, he is not able to enter into the reign of God.”
Catholics will say “That cuh-learly refers to baptism; how are you missing this?” Well, may I direct your attention to Matthew 3:11, which, unlike John 3:5, actually uses the word baptism. Do you really believe all true believers must be burned by fire in order to be saved? I doubt it.

This is the entire verse: “I baptize you with water for repentance. But after me will come one who is more powerful than I, whose sandals I am not fit to carry. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire.”

This one’s frequently used to argue that baptism of water is one baptism and baptism of the Spirit is another baptism. I don’t want to do that with John 3:5. “Water and the Spirit” represents one unified thing. (I initially included lots of extraneous info about the Ek/Kai syntactical structure stuff and how the two are linked and have common agency…read the source for more detailed stuff). It is the same thing as being born from above, no different at all. What I will use from Matthew 3:11, though, is the contrast between water baptism that gets you wet and Jesus’ baptism with the Holy Spirit. Mark this well: If you ever intend to read any form of the word “baptize” into John 3:5, it must be Jesus’ baptism from above with the Holy Spirit (also “of water/with fire,” referring to how it cleanses and purifies), not a water baptism like you’d get from John or Jesus’ disciples. This one, not that one, and not both. Got it?

Jesus’ baptism with the Holy Spirit that John could never give is the one that Jesus is describing to Nicodemus. He is not in any way describing water baptism. If you’d like to add “baptism with the Holy Spirit” to our equivalent terms, including “born from above,” “born of water and the Spirit,” and “born of the Spirit,” you may. But you may not include “born of the Spirit with water baptism as a requirement in order for the Holy Spirit to come.” That one is prohibited.

As far as that business with the fire goes, see if you can work your mind around Mat 3:11 without hurting yourself, and if you are successful, you should be able to get through John 3:5 without getting wet.

In case that wasn’t clear enough, you should compare the parallel structure of Mat 3:11 and John 3:5 (the Ek and Kai business, check the source) and understand that when Jesus saves you from your sins and you receive the Holy Spirit, the water that is talked about in John relates to the Spirit in the same way that fire does in Mat 3:11. In fact, both of these elements are there for the same purpose: to describe a quality of the work of the Holy Spirit, specifically that having to do with purification.

Finally, we come to a survey of 6 interpretations. It really is a survey in that sense, it doesn’t go much beneath the surface, and only 3 (or maybe 2 and a half) of the views surveyed are relevant to anyone on this thread. But there are some worthwhile points to be found there:

One is that the Spirit is described in verse 8: It comes and goes where it pleases, you hear it but you don’t know where it comes from or where it goes. So it is with everyone born of the Spirit. Does any description of water baptism fit with this? Nope.

The “amniotic fluid” perspective is number 3 on the list, and we saw that one mentioned on this thread already. The view supported by this author is the last one, and the author obviously finds no problems with it. I always have a little bit of a problem with that- he could at least deal with potential objections to it. But he doesn’t even recognize them. Each of these perspectives certainly deserves far more analysis than they are given, and while they are nice summaries and good reference points, they probably don’t include the exact perspective that any of us will specifically assent to. The first one comes closest to the average Catholic perspective, but I don’t think it matches up well at all with what you guys are really trying to get across. On the other hand, the purpose of this was not to present any kind of Catholic perspective at all. Catholic theology is a total non-issue in this article. Despite that, it gets you familiar with the issue, and the article as a whole raises some great points and makes some worthwhile comparisons among various passages of Scripture.
 
I really shouldn’t leave this before I formally answer the “how” question, though. How is a person “born of water and the Spirit”, “born of the Spirit”, and “born from above”, all of these referring to the same exact thing? (You may also include baptism “with the Holy Spirit and with fire,” even though it’s from Matthew instead of John). Nicodemus asks this question, and Jesus answers. Nice of him, huh?

How can this be?" Nicodemus asked.

See that guy there? Yes, right above this line. Right up there. That’s Nicodemus asking for more details, just like you. Jesus gives them. Are you paying attention Chrisb? theMutant? Nicolep? First, he chews Nicodemus out a little for being a teacher but not understanding the covenant theology that is spoken of in the Scripture he teaches about. Then Jesus explains some of the details about how His crucifixion is rooted in the Old Testament that Nicodemus is so familiar with.

13 No one has ever gone into heaven except the one who came from heaven—the Son of Man. 14 Just as Moses lifted up the snake in the desert, so the Son of Man must be lifted up, 15 that everyone who believes in him may have eternal life.

And the answer to your question is included there as well: How does a person go about being born from above (commonly translated “born again”)? By believing in Jesus, crucified for you. That is how Jesus describes the process. He goes on, though.

16 For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life. 17 For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through him. 18 Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe stands condemned already because he has not believed in the name of God’s one and only Son.

Really now, did you really think you could camp out in John 3 and successfully assert that there’s no possible way to understand how to be born again? It’s got some of the most-quoted Protestant favorites of all time in there. What do you take me for? You think I’m not going to go there? Don’t forget the fact that no form of the word “baptizw” appears in this entire conversation, and when Jesus explains to Nicodemus the way to be born again, he does not mention baptism a single time. The process of being born again- the how-to, if you will- is as follows: Believe in Jesus, and instead of perishing have eternal life. He doesn’t explain exactly what it means to “believe in Jesus,” but that’s a topic for an entirely different thread. (Do you understand that? Different thread. Pay attention. Don’t be an idiot).

So Jesus’ answer to the “how-to” question, stated quite plainly not once but twice, is to “believe in Jesus” and inherit eternal life. Believing in Jesus does not entail being baptized (in the most obvious sense of the sacrament), though it should happen relatively soon thereafter- it kind of depends on the person’s exact situation and timing, and it’s also not really optional. Nevertheless, it should be clear enough that water baptism is the time when you talk about (or, in more spiritual terms, confess to) how you have already received Jesus’ baptism of the Holy Spirit with fire (and of water) when you believed, not that it is about to happen. Is that clear enough?

Oh, ps- babies aren’t capable of receiving the baptism Matthew talks about in chapter 3- "He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire.” This is the same Spirit baptism talked about in John 3. The “how-to” of this kind of “baptism” (though the word is not used in John 3) is explained with pretty good clarity, too- I almost want to assign the word “perspicuity” to it. The only kinds of people unable to grasp how this can happen in their own lives are those who are told to refuse instruction from the Bible, those who are blinded or hindered by Satan or something else (those first two kinds of people are not mutually exclusive), and newborn babies, because they can’t understand much of anything. If a person is baptized as an infant and they are never “born from above” by receiving that Jesus-type baptism with the Holy Spirit, what good does the sacrament do them? It symbolizes nothing and does nothing. (That might have potential for a new thread). If a person is baptized as an infant and then later in life receives the Holy Spirit baptism while being born from above like Jesus is talking about in John 3, they should probably get baptized (the sacrament) again but I’m not willing to say that with 100% certainty- my general advice would be to avoid giving that sacrament to infants, mostly to dodge this uncertainty later in life.

That’s all I have for you today. I’m out.

Oh, and here’s that link again.

dbts.edu/journals/1999/McCabe.pdf
 
I took an Apologetics class a few years back, given by a Dominican Friar, Fr. Hayes. He was a brilliant, thoughtful and interesting defender of the faith. He told us not to be afraid of the semi-confrontational question, “Are you saved?” or “Born again?” He said that the concept is rooted in Sacred Scripture & that when asked, you must remember that it is with kind benevolence, concern for your salvation, that gives birth to the question. The answer is that salvation is an ongoing process, especially since we all were born with the stain of original sin. The proper answer for a Catholic, according to Fr. Hayes, is “Yes, of course. I was saved. I am being saved & I will be saved in the future. I accept Jesus as my personal Lord and Savior on my tongue, down my throat, into my entire being, every time I go to mass and receive the Eucharist. So, yes, I am always reborn when I am in His presence.” If the sheer length of the answer doesn’t quiet them, mulling it over in their head will, for at least a while. 🙂
 
Quote me one Early Church Father that did not recognize John 3:5 as referring to water baptism. This was one of the only doctrines that was unanimously agreed upon by all of the fathers. Baptism is a regeneration (see Titus 3:5) whereby our sins are forgiven (see Acts 2:38) and we are made a new creation in Christ. As Christians we are born again in baptism and we believed this for 2000 years. There was no sinners prayer or altar calls in the early century Church. Sorry but there is only one faith and one baptism (see Ephesians 4) for all, not 30,000 different denominations of Christians all disputing the commands of Christ…teachccd
 
I love this website. They have such good biblical support for Catholicism. I have copied and pasted about being Born Again in Water Baptism. I will post what they say on infant baptism in another post so that this one doesn’t get too long.

scripturecatholic.com/baptism.html

Scripture

I. Born Again in Water Baptism
John 1:32 - when Jesus was baptized, He was baptized in the water and the Spirit, which descended upon Him in the form of a dove. The Holy Spirit and water are required for baptism. Also, Jesus’ baptism was not the Christian baptism He later instituted. Jesus’ baptism was instead a royal anointing of the Son of David (Jesus) conferred by a Levite (John the Baptist) to reveal Christ to Israel, as it was foreshadowed in 1 Kings 1:39 when the Son of David (Solomon) was anointed by the Levitical priest Zadok. See John 1:31; cf. Matt. 3:16; Mark 1:9; Luke 3:21.

John 3:3,5 - Jesus says, “Truly, truly, unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God.” When Jesus said “water and the Spirit,” He was referring to baptism (which requires the use of water, and the work of the Spirit).

John 3:22 - after teaching on baptism, John says Jesus and the disciples did what? They went into Judea where the disciples baptized. Jesus’ teaching about being reborn by water and the Spirit is in the context of baptism.

John 4:1 - here is another reference to baptism which naturally flows from Jesus’ baptismal teaching in John 3:3-5.

Acts 8:36 – the eunuch recognizes the necessity of water for his baptism. Water and baptism are never separated in the Scriptures.

Acts 10:47 - Peter says “can anyone forbid water for baptizing these people…?” The Bible always links water and baptism.

Acts 22:16 – Ananias tells Saul, “arise and be baptized, and wash away your sins.” The “washing away” refers to water baptism.

Titus 3:5-6 – Paul writes about the “washing of regeneration,” which is “poured out on us” in reference to water baptism. “Washing” (loutron) generally refers to a ritual washing with water.

Heb. 10:22 – the author is also writing about water baptism in this verse. “Having our hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience and our bodies washed with pure water.” Our bodies are washed with pure water in water baptism.

2 Kings 5:14 - Naaman dipped himself seven times in the Jordan, and his flesh was restored like that of a child. This foreshadows the regenerative function of baptism, by water and the Holy Spirit.

Isaiah 44:3 - the Lord pours out His water and His Spirit. Water and the Spirit are linked to baptism. The Bible never separates them.

Ezek. 36:25-27 - the Lord promises He will sprinkle us with water to cleanse us from sin and give us a new heart and spirit. Paul refers to this verse in Heb. 10:22. The teaching of Ezekiel foreshadows the salvific nature of Christian baptism instituted by Jesus and taught in John 3:5, Titus 3:5, 1 Peter 3:21 and Acts 22:16.
 
Instead of copying it all, I have coppied the contents of the article here so that if you are interested in a certain area, you can go and check yourself.

scripturecatholic.com/baptism.html

SACRAMENT OF BAPTISM

(The Section with scriptural support)
Scripture

Born Again in Water Baptism
Baptism is Salvific, Not Just Symbolic
Infant Baptism
Pouring and Sprinkling versus Immersion
Original Sin

(The section with quotes from the Early Church Fathers)
Tradition / Church Fathers

“Born Again” Means Water Baptism
Infant Baptism
Original Sin
 
Yes. I was born again in the Sacrament of Baptism. At 2 weeks of age.
 
I. Born Again in Water Baptism
John 1:32 - when Jesus was baptized, He was baptized in the water and the Spirit, which descended upon Him in the form of a dove. The Holy Spirit and water are required for baptism.

Also, Jesus’ baptism was not the Christian baptism He later instituted. Jesus’ baptism was instead a royal anointing of the Son of David (Jesus) .

Jesus’s Baptism not the Christian one ? Then which/who’s Baptism was ? All the Apostles had received water baptism by John. Did Christ [or they] teach they needed receive a second water baptism to augment/supercede John’s ?

Christ sent out JTB to Baptize, had JTB Baptize him by water immersion … and then we see the Spirit Baptism from God upon Christ. John even warned the Pharisees who came to him for baptism … that it would do them no good w/o contrition and a sincere change of heart [works befitting of repentance].

It was then as now … water baptism [by man, since Christ never baptized anyone himself] PLUS, Spiritual baptism by Christ of converts.

Man has physical role, & God has spiritual role in the two stage rebirth process. Man annoints with water, Christ Confirms with H.S.
 
Yes. I was born again in the Sacrament of Baptism. At 2 weeks of age.
The water portion of your Rite of Baptism … yes.
Next, it was your Parents/Godparent’s duty to see to it you later got Confirmed [with H.S.]

Look how many Cradle Catholics today neglect to ever get Confirmed … and leave the Church.
 
I just skimmed through the posts, so forgive me if this was brought up already.
There is another perspective I didn’t notice in the thread:

When we are born physically we become aware of our physical body and the physical world.

Wouldn’t being born of the spirit require conscious awareness of a spiritual body and conscious perception of the spiritual world?

If we aren’t conscious of a spiritual body and able to perceive the spiritual world, I believe we’re simply imagining and/or pretending to have been born again of the spirit.
 
It would seem yes … you had a Confirmation of sorts, as a Baptized adult.

If the Church really believed infant baptism was the endall of grace for Catholics … they wouldn’t teach what they do re: Confirmation
I’m Catholic, and as such, I agree with you on both counts.

I like to describe my 1997 conversion experience as the beginning of the road to finding the fullness of truth. I received a strong desire to pray, study and learn just about everything I could about Jesus Christ and what it means to follow Him. And that journey ended up with me joining the Catholic Church and receiving the actual sacrament of confirmation.

And you’re right - if baptism were the end-all, then we wouldn’t have the other sacraments. And the Church wouldn’t teach that we’re involved in an ongoing process of conversion - turning away from sin and toward righteousness.

You’ve raised some excellent points, BRB1 - thanks for your contribution to this thread 👍
 
You’ve raised some excellent points, BRB1 - thanks for your contribution to this thread 👍
I like to think Protestants who convert to the Church make the best informed Catholics 😃
And Scott Hahn, Tim Staples, etc are among the best informed and fruitful of all Catholics.

We’ve been in the wilderness for so long … that when we find the fullness of faith and all of sacraments … we really appreciate what we once only imagined as the ultimate reality.
 
I like to think Protestants who convert to the Church make the best informed Catholics 😃
And Scott Hahn, Tim Staples, etc are among the best informed and fruitful of all Catholics.

We’ve been in the wilderness for so long … that when we find the fullness of faith and all of sacraments … we really appreciate what we once only imagined as the ultimate reality.
Thanks, BRB1!

I’ve got a whopper of a post in response to mmmcounts, so please, feel free to interject at any point you think I may have gotten it wrong and/or unclear. I didn’t address the torrent of words he used to explain this supposedly easy passage (John 3:5), but I attempted to hit at the logic and inconsistency in some of his methods.
 
My goodness, mmmcounts, you’ve obviously put an awful lot of effort in that series of responses, and I thank you – your effort is sincerely appreciated.

But I must say, and I’m trying as hard as possible to respond in a way most reflective of Our Lord and Savior – that’s some of the most stunningly arrogant and contradictory series of explanations I’ve ever read on these forums. Where do I even begin addressing the problems with what you’ve written?

You provided a link to a paper that touches on the means of salvation – specifically addressing the meaning of John 3:5. You mentioned that you don’t agree with everything in that document, but you recommended it nonetheless. So I asked, “How am I to know which of the information included in this document is reliable?” And your response to this question is the first contradiction I’d like to address:
40.png
mmmcounts:
Well, for starters you can easily verify much of the useful information that he draws out of Scripture. You can check the references and look at an online interlinear Bible to check up on the Greek stuff. Or use some other resource to check up on the parallel passages cited in the document.
I have verified what he says in scripture, and I’ve come to the conclusion that the guy’s just full of hot air, promulgating the doctrines of men (1 Tim 1:3), adhering to new winds of doctrine (Ephesians 4:14), not faithfully handing on the faith once delivered to the apostles (2 Tim 2:2, ). And he even admits such on the very first page of his essay:
Robert V. McCabe:
In the history of Christian interpretation, John 3:5 has often been
associated with Christian baptism.
When you see a setup like that, it’s clear that the author is going to take issue with what has been the historical interpretation of these passages for the 1500 years preceding the Protestant Reformation. He should’ve just stopped right there. What gives this guy the authority, ability, knowledge, whatever you’d like to call it, that qualifies him to take a different approach to scripture in comparison to the approach that was taken for 1500 years? Did the holy men of the Church get it wrong for 1500 years, thus allowing the gates of hell to prevail against God’s church until this novel interpretation came along? These were men who knew ancient Greek, who studied in succession from the apostles, who were responsible for compiling the canon of scripture in the 3rd and 4th centuries, who translated it into numerous vernacular languages in order to evangelize the world with the Gospel – and then someone comes along in the late 20th century (yes, I know that this peculiar, ahistorical, anti-scriptural interpretation existed before Prof. McCabe), thinking he knows better? It’s laughable. After I read that statement, I decided it wasn’t necessary to read any more of this guy’s essay.

You’ve also said that “[t]he right way to be saved is found in the Bible.” But then you send me a document written by someone associated with a Baptist seminary that explains what the Bible means. Now, if I’ve come to a different conclusion about the means of salvation (and I have, otherwise I’d still be Baptist), then what? My conversion to the Catholic Church – a church that teaches the necessity of baptism as well as baptismal regeneration – came after careful study of scripture, prayer, writings of early church fathers and comparisons to doctrines of other churches (including those of the one I left). And the Bible played the biggest role in leading me to this conclusion, when I started to realize that the teachings of the Protestant churches I’d attended in the past didn’t line up with the plain sense of scripture – not just on the matter of baptism, but on a whole host of matters.

So I can’t trust the words of a man above the words of the Bible, but you’ve asked me to do just that. The plain sense of scripture, and the plain understanding of the Church for at least 1500 years, says that this passage (John 3:5) is talking about water baptism. And my reading of scripture, which you’ve told me to elevate above the teachings of men (and I agree with you on that point, BTW), confirms what the Church teaches. So who’s right about this passage – you, me, the Catholic Church, or Dr. McCabe? I mean, this is where the false, man-made doctrine of sola scriptura has gotten us – a mess of confusion and contradiction.

Again, I’d like to propose that the means of salvation, if it’s left up to everyone to determine them on the basis of scripture alone, can be whatever anyone claims them to be. Everyone with recourse to scripture has the right to read, interpret and apply as he sees fit, without any human authority or expert to correct him. And thus, you have absolutely no basis to say that anything the Catholic Church teaches on this matter is incorrect.
 
You’ve also said that “If in anything they have ‘rightly divided the Word of Truth,’ you can call that what it is.” First, I don’t know exactly what that means (especially the second part). Second, how am I to tell whether any of these human theologians have “rightly divided the Word of Truth?” If I read the same passages they do, and come to radically different conclusions about the meanings of those texts, then whom shall I trust? After all, I received confirmation in my Spirit of having been made alive with Christ (really, having the graces of my baptism brought to fruition) when I accepted Christ as personal Lord and Savior. Thus, I possess the same Holy Spirit you claim to possess. Shouldn’t I be as capable of being led into an understanding of all truth (John 16:13) as you or Dr. McCabe or St. Ignatius of Antioch?

I then posed a question about your use of the Greek language to explain the words of scripture, and you responded by saying, “The knowledge of salvation is readily understood by regular unchurched lay people just by reading the Bible. It takes a little more work to understand all the nitpicky details that theologians go super in-depth about, but the important thing is that someone can read the Bible and understand how to be saved. As far as salvation goes, it’s not that hard.” But then you proceed to write 4 posts explaining this thing that’s supposed to be so easy to understand.

If the “knowledge of salvation is readily understood by regular unchurched lay people,” then why is there a need to go into such detail to ensure that they understand it properly? If I, a regular layperson (though a ‘churched’ layperson, since 1995 anyways) comes to a different conclusion than the one you’ve put forth, is it really that easy to understand? If you need to resort to theologians to clarify it for me, is it really that easy to understand? If it were so easy to understand, you wouldn’t be going through such a concerted effort to convince me that the teachings of the Catholic Church were wrong, as it would just be readily apparent to me.

So I ask you again – you went to great lengths to explain the meaning of this passage to me, making recourse to Greek grammar and vocabulary, in order to say something that the plain text does not say. Did the translators of every single English-language edition of the Bible mess this up? If the translations of the Greek words mean what they say you mean, then why did the translators of scripture deliberately attempt to confuse us by substituting inadequate words for the Greek originals?

I’ve just pasted your entire theological explanation into a MS Word document, single-spaced, 10 point Times New Roman font, and it took up over 4 pages. Is that your idea of something that’s easy to understand for the unchurched layman? Now it seems that it’s no longer sola scriptura – it’s the Bible, plus a degree in ancient Biblical languages (and you think the average layperson has access to an education in ancient Biblical languages?), explanations from holy men of God (but only if they line up against the scriptures, but you’ve not given me any way but subjectivity to determine if that’s the case for any particular teacher), and my own guidance from the Holy Spirit (the Spirit testifying to my spirit, and guiding me into all truth, as scripture itself words it). This is starting to look and sound awfully complicated for something you claim is just so darned plain to the average person. So I guess I’d call this the biggest whopper of a contradiction in a sea of contradictions that you’ve written.

You’ve done a lot of work to explain something that’s supposedly so easy to understand. Why is that, do you think?
Such arrogance (telling me not to respond unless I read this-or-that, assuming that you’re right and the learned men of the first 1500 years of Church history - including those who learned from Jesus, or learned from those who learned from Jesus – are wrong), contradiction (it’s easy to understand, but you have to know and make recourse to Greek vocabulary and grammar as well as learned men, but you can only trust these men if they rightly divine the Word of Truth, but I haven’t revealed to you how you know they’ve rightly divided it, it’s easy to understand but I had to write 20,000 words to explain it to you) and condescension (“Are you paying attention Chrisb? theMutant? Nicolep).

And fundamentalists wonder why they leave such negative impressions on non-fundamentalists.
 
John 1:10-13
He was in the world, and the world came to be through him, but the world did not know him. He came to what was his own, but his own people did not accept him. But to those who did accept him he gave power to become children of God, to those who believe in his name, who were born not by natural generation nor by human choice nor by a man’s decision but of God.

To me this passage is pointing to baptism as the means to be born again.
Look closely at what it says, especially with the Protestant view of being born again, as a decision to accept Jesus as your personal Lord and Savior.
I see this passage saying that God gave us power to become his children, by believing yes, but also added to that is the power given by being born of God.

John 2:23-25
While he was in Jerusalem for the feast of Passover, many began to believe in his name when they saw the signs he was doing. But Jesus would not trust himself to them because he knew them all, and did not need anyone to testify about human nature. He himself understood it well.

Here, we see that the people began to believe in Jesus, but that was not enough, because Jesus saw what was really inside the people. They needed a “divine power” to move beyond believe and to become Children of God.

How do we receive this “divine power” to become children of God, a power which is beyond a simple belief, or a just man’s decision to accept Jesus as his personal Lord and Savior?

Nicodemus refers back to the problem of John 2 when he asks Jesus in John 3:2
“Rabbi, we know that you are a teacher who has come from God, for no one can do these signs that you are doing unless God is with him.”

Jesus replies back in John 3:3
“Amen, amen, I say to you, no one can see the kingdom of God without being born from above.”
And further clarifies this when Nicodemus is confused with his follow up in John 3:5
“Amen, amen, I say to you, no one can enter the kingdom of God without being born of water and Spirit.”

It is beyond a man’s decision to accept Jesus as Lord and Savior and think that he is born again, he must be born of water and spirit, that is he must be baptized to be born again.

Look back to Ezekiel 36: 25-28 It matches up with what Jesus is saying.
"I will sprinkle clean water upon you to cleanse you from all your impurities, and from all your idols I will cleanse you.I will give you a new heart and place a new spirit within you, taking from your bodies your stony hearts and giving you natural hearts. I will put my spirit within you and make you live by my statutes, careful to observe my decrees. You shall live in the land I gave your fathers; you shall be my people, and I will be your God."
 
The right way to be saved is found in the Bible. You should not place that kind of trust in men- even studly men of God who have done a lot for Christianity. If in anything they have “rightly divided the Word of Truth,” you can call that what it is. No person is infallible though; only the Bible is, because it is of God.
How is it that the Bible can be inerrant in matters of faith and morals, if the Catholic men (including a Pope) who wrote it were not, themselves, infallible with regard to their teachings on faith and morals? 🤷

Or do you believe that the Bible fell down from Heaven already written, collected, and bound into its codex binding - or that God took hold of those men, possessed their bodies, and forced them to write His words by means of automatic writing? 😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top