Mandatory mask poll

  • Thread starter Thread starter jgaw1234
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have no idea what science I have studied.
Then lay it out there.

As far as I’m concerned (and it sounds like others as well) are pretty convinced you haven’t studied any scientific/peer reviewed stuties, or know your sources are “sketchy at best” and that’s why you won’t share them.

If you had, you’d have shared them by now.
Not really. Yall vote for your mommies and daddies.
:roll_eyes:
Sure I do. I just did.
🤔 so you can…
 
As far as I’m concerned (and it sounds like others as well) are pretty convinced you haven’t studied any scientific/peer reviewed stuties
Seems we’ve covered that already. That’s fine if you’re convinced of it. Really 😀
 
I don’t know, ForeverLearn. A couple of issues come to mind. One the one hand, we might be able to say that not wearing a mask may potentially affect more people but I’m not sure we could argue that it directly kills people.
Then there is the numbers issue. I wonder if pitting the many against the few (in our example case of one killed child and possibly many ill people works well within a Catholic framework?
It seems, in my mind, to be a utilitarian argument (the greatest happiness of the greatest number).
These are just a few ideas that I am grappling with-I can’t say that I have any answers right now-just questions I am pondering.
May God bless you and all who visit our thread.
jt
I agree that it may not fit well, however, it could be a determiner as to the direction that one may cast their vote.
 
@Anicette: We had a shelter-in-place law in N.J. Residents
could go out to pharmacies, grocery stories, liquor stores,
and the doctor.

Essential workers could go to their jobs.

Now, that new infections have plunged, restaurants are
open for outdoor dining. Golf courses, parks, salons, and
barber shops are also open.

Humanity has endured worse.

Today’s pandemic pales in comparison to the Black
Plague. The mortality rate is of an untreated COVID-19
case is infinitesimal compared to Black Plague infection.

In the 14th century, the Black Death spread unchecked
from Mongolia, to northern India, through the Middle East,
and North Africa, and across Europe, all the way to Ireland.

Now that we know how diseases spread, we can do
our part to slow this pandemic. Yes, wearing masks
is annoying.

But when we consider that 14th plague survivors had
to bury one third of the human race in mass graves,
we know we can prevail during a pandemic that has
far-less-lethal consequences.

@vz71 and @RuthAnne: My point is humanity has endured worse.

According to History.com, 50 percent of Europe’s population
perished in the Black Plague.

Today’s pandemic pales in comparison. The mortality rate is
of untreated an COVID-19 is infinitesimal compared to untreated
Yersinia pestis infection.

People were buried in mass graves.

In the 21st century, we have modern medicine to help us through
this crisis.

We can draw strength from knowing we can endure this time
when our ancestors went through far worse.

If you want to dismiss that comparison, that’s fine.
 
Last edited:
Wish more people were that considerate. While I am not for government mandates, I think it is a sorry state of affairs that they feel they have to.
 
@RuthAnne and @vz71: See my response. I was not
comparing the mortality rate of COVID 19 to Yersinia
pestis. I’m not saying that one third of the human race
is going to die if we don’t wear masks.

I’m saying: We can draw hope of about human endurance
in far darker times.

Based on your feedback, I reworded my initial post to clarify
the comparison.

@vz71: To be honest, my post needed some clarification.
Thanks for pointing out that necessity.
 
Last edited:
4 1/2%
Math is math and anyone who can do basic division can calculate the rate.
 
Last edited:
I’m pro life, and that means I want to protect the vulnerable and weak. So I wear a mask everywhere I go. It’s the least I can do. I wish it was mandatory in Florida, but it’s not.
 
4 1/2%
Math is math and anyone who can do basic division can calculate the rate.
Are you saying the death rate is 4.5% or .45%? 4.5 is absurd so you must mean .45, which is still likely high for combined all age groups.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top