Mormonism, Catholicism and Devoutness

  • Thread starter Thread starter HopingforGodtohelp
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I thought you get a kick out of that. I am speaking to the times when these orders were Catholic who refused to obedience to the secular King and left or have their heads chopped off. Those protestants who remained in keeping with these Catholic orders could not submit obedience to the Church Jesus founded upon Peter and the Apostles. The point is made clear. You should admit the difference and no comparison can be made.
 
It went well. I searched the scriptures. What I prayed about is between me and my God.
 
Mormons take a vow of Chastity, Poverty and Obedience?
Yes they do, basically. In the temple they make an oath to not have sexual relations with anyone but your husband or wife to whom you are legally and lawfully wedded to. I’m not exactly how that works now that you can be legally and lawfully wedded to someone of the same gender. In the temple they also make strict covenants of obedience. They don’t actually vow to poverty but they do vow to give their time, talents and energy and everything that God has or will give to them for the building up of the church.
 
Last edited:
It went well. I searched the scriptures. What I prayed about is between me and my God.
Which scriptures lead you to believe that God the Father is composed solely of an immaterial spirit essence?
 
How did this come to be the case? It baffles me. The people following a religion that has very little evidence and is not very difficult to falsify are far more serious about it than people in the Catholic Church are.
I get your consternation with this. Growing up, through middle and high schools, even uni, all my closest friends were Mormon. They were the ones living out their faith (I was evangelical at the time). I was invited to their family home evenings and experience family with them I lacked elsewhere. I went to many activities and even met with the missionaries to learn about the faith. I never converted because it was clear to me deep down that the faith wasn’t based on Truth. But I was very close. I felt a sense of belonging. I think that this is the attraction and where the Catholic and evangelical/Protestant churches generally drop the ball. Yes, there are some Christian communities that foster community and belonging. But the Mormon church is structured around the family and community–they excel in this area. I know the faith is a false one and there is nefarious activity higher within the structure, but I know many average Mormons who love God and are amazing people, giving of themselves and maintaining consistency in engagement and growth in faith. There is a lot the Mormon Church offers the average person. Nonetheless, I knew in my heart the doctrine was false and never joined the faith. I have maintained long and solid friendships with many Mormons who are as dedicated to their faith and family as I am to mine.
 
I take it you are not very familiar with Catholicism. To ask what scriptures I referred to says to me that you don’t know what the Catholic scriptures are. Well, for sure they aren’t the Book of Mormon or the D&C.
 
I don’t think you can find a single protestant or non-catholic who live and have taken a vow of chastity, poverty and obedience to faith in Jesus Christ body.
Off topic, but where I live, there are Protestants monastic communities. They very much take (perpetual) vows of chastity, poverty and obedience.
 
I take it you are not very familiar with Catholicism.
Try me.
To ask what scriptures I referred to says to me that you don’t know what the Catholic scriptures are.
OK, let me rephrase. Which scriptures (meaning verses in the Old and New Testament - including the deuterocanonical books) accepted by the Catholic Church lead you to believe that God the Father is composed solely of an immaterial spirit essence?
 
You’re making no sense. If you understand Catholicism then you wouldn’t ask which scriptures. You would already know. So I rest my case.

I wouldn’t ask which Mormon scriptures says that God is a spirit. I’ve read the Book of Mormon enough times to know. I wouldn’t ask you to explain why the Mormon church changes its doctrine. I have been there. I already know.
 
I gauge devoutness to those practicing members. Do Mormons take a vow of Chastity, Poverty and Obedience?
Does a Catholic baptism not include a promise to obey God’s commandments? What is the point of the additional “Vow of Obedience”?
 
Does a Catholic baptism not include a promise to obey God’s commandments? What is the point of the additional “Vow of Obedience”?
The same could be asked of Mormons. What is the point of the law of obedience given in the temple?
 
Last edited:
This statement is untrue. Where where might you have heard this?
That’s a very disingenuous question unless you’re just being a trouble maker who knows as little about Mormonism as you do Catholicism.
 
Mormons used to have a prophet named Boyd K. Packer. He said that only the church of the Lamb of God has the required saving ordinances of the gospel. The Book of Mormon says that there are only two churches. The church of the Lamb of God and the church of the devil and if you’re not a member of the church of the Lamb of God then you belong to the church of the devil. He went on to say that these are hard truths for Mormons to admit but that we must be strong enough to proclaim them.

So, Catholics belong to the church of the devil. That’s pretty bold.
 
Sure. I can only share my thoughts and @Formon will have to speak for himself.

The Book of Mormon describes “The Great and Abominable Church” whose characteristics are these:
  1. It persecutes, tortures, and slays the Saints of God (see 1Nephi 13:5).
  2. It seeks wealth and luxury (see1Nephi13:7-8).
  3. It is characterized by sexual immorality (see 1 Nephi 13:7).
  4. It has excised plain and precious things from the scriptures (see 1 Nephi 3:26-29).
  5. It has dominion over all the earth, among all nations, kindreds, tongues, and people (see 1 Nephi 4:11).
  6. Its fate is to be consumed by a world war, when the nations it incites against the Saints war among themselves until the great and abominable church itself is destroyed (see 1 Nephi 22:13-14).
In addition, 5 of these 6 attributes are also listed in Revelation 17 & 18 describing the “Whore of Babylon”.

(For a full treatment of the topic see here.)

The Catholic Church simply does not meet these 6 criteria from the Book of Mormon.
 
Last edited:
Mormons used to have a prophet named Boyd K. Packer. He said that only the church of the Lamb of God has the required saving ordinances of the gospel. The Book of Mormon says that there are only two churches. The church of the Lamb of God and the church of the devil and if you’re not a member of the church of the Lamb of God then you belong to the church of the devil. He went on to say that these are hard truths for Mormons to admit but that we must be strong enough to proclaim them.

So, Catholics belong to the church of the devil. That’s pretty bold.
It is very true. Mormons have made a gigantic claim that basically damns themselves if they are wrong for rejecting Christ’s Church. Protestants take a more cautious approach when attempting to validate their rejecting of Christ’s church. Many Mormons do not question their faith but it would be wise. We must remember, when you reject Christ’s Church, you are rejecting Christ.
 
But the Mormon church is structured around the family and community–they excel in this area.
That is a common myth. The Mormon church is the source of many many family breakups, divorces and so forth. Non Mormon families can’t see their relatives get married for instance. I had numerous, painful conversations with mostly women who were married to non Mormon husbands and their lives were hell. Mormons only care about families to the extent that their families are also Mormons.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top