NFP abused is sinful

  • Thread starter Thread starter tundra1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But NFP CAN be used to help conceive.

Using NFP without a just reason is not sinful in the same way that contraceptives are. It might be a sin agains generosity or selflessness, but it’s not contraceptive in nature. There are lots of good things that can become sinful if used with a wrong intent, for instance food and eating are good, but can be abused if we are gluttonsous. So, NFP could be used with a wrong intent but it’s still moral.
 
So using NFP is sinful, not using is sinful, and using it incorrectly may be sinful.

Yikes! No wonder so many Catholics seem neurotic! :D:D:D
You have no idea. I’m so glad I was raised Protestant, since Protestants have a very positive and healthy view of marriage and sex. They see them as positive goods, not necessary evils.
 
You have no idea. I’m so glad I was raised Protestant, since Protestants have a very positive and healthy view of marriage and sex. They see them as positive goods, not necessary evils.
And you clearly have no idea what the Church actually teaches about sex and marriage to make such a statement.
 
And you clearly have no idea what the Church actually teaches about sex and marriage to make such a statement.
Knowing church teachings and forming an impression of their results are two different things if one uses this forum as a way to learn about the Catholic faith. I must say that as a non-Catholic I am shocked at how many posts on this website refer to frustration and discouragement in regards to following church teachings on sexual relations/birth control within marriage. The best answers people can give is “take up your cross”. I don’t know about you but that is not a very inspiring, joyful outlook. I certainly hope that the large number of posts on this topic are not representative of the majority of Catholics as that would be very sad.
 
Knowing church teachings and forming an impression of their results are two different things if one uses this forum as a way to learn about the Catholic faith. I must say that as a non-Catholic I am shocked at how many posts on this website refer to frustration and discouragement in regards to following church teachings on sexual relations/birth control within marriage. The best answers people can give is “take up your cross”. I don’t know about you but that is not a very inspiring, joyful outlook. I certainly hope that the large number of posts on this topic are not representative of the majority of Catholics as that would be very sad.
“Take up your Cross” is the most joyful thing a person can do. What is a Christian? Someone who follows Christ. Where did Christ lead? To the cross. How did he conquer death? On the cross. Suffering embraced and offered up to God is one of the best ways to draw near to Him.

As an aside, I would advise you to look into the history of Protestantism and artificial birth control. You will find that what is widely accepted today was once condemned as sinful. How does the truth change? How can evil be good? Was the church wrong then, or wrong now? And either way, if it was wrong once, why can’t it be wrong again. Contraception is one of the many places where a thoughtful examination will lead to the collapse of Sola Scriptura and with it the Protestant conception of how church authority works.

Pax and God bless.
 
You have no idea. I’m so glad I was raised Protestant, since Protestants have a very positive and healthy view of marriage and sex. They see them as positive goods, not necessary evils.
And you clearly have no idea what the Church actually teaches about sex and marriage to make such a statement.
Jennifer, I converted to the Catholic Church 5 and a half years ago. I didn’t really bother to study what the Church had taught about marriage and sex before I converted. Then I started reading what the saints had written about marriage and sex throughout history. I was devastated. I felt deceived. It took me over a year to decide whether or not I wanted to stay in the Church.

I finally decided to stay, because I realized that whatever the Church used to teach, it’s teachings about marriage and sex are now more in line with what I learned as a Protestant. In other words, what the Church teaches now is true. I didn’t want to leave the Church because of what Catholics and saints used to teach. However, if the Church ever starts to teach what the saints have said throughout history, I will leave. I will run for the door and not look back.

That being said, I went to a meeting of the woman’s group at my parish. They were reading The Life and Thought of Edith Stein. One of the chapters was about her writings about marriage, sex, and women. The leader of the discussion asked “Could she have written like this if she had been raised Catholic?” The unanimous consensus was “No.” The women then went on to talk about how Jews have such a healthy and positive view of sexuality, and how they all envied that.
 
The doctrines on faith and morals have never changed. If they had changed, the Church would be a lie.
 
The doctrines on faith and morals have never changed. If they had changed, the Church would be a lie.
Maybe it’s not so simple. After all, the Church had to discern whether or not Mary was immaculately conceived, and it took 1858 years.
 
Maybe it’s not so simple. After all, the Church had to discern whether or not Mary was immaculately conceived, and it took 1858 years.
No, there was a great heresy spreading that she was NOT immaculately conceived and the Church simply pronounced what had been held from the beginning. No change.
 
You have no idea. I’m so glad I was raised Protestant, since Protestants have a very positive and healthy view of marriage and sex. They see them as positive goods, not necessary evils.
You’ve been Catholic 5.5 years and you’ve never read the Catechism?
**2362 **"The acts in marriage by which the intimate and chaste union of the spouses takes place are noble and honorable; the truly human performance of these acts fosters the self-giving they signify and enriches the spouses in joy and gratitude."145 Sexuality is a source of joy and pleasure:
Code:
The Creator himself . . . established that in the [generative] function, spouses should experience pleasure and enjoyment of body and spirit. Therefore, the spouses do nothing evil in seeking this pleasure and enjoyment. They accept what the Creator has intended for them. At the same time, spouses should know how to keep themselves within the limits of just moderation.146
Sorry, where does that say that sex is a “necessary evil”?

Can you quote Church teaching from ANYWHERE that states sex is “a necessary evil”?

I’ve been studying Church teaching on sex and marriage for nearly a decade - I volunteer with the marriage prep program at my parish - and I am BAFFLED how anyone could do even a cursory study of Church teaching on sex and marriage and come to the conclusion that the Church believes sex is a “necessary evil.” There is absolutely NOTHING in Church teaching to support that view.
 
No, there was a great heresy spreading that she was NOT immaculately conceived and the Church simply pronounced what had been held from the beginning. No change.
So then why did St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Bernard of Clairvaux deny the Immaculate Conception?
 
You’ve been Catholic 5.5 years and you’ve never read the Catechism?

Sorry, where does that say that sex is a “necessary evil”?

Can you quote Church teaching from ANYWHERE that states sex is “a necessary evil”?

I’ve been studying Church teaching on sex and marriage for nearly a decade - I volunteer with the marriage prep program at my parish - and I am BAFFLED how anyone could do even a cursory study of Church teaching on sex and marriage and come to the conclusion that the Church believes sex is a “necessary evil.” There is absolutely NOTHING in Church teaching to support that view.
Sure I read what the Catechism says. But I never bothered to read what Catholics and saints said about marriage and sex before the year 1900. I assumed that the Church’s teachings hadn’t changed, the saints and Catholics must have believed what the Catechism teaches. They did not. That was what was so scandalous to me.

And I do think there is still some baggage from those early ideas that the saints and other Catholic writers had.
 
So then why did St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Bernard of Clairvaux deny the Immaculate Conception?
Because they were human beings who made mistakes, neither of them were speaking ex cathedra.

Maybe doing some reading on infallibility will help?
 
Because they were human beings who made mistakes, neither of them were speaking ex cathedra.

Maybe doing some reading on infallibility will help?
Neither St. Bernard of Clairvaux nor St. Thomas Aquinas have ever been condemned for teaching heresy. Especially not St. Thomas Aquinas! If his beliefs about the Immaculate Conception were considered heretical at the time of his writing, why were he and his writings not condemned?
 
Neither St. Bernard of Clairvaux nor St. Thomas Aquinas have ever been condemned for teaching heresy. Especially not St. Thomas Aquinas! If his beliefs about the Immaculate Conception were considered heretical at the time of his writing, why were he and his writings not condemned?
Not to mention the fact that popes who promoted St. Thomas Aquinas’ writings would have been promoting a heretic as an example of faith. None of them noticed that he denied the Immaculate Conception?
 
Neither St. Bernard of Clairvaux nor St. Thomas Aquinas have ever been condemned for teaching heresy. Especially not St. Thomas Aquinas! If his beliefs about the Immaculate Conception were considered heretical at the time of his writing, why were he and his writings not condemned?
Going too far afield for this thread.

Hang on, I will link to some resources.

Here is one

catholic-convert.com/2009/11/21/can-peter-walk-on-water-can-sinful-men-be-infallible/

Here are more

catholic.com/search/content/infallible
 
“Take up your Cross” is the most joyful thing a person can do. What is a Christian? Someone who follows Christ. Where did Christ lead? To the cross. How did he conquer death? On the cross. Suffering embraced and offered up to God is one of the best ways to draw near to Him.

As an aside, I would advise you to look into the history of Protestantism and artificial birth control. You will find that what is widely accepted today was once condemned as sinful. How does the truth change? How can evil be good? Was the church wrong then, or wrong now? And either way, if it was wrong once, why can’t it be wrong again. Contraception is one of the many places where a thoughtful examination will lead to the collapse of Sola Scriptura and with it the Protestant conception of how church authority works.

Pax and God bless.
If anything, Protestants realized that sexual relations within marriage are something the church needs to keep their nose out of and leave it between God, husband and wife.
 
But that doesn’t answer the core question of why the aforementioned views pointed out by Valient Lucy were not condemned by the Church.
Correct. St. Thomas Aquinas, according to Costello, was teaching heretical views because he did not believe that Mary was conceived without original sin. Yet the church leaders at the time never condemned his views or his writings as heretical.

The reason is quite simple. The Church at the time had simply not determined whether or not Mary had been spared from original sin at the moment of her conception. They believed that she never sinned, but they hadn’t yet determined if she had been spared from original sin from the very first moment of her conception. So St. Thomas Aquinas was not bound to believe in the Immaculate Conception as defined by Pope Pius IX.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top