Oklahoma Execution Botched

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sooner87
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There are few if any on Death Row in America who are not guilty. We have had one prison guard murdered in a local prison last year by a proven killer. Years back, a local 17yo was stuck in a cell with a murderous kook, NIcholas Karabin, who killed at random with the plan to ultimately kill his wife. Since Karabin was kept alive in the slammer, the young man left in a body bag, “convicted” in a “fun” kangaroo court by “Judge” Karabin behind bars. 😦 Rob
Whether I can say “facts are facts” I don’t know but Illinois abolished the death penalty because they were afraid they were going to execute innocent men/women. I don’t know if that was the best decision but that is how it has played out.
 
Few is not the same as zero, and given the severity of the punishment it needs to be zero.
In Northeast Pa, there is no doubt whatsoever about the guilt of our killers. Where there is doubt, if such a death row case exists, I would agree with you. :sad_yes:
 
I don’t see how you got that from his comment- “For people crying foul on him suffering during the execution, get over it. It is an honor to suffer like Christ did on the cross.” This quote plus the manner in which he crafted his comment, plus the listings of what these two criminals did indicate to me he was arguing against those who object to this man’s suffering due to a botched execution. His follow up comment about suffering being good and that Christ was guilty of nothing also indicates to me that he understands there is just and unjust suffering. Given that the suffering the executed criminal went through due to his botched execution was unintentional, it would have to be classified as unjust suffering. I don’t remember Christ or the Church teaching us to just “get over” unjust suffering.
What I am meaning is that an unintentional botch doesn’t necessarily make it just or unjust. He could well have gotten his dues. To give him that, though, wouldn’t be justified on grounds of mercy, but I think Punisherthunder was more frustrated over how comments seem to sympathise more with the criminal because of his execution rather than the girl who he murdered.
 
I’m afraid there is far too much “1:1” and “justice” talk. Did Christ not come to teach us that mercy is greater than justice? That we must love our enemies? "You have heard it said an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth, but I say to you, do not resist an evildoer. If one strikes you on the cheek, turn to him the other "

I am not against the death penalty on the basis of false sentimentality of those who commit such a heinous deeds. They will have to face God, as we all must. But we deny them the chance for repentance if we murder them.

We also make men into murderers. Those who put these men to death do not truly know their guilt. Killing itself is an evil act and I am wary to use it.

Some need not forget that Jesus Christ was put to death for a crime. Was this too justice?
 
Of course there is more sympathy expressed for the culprit than the victim.

Unless one lives in Oklahoma, they probably knew nothing about this case until hearing about the “botched” execution. That is what pushed the sympathy buttons.

This is a problem with the death penalty generally: it turns the condemned person into a kind of anti-hero, a helpless human being whose life is taken from him by the cruel Society. This gins up a lot of undeserved mass sympathy. The crimes that were committed to earn the punishment are never thought of.

Gary Gilmore, shot in Utah in 1977, was the subject of a Norman Mailer novel and a film based on the novel. The two men he shot in the head were forgotten, except by their families.

ICXC NIKA.
 
I’m afraid there is far too much “1:1” and “justice” talk. Did Christ not come to teach us that mercy is greater than justice? That we must love our enemies? "You have heard it said an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth, but I say to you, do not resist an evildoer. If one strikes you on the cheek, turn to him the other "
He didn’t say anything about what happens when someone puts a bullet in your head or stabs you in your heart. Why? You can no longer love or forgive the person that murders you.
I am not against the death penalty on the basis of false sentimentality of those who commit such a heinous deeds. They will have to face God, as we all must. But we deny them the chance for repentance if we murder them.
We also make men into murderers. Those who put these men to death do not truly know their guilt. Killing itself is an evil act and I am wary to use it.
People tend to forgot that in the U.S., the actual carrying out of death sentence is and extremely rare occurrence. Most of these people are simply extremely sick and dangerous human beings; threats to a society. I am most certainly not for killing people. But I am also not for allowing the possibility of murderers to murder again.
Some need not forget that Jesus Christ was put to death for a crime. Was this too justice?
In the U.S., we do not put people to death for the “crimes” Christ committed.
 
What I am meaning is that an unintentional botch doesn’t necessarily make it just or unjust. He could well have gotten his dues. To give him that, though, wouldn’t be justified on grounds of mercy, but I think Punisherthunder was more frustrated over how comments seem to sympathise more with the criminal because of his execution rather than the girl who he murdered.
This thread is about a bothched excecution, not the crime that put him there. It’s a diversionary tactic to make the opposition seem uncaring.
 
What I am meaning is that an unintentional botch doesn’t necessarily make it just or unjust. He could well have gotten his dues. To give him that, though, wouldn’t be justified on grounds of mercy, but I think Punisherthunder was more frustrated over how comments seem to sympathise more with the criminal because of his execution rather than the girl who he murdered.
Ok, that frustration is totally understandable. I think how I approach this subject (sympathy and concern for the victim is an assumed given, objections to the death penalty are based on the morality of its usage and method of usage, not on the morality of the death penalty itself- the Church teaches that it is a moral form of punishment and safeguarding the populace) led me to not understand the intent of his comments.

Punisher- If POJIUJH’s assessment is correct I apologize for my misreading of your intent.
 
I understand the visceral reaction we have when confronted with these heinous crimes. However, one’s position on this topic does not in anyway diminish the empathy one has for the victim’s and their loved ones.
And that is the tool continually used to defend this- and execution in general.

The revulsion, anger, and distaste for the murderous acts- and the murderer, do not remove us from the question of the suitability of the death penalty.

We should never forget the murdered or the crime of the murderer but this doesn’t mean we need to support the death penalty.

Many of us- myself included- would rather those guilty of heinous murder to be given a life sentence without any human comforts- save limited exercise and bathing.
 
What I am meaning is that an unintentional botch doesn’t necessarily make it just or unjust. He could well have gotten his dues.
Unintentional suffering in this scenario would still be unjust; it would just not hold the same weight of immorality (if any, my limited understanding leads me to believe that such unintentional suffering can be morally neutral) as intentional suffering (which I believe would always be immoral based on it being unjust).

The just (for the sake of argument we will assume the usage of the death penalty in this case was just) punishment was the execution. The unjust part was the addition of the unintentional suffering to the execution and that this suffering was a direct effect of the execution. It being unintentional doesn’t make it just or neither just or unjust.
 
I’m afraid there is far too much “1:1” and “justice” talk. Did Christ not come to teach us that mercy is greater than justice? That we must love our enemies? "You have heard it said an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth, but I say to you, do not resist an evildoer. If one strikes you on the cheek, turn to him the other "

I am not against the death penalty on the basis of false sentimentality of those who commit such a heinous deeds. They will have to face God, as we all must. But we deny them the chance for repentance if we murder them.
I am not clear that this is true. Most spend years on death row. They do have the opportunity for repentance. In fact, having to face the death penalty may be a compelling reason to not avoid repentance since the finality of the penalty is a strong compelling reason to face reality and not defer or put off finally taking the option of repentance. A great many saints have made the point that facing one’s own death and living each day with an understanding that today could be your last one results in not taking life too lightly and our actions seriously.

The death penalty, in fact, may serve to induce individuals to take a stand vis a vis their guilt and take ownership of it. What they have done was a grave evil and faced with the just consequences of putting them in the place of their victims serves as an opportunity for empathizing with the person who was on the receiving end of their action.

Certainly capital punishment is a serious and grave matter, but so were the consequences of their actions. God’s mercy does not mean we necessarily avoid punishment. If we are truly repentant, that would mean we realize the seriousness of our actions and accept what we deserve because of our commission or omission.
We also make men into murderers. Those who put these men to death do not truly know their guilt. Killing itself is an evil act and I am wary to use it.

Some need not forget that Jesus Christ was put to death for a crime. Was this too justice?
Jesus was innocent. It wasn’t justice BECAUSE he didn’t deserve crucifixion. That is an important distinction.
 
What I am meaning is that an unintentional botch doesn’t necessarily make it just or unjust. He could well have gotten his dues. To give him that, though, wouldn’t be justified on grounds of mercy, but I think Punisherthunder was more frustrated over how comments seem to sympathise more with the criminal because of his execution rather than the girl who he murdered.
Mercy isn’t a finite resource. We’re called to be merciful to many – even those we don’t wish to be merciful to. Twice in this thread I’ve referred Punisherthunder to the CCC. If it makes us feel uncomfortable to show mercy to murderers, this is all the more reason to rely on Church teachings. Christ and His Church ask us to safeguard against criminals, certainly – but they also require us to recognize that even the murderer is a child of God.
 
Mercy isn’t a finite resource. We’re called to be merciful to many – even those we don’t wish to be merciful to.
IMHO, forgiveness, mercifulness, etc. is not up to me or you, simply because we are not the ones that were wronged. That is up to the victim’s family and the legal system.
 
IMHO, forgiveness, mercifulness, etc. is not up to me or you, simply because we are not the ones that were wronged. That is up to the victim’s family and the legal system.
Mercy includes permitting the convicted an opportunity to turn to Christ. If he or she is put to death, that’s not possible.

In general, the Church prefers the option that privileges the dignity of the human person. And every human being has dignity – even the criminal. It’s only when putting the criminal to death is the only way to protect society that the death penalty is permitted.
 
Mercy includes permitting the convicted an opportunity to turn to Christ. If he or she is put to death, that’s not possible.

In general, the Church prefers the option that privileges the dignity of the human person. And every human being has dignity – even the criminal. It’s only when putting the criminal to death is the only way to protect society that the death penalty is permitted.
Jesus is available 24/7 anywhere, anytime, so he could convert at anytime. I am hoping in those agonizing moments (heart attack) he was provided the grace to repent. It was there if he wanted it.
Least we for forget the good thief on the cross with Jesus; it is possible even when you have pushed everyone else away.
 
The bigger issue is liberal statesmen/media crying foul that virtually any form of execution is cruel and unusual. Hang ropes, firing squads, and let’s face it…guillotines were effective and quick for how many years?
 
Mercy includes permitting the convicted an opportunity to turn to Christ. If he or she is put to death, that’s not possible.
I’m aware of that. The victim’s family can discuss that with their attorneys.
 
Mercy includes permitting the convicted an opportunity to turn to Christ. If he or she is put to death, that’s not possible.
The victims of those rightly convicted of capital punishment were deprived of that same opportunity BECAUSE they were murdered. Yet, those awaiting execution are given months and years to “turn to Christ.” Your argument gets stood on its head.

This reminds me of the parable of the unmerciful servant. The servant who was forgiven a great debt remains unforgiving of another who owes him a trifle.

A cursory dismissal of the death penalty seems a great deal like someone, themselves being owed a trifle, being quite willing to dismiss the great debt owed to another - the murder victim.

In a sense, the convicted murderer acts out this parable in reverse. He shows no mercy to the one he murders, but relies upon being shown great mercy by the legal system after the fact. Why should this be so? He showed no mercy to the one he killed.

In the parable, what happens to the unmerciful servant?
'You wicked servant! I forgave you all that debt because you besought me; and should not you have had mercy on your fellow servant, as I had mercy on you?’ And in anger his lord delivered him to the jailers, till he should pay all his debt. So also my heavenly Father will do to every one of you, if you do not forgive your brother from your heart.” (Matt 18:21-35)
In a very real sense, the killer offers no mercy to his victim, but demands the last drop of his blood. The recourse of “his lord” was to demand that “he pay all his debt.” Crimes ought not be treated lightly. I do not suppose blithely casting mercy on any unrepentant being is what is called for. The point is that evil needs to be seen for what it is and the gravity of its effects. A human life was taken and taken unmercifully. What does repaying “all his debt” mean under the circumstances of taking another life? What does it mean to truly be repentant of that?
 
Murderers, IMHO, have to be treated differently from others. People that have already shown that they will willfully take the lives of others, and in some cases for no reason (such as the baby rapist/murderer was execution was delayed as a result of this “botched” execution) are an imminent threat to others lives. You can’t just forgive and forget. And there are no good choices. Some have suggested a life sentence in isolation. This is effectively torture, and is that the right thing to do?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top