You are taking the actions of a few Protestants and making a blanket statement about all Protestants, which is offensive.
You can pray for me anytime you want!
All I need here is my dictionary:
Vatican II is NOT infallible. Read here: coomaraswamy-catholic-writings.com/What%20Vatican%20II%20Teaches.htm#_ftn3
The CCC is not infallible. It is good, too, because if it were then the Church would be fallible because it professes errors in it. The mother of a close friend of mine read through the entire CCC and marked all its errors. If you have a newer edition, you will find that the Pope did the same thing, as his corrections are either in the back or already implemented into the text. If the Pope had to correct it, it was not infallible. I have never heard of that being done (for ANY reason) on any other infallible document, be it a council or other Papal declaration. God bless.
By your own definition, you are a heretic. This is not a word that should be slung about wildly.
It is interesting that he cites *J’acuse le Council *by Archbishop Lefebvre as his source. I understand Archbishop Lefebvre was excommunicated. Is he, then, a reliable source?
You didn’t grow up in Northern Ireland, until you have met a Protestant from over here then you don’t have room to speak.
Ah…protestants from N. Ireland. Have you read Angela’s Ashes? There is one part in there that is very funny. My brother read it, and he told me about it. He said that the main character and his friend see protestants playing croquet. The main character says, “What’s the point of playing croquet if they’re going Hell anyway.” His friend replies, “What’s the point of not playing croquet if you’re going to Hell anyway.” It’s too bad Catholics nowadays do not believe Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus as all did unequivocally in times past. God bless.
I saw the movie, and the point your trying to make ? in plain English, please.
Rev. Ian Paisely
First of all, Vatican II was obviously an action of all of the bishops in union with the Pope, and hence its teachings are a function of the ordinary Magisterium, and hence are to be held as true by the Catholic faithful.
From the Catechism of St. Pius X:
It’s too bad that you presume to authentically interpret Catholic Tradition contrary to the Pope and the Bishops in communion with him, to which is vested the authentic magisterium.
From Pope Pius IX (1846-1878).
Pope St. Pius X quoted Pius IX quite favorably. Surely you are not charging Pius IX of modernism, are you?
ralphinal:
Yes, me. I agree with you on this post and your original one. I, too, feel offended and angry towards anti-Catholics. They are so arrogant and they are so certain they are right and they are so wrong. They don’t even want to discuss issues, they just want to criticize. It’s a sport to them. They claim to be christians but they certainly don’t act like christians.
Someone touched on a point in an earlier post about how protestants did not actively leave the church like Luther did, but follow him now becuase they do not know any better. I have a similar question about protestant ministers (see the thread under non Catholic religions).