Strong Desire to Attend Mass, But Not Catholic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Susan_Calvin
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think in this case, I’m more shocked by the source - my close friend - than anything else. I certainly never expected this from her.
Its amazing to me also… I’m still quite stunned by everything. Worried a bit too at how fast things are moving… once I decided to attend mass it was like opening the floodgates. Its a bit scary still. Though if I’m honest, this is something I have wanted for a long time and just never admitted it to myself.

Yes I agree with what you are saying and I’m really quite conflicted. On the one hand I am hurt and upset with her, and I will stand up for myself; on the other hand I care about her deeply and I want to continue the friendship. I guess I’ll just have to wait and see. I still have not heard from her, and at this point, I’m trying to decide if I should email her or not. Just to let her know I am open to chatting still. Its difficult too because we are in different countries at the moment; its not like I can just show up at her doorstep and speak with her face to face to resolve this…
I think your friend secretly might be jealous because you have discovered something she doesn’t have, and might covet

Catholics get used to people’s uncharitable behavior toward our religion…We know we have a treasure, and others can’t seem to let us enjoy it without trying to cast a shadow
thinking about your friend and her reaction, i agree with what is being said here and while you can’t convert her (without Jesus’ help) you can work toward planting seeds to help in her conversion. maybe she is totally anti-catholic, but then maybe she is ashamed of her past sins and thinks she is not worthy (not that any of us are anyways).

but, you value your friendship, and hopefully she is a true friend who will accept your new found religiousness. if that is the case, and even if not, contact her soon and share your joy of what you are learning, how it is making you feel, etc. tell her this is wonderful, and maybe she should go to mass once as well. friends share things and hopefully, hopefully she will come around.
 
but, you value your friendship, and hopefully she is a true friend who will accept your new found religiousness. if that is the case, and even if not, contact her soon and share your joy of what you are learning, how it is making you feel, etc. tell her this is wonderful, and maybe she should go to mass once as well. friends share things and hopefully, hopefully she will come around.
Thanks, I hope we talk again soon… I really want to remain friends with her. This morning I emailed her to say no hard feelings, and if she wanted to email or phone to talk she could. So now I’m just waiting to see what happens.
 
Did you know the superior, Sister Andrea?
Is this her? There’s quite a few photographs but if you scroll down there are two of her, with the caption Sr. Andrea underneath:

motherteresa.org/07_family/Volunteering/Ph_v.html

I looked her up, to see if she was the same Sr. Andrea that I vaguely remember. I think it is, though I was very young when she was the superior. Any memories I have of her are very vague, and mixed up with what my mother said about her. When I was an “older” kid, there was an Indian nun who was the superior, her name escapes me at the moment. But my mother definitely knew a Sr. Andrea!
We used to bring homegrown produce from our farm in NH.
So you would have been one of those trucks to come and unload produce! I remember those trucks and vans. There was kind of a gate thingie that the Sisters opened so the vans could pull up, and the Sisters would help unload the produce and take it through the yard into the shelter. Sometimes I was hanging out on the street and/or being a pest… I remember being told by the Sisters more than once to go home and go to bed lol. It was usually in the evening as I recall… when the vans came.
The South Bronx was like a war zone back then. I can’t imagine how you could grow up there and end up with a PhD. Angels protected you. For a reason.
In retrospect yes it was a pretty scary neighborhood, and though it has improved since the 70s its still one of the poorest neighborhoods in America, crime and drug use and so on. At the time though, I didn’t know any better or different, just seemed normal to me. There were a few besides me who “escaped” the neighborhood but lots of classmates of mine are now dead or in prison. Many joined gangs of course so that was a big factor. The last time I was in Manhattan, about 3 years ago, I saw a man on the street who was a classmate of mine, up until about grade 5. He was very dirty and disshevelled looking and I assume a homeless person. I approached him and said who I was but I don’t think he remembered me because he just kept asking for spare change. Eventually I gave him some money and he left. I was sickened, he was such a cute funny kid back in school.

That time in Manhattan 3 years ago, I also had an urge to visit the Sisters in the Bronx, but I couldn’t find a cab willing to take me there!! And I only had a limited time frame so I had to give up…

Part of the reason I was “saved” too I think was, I left the borough when I was 12. The school that priest sent me to was in a much better area, and I’ve not been back to the Bronx since. Really, that priest saved my life, probably quite literally. I wish I could remember his name because I would like to write to him if he’s still alive. I’ve considered contacting the Sisters at my school to see if they know.
My brother in-law also has a similar story. He got a free education at Cardinal Hayes school for boys and ended up very wealthy. Today he is paying it back a thousand times over, supporting Salesian schools for girls and his alma mater. He will do just about anytihng to keep kids in Catholic schools.
Yes, I have that sentiment. I feel so grateful to them and I’ve also sent money to my school, in fact after graduate school and getting my first great job, I sent anonymous donations to the school, totalling the amount of what my tuition would have been. I continue to donate money to them. Not sure why I’m choosing to remain anonymous but so far I have.
Mother Theresa prays for you still, but there is one futher thing to be aware of. You can direct your own prayer intentions to her and she will join you in them. She will pray for your friend and her soul if you aske her.
Wow… okay! That’s great!! 🙂 🙂 I was wondering that, but because she’s not canonized yet I wasn’t sure. I was going to ask the priest but thanks for letting me know.
I revere them. Do you know how in American celebrity culture people put actors and actresses or sports figures or rock musicians on pedestals? I don’t get it. There is nothing admirable about any of them. Those nuns are my real life heroes. The bring the love of God directly into the lives of the most wounded and broken. I would do anything for them.
I know what you mean… I feel the same way about them, always have, though I’ve kept it to myself mostly. Also the priest and the Sisters from my school… all those people were wonderful. One of my friends from school, my best friend in highschool actually, became a nun herself, a Daughter of St. Paul. I’ve kind of lost touch with her now, I sent her a card when she took her perpetual vows a couple of years ago, but we haven’t really been in touch since… she was going to Rome last I heard, and she might still be there, not sure. We were really close friends though, best friends, and now I’m wondering if maybe I shouldn’t track her down and tell her what’s going on.
 
One of my friends from school, my best friend in highschool actually, became a nun herself, a Daughter of St. Paul. I’ve kind of lost touch with her now, I sent her a card when she took her perpetual vows a couple of years ago, but we haven’t really been in touch since… she was going to Rome last I heard, and she might still be there, not sure. We were really close friends though, best friends, and now I’m wondering if maybe I shouldn’t track her down and tell her what’s going on.
DEFINITELY track her down!!! She will be a beautiful, encouraging, supportive and knowledgable friend for you on your journey to Christ and His Church. I know she would love to hear from you.

If you ever have the chance to go to Rome, DO IT!!! It is absolutely beautiful and awe inspiring. There is so much Church history there. The priest that baptized our middle child was assigned to Rome by John Paul II just prior to his death. We went over the summer of 2006 and it was my favorite trip ever. Father Mike took us to all the different churches and explained everything to us. There is a church there (I will have to come up with the name) that has the actual stairs that Jesus went up when he was condemned to death by Pontious Pilot. You have to crawl up them in prayer. St. Helena (Constantine’s mother) sent a bunch of ships back to the Holy Land and brought back so many things. You will leave there knowing that you just witnessed and saw the beginnings and history of Christianity.
 
There is a church there (I will have to come up with the name) that has the actual stairs that Jesus went up when he was condemned to death by Pontious Pilot. You have to crawl up them in prayer. St. Helena (Constantine’s mother) sent a bunch of ships back to the Holy Land and brought back so many things. You will leave there knowing that you just witnessed and saw the beginnings and history of Christianity.
those steps are just outside of the basilica of st. john lateran, the cathedral of the bishop of rome, i.e, the pope. i can’t find the name of the church/chapel with the holy steps right now either. but yes, rome is a must see.
 
I never thought of looking her up on facebook! I was just going to call Boston (the motherhouse) and ask if they knew where she was assigned currently. But that’s a great idea! I wouldn’t be surprised if she is on facebook, given she is a Daughter of St. Paul and their ministry is the media. I’ll let you know if I find her.

Thanks to everyone who’s responded in the last couple of days, and to those who I haven’t responded back to yet, I’m still going to answer you and comment. Just really busy with work right now and I’ve already been on here too much today. This thread seems to have taken on a life of its own and I’m having trouble keeping up! 😉
 
So, I am asking you, as Catholics, what do you think? Is my friend right? Should I avoid the Church or should I try mass and see what happens? I know a bit about the teachings of the Church; to be perfectly honest, some aspects are appealing to me and others are not. I worry I would be attending for the wrong reasons, as my friend suggests. I also do not want to be unintentionally disrespectful to the church, with being an agnostic. Though, lately I feel open to changing my beliefs.

Thank you in advance for any and all responses.
I just found this thread, so please excuse my intrusion. God has cared for you throughout your life. He has cared for you in the happy times, but especially through your suffering. As scripture is a seamless garment from beginning to end, so is your life and how the Lord calls out to you. Look at who came to your assistance during your trials. Look at the love that was shown to you when you likely did not feel very lovable. The Sisters, the Priest, those in the school - all were sent by the Lord to care for you. So, since nothing happens by simple coincidence, there is a reason that there is a Parish nearby, and that you are attracted to it.

Your friend has only a worldly view, not a spiritual view. Since we are created both body and spirit, to address only one of the two is incomplete. There are more complete sources of advice than her, as good a friend as she may be. Consider also that the Lord may very well be using you to call her to a spiritual life…

Also, being Jewish grants you a special blessing. Jesus Himself was sent to the lost sheep of Israel. If this does not describe you, whom does it describe? As to the difficulties of Jewish-Christian conversion, you might seek out Rosalind Moss (originally Moskewitz), who along with her brother David converted to Catholicism. She appears on EWTN frequently. Also, Brother Robert Fischmann is another convert who is an expert on the Old Testament. He also has a program on EWTN. Please consider reading into the blessings that they received before, during and since their conversions.

May the Lord bless you on your journey, and you know that you have prayers and friends here.
 
Is this her? There’s quite a few photographs but if you scroll down there are two of her, with the caption Sr. Andrea underneath:

motherteresa.org/07_family/Volunteering/Ph_v.html

I looked her up, to see if she was the same Sr. Andrea that I vaguely remember. I think it is, though I was very young when she was the superior. Any memories I have of her are very vague, and mixed up with what my mother said about her. When I was an “older” kid, there was an Indian nun who was the superior, her name escapes me at the moment. But my mother definitely knew a Sr. Andrea!
.
I met her when about 33 years ago. She was 45 then.
 
I apologize for not being online for a few days, I was busy with work and then I got the flu! I’m still recovering, been resting a lot. I’m still not up to writing much. I have a bit of good news to share though. I contacted the Sisters who were my highschool teachers. I found them through email and have since exchanged a couple of emails with my principal and also chatted with her on the phone. She was very happy to hear from me and has been encouraging me in my desire to go to mass. She confirmed what everyone here has said; she and the other Sisters have been praying for me all these years.

My principal was also able to tell me where my friend who became a Sister is. She’s no longer in Italy, she is back in the United States, and I now have her phone number and address. I sent her an email today, just waiting for a reply. I’m pretty excited. It was really great re-connecting with the Sisters from my school and I can’t wait to talk to my friend too!

I’m still feeling fairly sick so I’ll close for now but hopefully write more in a few days. Thanks again to everyone for the encouragement and prayers.
 
that’s excellent, susan!
see that, prayers do work.
hopefully you’re sending some to heaven for your friend 🙂
we are too.
 
I apologize for not being online for a few days, I was busy with work and then I got the flu! I’m still recovering, been resting a lot. I’m still not up to writing much. I have a bit of good news to share though. I contacted the Sisters who were my highschool teachers. I found them through email and have since exchanged a couple of emails with my principal and also chatted with her on the phone. She was very happy to hear from me and has been encouraging me in my desire to go to mass. She confirmed what everyone here has said; she and the other Sisters have been praying for me all these years.

My principal was also able to tell me where my friend who became a Sister is. She’s no longer in Italy, she is back in the United States, and I now have her phone number and address. I sent her an email today, just waiting for a reply. I’m pretty excited. It was really great re-connecting with the Sisters from my school and I can’t wait to talk to my friend too!

I’m still feeling fairly sick so I’ll close for now but hopefully write more in a few days. Thanks again to everyone for the encouragement and prayers.
Praise God in Heaven! Knock and the door will be opened unto you!
 
Thanks to all three of you… still not feeling good but just checking in quickly. My friend who became the Sister has emailed me back! 🙂 She wants to get together with me when I come back to the States. I’m really excited, we’ve been catching up a bit and its like no time has passed between us, we are still good friends it seems. My other friend (the atheist) I still have not heard from, in spite of emailing her a few days back. I’m sad about the situation but really not sure what else to do. I emailed her so the ball is in her court now…
 
Thanks to all three of you… still not feeling good but just checking in quickly. My friend who became the Sister has emailed me back! 🙂 She wants to get together with me when I come back to the States. I’m really excited, we’ve been catching up a bit and its like no time has passed between us, we are still good friends it seems. My other friend (the atheist) I still have not heard from, in spite of emailing her a few days back. I’m sad about the situation but really not sure what else to do. I emailed her so the ball is in her court now…
You see the difference between the two that having the love of Christ inside oneself makes! Your atheist friend may now somehow feel threatened by your “religiosity”, as silly as that sounds, and likely is avoiding you. An analogy that comes up is finding that you have a lump and then avoiding a visit to the doctor out of fear that you just might hear good news.

Pray for her, no matter how imperfectly. The Lord will hear your request and He already knows your heart.
 
Thanks to all three of you… still not feeling good but just checking in quickly. My friend who became the Sister has emailed me back! 🙂 She wants to get together with me when I come back to the States. I’m really excited, we’ve been catching up a bit and its like no time has passed between us, we are still good friends it seems. My other friend (the atheist) I still have not heard from, in spite of emailing her a few days back. I’m sad about the situation but really not sure what else to do. I emailed her so the ball is in her court now…
So you got back in contact with the Nuns from your school and your friend? WOW!
This is all terrific news. Very beautiful that the people from your school had been praying for you all this time. I am sure your testimony to them further strengthened their faith. Seems like you have had alot of people who have deeply cared about you all these years. What a blessing.

Cant wait to hear more news from you.
  • Gerrie
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top