The JWs have serious problems with their doctrine of soul sleep. One of the biggest ones is what I like to call the “is it live or is it Memorex?” problem.
You see, the JWs believe that when the spirit or life-force is joined to the body that the man becomes a living soul. They say the following:
“At death the life-force in time leaves all the body cells and the body begins to decay. But this does not mean that our life force literally leaves the earth and travels through space to God. Rather, the spirit returns to God in the sense that now our hope for future life rests entirely with God. Only by his power can the spirit, or life-force, be given back so that we can live again.” -You Can Live Forever in Paradise On Earth page 79
They make it clear that they believe that there is no superiority between humans and animals. On page 77 of the same book quoted above they say:
“The “spirit” that makes animals live is the same as that which makes humans live.”
They also make it clear that when one dies this spirit no longer exists. On page 77 they also say the following:
“At death man’s spirit, his life force, which is sustained by breathing, “goes out”. It no longer exists. So man’s senses of hearing, sight, touch, smell, and taste, which depend upon his being able to think, all stop working. According to the Bible, the dead enter a state of complete unconsciousness.”
So for most JWs, at death they believe their life force goes out and the body decays and all they think and are is gone. For them, there is nothing unique to them that continues to exist in some form. In other words, there is nothing unique to them that is eternal. Their only hope for future life is that God will re-create them from memory. But will this re-creation really be them or just a copy of them if there is nothing about them that is permanent?
Ironically, the JWs at their website say the following about how to think about the resurrection:
“Actually, if you accept the existence of God, you should have no problem believing in the resurrection. To illustrate: A person can videotape his last will and testament, and after he dies, his relatives and friends can see and hear him, in effect, as he explains how his estate is to be handled. A hundred years ago, such a thing was unthinkable. And to some people now living in remote parts of the world, the technology of video recording is so beyond comprehension as to seem miraculous. If scientific principles established by the Creator can be used by humans to reconstruct such a visible and audible scene, should not the Creator be able to do far more? Is it not reasonable, then, that the One who created life is capable of re-creating it?”
watchtower.org/e/we/index.htm?article=article_05.htm
We all know that the videotaped person is just a copy of that person and is not the same as having that actual person in the room with you. But that is the best that the JWs believe that God can do.
In the Catholic perspective, at the moment of conception the child receives an immortal soul from God. The parents participate with God in a special creation of a unique being who has the ability to freely choose to love and serve God for all eternity. The parents collaborate with God in changing the Universe for all eternity by bringing into being with God another immortal soul. At the resurrection when soul and body are reunited, the person is that actual person that once lived and not a mere copy or re-creation of that person as the JWs teach.
Interestingly the JWs’ tract asks,
If scientific principles established by the Creator can be used by humans to reconstruct such a visible and audible scene, should not the Creator be able to do far more?" Ironically, Catholics
do believe that God can and does do more than merely re-create a copy of that individual. It is the JWs themselves that do not believe that God can do more than this. For the JWs’ the best that they believe that God can do is to give us the memorex copy (or videotaped copy), of that individual.
Another thing is that the JWs teach that when those persons who are members of their 144,000 class die they are instantly changed into spirit creatures with a spirit body that goes to heaven to rule with Christ. They describe this process by saying that God transfers their life pattern from their human body to their spiritual body. Hmmmmmmm. I have often thought that the way they describe this “life pattern” that is transferred at death to a spiritual body for those of the 144,000 sounds very much like a human soul.
You guys might find my website helpful and I would like to invite my JW friends here to visit it as well.
www.catholicxjw.com
God’s blessings to all of you,
Jeff Schwehm
President
The Fellowship of Catholic Ex-Jehovah’s Witnesses