The incomplete Gospel

  • Thread starter Thread starter paul_c
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Mick you keep bringing up 2 Tim. 3:16-17 All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work.
You need to look at the whole passage:
2 Timothy 3:14-17
But as for you, continue in what you have learned and have firmly believed, knowing from whom you learned it and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings which are able to instruct you for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus. All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work."

We spoke earlier in the thread about Paul speaking of the old testament when he wrote this. Don’t put your own interpretation to the words, lets read and analyze them for what they say.

Paul is speaking to Timothy saying But as for you He also speaks of continue in what you have learned and have firmly believed So here their is already a belief instilled in him(Timothy)Paul speaks of. Paul does not want timothy to abandon this belief because Paul says he knows where he(Timothy) learned it from knowing from whom you learned it and some thing even more interesting than that, he speaks of scripture. and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings which are able to instruct you for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus. Not only were all the writings not written when this book was written, but Paul is speaking of the old testament writings. and how from childhood you(Timothy) have been acquainted with the sacred writings As a child timothy only had the old testament writings to rely on and Paul is speaking of them as sripture.

The passage you quote to us quite often 2 Tim. 3:16-17 All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work. has no bearing on what scripture is inspired and even less bearing on Sola Scriptura.
Hi Ina,

It is true that the only written Scriptures at that time were OT books, but you seem to have become focused on some sort of anti-Sola Scriptura argument. The SS doctrine is not the main issue as I see it. The central issue is instead, what gospel is the complete one? Is it the biblical gospel, the one that is all about trusting in Jesus, or is it a different gospel that imposes an unbiblical additional requirement on our faith and devotion? Who, or what, is the object of your faith, love, adoration, and devotion? What does the bible teach about this? Did Jesus come here to start a new religion, a religion that takes our focus AWAY from Jesus, or did Jesus teach salvation only in Him?
 
Hi Ina,

It is true that the only written Scriptures at that time were OT books, but you seem to have become focused on some sort of anti-Sola Scriptura argument. The SS doctrine is not the main issue as I see it. The central issue is instead, what gospel is the complete one? Is it the biblical gospel, the one that is all about trusting in Jesus, or is it a different gospel that imposes an unbiblical additional requirement on our faith and devotion? Who, or what, is the object of your faith, love, adoration, and devotion? What does the bible teach about this? Did Jesus come here to start a new religion, a religion that takes our focus AWAY from Jesus, or did Jesus teach salvation only in Him?
Ok Mick

This is getting a little crazy. Are you even hearing or reading what you write? You say, “The SS doctrine is not the main issue as you see it”. Yet you question which Gospel is complete or which is biblical or unbiblical. The only way you can answer any theological question is by going to the bible alone because that’s what you believe. So don’t say that I seem to have become focused on some sort of anti-Sola Scriptura argument. With out the bible you can not answer any question posed to you by anyone and that my friend is sola scriptura. So I would have to say that the focuse comes from your belief of SS which is 100% unbiblical. You can’t go to the bible itself to prove it is the sole rule of faith. That is the real definition of circular reasoning and you’ve been circular with your reasoning throught out this whole thread. You will not open your eyes to the truth beacause of this false notion of sola scriptura. It is the biggest obsticle protestants have when it comes to opening their eyes to the truth. If it’s not in the bible then it’s not true.
 
You wouldn’t even know about the Bible, from which you learned about Jesus, if it wasn’t for the Catholic church, from which it came.
Hi Paul,

Let me tell you a true story that might illustrate to you where your your primary emphasis seems to be. I met my wife through my wife’s cousin, who also happens to be a very beautiful woman. On a couple of occasions I’ve expressed my gratitude to my wife’s cousin for introducing me to my wife.

At this forum, it is hard to miss the most obvious thing we can observe: that the CC has become the primary focus of many people’s faith, love, and devotion. There is nothing wrong or evil for a Catholic to be grateful to the CC if the CC has introduced lots of people to Jesus and His precious good news. But many of you have gone much further than this. It is often said here, by devout Catholics, that outside of the CC there is no salvation.

What would my wife say if I kept on reminding her endlessly about how important her cousin is to me…that, her cousin is the means by which I’ve come to know her, love her, and that without her cousin, I might still be lonely, miserable, and feel incomplete? At some point, my wife will grow a bit weary of the endless praise of her cousin, and she will begin to think that it is her cousin that is important to me! If the biblical God is a jealous God, I’m not going to give the messenger (the church) any more praise than that which is due it.
 
Hi Paul,

Let me tell you a true story that might illustrate to you where your your primary emphasis seems to be. I met my wife through my wife’s cousin, who also happens to be a very beautiful woman. On a couple of occasions I’ve expressed my gratitude to my wife’s cousin for introducing me to my wife.

At this forum, it is hard to miss the most obvious thing we can observe: that the CC has become the primary focus of many people’s faith, love, and devotion. There is nothing wrong or evil for a Catholic to be grateful to the CC if the CC has introduced lots of people to Jesus and His precious good news. But many of you have gone much further than this. It is often said here, by devout Catholics, that outside of the CC there is no salvation.

What would my wife say if I kept on reminding her endlessly about how important her cousin is to me…that, her cousin is the means by which I’ve come to know her, love her, and that without her cousin, I might still be lonely, miserable, and feel incomplete? At some point, my wife will grow a bit weary of the endless praise of her cousin, and she will begin to think that it is her cousin that is important to me! If the biblical God is a jealous God, I’m not going to give the messenger (the church) any more praise than that which is due it.
I tell you what mick, you ideas of theology and explanations of theology are amazing. How could you put you cousin on the same level as the bride of Christ? Then you put your wife on the same level as the groom. That analogy is so out of whack. It doesn’t even make sense.
The church of christ is a visible thing not invisible. Someone(peter) by the grace of God was left incharge here on earth to feed his sheep and tend to his flock.Now that is a real miracle if you ask me.
 
I tell you what mick, you ideas of theology and explanations of theology are amazing. How could you put you cousin on the same level as the bride of Christ? Then you put your wife on the same level as the groom. That analogy is so out of whack. It doesn’t even make sense.
I said it was a true story that might serve to illustrate the seriously misplaced emphasis on the part of many Catholics. I never suggested it to be anything more than a simple way of illustrating my point, which is that it is God alone who is worthy of all praise, honor, love, devotion, and faith. But unfortunately, whenever I try to re-focus this discussion back on the biblical gospel, you guys go right back to how wonderful and indispensable the CC is. It is as though you are so in love with your religion that you’ve completely lost sight of what is truly good, truly necessary, and truly worthy of all our love, faith, and devotion…it looks like the worship of your religion, which is really no different from what devout Muslims and other lost people would want to do.
The church of christ is a visible thing not invisible. Someone(peter) by the grace of God was left incharge here on earth to feed his sheep and tend to his flock.Now that is a real miracle if you ask me.
I rest my case.
 
Hi Paul,

Let me tell you a true story that might illustrate to you where your your primary emphasis seems to be. I met my wife through my wife’s cousin, who also happens to be a very beautiful woman. On a couple of occasions I’ve expressed my gratitude to my wife’s cousin for introducing me to my wife.

At this forum, it is hard to miss the most obvious thing we can observe: that the CC has become the primary focus of many people’s faith, love, and devotion. There is nothing wrong or evil for a Catholic to be grateful to the CC if the CC has introduced lots of people to Jesus and His precious good news. But many of you have gone much further than this. It is often said here, by devout Catholics, that outside of the CC there is no salvation.

What would my wife say if I kept on reminding her endlessly about how important her cousin is to me…that, her cousin is the means by which I’ve come to know her, love her, and that without her cousin, I might still be lonely, miserable, and feel incomplete? At some point, my wife will grow a bit weary of the endless praise of her cousin, and she will begin to think that it is her cousin that is important to me! If the biblical God is a jealous God, I’m not going to give the messenger (the church) any more praise than that which is due it.
Mick,
I can understand why a non-Catholic would be offended by the statement that there is no salvation outside the Catholic church. But that doesn’t make it any less true and it doesn’t lessen our responsibility to tell you what we believe. In fact, telling you that you need to be a member of the Catholic Church to be saved is a work of mercy. You may not see it that way now, but you may someday if you are willing to listen to the Holy Spirit, who led you here.

And you continually set up the false dichotomy that we worship the Church instead of Jesus. We do not. We do not worship the church at all. The church is Jesus’ chosen mechanism to bring people to him. Why can’t you accept that instead of constantly claiming we worship the Chruch instead of God? We don’t claim you worship the Bible instead of Jesus, do we. How is that any different?
 
Mick,
I can understand why a non-Catholic would be offended by the statement that there is no salvation outside the Catholic church. But that doesn’t make it any less true and it doesn’t lessen our responsibility to tell you what we believe. In fact, telling you that you need to be a member of the Catholic Church to be saved is a work of mercy. You may not see it that way now, but you may someday if you are willing to listen to the Holy Spirit, who led you here.

And you continually set up the false dichotomy that we worship the Church instead of Jesus. We do not. We do not worship the church at all. The church is Jesus’ chosen mechanism to bring people to him. Why can’t you accept that instead of constantly claiming we worship the Chruch instead of God? We don’t claim you worship the Bible instead of Jesus, do we. How is that any different?
You don’t really need to worry if I might get offended by what you believe. You should worry about offending God instead!

When I read the bible, it never seems to me that the bible is telling me about how wonderful, necessary, and good, the CATHOLIC CHURCH is. From beginning to end, the bible is all about how wonderful, necessary, and good GOD is. I can tell you for certain that the God of the bible is a jealous God. He can read your attitudes thoughts and intentions and thereby know what it is that you are totally devoted to. Is He your God? Then worship Him, and Him alone!

If your religion is what’s really important to you, then you would be no different from a man who endlessly and tirelessly tells his wife about how much her cousin means to him…for having introduced him to her. Or a man who keeps telling his wife how wonderful the match-making agency is, for making it possible for them to meet. At some point, after years of hearing how wonderful the the match-making service is, the wife will naturally wonder if she means anything to him, especially if he seems a lot more focused on how wonderful the match-making service is, and that there is no love outside of that particular (and wonderful, infallible) match-making service. Wherever your treasure is, there will your heart be also.
 
You don’t really need to worry if I might get offended by what you believe. You should worry about offending God instead!

When I read the bible, it never seems to me that the bible is telling me about how wonderful, necessary, and good, the CATHOLIC CHURCH is. From beginning to end, the bible is all about how wonderful, necessary, and good GOD is. I can tell you for certain that the God of the bible is a jealous God. He can read your attitudes thoughts and intentions and thereby know what it is that you are totally devoted to. Is He your God? Then worship Him, and Him alone!

If your religion is what’s really important to you, then you would be no different from a man who endlessly and tirelessly tells his wife about how much her cousin means to him…for having introduced him to her. Or a man who keeps telling his wife how wonderful the match-making agency is, for making it possible for them to meet. At some point, after years of hearing how wonderful the the match-making service is, the wife will naturally wonder if she means anything to him, especially if he seems a lot more focused on how wonderful the match-making service is, and that there is no love outside of that particular (and wonderful, infallible) match-making service. Wherever your treasure is, there will your heart be also.
Mick, you don’t get it. The Catholic Church is an aid for us to generate a personal relationship with Jesus, teaching us what he taught and who he is, bringing us his graces through the sacraments and teaching us how to reach him through prayer and meditation. You simply are in no position to judge us on this, having never had the benefit yourself. Jesus is not jealous of his church, it is both his bride and his body.

My recommendation to you, stop acting like we worship the church instead of God. Give us that much benefit. I absolutely guarantee that you can’t name one thing you do to worship God that Catholics don’t also do. And I’ll bet you can identify some things Catholics don’t that you don’t do, but you won’t be able to show they are detrimental.
 
You don’t really need to worry if I might get offended by what you believe. You should worry about offending God instead!

When I read the bible, it never seems to me that the bible is telling me about how wonderful, necessary, and good, the CATHOLIC CHURCH is. From beginning to end, the bible is all about how wonderful, necessary, and good GOD is. I can tell you for certain that the God of the bible is a jealous God. He can read your attitudes thoughts and intentions and thereby know what it is that you are totally devoted to. Is He your God? Then worship Him, and Him alone!

If your religion is what’s really important to you, then you would be no different from a man who endlessly and tirelessly tells his wife about how much her cousin means to him…for having introduced him to her. Or a man who keeps telling his wife how wonderful the match-making agency is, for making it possible for them to meet. At some point, after years of hearing how wonderful the the match-making service is, the wife will naturally wonder if she means anything to him, especially if he seems a lot more focused on how wonderful the match-making service is, and that there is no love outside of that particular (and wonderful, infallible) match-making service. Wherever your treasure is, there will your heart be also.
Mick
Jesus shows us that he believes in a higherarchy of authority. So it’s not to far fetched to think that he would leave his church under someones care. What do you think about

Matthew 23:1-3 1(A)Then Jesus spoke to the crowds and to His disciples,
2 saying: "(B)The scribes and the Pharisees have seated themselves in the chair of Moses; 3 therefore all that they tell you, do and observe, but do not do according to their deeds; for they say things and do not do them.

Why is this so important for Jesus to teach?
Where did this idea of chair come from?
How did the Apostles take this teaching?
 
Mick
Jesus shows us that he believes in a higherarchy of authority. So it’s not to far fetched to think that he would leave his church under someones care. What do you think about

Matthew 23:1-3 1(A)Then Jesus spoke to the crowds and to His disciples,
2 saying: "(B)The scribes and the Pharisees have seated themselves in the chair of Moses; 3 therefore all that they tell you, do and observe, but do not do according to their deeds; for they say things and do not do them.

Why is this so important for Jesus to teach?
Where did this idea of chair come from?
How did the Apostles take this teaching?
Hi Ina,

All you are doing now is proving my whole point. To you (it seems from what you are saying) the CC is the main thing, and not God. It wouldn’t be very surprising if people read what you people write, and come to the conclusion that you love the CC and you love CC apologetics rather than the biblical good news. 🙂
 
Hi Ina,

All you are doing now is proving my whole point. To you (it seems from what you are saying) the CC is the main thing, and not God. It wouldn’t be very surprising if people read what you people write, and come to the conclusion that you love the CC and you love CC apologetics rather than the biblical good news. 🙂
YOu are so quick to judge Catholics as loving the church instead of God. What gives you so much insight into the Catholic heart and psyche? You have no basis on which to make these statements except your own perception. Is it possible that you hard just biased against the Catholic Church?
 
YOu are so quick to judge Catholics as loving the church instead of God. What gives you so much insight into the Catholic heart and psyche? You have no basis on which to make these statements except your own perception. Is it possible that you hard just biased against the Catholic Church?
I can’t look into your soul and judge you for worshiping your religion, only God can know these things. But I can tell you how your views, as you’ve expressed them here, appear to me just from what you all have written. Here (below) is what I said to Ina:
All you are doing now is proving my whole point. To you (it seems from what you are saying) the CC is the main thing, and not God. It wouldn’t be very surprising if people read what you people write, and come to the conclusion that you love the CC and you love CC apologetics rather than the biblical good news.
If I’m wrong about what you have written, and that it appears to be a kind of religion worship, I hope you can forgive me for misunderstanding your words. It is not my intention to misunderstand you. I’m only reading your words and interpreting them the best I can.
 
I can’t look into your soul and judge you for worshiping your religion, only God can know these things. But I can tell you how your views, as you’ve expressed them here, appear to me just from what you all have written. Here (below) is what I said to Ina:

If I’m wrong about what you have written, and that it appears to be a kind of religion worship, I hope you can forgive me for misunderstanding your words. It is not my intention to misunderstand you. I’m only reading your words and interpreting them the best I can.
Those are your words, not Ina’s.

I’ll put a challenge out to you. Show me one place where you think we worship the Church rather than God. If you can, then simply change the words in the statement from the church to the Bible, and see whether you wouldn’t be just as guilty of that rhetoric you condemn Catholics for.
 
Those are your words, not Ina’s.

I’ll put a challenge out to you. Show me one place where you think we worship the Church rather than God. If you can, then simply change the words in the statement from the church to the Bible, and see whether you wouldn’t be just as guilty of that rhetoric you condemn Catholics for.
Sorry, you are wrong about this. The Church still claims there is no salvation outside it. The Catechism of the Catholic Church very carefully explains what the Church means/doesn’t mean by that. You need to read it.
Jesus said, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”
Jesus said, “I tell you the truth, the man who does not enter the sheep pen by the gate, but climbs in by some other way, is a thief and a robber.”
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by paul c
Those are your words, not Ina’s.

I’ll put a challenge out to you. Show me one place where you think we worship the Church rather than God. If you can, then simply change the words in the statement from the church to the Bible, and see whether you wouldn’t be just as guilty of that rhetoric you condemn Catholics for.

Quote:
Sorry, you are wrong about this. The Church still claims there is no salvation outside it. The Catechism of the Catholic Church very carefully explains what the Church means/doesn’t mean by that. You need to read it.

Quote:
Jesus said, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”

Quote:
Jesus said, “I tell you the truth, the man who does not enter the sheep pen by the gate, but climbs in by some other way, is a thief and a robber.”
Mick, How does this demonstrate that we worship the Church rather than God? Because we think you need to follow the Church’s teachings to get to Heaven? You think you need to follow the Bible to get to Heaven, right? Well that is a Church teaching.
 
I appreciate what the OP is trying to do and even agree with most/all of it substantially. I just think it might be too broad and tend to invite a “free for all” where almost any statement could be construed as ‘on topic’…
 
I appreciate what the OP is trying to do and even agree with most/all of it substantially. I just think it might be too broad and tend to invite a “free for all” where almost any statement could be construed as ‘on topic’…
Why is that a problem?
 
On these pages, there are often discussions started by Evangelicals / Protestants that claim that we Catholics teach a different Gospel from them. Well, I would like to discuss a different hypothesis, that the Protestants/ Evangelicals actually teach AN INCOMPLETE GOSPEL in comparison with the Catholic Church, which has the fullness of truth. Of course, depending on the closeness of their teaching to the Catholic Church, different denomination’s Gospels are more or less incomplete.

Here’s my proof points for discussion:
  1. Protestants can not show that they do a single thing that Catholics don’t also do toward their salvation. And here’s an open challenge to any that question this statement: give us an example of what you do that Catholics don’t also do. I started a thread that reached 200 posts and not one person claimed they did something that Catholics don’t also do. In fact, many Evangelicals countered that there wasn’t anything to do for Salvation, because Christ did all the work.
  1. Everyone can identify things that Catholics do toward salvation that Protestants don’t also do, starting with the 7 sacraments and extending to devotions like eucharistic adoration, the stations on the cross, rosaries, novenas, etc. But no one has been able to show that any of these things are detrimental to the soul. Some said they were not required to be saved, but its hard to argue that confessing your sins to a priest, going to mass, or praying a rosary could in any way harm your soul.
  2. When you talk about core beliefs, the Protestant views are typically truncated views of what Catholics teach.
    a) Protestants teach sola scriptura, Catholics include Sacred Tradition and the views of the Magesterium as valid truths
    b) Protestants teach Sola Fide, while Catholics say that Faith must be completed with works of love to gain eternal life
    c) Protestants believe in the priesthood of the people. Catholics believe that priests must be validly ordained by a Bishop who is part of apostolic succession.
    d) Protestant’s believe that you must develop a faithful relationship with Jesus Christ, Catholics say not only do you need to develop such a relationship, but you must also follow in his footsteps, loving God and Neighbor to achieve eternal life.
    e) Protestants say that you must repent of your sins, Catholics believe that you must do this sacramentally to regain saving grace.
And so it goes, Protestants/ Evangelicals consistently preach a truncated Gospel, requiring less than the Catholic Church teaches.

Now to be sure, there are individual Protestants / Evangelicals who do more than their church expects of them and thus approach what a devout Catholic does (except they don’t partake of valid sacraments) and this is not to condemn anyone.

I simply want to point out that the Protestant Gospel is just an incomplete version of the one true Gospel. Can anyone really counter this with examples of what Protestants do that the Catholics don’t also do?
Paul, you may also point out to them that the Bible does not contain everything Jesus said or did. Refer them to John 21:25. Also, mention that if one were to compile every quote of Jesus from the New Testament, it would only be about 15-20 pages, and take less than 2 hours to read aloud. Do they believe that everything Jesus said in His three year ministry could be said in less than two hours?! I would think not!

Then, point out that Jesus commanded the Apostles to go and teach all that He had taught them. (Refer them to Matt. 28:20.) So, this creates a gap in their approach to “God’s Word.” Not everything is written down (Scripture), BUT Jesus commanded the Apostles (and their successors) to teach ALL that He had taught them.

So, how does one fill this gap? With Oral Tradition, a.k.a., Holy Tradition. Refer them to 2 Thes 2:15 where St. Paul makes Oral Tradition (Holy Tradition) the equal of Written Tradition (Scripture). That’ll give 'em something to chew on…unless, of course, they’re not intellectually honest.
 
Why is that a problem?
Good question.

Aside from the intrinsic problem (pages and pages of replies and rarely seeing one that is addressing the topic - or in this case subtopic) the moderators here have been known to shut down threads that don’t stay on topic.

My experience with certain (not all) detractors of the Faith is they tend to switch topics when confronted. Seems to me having a needlessly broad topic only invites this sort of behavior.
 
Good question.

Aside from the intrinsic problem (pages and pages of replies and rarely seeing one that is addressing the topic - or in this case subtopic) the moderators here have been known to shut down threads that don’t stay on topic.

My experience with certain (not all) detractors of the Faith is they tend to switch topics when confronted. Seems to me having a needlessly broad topic only invites this sort of behavior.
Well, my main goal is still to prove the point that Catholics do everything a Protestant /Evangelical does and more. And that the more includes the sacraments.

I have yet to find one Protestant / evangelical that can claim he does something toward his salvation or in support of the Kingdom of God that a Catholic doesn’t also do.

Usually, as you say, when confronted with theis fact, they switch topics . For instance, MIck Taylor took to saying that Catholics worship the Church instead of God. Without any substantiation other than his own perception, of course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top