The myth of Adam and Eve

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bahman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Could you please offer your opinion which could be the result what you have read somewhere instead of simple quoting? It is really hard to follow you.
Those quotes answer your questions:

That angels could fall because they were not in Heaven when they sinned. The same is true of mankind. God allows evil to happen because He has given free will, both to angels and mankind.

Through free will we can be Christlike and choose good, to love God and neighbor. Without free will we would be unable to choose to love and would then not be Christlike.
 
I feel I do have answers, found in Christ, Scripture, and the Church.
So what is God’s purpose?
But that’s neither here nor there at the moment. You can’t make it an objection to the existence or goodness of God and then admit there could be a good reason you’re not aware of.
I don’t understand you. Could you please elaborate?
So your third point is completely moot.
I don’t understand you.
 
Well, I know why I suffer. Most of the time my own suffering falls under my “Wrench theory of learning.” I go about life trying to fix the world, to do my best, to have a good life with this wrench. Inadvertently, I have been using the wrench to beat on my own head. Finally, at some point, I realize that I have been making a bloody painful mess, especially on myself, and say something very insightful and intelligent like “Oh, that hurts.”

Sometimes I wonder if hours on the CAF are such a wrench for me.

Then, I put the wrench down. I have suffered, and I have learned something.

Then, of course, I reach for a new wrench… 😉

The rest of it, natural disasters and so forth, fall under “deconstruction in order to build”, or some other perhaps seemingly unpurposeful natural occurrence. There must be some reason, but I don’t know it exactly. I do not know that God is Love because of natural disasters, I know that God is Love because that is how I experience Him in myself and other people, in creation itself.

So, to me, suffering serves a purpose. We have evolved (been created) with a capacity to suffer so that we avoid doing those things that take away from our ability to thrive.

What do you think? Does that raise more questions? Can you relate, a little?
Interesting. What is purpose in your opinion?
 
So we won’t be so attached to the world. At some point we are all going to die. Suffering is a way to willingly let go of this world. There’s a better place afterwards.
That was not a good answers to my question. What is the purpose?
 
Really??? No Adam and Eve, No us. No original sin, No need for Jesus to redeem people who don’t actually exist. So what do you think this is all about ? The “smarter” we get, it seems we know more than God. I TRUST HIM! God Bless, Memaw
:ehh:
Screaming “I TRUST HIM!” is neither a logical argument nor likely to advance the debate.

Implying that I assert that there is “No us” is just bizarre.

As it happens, I personally do not believe in a literal Adam and Eve or original sin, but nowhere here did I deny that Catholics should or do do so.

All I said was that issues such as questioning why God chose to put the Tree of the knowledge of good and evil in the same garden as Adam and Eve without so much as a fence around it are easily resolved by not trying to interpret Genesis too literally. 🤷

Do any serious modern Catholic theologians interpret ‘original sin’ as the physical act of a woman eating a fruit? If they do, then is the OP’s question not a reasonable one? Your username suggests that you have raised at least one generation - would you leave a toddler with no understanding of alcohol poisoning alone with a tankard of vodka with no more than a verbal warning not to drink it? How, for that matter, could an omnipotent omnipresent omniscient God not know of and intervene in the situation as it occurred? If, that is, you interpret it literally.
 
i know, I am one of them but at the same time I am joyful at being able to offer up my pain to my Lord and Savior with the knowledge that it is not in vain but allows me to glorify God through that which I suffer.
I am so sorry for your suffering. I however don’t understand your way of approaching toward life and suffering.
 
Those quotes answer your questions:

That angels could fall because they were not in Heaven when they sinned. The same is true of mankind. God allows evil to happen because He has given free will, both to angels and mankind.

Through free will we can be Christlike and choose good, to love God and neighbor. Without free will we would be unable to choose to love and would then not be Christlike.
That is kinda strange to me if we could sin in Heaven. This means that heaven becomes empty after a while.
 
.

The answer to all these questions lies in the answer to why Jesus was called the “new Adam”?

.
 
:ehh:
Screaming “I TRUST HIM!” is neither a logical argument nor likely to advance the debate.

Implying that I assert that there is “No us” is just bizarre.

As it happens, I personally do not believe in a literal Adam and Eve or original sin, but nowhere here did I deny that Catholics should or do do so.

All I said was that issues such as questioning why God chose to put the Tree of the knowledge of good and evil in the same garden as Adam and Eve without so much as a fence around it are easily resolved by not trying to interpret Genesis too literally. 🤷

Do any serious modern Catholic theologians interpret ‘original sin’ as the physical act of a woman eating a fruit? If they do, then is the OP’s question not a reasonable one? Your username suggests that you have raised at least one generation - would you leave a toddler with no understanding of alcohol poisoning alone with a tankard of vodka with no more than a verbal warning not to drink it? How, for that matter, could an omnipotent omnipresent omniscient God not know of and intervene in the situation as it occurred? If, that is, you interpret it literally.
The “original” the sin was the “original” disobedience of our “Original” parents, Adam and Eve.
Adam and Eve were created with infused knowledge and were capable of making a decision to either obey God or disobey HIM. They had a free will, just as you and I do to either believe HIM or not. I DO TRUST in HIM and shout it I will, forever! God Bless, Memaw
 
That was not a good answers to my question. What is the purpose?
I don’t care if you think it’s a “good” answer or not. The truth is Bahman , you are going to die. If you become too attached to this world, you will not want to leave it. The reason you do not want to leave it is because you do not believe in the afterlife, you think this life is all there is. In the afterlife there will be no more suffering, except if you turn away from God in this life, and in that case you will have infinite suffering in Hell, which is just another way of saying you will never be near God. In this life, even if you suffer, you can be comforted by the fact that God is near you always.
 
I am so sorry for your suffering. I however don’t understand your way of approaching toward life and suffering.
This is simply because you are not yet a believer, but God will have you if you allow Him.🙂
 
I don’t care if you think it’s a “good” answer or not. The truth is Bahman , you are going to die. If you become too attached to this world, you will not want to leave it. The reason you do not want to leave it is because you do not believe in the afterlife, you think this life is all there is. In the afterlife there will be no more suffering, except if you turn away from God in this life, and in that case you will have infinite suffering in Hell, which is just another way of saying you will never be near God. In this life, even if you suffer, you can be comforted by the fact that God is near you always.
I don’t understand where did you find all these thing about my system belief. They don’t really reflect who I am.
 
Lets put fact together to see if a God who is all wise allows this:
  1. Fall of angles: It is mentioned that angels fall was because of sin of pride. It however doesn’t mentioned that how one can sin in blessed Heaven. State of mind is the state of love and harmony in haven. How then angels could fall?
  2. Fall of Adam and Eve: Fall of Adam and Eve was because of eating the fruit from the tree of knowledge. Why God should keep the tree in the garden knowing the fact Adam and Eve would eat it? Moreover why God give access to the garden to Satan knowing the fact that he can manage to tempt Adam and Eve?
  3. It is obvious that a God who is all wise wouldn’t allow to this happen. The only option which is available is that all these were part of God plan. But how a God who is all good can allow that evil happen?
Your thought?
It looks like you’ve put a lot of thought into these questions, and I get the feeling they are coming from a sincere desire to understand or at least seek out Truth (with a capital T). As it says in your profile for what your religion is, you are looking “wherever it may go” so I believe you are definitely searching with a sincere heart.

The questions are great, and I want to address them one by one. But first I want to address something that you emphasize and see if we can agree on something.

You talk about God’s wisdom and this seems to be the emphasis in your questions. You look to be confused on God’s Wisdom in making certain choices, particularly regarding our (and the angel’s) freedom.

When we think of wisdom we tend to lean towards “logic” and “knowledge” as being the major factors. So, say I wanted to build a robot that would clean my house and cook my food. It would be “wise” for me in that instance to not program into the robot the ability to disobey my commands because logic says that if it can disobey me then it may not carry out the tasks that I ask of it.

But God’s Wisdom does not work solely on logic and knowledge. God’s wisdom operates first from a pure Love. And when I say Love here, I do not mean wanting to be “kind” or "nice’ the loved, but willing what is best for the Loved. God’s Love wants us in heaven next to Him, and we get there by developing a genuine relationship with Him and by coming to love Him just as purely as He loves us.

In God’s Wisdom, acting out of His Love, He did not decide to make a robot that could carry out tasks for Him, but to make something to have a genuine relationship with. And any genuine relationship requires consensus from both sides. This means that we need to be able to say “no” to Him in order for our “yes” to actually mean anything.

To your questions:
  1. There’s no reason to believe that the angels were not given some freedom of choice.
  2. It is important to remember that this story is a myth (a story bearing Truth). We do not know the exact action that took place, but we do know that it had to do with man’s desire to be like God, or to be His equal. But for our relationship with God to be pure and based in Truth, we need to understand that we are not God’s equal. He is Creator, we are created.
  3. How can God allow evil to happen? If He was a tyrannical ruler, or ‘robot programmer’ (which He could have done) then we would all make all the right actions at all the right times, but they would not be out of love for Him. They would be out of ‘programming.’ In this case, there is not genuine relationship. Even though our ‘yes’ would be prompt and absolute, it would be completely devoid of meaning. And if our ‘yes’ is meaningless, than our state of grace in heaven is rendered meaningless as well. Is that what is best for us?
I don’t think so.

What I think is interesting is that in the story of The Fall we see our desire to be like God, which is the complete opposite of the mindless robot analogy I used. But when we challenge the ‘wisdom’ of God to put the Tree of Knowledge in the garden in the first place we immediately ask something along the lines of ‘why not make us perfect choice-making robots’?

Any thoughts?
 
There is no right or wrong way to tie my shoelaces. I’m just happy that they don’t come undone. You all are undoing my shoelaces.😃
 
That is kinda strange to me if we could sin in Heaven. This means that heaven becomes empty after a while.
When the angels fell, they were not in heavenm abnd when our first parents fell, they were not in heaven, so there is no decrease of beings in heaven.
 
I was asking what is God’s purpose for creation?
O SON OF MAN! Veiled in My immemorial being and in the ancient eternity of My essence, I knew My love for thee; therefore I created thee, have engraved on thee Mine image and revealed to thee My beauty. - Baha’u’llah

reference.bahai.org/en/t/b/HW/hw-4.html

I am confident the Catholic perspective for God’s purpose for creation is similar, namely, to know God, and to worship Him through deeds of love.

.
 
I don’t understand where did you find all these thing about my system belief. They don’t really reflect who I am.
I don’t think you have a “belief system”. I think you have a “disbelief system”!🙂
 
I was asking what is God’s purpose for creation?
To manifest and share himself with us, and for us to find our ultimate purpose in him.

CCC 293 Scripture and Tradition never cease to teach and celebrate this fundamental truth: "The world was made for the glory of God."134 St. Bonaventure explains that God created all things “not to increase his glory, but to show it forth and to communicate it”,135 for God has no other reason for creating than his love and goodness: "Creatures came into existence when the key of love opened his hand."136 The First Vatican Council explains:

This one, true God, of his own goodness and “almighty power”, not for increasing his own beatitude, nor for attaining his perfection, but in order to manifest this perfection through the benefits which he bestows on creatures, with absolute freedom of counsel "and from the beginning of time, made out of nothing both orders of creatures, the spiritual and the corporeal. . ."137

294 The glory of God consists in the realization of this manifestation and communication of his goodness, for which the world was created. God made us “to be his sons through Jesus Christ, according to the purpose of his will, to the praise of his glorious grace”,138 for "the glory of God is man fully alive; moreover man’s life is the vision of God: if God’s revelation through creation has already obtained life for all the beings that dwell on earth, how much more will the Word’s manifestation of the Father obtain life for those who see God."139 The ultimate purpose of creation is that God "who is the creator of all things may at last become “all in all”, thus simultaneously assuring his own glory and our beatitude."140
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top