He was asked specifically if they use the “Task” board
Boards are a common tool in collaborative projects. In software form I use Azure Boards and Trello. Some people just use a white board with columns drawn on it and post-it notes for the tasks that make up a project. There’s not a lot of information to extract from the use of such a thing.
(
Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
to coordinate their responses with regard to censoring certain pieces of information and links.
They didn’t have an agreement on this. Mark said he disagreed with the characterization from which Josh was speaking.
Josh Halley also expressed the belief that the board was somehow indicative of collaboration with entities outside of Facebook. He didn’t share how he came to this conclusion.
He couldn’t answer that. What precisely would he not know?
Josh was asking about coordination between Facebook and other companies. Mark shared the collaboration of which he does know (security, child exploitation content, signals around terrorist attacks, foreign government influence operations).
Josh got a little more specific.
“Do your Facebook moderation teams speak with their counterparts at Twitter or Google.”
This got a reply “I am not aware of anything specific.” That may be his honest answer. Had he answered that question with “No,” and if there were any single person in the moderation team that has had a conversation with someone at either of these companies about moderation, then his sworn statement would be false. There is no way to know what conversations that people at a company of 45,000 people have had.
Josh also asked for a list of every item in their collaboration tool that mentioned Google or Twitter. Mark did not commit. This was also reasonable. Had he committed, and if there is any item that is not appropriate for public consumption (such as because of contractual obligation), then the only options are to either violate a confidentiality agreement or break the commitment. I can think of other reasonable motivations to not commit.
A better person to talk to about Facebooks moderation practices would have been Monika Bickert (VP of Global Policy Management).