I was in my 30’s when I got pregnant out of wedlock, and my parents believed that I should put the baby up for adoption. My mom died just before my son was born, and she died thinking that I was being selfish and making a terrible mistake. I cried at my wedding last winter because she never got to see that it all turned out OK. My father has said that, much to his utter amazement, having the baby was the best thing that ever happened to me and my whole life has been vastly better since then.
I bring this up because reading this thread has reopened some of those wounds. It really, really hurts to be told that you wouldn’t be a good mother/don’t deserve the baby/are selfish to want to keep the baby when there are so many “better” people out there. To this day - even though I lead a good, stable life and my child wants for absolutely nothing - I sometimes wonder if, after all, there weren’t some perfect couple out there that would be better parents than I could ever be.
My mother was already preoccupied with her own cancer, but she just never did get on board with the baby thing… when I brought it up - to show her sonogram photos or whatever, perhaps naively hoping this would give her something besides chemo and pain to think about - she would just go kinda blank and I could see that she wasn’t really able to be happy about it. I asked her “Do you think maybe you could, you know, be optimistic about this baby?” and she just said, “but, how can you raise a child as a single mother? How can I see that as anything but tragic?”
It hurts very deeply that my mother died so profoundly disappointed in me, and that she never had any confidence in me.
So… maybe those posters here who are focusing on the fact that this girl is 17 and behaving irrationally are justified in worrying about the baby, but trying to force her to put the baby up for adoption could harm her in ways you can’t imagine. Think about it - who here can even imagine giving up one of their babies? I know I couldn’t do it.
We don’t know for sure that she will continue to rebell. She may just be scared. Maybe there’s been a power struggle over adoption for the whole pregnancy. Maybe, if you give her some compassion and say, “How can I help you to be a good mother?” and really try to be enthused about the baby, she’ll come around. It will probably be a bumpy ride, since she’s 17 and growing up overnight isn’t going to happen, but it needn’t be a total disaster.