Vaccinations Should Be Mandatory - Ben Carson

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lost_Sheep
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Just for lagniappe, here’s a timeline about smallpox and inoculation/vaccination: historyofvaccines.org/content/timelines/all.

Gen. George Washington ordered that all troops who had not previously had smallpox be inoculated.
Andrew Jackson caught smallpox while being held by the British and his brother (likewise a POW) died of it.

Inoculation was not with a clean, sterile needle, it consisted of taking pus from someone who had active smallpox and and scratching the patient with it, often with a feather of the like.

Our benighted forbears didn’t have anyone to warn them about Big Pharma or Big Government. They did know all about smallpox since they had all lost friends, spouse and children.
 
“incentives” and “force” are just two points along the same continuum. When incentives are strong enough, they become de facto force. How about this incentive: You can have the benefit of moving around and being a part of this society only if you consent. There, that’s not force.
Not necessarily.

If you offered, say, a 500 dollar tax credit for every child immunized, no one is forcing your hand. Your rights remain the same as the general population whether you accept or decline.

If you add a punitive penalty of a thousand dollar fine for failure to vaccinate, it’s an action of force.
 
Just for lagniappe, here’s a timeline about smallpox and inoculation/vaccination: historyofvaccines.org/content/timelines/all.

Gen. George Washington ordered that all troops who had not previously had smallpox be inoculated.
Andrew Jackson caught smallpox while being held by the British and his brother (likewise a POW) died of it.

Inoculation was not with a clean, sterile needle, it consisted of taking pus from someone who had active smallpox and and scratching the patient with it, often with a feather of the like.

Our benighted forbears didn’t have anyone to warn them about Big Pharma or Big Government. They did know all about smallpox since they had all lost friends, spouse and children.
“Lagniappe” - one of my favorite words. I try to use it every day, if only in my head.

I think all children should be vaccinated, as it’s a matter of public health.
 
“Lagniappe” - one of my favorite words. I try to use it every day, if only in my head.

I think all children should be vaccinated, as it’s a matter of public health.
That sound you hear is the sound of my vocabulary enlarging. 🙂 I never heard that word before.
 
Not necessarily.

If you offered, say, a 500 dollar tax credit for every child immunized, no one is forcing your hand. Your rights remain the same as the general population whether you accept or decline.

If you add a punitive penalty of a thousand dollar fine for failure to vaccinate, it’s an action of force.
But that’s essentially the same thing (except for the fact that one is $500 and the other is $1000). Not getting the tax credit that everyone else is getting means you have to pay more in taxes. That has the same effect on your bank account as having to pay the same amount and calling it a fine.
 
But that’s essentially the same thing (except for the fact that one is $500 and the other is $1000). Not getting the tax credit that everyone else is getting means you have to pay more in taxes. That has the same effect on your bank account as having to pay the same amount and calling it a fine.
You’re not paying any more, you’re just not paying less. Next year, I’ll be able to take a deduction for my mortgage payments. If I choose to do so, I’ll be paying less taxes. If I don’t, I won’t be paying any more, I’ll simply be paying the same as I did this year.
 
But that’s essentially the same thing (except for the fact that one is $500 and the other is $1000). Not getting the tax credit that everyone else is getting means you have to pay more in taxes. That has the same effect on your bank account as having to pay the same amount and calling it a fine.
No it isn’t.

In the benefits case: One is enhancing your position(more money) if you agree and your status remains neutral if you don’t consent.

In the punitive tax case: One is hurting your status(less money) while the other remains the status quo (getting the vaccine)

For example: There’s a mortgage interest deduction in the US Tax Code. This is an incentive for some people to buy a house. It does not affect people who are not buying a house. There is no element of force that is making you buy a house.

Say a person walked door to door offering 500 dollars, no strings attached. You are free to refuse the money, no one is forcing you to take it, and the fact that everyone else will likely take it doesn’t mean there was any coercion involved.
 
That sound you hear is the sound of my vocabulary enlarging. 🙂 I never heard that word before.
Always glad to be of service.
I’ve known the word for a long time, it means a little something extra, like the 13th donut in a baker’s dozen but I just found out the history from a podcast awhile ago. It comes from some Meso-American languange as “napa”, it was adopted into Spanish as “(ny)apa” – sorry, I can’t do the tilde. The Spanish brought it New Orleans where the French la (the) (ny)apa turned into lagniappe. In English I’ve heard it pronounced closer to the French “lahn-yahp” or more Anglicised, “lane-yap.”

I love English, we’ll steal anything from anywhere 😃
 
I read somewhere that reactions are very slim. Like, you are more likely to be struck by lightening. So, I’m not worried about it. I besides if they were going to get a reaction you would think it would happen the first time.🤷
The current US vaccine injury reporting system does a very poor job of capturing vaccine injuries. The system relies mostly on self reporting and most people don’t know what a vaccine injury looks like.
 
This kind of talk by ucfengr is irresponsible. Check out the CDC website which cites cases of polio worldwide as 483 in 2001: when rumors about the vaccine’s safety came out in 2003, refusal of vaccine by parents in Nigeria led to increase in number of cases & spread of the virus in nearby countries that were previously polio-free. In 2003, there were 784 reported cases, in 2004, 1255 cases.
The problem in places like Nigeria isn’t a lack of polio vaccine, it’s a lack of sanitation. Polio is passed by the fecal-oral route. If you have proper sanitation, it isn’t a problem.

Polio, 90% of the time, only results in mild intestinal distress. Rarely it can attack the myelin sheaths surrounding the nerves (polio myelitis) leading to muscular weakness, and in rare cases, paralysis. We don’t know why polio sometimes becomes virulent, but it was speculated in an article “The Age of Polio” that it might be a synergistic reaction to heavy metal poisoning. The first serious polio outbreaks in the US occurred in agricultural areas effected by gypsy moths. Lead Arsenate pesticides were used heavily to combat the gypsy moth. These pesticides are very neuro-toxic and may have provided a route for an opportunistic polio infection to become virulent.

ageofautism.com/2011/09/the-age-of-polio-how-an-old-virus-and-new-toxins-triggered-a-man-made-epidemic.html
 
No it isn’t.

In the benefits case: One is enhancing your position(more money) if you agree and your status remains neutral if you don’t consent.
No, your status does not remain neutral, because to pay for the tax break, they will undoubtedly raise taxes overall.
 
The problem in places like Nigeria isn’t a lack of polio vaccine, it’s a lack of sanitation. Polio is passed by the fecal-oral route. If you have proper sanitation, it isn’t a problem.

Polio, 90% of the time, only results in mild intestinal distress. Rarely it can attack the myelin sheaths surrounding the nerves (polio myelitis) leading to muscular weakness, and in rare cases, paralysis. We don’t know why polio sometimes becomes virulent, but it was speculated in an article “The Age of Polio” that it might be a synergistic reaction to heavy metal poisoning. The first serious polio outbreaks in the US occurred in agricultural areas effected by gypsy moths. Lead Arsenate pesticides were used heavily to combat the gypsy moth. These pesticides are very neuro-toxic and may have provided a route for an opportunistic polio infection to become virulent.

ageofautism.com/2011/09/the-age-of-polio-how-an-old-virus-and-new-toxins-triggered-a-man-made-epidemic.html
Is this accepted science? Why I ask is that I date back to pre-Salk days, and my distinct memory is that my parents prevented me from going swimming when polio was raging. Many parents did. And it’s difficult to see FDR’s polio as attributable to poor sanitation or the “fecal-oral route.”
 
Not necessarily.

If you offered, say, a 500 dollar tax credit for every child immunized, no one is forcing your hand. Your rights remain the same as the general population whether you accept or decline.

If you add a punitive penalty of a thousand dollar fine for failure to vaccinate, it’s an action of force.
Refusing to vaccinate your kids unless I remit money to you is extortion. If parents want to risk the death of their own children then thats fine but they should be held legally liable if their children spread the disease to someone else.
 
I think this is the story you’re referring to:

freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/oakland/2015/02/03/measles-vaccine-family-neglect-oakland-county-brian-kenny-daniel-bagdade-attorney-oakland-county/22827221/

The children weren’t removed because they hadn’t been vaccinated - they were removed for abuse and neglect, and then after that happened, the attorney found that they hadn’t been vaccinated.

I do think this is an interesting case, and one I plan to keep an eye on - as the ruling could have future implications for cases. The children aren’t currently under parental custody, and it is unclear if they will return there or not, but the parents do not want their children to be vaccinated, due to their personal research and beliefs. If the children are permanently removed, then the parents’ opinions wouldn’t matter anymore in terms of if it’s legal to vaccinate the children against their wishes, but this middle ground waiting period that they’re currently in seems to be a little more grey on the issue.
Thank-you for the clarification. I first heard the story this morning on WJR, a major radio station of the area and all that was mentioned was that there were four kids being threaten with removal due to the fact that they were not vaccinated for measles yet. There was no other mention of abuse or neglect or drug use etc by the parents. It looks like a complex story and I can see how it can be used to charge up people over vaccinations.
 
Is this accepted science? Why I ask is that I date back to pre-Salk days, and my distinct memory is that my parents prevented me from going swimming when polio was raging. Many parents did. And it’s difficult to see FDR’s polio as attributable to poor sanitation or the “fecal-oral route.”
Yes. Polio is an intestinal virus passed primarily through the “fecal-oral” route. You have to remember, FDR contracted polio in the 1920s, when water sanitation was no where near as comprehensive as it is now. Farmers using human waste as fertilizer was also fairly common.
 
Yes. Polio is an intestinal virus passed primarily through the “fecal-oral” route. You have to remember, FDR contracted polio in the 1920s, when water sanitation was no where near as comprehensive as it is now. Farmers using human waste as fertilizer was also fairly common.
Agricultural run-off, yes - my mother contracted polio as a child from swimming in a lake. She eventually recovered but missed nearly a year of school.
 
The current US vaccine injury reporting system does a very poor job of capturing vaccine injuries. The system relies mostly on self reporting and most people don’t know what a vaccine injury looks like.
You are worried about something so minimal that it isn’t reported? Lol Alrighty.
 
Refusing to vaccinate your kids unless I remit money to you is extortion.
There are plenty of incentives in the tax code for all sorts of behaviors. I don’t consider those extortion.
If parents want to risk the death of their own children then thats fine but they should be held legally liable if their children spread the disease to someone else.
Agree in principle, but good luck proving it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top