Vaccinations Should Be Mandatory - Ben Carson

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lost_Sheep
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You are worried about something so minimal that it isn’t reported? Lol Alrighty.
Well, no, that’s not what I said. What I actually said is that relying on people (parents) who don’t know what a vaccine injury looks like to report vaccine injuries is going to lead to dramatic underreporting.
 
I think the democrats are trying to spark an interest in vaccinations in order to get more people to sign up for obamacare… They know that if they line republicans up as being anti-vaccination, then all liberals will immediately flock to get vaccinated.
 
The Autism thing is a fraud, adverse effects are not.

cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/side-effects.htm

Parents have to do a risk-benefits analysis. Saying, “well you your child was the one in a million that had a severe reaction, sorry about that.” doesn’t cut it. There are risks, even if those risks are rare. Parents have the right to gauge whether the risks outweigh the benefits. Just because I believe the benefits outweigh the risks doesn’t mean another parent has the same mentality.

As I stated earlier, if you want “herd immunization”, make incentives to do so without resorting to force.
The “incentive” is that we care for others, especially helpless children, and we want to do whatever we can (without sinning) that will keep them healthy and alive.

I shouldn’t have to be paid $500 or any money to be kind to others.
 
My opinion? If one wants to avoid needles and the risks, (minute risk) for them or their children, and thereby contribute to the possibility of an outbreak of disease, knowing some cannot be vaccinated for health reasons, that is not liberty. That is cowardice. It is contrary to the teaching of St. Paul who said.

Philippians 2:
Let nothing be done through strife or vainglory; but in lowliness of mind let each esteem other better than themselves.
**
Look not every man on his own things, but every man also on the things of others**.
It is contrary to the Gospel that we put ourselves first and the good of others last.

Now you mays say, “But they are my children and I am supposed to put their good first.” The child you raise will learn from you, mostly by your example. If you are teaching that you and your family come first, they will learn that. If you teach others should come first, they will learn that. If my son could not possibly get the measles, yet he could contract and spread them, I would still have him vaccinated and incur the risk solely for the sake of other children. Even though my job is to look after his health, my first obligation is to see to his soul and stand and say, “As for me an my house, we will serve the Lord.” As fathers, we stand as leader for the whole family, including making sacrifices.

But, yes, I think TEPO is also right in that this current push is political.
 
The “incentive” is that we care for others, especially helpless children, and we want to do whatever we can (without sinning) that will keep them healthy and alive.

I shouldn’t have to be paid $500 or any money to be kind to others.
It’s a greater evil for the state to usurp the parent’s right to raise their kids how they deem proper. The parent’s first priority is to their family, even before society at large. A tax incentive is a reasonable compromise to get enough action to achieve herd immunity. As I said, vaccines are a risk/reward issue. Not vaccinating is not child abuse.
 
My opinion? If one wants to avoid needles and the risks, (minute risk) for them or their children, and thereby contribute to the possibility of an outbreak of disease, knowing some cannot be vaccinated for health reasons, that is not liberty. That is cowardice. It is contrary to the teaching of St. Paul who said.

Philippians 2:

It is contrary to the Gospel that we put ourselves first and the good of others last.
The problem with this is people concerned with vaccine safety aren’t convinced that we’re being given an accurate appraisal of the actual risks involved or the actual benefits. Polio, for example is something every vaccine supporter likes to bring up, usually by painting lurid pictures of kids in iron lungs. But the reality is due to improved sanitation, polio had been on the decline for years before the introduction of the Salk vaccine.
 
The biggest threat of going to a government school is not the vaccines they will make you get but the experience of the school itself.
The Government mandating chemicals going into your children without your approval is chilling.
This is nothing new. Many city governments mandate fluoride go into you and your children via the water supply. This is forced medication with a toxic chemical which if it has any benefit is from topical application not from ingesting. Forced fluoridation and vaccination would be violations of the Nuremberg Code, if that sort of thing mattered, and it doesn’t.
But the reality is due to improved sanitation, polio had been on the decline for years before the introduction of the Salk vaccine.
With most diseases the evidence seems to be the vaccine was invented after the disease was waning. This improvement in infection was most likely due to better sanitation and medical treatment, such as isolation.
Compared to some countries, the US’s 100 cases of measles this year is nothing. In 2013 Germany had 1700, Italy had 2251, Netherlands 2640, UK 1900, and China 27,825.
Measles is not a very deadly disease. You have a far greater likelihood of dying from a car accident in your lifetime than dying from measles. The US seems to have lost perspective on the effects of various diseases.
 
redstate.com/2015/02/04/rand-paul-pandering-paranoid/
The truth is that vaccination is not a binary issue and neither is the characterization of vaccines as “mandatory.” During the fight to eradicate smallpox, government inspectors would literally conduct “vaccination raids” where they would send health officials into tenements where immigrant communities (who were hostile to vaccination) were known to live and literally rip babies from mothers’ arms and forcibly vaccinate them. This was probably the last truly mandatory vaccination program in the country. The current debate, which is almost entirely a media creation, is over whether the standard MMR vaccine ought to be “mandatory” – by which it is meant that people cannot send their kids to free public school without it. No one is suggesting that the same measures that were taken to eradicate smallpox be used with MMR, but rather whether the current policy is a good fit to the evil that it is attempting to address. Similarly, the Texas Gardisil vaccination program was described as “mandatory” by certain hyperventilating pundits in spite of the fact that parents could opt out by checking a box on a form with literally no consequence at all.
How The ‘Pox’ Epidemic Changed Vaccination Rules
 
The problem with this is people concerned with vaccine safety aren’t convinced that we’re being given an accurate appraisal of the actual risks involved or the actual benefits. Polio, for example is something every vaccine supporter likes to bring up, usually by painting lurid pictures of kids in iron lungs. But the reality is due to improved sanitation, polio had been on the decline for years before the introduction of the Salk vaccine.
Which not to say that Polio would have been eliminated by these measures alone.
 
With most diseases the evidence seems to be the vaccine was invented after the disease was waning. This improvement in infection was most likely due to better sanitation and medical treatment, such as isolation.
(See my previous posting).
Measles is not a very deadly disease. You have a far greater likelihood of dying from a car accident in your lifetime than dying from measles. The US seems to have lost perspective on the effects of various diseases.
The US has a much better perspective on these things than the perspective you just presented. You likelihood of dying from a car accident has absolutely no bearing on how diseases ought to be treated. As for measles not being very deadly, please read this.
 
Well, no, that’s not what I said. What I actually said is that relying on people (parents) who don’t know what a vaccine injury looks like to report vaccine injuries is going to lead to dramatic underreporting.
Something serious like anaphylaxis, seizures, etc. is going to be reported. Because like, any competent parent is going to take their child to the ER. A sore arm? No, normal parents aren’t going to freak out over a sore arm afterwards.
I got my flu shot. I woke up the next day with a sore arm. No, I didn’t go to the hospital or called my physician. Why? Oh, because IT IS COMMON and nothing to freak out about. If I had a child, she would have gotten a flu shot. If she said her arm was sore, I would tell her it was normal and that it would go away in a day or so. No need to freak out about something so MINIMAL. If you wanna freak out and not give your children their immunizations, fine. You just won’t be allowed over for our weekly play date or anything else.
 
I think the democrats are trying to spark an interest in vaccinations in order to get more people to sign up for obamacare… They know that if they line republicans up as being anti-vaccination, then all liberals will immediately flock to get vaccinated.
Ben Carson is a republican. :confused:
 
The US has a much better perspective on these things than the perspective you just presented. You likelihood of dying from a car accident has absolutely no bearing on how diseases ought to be treated. As for measles not being very deadly, please read this.
The US has a better perspective? How so? What I mean is it seems to me many folks think measles is a very dangerous disease, like they think the flu is.

I bring up the odds of dying in a car accident because most people don’t realize their lifetime risk of dying in a car crash is greater than one in one hundred. Ultimately each person should be allowed to evaluate the risk versus reward for medical treatments. But at the very heart of this issue for many is that they don’t think people have a proper perspective on the risks of various diseases versus the risk of the vaccines and the actual efficacy of those vaccines.
 
Something serious like anaphylaxis, seizures, etc. is going to be reported. Because like, any competent parent is going to take their child to the ER. A sore arm? No, normal parents aren’t going to freak out over a sore arm afterwards.
I got my flu shot. I woke up the next day with a sore arm. No, I didn’t go to the hospital or called my physician. Why? Oh, because IT IS COMMON and nothing to freak out about. If I had a child, she would have gotten a flu shot. If she said her arm was sore, I would tell her it was normal and that it would go away in a day or so. No need to freak out about something so MINIMAL. If you wanna freak out and not give your children their immunizations, fine. You just won’t be allowed over for our weekly play date or anything else.
You seem to have a binary view of adverse vaccine reactions that it’s either anaphylactic shock or a sore arm, but there’s quite a lot in between that you wouldn’t capture.

How seriously do you take this? Do you demand that every child coming to your weekly play date bring their shot records or have their blood tested to show immunity? The vaccine schedule in 1983 was about 1/3 the size of the current schedule. Do you demand that parents born before 1975 show that they’ve vaccinated themselves to the current schedule before you allow them to bring their kids over? You seem to be the one that’s freaking out over an imaginary crisis. If your kids are fully immunized, how are unvaccinated kids any danger to them?
 
Something serious like anaphylaxis, seizures, etc. is going to be reported. Because like, any competent parent is going to take their child to the ER. A sore arm? No, normal parents aren’t going to freak out over a sore arm afterwards.
I got my flu shot. I woke up the next day with a sore arm. No, I didn’t go to the hospital or called my physician. Why? Oh, because IT IS COMMON and nothing to freak out about. If I had a child, she would have gotten a flu shot. If she said her arm was sore, I would tell her it was normal and that it would go away in a day or so. No need to freak out about something so MINIMAL. If you wanna freak out and not give your children their immunizations, fine. You just won’t be allowed over for our weekly play date or anything else.
A sore arm could be nothing or it could be serious. My friend’s son ended up with blood poisoning due to one of the vaccinations. He complained of a sore arm. Thankfully his mom didn’t just blow him off.
 
A sore arm could be nothing or it could be serious. My friend’s son ended up with blood poisoning due to one of the vaccinations. He complained of a sore arm. Thankfully his mom didn’t just blow him off.
Same with a headache. I could be a headache or it could be vaccine induced encephalitis. How do you tell?
 
A sore arm? No, normal parents aren’t going to freak out over a sore arm afterwards.
I got my flu shot. I woke up the next day with a sore arm. No, I didn’t go to the hospital or called my physician. Why? Oh, because IT IS COMMON and nothing to freak out about.
Just because a reaction is common does not mean it is good or nothing to be concerned with. A normal or common reaction to ingesting poison might be to vomit. We wouldn’t say that such a normal reaction is no reason to be concerned about the cause.

Why do arms get sore after shots? I really don’t know but I know they are quick to tell us it is no concern because it is common. Is it because of an inflammation of the area? If so inflammation in the body is generally considered a bad thing. Maybe the inflammation is temporary and not an indicator of any further negative health consequence. But maybe it is a bad sign. The problem with many medical treatments is they look at the short term consequences only. We can be guinea pigs and only later learn their treatments were not good for us.
 
Couple things:

About Schools and Vaccine Requirements. At least in California, many homeschoolers will know this since you establish your home as a school when you homeschool, what legally defines something a school is that you keep records of your students vaccinations. It does not mandate that you require vaccinations, but simply that you have a record of all your students vaccinations. (hope that makes sense). If a school chooses to require certain vaccinations, they have the power to do so.

About Government Power: Mandating vaccines at a state level just sounds wayyyyy too Brave New World. Even if science unequivocally proves something, plenty of people choose something else for a variety of reasons. Yes, I see the risk placed on other people, but that can get spun out as well. An untreated schizophrenic can become homicidal, but we can’t force them to take the Lithium.

About the Controversy: I am very concerned about the anger popping up about vaccinations lately. There is pure, bitter, hatred. Exhibit A: scontent-a.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xap1/v/t1.0-9/s720x720/1510950_640872219316124_2060182470_n.jpg?oh=dc3ab8680cf39fc9c5ce09f567db6df3&oe=556BB4E3

“crotch fruit” “plague pits” “cretins” “ankle-biters”

Are anti-vaxxers the new lepers?

All my husband and I can come up with is it is a double edged sword about endangering children, which is clearly an easy way to get anyone heated up. Anti-vaxxers are afraid of hurting their children because vaccines are not risk-less. Yes the risk is mighty mighty low, but not risk-less (And yes, people will obviously want to protect their children even at the expense of other people’s children! Selfish? Probably, but don’t suggest that is some unique behavior to Anti-vaxxers) And Pro-vaxxers are afraid of their children being sick, or that their children might get other people sick. It is a hard weight to bear, and it is something I still very much worry about (both ways!)

Full Disclosure! I delayed some vaccines, opted out of some (like Rotavirus which is not given to children after 14 weeks because it is unnecessary). I was lucky enough to stay home with my daughter until she was 2, she was exclusively breastfed, and then once she was getting ready to go to preschool she got caught up. I was happy my decision because she still ended up being fully vaccinated and she ended up with much fewer shots. I do consider myself skeptical of both sides, although the fact that I deviate from the standard usually places me in the anti-vaxx category…
 
Just because a reaction is common does not mean it is good or nothing to be concerned with. A normal or common reaction to ingesting poison might be to vomit. We wouldn’t say that such a normal reaction is no reason to be concerned about the cause.

Why do arms get sore after shots? I really don’t know but I know they are quick to tell us it is no concern because it is common. Is it because of an inflammation of the area? If so inflammation in the body is generally considered a bad thing. Maybe the inflammation is temporary and not an indicator of any further negative health consequence. But maybe it is a bad sign. The problem with many medical treatments is they look at the short term consequences only. We can be guinea pigs and only later learn their treatments were not good for us.
Arms probably get sore because you get bruised. Jab your arm with a plain needle, a thicker sewing needle will be more like a injection needle. It will hurt for a while. And depending on how thick one’s skin is, one has to jab pretty hard. Ask any diabetic or nurse.

Saline solution will also hurt if injected into the muscle. A shot in the rump will also hurt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top