Couple things:
About Schools and Vaccine Requirements. At least in California, many homeschoolers will know this since you establish your home as a school when you homeschool, what legally defines something a school is that you keep records of your students vaccinations. It does not mandate that you require vaccinations, but simply that you have a record of all your students vaccinations. (hope that makes sense). If a school chooses to require certain vaccinations, they have the power to do so.
About Government Power: Mandating vaccines at a state level just sounds wayyyyy too Brave New World. Even if science unequivocally proves something, plenty of people choose something else for a variety of reasons. Yes, I see the risk placed on other people, but that can get spun out as well. An untreated schizophrenic can become homicidal, but we can’t force them to take the Lithium.
About the Controversy: I am very concerned about the anger popping up about vaccinations lately. There is pure, bitter, hatred. Exhibit A:
scontent-a.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xap1/v/t1.0-9/s720x720/1510950_640872219316124_2060182470_n.jpg?oh=dc3ab8680cf39fc9c5ce09f567db6df3&oe=556BB4E3
“crotch fruit” “plague pits” “cretins” “ankle-biters”
Are anti-vaxxers the new lepers?
All my husband and I can come up with is it is a double edged sword about endangering children, which is clearly an easy way to get anyone heated up. Anti-vaxxers are afraid of hurting their children because vaccines are not risk-less. Yes the risk is mighty mighty low, but not risk-less (And yes, people will obviously want to protect their children even at the expense of other people’s children! Selfish? Probably, but don’t suggest that is some unique behavior to Anti-vaxxers) And Pro-vaxxers are afraid of their children being sick, or that their children might get other people sick. It is a hard weight to bear, and it is something I still very much worry about (both ways!)
Full Disclosure! I delayed some vaccines, opted out of some (like Rotavirus which is not given to children after 14 weeks because it is unnecessary). I was lucky enough to stay home with my daughter until she was 2, she was exclusively breastfed, and then once she was getting ready to go to preschool she got caught up. I was happy my decision because she still ended up being fully vaccinated and she ended up with much fewer shots. I do consider myself skeptical of both sides, although the fact that I deviate from the standard usually places me in the anti-vaxx category…