Vaccinations Should Be Mandatory - Ben Carson

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lost_Sheep
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
How can you honestly make a claim that it is minimal if there are no reports telling us how often this happens?
By that logic, we should all beware of unicorn attacks. After all, there are no reports of them, but that doesn’t mean they don’t happen… :rolleyes:
 
The US has a better perspective? How so?
Better in comparison to the perspective where one considers the risk of dying in a car accident. That perspective is useless for making decisions about vaccines.
What I mean is it seems to me many folks think measles is a very dangerous disease, like they think the flu is.
Did you read my link to the CDC on measles?
I bring up the odds of dying in a car accident because most people don’t realize their lifetime risk of dying in a car crash is greater than one in one hundred. Ultimately each person should be allowed to evaluate the risk versus reward for medical treatments. But at the very heart of this issue for many is that they don’t think people have a proper perspective on the risks of various diseases versus the risk of the vaccines and the actual efficacy of those vaccines.
More than that, the risks and rewards are not just an individual thing. Unlike the case of one person getting treated for one disease, vaccines also treat the population as a whole. Therefore an individual should not consider only his own personal welfare when evaluating the risk/rewards of getting a vaccination. The common good should be taken into account. So I disagree with your statement that “Ultimately each person should be allowed to evaluate the risk versus reward for medical treatments”, since the consequences of that person’s decision affects others in the community.

The odds of dying in a car accident might be relevant in a discussion about car accidents, but this is not.
 
You seem to have a binary view of adverse vaccine reactions that it’s either anaphylactic shock or a sore arm, but there’s quite a lot in between that you wouldn’t capture.

How seriously do you take this? Do you demand that every child coming to your weekly play date bring their shot records or have their blood tested to show immunity? The vaccine schedule in 1983 was about 1/3 the size of the current schedule. Do you demand that parents born before 1975 show that they’ve vaccinated themselves to the current schedule before you allow them to bring their kids over? You seem to be the one that’s freaking out over an imaginary crisis. If your kids are fully immunized, how are unvaccinated kids any danger to them?
I’m so very sorry that I didn’t list every single side effect. My bad. My point was being that something serious will definitely be reported. While common side effects won’t.
There could be a kid at the play date that can’t receive immunizations because of immune system problems, you never know. Most people who are against vaccinations will typically proudly tell you. It’s kind of like the people who are pro-choice. No need to ask them, they’ll let you know.
 
Measles is not a very deadly disease. You have a far greater likelihood of dying from a car accident in your lifetime than dying from measles. The US seems to have lost perspective on the effects of various diseases.
What do you consider very deadly? Is 400 per day not enough?
 
Just because a reaction is common does not mean it is good or nothing to be concerned with. A normal or common reaction to ingesting poison might be to vomit. We wouldn’t say that such a normal reaction is no reason to be concerned about the cause.

Why do arms get sore after shots? I really don’t know but I know they are quick to tell us it is no concern because it is common. Is it because of an inflammation of the area? If so inflammation in the body is generally considered a bad thing. Maybe the inflammation is temporary and not an indicator of any further negative health consequence. But maybe it is a bad sign. The problem with many medical treatments is they look at the short term consequences only. We can be guinea pigs and only later learn their treatments were not good for us.
Per the CDC the reason you arm hurts after the flu shot is because your body is making protective antibodies in response to being vaccinated. It should only last one to two days.
 
Did you read my link to the CDC on measles?
No, I wasn’t sure what the point was. That was a very long article. What was your point you were backing up with the article?
More than that, the risks and rewards are not just an individual thing. Unlike the case of one person getting treated for one disease, vaccines also treat the population as a whole. Therefore an individual should not consider only his own personal welfare when evaluating the risk/rewards of getting a vaccination. The common good should be taken into account. So I disagree with your statement that “Ultimately each person should be allowed to evaluate the risk versus reward for medical treatments”, since the consequences of that person’s decision affects others in the community.
Whoa. This is exactly the kind of claim that makes me think vaccines are a complete hoax. The claim of vaccination is that introduction of a virus causes the vaccinated’s immune system to produce antibodies which make that person resistant to that disease. If that is the case then anyone who wants to not get the disease can simply take the vaccine. If it is the case that a person who doesn’t want to get the disease in some way relies on others taking the vaccine then it seems to me the theory of vaccination is wrong.
The odds of dying in a car accident might be relevant in a discussion about car accidents, but this is not.
It is absolutely relevant when considering how much we compel people. If we can compel people to get vaccinations to protect others from a disease (because vaccines don’t work the way they say they do) then why can’t we compel all people to have those alcohol detecting ignition systems for their cars or devices that prevent them from texting while driving. Your risk of being killed by a careless driver is far greater than dying from a disease someone wasn’t vaccinated for. The relevance is in regards to the principle of compulsion.
What do you consider very deadly? Is 400 per day not enough?
Very deadly would be something that is more deadly than many other things. I don’t know where you get 400 per day. In the US prior to the measles vaccine I think about 450 measles related deaths were reported. And even that number would have to be investigated more and circumstances considered. For instance it might be that an already sick or compromised person got measles and that was the proximate cause of death. But their prior circumstances were also relevant.
Arms probably get sore because you get bruised. Jab your arm with a plain needle, a thicker sewing needle will be more like a injection needle. It will hurt for a while. And depending on how thick one’s skin is, one has to jab pretty hard. Ask any diabetic or nurse.

Saline solution will also hurt if injected into the muscle. A shot in the rump will also hurt.
Jabbing anything into the body is to some degree traumatic. But injecting certain substances could be more dangerous.
 
A sore arm could be nothing or it could be serious. My friend’s son ended up with blood poisoning due to one of the vaccinations. He complained of a sore arm. Thankfully his mom didn’t just blow him off.
Blood poisoning happens when an infection enters the bloodstream. I did a quick Google search and couldn’t find that vaccines cause blood poisoning. Aches are typically in joints, not in a muscle where shots are given.
Also, I didn’t say to blow a child off, but that soreness where you got a shot is very typical a day or so afterwards. You
have more symptoms of blood poisoning than just soreness of the joints, BTW.
 
Blood poisoning happens when an infection enters the bloodstream. I did a quick Google search and couldn’t find that vaccines cause blood poisoning. Aches are typically in joints, not in a muscle where shots are given.
Also, I didn’t say to blow a child off, but that soreness where you got a shot is very typical a day or so afterwards. You
have more symptoms of blood poisoning than just soreness of the joints, BTW.
I didn’t say it was a side effect of vaccines. It is a side effect of injections. And until vaccines enter the body by means other than an injection, it will always be a possibility. And when caught early enough, there are few symptoms. Hence my warning not to blow off even minor symptoms. Just because soreness is a sign of a minor issue, doesn’t mean it can’t be a sign of a more serious issue as well.
 
Very deadly would be something that is more deadly than many other things. I don’t know where you get 400 per day. In the US prior to the measles vaccine I think about 450 measles related deaths were reported. And even that number would have to be investigated more and circumstances considered. For instance it might be that an already sick or compromised person got measles and that was the proximate cause of death. But their prior circumstances were also relevant.
The US isn’t the only country in the world. We have very few cases of measles because we have high rates of vaccination. Other countries that aren’t so vigilant have much higher rates of infection and more deaths.

According to WHO, It is the 8th leading cause of death for people of all ages worldwide. (400 per day)
 
Ben Carson is a republican. :confused:
Yeah, I know. This began before Carsons statement. It was the liberal media which purported that the anti-vaccination dilemma was a republican problem. Ben Carson is proving it isn’t. Make sense now…?
 
Yeah, I know. This began before Carsons statement. It was the liberal media which purported that the anti-vaccination dilemma was a republican problem. Ben Carson is proving it isn’t. Make sense now…?
Ohhh ok. Makes total sense. 🙂
 
Per the CDC the reason you arm hurts after the flu shot is because your body is making protective antibodies in response to being vaccinated. It should only last one to two days.
Does the vaccine stay in your arm? Shouldn’t it diffuse through your body? Does your body produce antibodies only in the arm or area of injection?
The US isn’t the only country in the world. We have very few cases of measles because we have high rates of vaccination. Other countries that aren’t so vigilant have much higher rates of infection and more deaths.

According to WHO, It is the 8th leading cause of death for people of all ages worldwide. (400 per day)
We have very few cases of measles and high vaccination rates. Maybe the vaccination rates have kept down incidents of measles. But the fact remains measles are not very deadly in the US or in countries with the level of medicine or sanitation the US had in 1960. Other countries would probably do better to improve sanitation and basic medical practices since it would protect against a wide array of disease.

The evaluation of a vaccine has to be done against the situational risks from the vaccine and the disease. If the risk of harm from the vaccine are significant it still may be wise to take the vaccine if the disease is very deadly. If the risk from the vaccine is high, but you live in a country where the disease is not very deadly, it may not be worth taking the risk. These decisions should be left to the individual because of the many factors.
 
Does the vaccine stay in your arm? Shouldn’t it diffuse through your body? Does your body produce antibodies only in the arm or area of injection?
.
Yes, the vaccine is only good for that arm. :rolleyes: Again per the CDC it takes about 2 weeks for the antibodies to go through out your body. These antibodies would definitely start to develop where the vaccine was injected, causing soreness in that area on top of being poked with a needle that also can cause soreness.
Goodness, can’t you use Google?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top