Went undercover to a Baptist church today

  • Thread starter Thread starter montanaman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Calling teens into the mass… sorry, I still don’t understand. Is it because the teens are up by the alter? Is only the Priest supposed to be up there (forgive me if these are dumb questions, I’m not Catholic) Also, if it’s wrong why would the Priest do it? Aren’t they supposed to follow a procedure for every mass?
 
thank you all for letting me know what a baptist sunday is all about. iam originally from puerto rico so catholic churches are everywhere so you don’t think about the way other practice. but comming to the states what a difference :bigyikes: in new jersey wasn’t so bad there are a lot of catholic churches, but know that iam in killeen texas there so many baptist churches that you have to go to the yellow pages to find where is the catholic church:bowdown: . finally i found the only one in here but with all this baptist around you wonder.i wish i can go an see one baptist service out of curiosity but with a three year old is hard. so once again ty. about latin mass services if you know spanish does it make it easy to understand?🙂 god bless all
 
carol marie:
Calling teens into the mass… sorry, I still don’t understand. Is it because the teens are up by the alter? Is only the Priest supposed to be up there (forgive me if these are dumb questions, I’m not Catholic) Also, if it’s wrong why would the Priest do it? Aren’t they supposed to follow a procedure for every mass?
At the consecration only ordained men are allowed in the sanctuary, Bishops, Priests, and Deacons. Life Teen is a program that caters Catholicism and the Mass to Teens. It has upbeat music, usually rock and roll. It is also one of the biggest controversies in this forum. Many people prefer the Traditonal Liturgy compared to the current Liturgy, Life Teen is viewed by some as a pimple on the church.
 
Psalm45:9:
At the consecration only ordained men are allowed in the sanctuary, Bishops, Priests, and Deacons.
When you say sanctuary are you refering to the alter or the entire church? I thought that a consecration (when Jesus becomes the bread & the wine ?) occurs at every mass (when they ring the little bell) or is that something that happens before hand when only the Priest is present?
 
Hi:wave: --I am very new here, but I’ve really enjoyed this thread!

As a Lutheran/Baptist/BornAgain/nowGenericProtestant believer in Christ, the only Church that I have found, in which I most love to worship, has always been a Catholic one–even before I was baptised into the Lutheran Church{Missouri Synod} at age 18, I kept on asking my Uncle, whose Church I was joining, if the Lutheran services were “like the Catholic ones”?

However, Uncle had no idea that, just before he had talked me into going to the Lutheran Catechism classes, I had a rather strange experience, while giving some Nuns directions to the new Catholic Church, near my home–after I had told them where it was, and they started to drive away, I felt the most OVERwhelming urge to yell, to them, “Take me with you!”, and I was, also, struck with the most heartfelt desire to become a Nun! No one could have been more surprised, and utterly confused, by that, than I was! Especially, since, at the time, I thought a person had to be “born Catholic”, sort of like being born Jewish!

However, while attending the Lutheran classes, every time either my Uncle, or the Pastor, would use the term “catholic”, I would feel so much joy just well right up inside–even though, I had learned that “catholic” only meant “universal”, not that we all were Catholics!

3 years later, though, ironically, I ended up being married in that very same Catholic Church, to an Italian Catholic!

To me, though, something DOES seem very lacking at a Protestant service–and, I’ve never been able to “put my finger” on exactly what I felt was lacking–but, when I attend Mass, even though I am not a Catholic yet, and can not partake in the Holy Eucharist, just being there fills up this empty ‘hole’, I feel as though I have, inside.

As for the Lord’s mother, Mary–to me, it will take a bit of getting used to, for me to speak to anyone but the Lord, in prayer–because I am not familiar with doing that, as well as because of how badly it is condemned in the Protestant world–but, that is already beginning to disappear, and I bought a Rosary–and, I’m planning to use it, too!😉 🙂
.:amen:

Well, here is the only Latin that I know:

PAX CHRISTI,
Christieann
:blessyou:
 
carol marie:
When you say sanctuary are you refering to the alter or the entire church? I thought that a consecration (when Jesus becomes the bread & the wine ?) occurs at every mass (when they ring the little bell) or is that something that happens before hand when only the Priest is present?
The Sanctuary is the area around the altar and tabernacle. Only ordained men are supposed to be at the altar at the point of Consecration: “This is my body which will be given up for you.”
The Bell is rung because it symbolizes that it is no longer bread and wine, but Jesus. Before consecration, altar servers may approach the altar, and the readers place the Gospel book on it. But a member of the congreation who is neither should never approach the altar durring mass.
 
I had the opportunity to attend two services while dating my ex-boyfriend. The first one was at a small, pentecostal church. I got there late because I attended mass first. (It just happened to be an explanatory mass. The priest explained what every part of the mass is and why it is part of the mass. IT WAS GREAT!!!) Needless to say, I left the pentecostal service feeling like there was something missing. I knew that it was the Eucharist and mentioned this to him. He said that at the other church he was currently attending they had a communion service more frequently. I knew it was not the same as receiving the Eucharist and that I would not participate in it, but about a month later I went to another service with him.

This church was a non-denominational church. The singing and the sermon were both good and his family members attending were very welcoming, however there was still something missing. I think that aside from the Eucharist, the element of worship was not present. During their communion service, they had an altar call and baptisms all at the same time, which the pastor said was not a usual practice at the church. This spontaneity struct me as awkward; there were too many things going on at the same time. It seemed almost irreverent to both the baptisms and to the communion service.

I have a new appreciation for other churches and I am sure that God bestows graces outside of the Catholic Church, but as for me I find the fulness of the faith in the Catholic Church. AMEN!

Peace,
Lourdes http://forums.catholic-questions.org/images/icons/icon7.gif
 
40.png
homer:
Good for you! You are making God vulnerable and changing his mind due to Mary. Jesus is not the little boy who has to do everything his mother orders him to do like the Catholic church always likes to picture him. Jesus is God and every human being including you and me and Mary and all the Saints is NOTHING compared to him.
homer - you’re a good person, but you’re starting to rant. I really think you’re afraid the Catholic Church is a threat to your belief in the Bible alone. I’m secure in the belief that the Catholic Church is the one true Church established by Jesus Christ. Why would I want to go anywhere else? When I was a Methodist the Bible made little sense to me. There were too many conflicts as to what was taught to what was in the Bible. The Bible didn’t make sense until I became a Catholic and had the guidance of the Catholic Church. Everything became understandable and logical. I’m going to pray to Mary for you, homer.
 
Had a similar, but not quite as amusing experince at a “Fundamental Baptist” church many years ago. I went with a high school friend who had been told at sunday school the week before to bring a friend the next week. (In hindsight, I suppose this was a coordinated evangelism attempt). There was a visiting preacher who taught the Sunday school lesson, who railed on for what seemed like an eternity about how good christians never listen to rock music (because it has similar rhythms to pagan drum beats), never listen to music performed by homosexuals, never go to dances (because you know what people do afterwards!), and good christian men never pierce their ears. A neighbor of mine who had been brought there at the same time was sitting behind me with his ear piercing and baggy jeans, and I knew for a fact that he was a rock fan. I always wondered what he was thinking at that point.

I also witnessed my first altar call that Sunday.

This man’s laundry list of don’ts was so long, I don’t even remember what he said about a relationship w/ Christ (if he said anything)

Fortunately, I have had better experiences with the preaching at other Protestant churches, but none of them have made me want to stop being a Catholic. Must have something to do with the Eucharist.
 
I used to visit a Baptist church with my (now Catholic) wife. The most common response I got was…(drum roll please)

“I’m Sorry…” (pat on the back…)

Like I had some strange (and incurable) disease…

Thank goodness thats over…
 
As one’s said,

“Jesus gave us a Church, not a book. The book came later.” 👍
 
40.png
homer:
… This is GOD we are talking about, you don’t need to have connections in order for him to accept your prayers. Only and only Jesus knows the heart of human beings unlike Mary who is now in heaven but cannot hear the prayers of millions of people because she’s only a human being and doesn’t know what is in the hearts of human beings because only God has this power.
Absolutely, you don’t need to. But morally and normatively, you do. Who are you but unworthy sinner in the eye of God. Offer your defective offerings in the hand of the good Queen Mother and she will set it right for you.

Yes, God has that power. But who are you to tell what God can or cannot do? Can’t God give that power to His saints, especially to His worthy Mother – the very vessel through which He came to thie earth?
 
No crosses
Given the emphasis that we Baptists put on the cross, I find that a little hard to believe.
But some of the stained-glass windows had bibles in them. Conclusion–images of Christ is verbotten, but they raise the Bible to a fourth member of the Trinity, apparently.
Well, it is God’s word and does deserve honor.
They opened with four hymns, then basically had a “meeting.” Missionaries spoke about their experiences, and the pastor assigned people to pray for their intentions.
Oh, like the Bible says to.
I SO wanted to talk to someone about Marian intercession. lol.
I can’t imagine praying to the dead would go over very well in a Baptist church.
A nice, sharply angled marine and I had a decent conversation later. He was amazed that I admitted many Catholics were drawn away by fundamentalists who knew their Bible better.
This actually happens quite a bit. I have a copy of a letter that an evangelist friend sent me. A priest wrote to him to ask him to stop sharing the Gospel with the people in his church because they were all getting saved and leaving.

We have a ton of people in our church who were Roman Catholics.
Other than that, it was pretty uneventful. My overwhelming impression was of emptiness. They were all sincere, zealous, but there was something missing. I guess it was the Eucharist…
I know what you mean. I always felt something was missing when I would attend mass. I guess it was God’s word.
 
I know exactly what you mean. I grew up hard-core Southern Baptist, and while intentions were well; there always felt like something was missing. Every time I asked a question about ANYTHING, I was always greeted with “Just read your bible.”

It is weird to in EVERY protestant church I have ever been to, they have always bad mouthed everyone but their church. We were always taught to hate Catholics, or “Cat-licks” as they put it.

This is how I feel though, “Catholic” means “universal,” and Jesus’ love was a “universal love.” He musta been a Catholic. lol

I am so happy that I am a Catholic now. 👍
 
Wow, talk about resurrection. This thread is ancient. Lol.

One thing about the new response, though:
This actually happens quite a bit. I have a copy of a letter that an evangelist friend sent me. A priest wrote to him to ask him to stop sharing the Gospel with the people in his church because they were all getting saved and leaving.
You can interpret it that way if you want, but from my (our) point of view, that’s a condescending, wildly misinterpreted load of it. The priest did NOT write to stop “sharing the Gospel,” as you say. The Catholic was getting that every week at Mass. And they weren’t “getting saved,” they were already saved. It’s more likely that they lessened their chances of ultimate salvation by losing the Eucharist. They rejected Christ, in a way, for an emotional high somewhere else.

But whatever. Take a look at the character and intellect of Catholic converts, and then compare them to the hateful, ignorant, bigoted ex-Catholics who suddenly become Catholic scholars as soon as they leave the thing they never understood.
 
Well, it wasn’t so much “undercover” as it was an exploratory journey. And I blew my cover pretty quickly, too. After one of their MANY intercessory prayers for members of the congregation, I made the sign of the Cross. Lol. You can take the Catholic out of the Church, but you can’t take the Catholocism out of the Catholic.

Or something like that… 🙂

Anyway, I don’t have much to say about it. I was invited by a nice fundamentalist co-worker friend and I thought it’d be interesting. It certainly was, but for a Baptist church, it was amazingly laid-back.

Some notes:

No crosses, crucifixes, nothing. But some of the stained-glass windows had bibles in them. Conclusion–images of Christ is verbotten, but they raise the Bible to a fourth member of the Trinity, apparently.

They opened with four hymns, then basically had a “meeting.” Missionaries spoke about their experiences, and the pastor assigned people to pray for their intentions. I SO wanted to talk to someone about Marian intercession. lol.

A nice, sharply angled marine and I had a decent conversation later. He was amazed that I admitted many Catholics were drawn away by fundamentalists who knew their Bible better. He also later called Rome a “fever swamp” of bad ideas.

Other than that, it was pretty uneventful. My overwhelming impression was of emptiness. They were all sincere, zealous, but there was something missing. I guess it was the Eucharist…
By the way, I married that nice fundamentalist co-worker. Lol. We’re about to have our first child, a boy, named Joseph–after my patron saint. 👍
 
You can interpret it that way if you want, but from my (our) point of view, that’s a condescending, wildly misinterpreted load of it. The priest did NOT write to stop “sharing the Gospel,” as you say.
That’s what he said.

Why would you say that the priest isn’t telling the truth?
The Catholic was getting that every week at Mass.
I never got it. Evidently, a lot of Roman Catholics don’t get it because when we share it with them, they say they’ve never heard that.
And they weren’t “getting saved,” they were already saved.
How do you know?
They rejected Christ, in a way, for an emotional high somewhere else.
So, repentance, faith in Christ, and dying to the flesh and being raised to new life in Christ are really just rejecting Christ for an emotional high?
But whatever. Take a look at the character and intellect of Catholic converts, and then compare them to the hateful, ignorant, bigoted ex-Catholics who suddenly become Catholic scholars as soon as they leave the thing they never understood.
On the other hand, take a look at the hateful, bigoted, ex-Christians who suddenly become Christian scholars as soon as they leave the thing they never understood.

If anybody is hateful or bigoted, then they’re wrong. Fortunately, ignorance can be fixed.

But it’s just dishonest on your part to say that it’s a one way street. I can’t tell you how many Roman Catholics I talk to who claim to be former Christians who call us names, tell us that we’re not really a part of the church, tell lies about us and what we believe, etc.
 
That’s what he said.

Why would you say that the priest isn’t telling the truth?
I didn’t say that. When speaking to me, please drop the fundamentalist trait of putting words in my mouth. I get that enough from my in-laws and their lying pastor.

IF the priest used the unfortunate word sequence “sharing the Gospel” with you or whoever, that’s, well, unfortunate. But I guarantee that’s not what he meant. Even the most jaded liberal priest shares the Gospel in Mass, in which scripture is read, prayed and sung.

It could mean a lot of things, but I guarantee you that whatever happened, it had nothing to do with your implications–that the priest was worried someone was “getting the truth.” :rolleyes:
I never got it. Evidently, a lot of Roman Catholics don’t get it because when we share it with them, they say they’ve never heard that.
I hear that a lot. But then, a lot of ex-fundamentalists and Bible scholars become Catholic after really digging deep into scripture and Church history.
How do you know?
I always try to assume the best of people. If he was baptized and in a state of grace, he was saved.
So, repentance, faith in Christ, and dying to the flesh and being raised to new life in Christ are really just rejecting Christ for an emotional high?
Yeah, that’s exactly what I’m saying. :rolleyes:
But it’s just dishonest on your part to say that it’s a one way street. I can’t tell you how many Roman Catholics I talk to who claim to be former Christians who call us names, tell us that we’re not really a part of the church, tell lies about us and what we believe, etc.
Oh, I know it’s a two-way street. But I’ve never come across a Catholic who persists in spreading lies about Protestants. Sure, he may be insanely prejudiced, but not a liar. I see a lot of people continually misrepresent what Catholics believe even after being explained XYZ doctrine hundreds of times.

Look, I don’t care to share anecdotal stories about who’s worse because of why. I’m over it. In my experience, committed anti-Catholics or even most fundamentalists simply don’t give a damn about what Catholics really believe. So, whatever. I just hang them with their hypocrisy and have a few laughs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top