Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
gilliam:
Only on listening in on suspected al-Qaeda phone calls coming into the US. You really think a US Congress will seriously impeach a president of the United States over this? Come on, wake up and smell the Kansas Beef!
I think impeachment has more to do with which political party is in Congress versus the White House, so no, I don’t think impeachment is likely here.

Strictly on the merits, though, I find the implicit authorization the WH is claiming to be extremely tenuous. If there were an actual chance of impeachment charges being brought, I think violation of FISA would be the most viable cause. It may not be clearly illegal, but it is certainly not clearly legal either. Your statement that they are listening to suspected al-Queda phone calls already assume far more than we actually know. As more facts come out, hopefully the actual status (and legal standing) of the NSA actions will become clearer.

BTW, Kansas beef is good, but personally I prefer bison 🙂
 
40.png
NotWorthy:
These are the same Senators that tend to leak information like a sieve??? No, your reasoning doesn’t add up, Thekla. With “unidentified sources” the rage of the day, they would have got Bob Woodward involved in a heartbeat.

Notworthy
Your speculation does not match what they are on the record as saying. And Senator Graham has said essentially the same thing. Senator Rockefeller hand wrote a memo outlining his concerns since he was not allowed to to consult with anyone or possibly violate law.

You are the one who says that they were consulted. Where is your proof of actual “consultation?” There is no evidence that they are all lying. No one has disputed Daschle. As for Woodward, he’s the president’s boy. I think you’ve got it backwards.
 
Let me get this straight.

Terrorists declared war on the United States and hit us time after time, culminating in the attacks that took place on September 11, 2001.

Congress then told the President it was ok to go after the terrorists AND their supporters. HOWEVER, it is not ok to collect intelligence information as to where the terrorists are and what their identities are.

Hmmmm.

Did I get that right?
 
Al Masetti:
Let me get this straight.

Terrorists declared war on the United States and hit us time after time, culminating in the attacks that took place on September 11, 2001.

Congress then told the President it was ok to go after the terrorists AND their supporters. HOWEVER, it is not ok to collect intelligence information as to where the terrorists are and what their identities are.

Hmmmm.

Did I get that right?
No, you kind of left out the whole Constitution bit. Even in war (which, once again, I must point out that Congress has neglected to find the courage to challenge the president’s usurpation of it’s authority to delcare war), the president has to follow the law.

Was the law broken? I don’t know, that’s why we have to find out. No one gets a free pass, not even (perhaps especially) a president.
 
Al Masetti:
Let me get this straight.

Terrorists declared war on the United States and hit us time after time, culminating in the attacks that took place on September 11, 2001.

Congress then told the President it was ok to go after the terrorists AND their supporters. HOWEVER, it is not ok to collect intelligence information as to where the terrorists are and what their identities are.

Hmmmm.

Did I get that right?
No. You got it wrong and I think you know it. Especially with the “it’s not okay to find out who terrorists are” argument. With whom are you arguing?

As I pointed out to you earlier, without oversight there is no one checking to see which Americans they are spying on and why. That’s the point; not the other mind clutter.

Oh. And I looked up this “consultation” with the Congress question and I found this from today’s speech. Mr. Bush said, “We briefed members of the United States Congress, one of whom was Senator Pat Roberts, about this program.”

To “brief” is not to “consult.” Briefing means that you told them what you were doing, and, as I added before, told them they couldn’t talk about it with one another or “consult” with legal authorities. “Consult” is a different thing and I find it interesting that the president didn’t use that word.
 
Philip P:
No, you kind of left out the whole Constitution bit. Even in war (which, once again, I must point out that Congress has neglected to find the courage to challenge the president’s usurpation of it’s authority to delcare war), the president has to follow the law.

Was the law broken? I don’t know, that’s why we have to find out. No one gets a free pass, not even (perhaps especially) a president.
In our system of government, under the Constitution, the President is Commander-In-Chief of the military. He’s the super general. He orders the military to go forth. He is in charge. He gives the orders, Constitutionally.

So, exactly, precisely, which part of the whole Constitution bit, which words, which Articles, was omitted?
 
Al Masetti:
In our system of government, the President is Commander-In-Chief of the military. He’s the super general. He orders the military to go forth.

So, exactly which part of the whole Constitution bit was omitted?
Congress set up FISA. Congress has the authority to pass legislation. Unless/until the SCOTUS says otherwise, it’s the law. According to the constitution, the president is not above the law. In fact, as the executive, he’s supposed to execute the law, not change or ignore it as he sees fit. If he violated FISA, he overstepped his authority.
 
Philip P:
Congress set up FISA. Congress has the authority to pass legislation. Unless/until the SCOTUS says otherwise, it’s the law. According to the constitution, the president is not above the law. In fact, as the executive, he’s supposed to execute the law, not change or ignore it as he sees fit. If he violated FISA, he overstepped his authority.
And what, exactly, is FISA?
 
Um…I think you misread my post.
40.png
NotWorthy:
But the President did have council. He did NOT act on his own. He consulted the Foreign Intelligence Committees of both houses, made up of Republican’s and Democrat’s.

How can you say he did this in private.

If any of these people had reservations, why didn’t they voice them? Why? Because they knew the value of the intelligence!!! It was only after the public firestorm, er, I meant media storm (the public is not firestorming) that these democrats decided to voice their objections (But I’m sure that was just a coincidence, right?).

Notworthy
 
Philip P:
I think impeachment has more to do with which political party is in Congress versus the White House, so no, I don’t think impeachment is likely here.

Strictly on the merits, though, I find the implicit authorization the WH is claiming to be extremely tenuous. If there were an actual chance of impeachment charges being brought, I think violation of FISA would be the most viable cause. It may not be clearly illegal, but it is certainly not clearly legal either. Your statement that they are listening to suspected al-Queda phone calls already assume far more than we actually know. As more facts come out, hopefully the actual status (and legal standing) of the NSA actions will become clearer.

BTW, Kansas beef is good, but personally I prefer bison 🙂
If we were not not at war I might me more prone to weigh your arguement. But we are at war.

If I ever ate bison, I might be able to comment on the last sentence. 😉 I’ve smelled them though, and the only thing that smells worse is a dairy farm.
 
40.png
Thekla:
Oh. And I looked up this “consultation” with the Congress question and I found this from today’s speech. Mr. Bush said, “We briefed members of the United States Congress, one of whom was Senator Pat Roberts, about this program.”

To “brief” is not to “consult.” Briefing means that you told them what you were doing, and, as I added before, told them they couldn’t talk about it with one another or “consult” with legal authorities. “Consult” is a different thing and I find it interesting that the president didn’t use that word.
Yes, he briefed Congress - not consult. Consult means they had a hand in the decision process. Brief means they were made aware of. The President has made it clear that this was his decision (and God love him for it) and he had Congressional oversight.

Again, I find it hard to believe that they would sit back and let him do this if they disagreed. There are too many leakers on these committees to insure their silence, as Congress has proven too many times in the past.

Notworthy
 
Al Masetti:
Let me get this straight.

Terrorists declared war on the United States and hit us time after time, culminating in the attacks that took place on September 11, 2001.

Congress then told the President it was ok to go after the terrorists AND their supporters. HOWEVER, it is not ok to collect intelligence information as to where the terrorists are and what their identities are.

Hmmmm.

Did I get that right?
Yep, I think so. Makes sense to me. You can only chase terrorists but you can’t catch em.
 
40.png
rlg94086:
Um…I think you misread my post.
Yes, I grabbed the wrong Post. I meant to Grab someone else’s (I think the same one you were responding to) that claimed El Presidente was acting Solo!

Sorry! Once again my posting skills prove,

Notworthy
 
40.png
gilliam:
If we were not not at war I might me more prone to weigh your arguement. But we are at war.
Don’t really understand what you mean here. In the first place, we’re not at war - only Congress can declare war, and they haven’t. I don’t think even Samuel Alito would dispute this.

In the second place, this seems to imply that war is a special exception to the standard rules of legality and morality. That’s kind of like saying “wear your seatbelt, unless you’re in an accident.”

FDR was wrong to detain Americans in camps. Bush, if he violated FISA, acted illegally and improperly. (and besides which, FISA specifically addresses wartime, which it also notes is defined by a declaration by Congress, which you already know we don’t have).
 
Philip P:
Don’t really understand what you mean here. In the first place, we’re not at war - only Congress can declare war, and they haven’t. I don’t think even Samuel Alito would dispute this.

In the second place, this seems to imply that war is a special exception to the standard rules of legality and morality. That’s kind of like saying “wear your seatbelt, unless you’re in an accident.”

FDR was wrong to detain Americans in camps. Bush, if he violated FISA, acted illegally and improperly. (and besides which, FISA specifically addresses wartime, which it also notes is defined by a declaration by Congress, which you already know we don’t have).
Pssst. Congress gave Bush the authority via resolutions. I’d have preferred an all out declaration of war myself. However, it’s a moot point. Congress chose to give Bush the authority to act. Don’t like it? Work to change the make up of the Congress.

The reality is, we are at war with islamofacism/terrorism. Repeating your assertion over and over again, isn’t going to change that reality.

The whine and moan of the left regarding the wiretaping of Al-Qeada calls coming from outside the nation to numbers inside America won’t change the reality either.

“Authorization for Use of Military Force - Authorizes the President to use all necessary and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons, in order to prevent any future acts of international terrorism against the United States by such nations, organizations, or persons. States that this Act is intended to constitute specific statutory authorization within the meaning of the War Powers Resolution.”
 
Al Masetti:
And what, exactly, is FISA?
Dear Al,

I have to tell you that I find it extraordinary that you vehemently argue for the administration’s domestic spying program and you don’t know “what, exactly, is FISA?” One of your earlier posts said things like, " The activities do NOT include wiretaps," and you were quite emphatic about it. So please read up on this so that others, like me, don’t make the mistake of thinking you are speaking from a fact-based position when that appears not true.

Thekla:)
 
Thekla,

When the call originates from a suspected al-Qaeda operative off-shore, it is not a domestic spying program. I’m shocked that you would use such a term. 😉
 
Philip P:
FDR was wrong to detain Americans in camps. Bush, if he violated FISA, acted illegally and improperly. (and besides which, FISA specifically addresses wartime, which it also notes is defined by a declaration by Congress, which you already know we don’t have).
The courts disagree with you. They have held repeatedly that the President had this power. Congress can not pass a law limiting the consitutional powers of the President.
 
Evidently the “Talking Points” have been updated. Now, instead of this spying stuff was wrong (obviously the American Public believes protecting American is worthwhile), the channels the President went about doing it (or maybe the channels he bypassed) were wrong.

If the President would just ask Congress permission to do this, they will gladly give him the authorization.

Two Problems:
  1. If this is true, why did so many democrats claim it was wrong (after the story were uncovered, at least)?
  2. It’s too late!!! Now that the enemy knows that we are monitoring their call’s, they are going to switch tactics. Does ANYONE from the left have a problem with leaked information that lets our enemies know our tactics??? If they are for protecting America, why aren’t they protesting this? Is this “leaked information” less detrimental to national security than Valerie Plame’s (mis-spelled?)???
Notworthy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top