Why the Greens Hate Nuclear Power

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monte_RCMS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Plants eat CO2. Maybe it’s time to make use of that effect and reforest the earth.

No natural process will reverse radioactivity within human time.

ICXC NIKA
I’m always up for a few new trees. My main point here was that we physically know where nuclear waste is and can develop what we know to either recycle spent rods or bury it as safely as possible. There has also been further developments in reactor design.

My point is that once CO2 is in the air, it’s hard to get it back. That process may take much longer for nuclear waste to decay enough such that it is safe.
 
I’m always up for a few new trees. My main point here was that we physically know where nuclear waste is and can develop what we know to either recycle spent rods or bury it as safely as possible. There has also been further developments in reactor design.

My point is that once CO2 is in the air, it’s hard to get it back. That process may take much longer for nuclear waste to decay enough such that it is safe.
Actually, the CO2 life cycle has been grossly misrepresented by CAGW alarmists.

The average residence time of a CO2 molecule in the Earth’s atmosphere is about 4-7 years. Taking into account multiple exchanges leads to an estimate of a mean lifespan of 40 years.
sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921818116304787

Nuclear still makes sense as a cheap base load power source, while carbon fuels are almost ideal for transportation needs.
 
Actually, the CO2 life cycle has been grossly misrepresented by CAGW alarmists.

The average residence time of a CO2 molecule in the Earth’s atmosphere is about 4-7 years. Taking into account multiple exchanges leads to an estimate of a mean lifespan of 40 years.
sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921818116304787

Nuclear still makes sense as a cheap base load power source, while carbon fuels are almost ideal for transportation needs.
13 Year Old Invents Free Energy Device Nikola Tesla
youtube.com/watch?v=TVX6ftqK4wA
 
I’m always up for a few new trees. My main point here was that we physically know where nuclear waste is and can develop what we know to either recycle spent rods or bury it as safely as possible. There has also been further developments in reactor design.

My point is that once CO2 is in the air, it’s hard to get it back. That process may take much longer for nuclear waste to decay enough such that it is safe.
CO2 can be scrubbed at the point of injection into the atmosphere. We know how to do it but it costs money.

No amount of money will purify nuclear high-level waste, or reclaim the sites of Fukushima and Chernobyl.

ICXC NIKA
 
Actually, the CO2 life cycle has been grossly misrepresented by CAGW alarmists.

The average residence time of a CO2 molecule in the Earth’s atmosphere is about 4-7 years. Taking into account multiple exchanges leads to an estimate of a mean lifespan of 40 years.
sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921818116304787
Here’s your man, he’s an obscure retired Professor who’s written a few other anti-climate change articles.

hsu-hh.de/laser/index_xf8dd16rfJ6hg6A6.html

I think most telling for me is the tree of departments he’s listed under:

Startseite Universität » Fakultät für Elektrotechnik » Prof. Kip » Mitarbeiter » Ehemalige » Hermann Harde (retired)

The highlighted translates to Faculty for Electrical Technology. This guy is likely an Electrical Engineer or Physicist. Climatology is by far not his discipline. By the way, this guy is basically free to publish anything he wants as tenured German professors basically can’t be fired.
 
The area of the Earth is 196,900,000 square miles. The area in both of these zones is 1300 square miles, or 0.0007% of the area of the Earth. Please someone check my math.

If the ozone level, or sea level rose by 0.0007%, would you consider it significant?
I’ll recheck your maths when I get time. But there are 2 problems with the conclusion:
  1. We don’t breathe water, so multiply your 196.9 E6 sq.mi by 0.29 to reflect the amount of land available. Then subtract the areas of Antarctica, the Sahara, etc.
  2. More to the point, it’s not any old dry land that is now off limits, but watered, agriculturally useful land, and (in the case of Fukushima) in an already overcrowded country. If the nuclear explosions could be confined to the deserts they would not matter as much.
ICXC NIKA
 
No amount of money will purify nuclear high-level waste, or reclaim the sites of Fukushima and Chernobyl.
Molten-salt reactors, Thorium reactors, and breeder reactors can all use high-level waste as fuel, and their byproducts are safe within years instead of millennia. Fukushima should not have been built where it was, and Chernobyl was a catastrophic combination of bad design and worse procedures.
 
CO2 can be scrubbed at the point of injection into the atmosphere. We know how to do it but it costs money.
I believe you are talking about carbon sequestration, no? I’ve actually visited what I believe to be the only operational power plant (coal fired) in the US using (or seems not anymore) carbon sequestration. My sister-in-law was big into this while studying at MIT, I think one or two of her Masters are related to this. The whole project was canceled many due to costs:

sequestration.mit.edu/tools/projects/antelope_valley.html

There’s also the issue of finding a suitable place to put (usually inject) the CO2, which is not always possible.
 
I’ll recheck your maths when I get time. But there are 2 problems with the conclusion:
  1. We don’t breathe water, so multiply your 196.9 E6 sq.mi by 0.29 to reflect the amount of land available. Then subtract the areas of Antarctica, the Sahara, etc.
  2. More to the point, it’s not any old dry land that is now off limits, but watered, agriculturally useful land, and (in the case of Fukushima) in an already overcrowded country. If the nuclear explosions could be confined to the deserts they would not matter as much.
ICXC NIKA
Good points, to which I will counter that half of the area I calculated for Fukushima was in the ocean, and this can be countered by building on and near land not easily habitable, or at least less habitable. I still think that considering how small the percentage of land contaminated in the decades we have had nuclear power, even assuming no technological learning curve, would result in very little land contaminated of the centuries we might need nuclear power.

Besides, what other option do we have that is viable across the globe, besides nuclear and fossil fuels?
 
The problem with nukes is that we don’t yet have a safe means to sequester the high-level nuclear waste.

We as a species cannot afford any more Chernobyls or Fukushimas either. We don’t have that much good land to close forever from human life.

ICXC NIKA
We are supposed to reprocess the used fuel. [Like Everybody else.] But President Jimmy Carter banned reprocessing.

So we decided to bury the used fuel in Area 51. SW Corner of NTS … actually Area 25. But President Obama banned that.

Read “Underexposed – What if Radiation Is Actually Good For You” by Ed Hiserodt.

Excellent book.
 
So we decided to bury the used fuel in Area 51. SW Corner. But President Obama banned that.
Wouldn’t that have endangered the scientists studying the alien bodies?
 
So you are not going to respond to the science (why I included the link)

Just going straight to an ad hominem deflection, you don’t mess about.
Here’s your man, he’s an obscure retired Professor who’s written a few other anti-climate change articles.

hsu-hh.de/laser/index_xf8dd16rfJ6hg6A6.html

I think most telling for me is the tree of departments he’s listed under:

Startseite Universität » Fakultät für Elektrotechnik » Prof. Kip » Mitarbeiter » Ehemalige » Hermann Harde (retired)

The highlighted translates to Faculty for Electrical Technology. This guy is likely an Electrical Engineer or Physicist. Climatology is by far not his discipline. By the way, this guy is basically free to publish anything he wants as tenured German professors basically can’t be fired.
 
So you are not going to respond to the science (why I included the link)

Just going straight to an ad hominem deflection, you don’t mess about.
Because I can only see the abstract and I’m not going to pay $40 for the privilege of reading it, something I presume you haven’t done either. The abstract in no way really explains how he got to his conclusions, it just makes claims. This article is also not peer reviewed. So all that and the fact that his expertise seems to be in Electrical Engineering (or similar) leads me to believe there is not much to see here.

His little presentation reminds me a bit of the gibberish the Swedish Chef spoke (no I don’t mean his accent). He seems to be trying to use emissions of carbon 14 from nuclear tests to refute an observation made that carbon 12 (the most common carbon isotope) has a much higher concentration in long dead things like fossil fuels compared to carbon 13 and carbon 14 due to isotopic decay. Modern sources of emissions should have a more of these c13 and 14 isotopes due to minimal carbon half life decay. One support for man made CO2 being the source of CO2 increases is that there is more carbon 12 present in the atmosphere than should be if fossil fuels are not the source. How he gets there is where the gibberish starts.
 
Apologies, I wasn’t expecting you to pay for reading.

That’s still no excuse for resorting to ad hominems.
Climate science is a very recent field (not talking weathermen) and it shows ignorance to claim people without the right “degree” are not qualified to apply their expertise.

I’d say most physicists are well qualified to understand the chemistry and the climate models. Heck, the fathers of climate alarmism (Hansen & Mann) only have degrees in physics.
Because I can only see the abstract and I’m not going to pay $40 for the privilege of reading it, something I presume you haven’t done either. The abstract in no way really explains how he got to his conclusions, it just makes claims. This article is also not peer reviewed. So all that and the fact that his expertise seems to be in Electrical Engineering (or similar) leads me to believe there is not much to see here.

His little presentation reminds me a bit of the gibberish the Swedish Chef spoke (no I don’t mean his accent). He seems to be trying to use emissions of carbon 14 from nuclear tests to refute an observation made that carbon 12 (the most common carbon isotope) has a much higher concentration in long dead things like fossil fuels compared to carbon 13 and carbon 14 due to isotopic decay. Modern sources of emissions should have a more of these c13 and 14 isotopes due to minimal carbon half life decay. One support for man made CO2 being the source of CO2 increases is that there is more carbon 12 present in the atmosphere than should be if fossil fuels are not the source. How he gets there is where the gibberish starts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top