Why the Greens Hate Nuclear Power

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monte_RCMS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Because they build their nuclear plants on fault zones, on a river that flows downstream to populated areas, that the trade winds can carry to these same areas. (Our case anyway).
 
Last edited:
Your key statement is that solar and wind power are intermittent.

What good is that?

Why is it that after a hundred years we still do not have useful electricity storage devices. [Except for hydro-storage, for which there are only a couple of useful sites in the USA.]
 
At the end of 2016, 61 power reactors were under construction around the world. Many countries with existing nuclear power programs either have plans to, or are building, new power reactors.
 
Your key statement is that solar and wind power are intermittent.

What good is that?

Why is it that after a hundred years we still do not have useful electricity storage devices. [Except for hydro-storage, for which there are only a couple of useful sites in the USA.]
We do. Everything from gravity storage systems (ie. pumped hydroelectric dams) to one of the most ancient means of storing energy; flywheels.
 
In California, “they” are taking hydro dams down.
Up here in British Columbia they’ve decomissioned a few dams too. When they get older, and depending on t he type of dam, they can be very expensive to maintain. So the fact that some dams get decomissioned hardly means California is getting rid of hydro power.
 
Up here in British Columbia they’ve decomissioned a few dams too. When they get older, and depending on t he type of dam, they can be very expensive to maintain. So the fact that some dams get decomissioned hardly means California is getting rid of hydro power.
I would be very surprised that maintenance costs outweighed the cheap power and irrigation water benefits

Most decommissioning in the US is about fish habitat
 
I’ve never heard of any one hating nuclear power. I am however aware of those that have concerns with it. Right now the USA doesn’t have a plan for safely disposing of spent nuclear fuel rods. For now the place of the disposal is the plants in which they are used. Over time the accumulation of these rods will increase; they can’t be used to produce electricity but they are still dangerous if one is in close proximity or if they were to leak from the plants.

Thank being said I don’t think that there are any power sources that don’t have down sides. I remember there being a Windmill farm generating power that some people were protesting because a certain species of birds would sometimes be killed by the blades. In response the company maintaining the mills decided to start putting mills at a height at which the bird in question didn’t usually fly. The result is that a different species of bird was getting killed by the mills.
 
There are two ways of disposing of spent nuclear fuel rods.

One is to reprocess them, which is what most of the world does.

The other way is to bury them, but the completed facility which is north of Las Vegas in the desert in the Nevada Test Site, was forbidden to be used by Harry Reid.
 
Forget nuclear power any any type of “dirty” power that’s been used as a money maker for well over a hundred years. We’ve been totally on the wrong path technologically for more more than a century; imagine where we’d be had it been done right from the start! Nikola Tesla was well on the way to providing FREE clean power to all with an antenna. If he only had the funding…
 
Last edited:
Not the case. http://www.solarreserve.com/en/



Energy storage means less reliance on very expensive systems, and dangerous systems like nuclear power. How much does it cost to build one nuclear power plant? MSRs are not the answer and represent very old technology. What if a “modern” unit leaked?
 
Tesla’s funding disappeared when J.P. Morgan was told the power could not be metered. No money. No development. Tesla’s Niagara Falls plant design was implemented because it was limited and could be metered. Tesla finally got a monument but it wasn’t from the US.

“Tesla Monument at Goat Island, Niagara Falls, New York. Gift of Yugoslavia to the United States, 1976.”

“Nikola Tesla designed the first hydro-electric power plant in Niagara Falls. This was the final victory of Tesla’s Alternating Current over Edison’s Direct Current. The monument was the work of Croatian sculptor Frane Krsinic.”
 
I’d think molten salt a far better storage medium than fire bricks. Since it’s a fluid, it will be much easier to extract the energy from later.
 
Alternative energy sources will NEVER be enough. Nuclear power is the only Green energy that can meet the needs of the world.

Now, what I am talking about is the type of nuclear power that is not “dirty”, does not pollute, can use up the nuclear waste we already have, and is safe and stable.

The nuclear plants we have today are of the type that can produce material for nuclear bombs. The type I am talking about does not do that and is the solution for generations to come.
 
Last edited:
Pebble bed reactors were proposed in Germany years ago. I’m not convinced.
 
Pebble bed reactors were proposed in Germany years ago. I’m not convinced.
Pebble bed reactors are just a bad approach, not progressing towards safer solutions
  • It uses flammable graphite as a moderator.
  • It produces more high level nuclear wastes than current nuclear reactor designs.
  • It relies heavily on nearly perfect fuel pebbles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top