Why the Greens Hate Nuclear Power

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monte_RCMS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Apologies, I wasn’t expecting you to pay for reading.

That’s still no excuse for resorting to ad hominems.
Climate science is a very recent field (not talking weathermen) and it shows ignorance to claim people without the right “degree” are not qualified to apply their expertise.
I tried to take a crack at understanding his point, which is hard from an ad hominem. The man appears to be going through some contortions to prove that the levels of carbon 14 in the atmosphere have been over compensated for in the carbon isotope based arguments for climate change. In other words those who support climate change have accounted too many carbon 14 molecules to nuclear tests and therefore have established an artificially high amount of carbon 12 molecules in ratio to carbon 13 and 14. A higher ratio of carbon 12 would be reasonable proof that the increased carbon sources are due to fossil fuels.

As for degrees, I myself am an Electrical Engineer. I do not think that any training I have or someone like me makes us particularly qualified to have a definitive opinion on climate change, much less conduct and publish a peer reviewed paper. The only thing I’d claim is that we have a somewhat better grasp of physics (engineers are technically applied physicists), chemistry, and the scientific method than the general population.
 
Dennis Lee proved in court that free energy is real.
So, given the internet, why do we not now have unlimited free energy … everybody building one of these units in his/her basement work shop?
 
So, given the internet, why do we not now have unlimited free energy … everybody building one of these units in his/her basement work shop?
The Government, Electric Companies and the Oil Companies have been suppressing this type of technology for well over a century.
 
If you had studied the problem, you’d know that previous predictions on the life cycle of carbon were based on conjecture and inference, without direct measurement.

By measuring the isotopes in the atmosphere following specific global events, they have direct measurement of the CO2 lifecycle. Hard data always trumps conjecture in science.

The more you dig into climate science, the more you will realize how so much is based on conjecture and assumptions, not direct measurement.

Here is an intro to research from CERN, that is shredding the more alarmist projections
youtu.be/8M3up6T9Zeg
I tried to take a crack at understanding his point, which is hard from an ad hominem. The man appears to be going through some contortions to prove that the levels of carbon 14 in the atmosphere have been over compensated for in the carbon isotope based arguments for climate change. In other words those who support climate change have accounted too many carbon 14 molecules to nuclear tests and therefore have established an artificially high amount of carbon 12 molecules in ratio to carbon 13 and 14. A higher ratio of carbon 12 would be reasonable proof that the increased carbon sources are due to fossil fuels.

As for degrees, I myself am an Electrical Engineer. I do not think that any training I have or someone like me makes us particularly qualified to have a definitive opinion on climate change, much less conduct and publish a peer reviewed paper. The only thing I’d claim is that we have a somewhat better grasp of physics (engineers are technically applied physicists), chemistry, and the scientific method than the general population.
 
As I was saying, the Government, Electric Companies and the Oil Companies have been suppressing these types of technologies for over a century.
 
The more you dig into climate science, the more you will realize how so much is based on conjecture and assumptions, not direct measurement.

Here is an intro to research from CERN, that is shredding the more alarmist projections
youtu.be/8M3up6T9Zeg
He’s basically explaining how his experimentation has helped understand cloud cover better, basically that cloud cover was the same today as pre-industrial. Clouds have a cooling effect. Saying that there was not much variability in cloud cover means reducing compensation for additional cloud cover should indicate an even sharper rise than the pre-industrial baseline. Either way he ends the video still supporting climate change and seemingly that his results will sharpen climate models.

Look, you can be lax in addressing climate change, but what if you wrong? But assuming Rome is not burning with others saying it is, arguing about having a fire department is not a great idea.
 
The CERN research is significant because the models assumed pre-industrial skies were markedly different than now. CO2 feedbacks are driven by these faulty assumptions.

Revised assumptions backed by such actual research lower the model feedbacks, and thus the projected warming. Such research really puts a damper on the more alarmist projections. Instead of CO2 ECS being potentially as high as 8C with doubling, we will have confidence we are at the bottom end of IPCC estimates.

Rome isn’t burning, it’s very illogical of you to insist we turn the economy upside down on climate models that have shown themselves to be in error. Stop appealing to emotion to justify your cause, because it just might happen (alarmist fantasy).
He’s basically explaining how his experimentation has helped understand cloud cover better, basically that cloud cover was the same today as pre-industrial. Clouds have a cooling effect. Saying that there was not much variability in cloud cover means reducing compensation for additional cloud cover should indicate an even sharper rise than the pre-industrial baseline. Either way he ends the video still supporting climate change and seemingly that his results will sharpen climate models.

Look, you can be lax in addressing climate change, but what if you wrong? But assuming Rome is not burning with others saying it is, arguing about having a fire department is not a great idea.
 
The problem with nukes is that we don’t yet have a safe means to sequester the high-level nuclear waste.

We as a species cannot afford any more Chernobyls or Fukushimas either. We don’t have that much good land to close forever from human life.
Chernobyl and Fukushima were not a result of nuclear waste storage.
 
People often think windmill and solar panels are green, but windmill and solar panels have environmental dangers as wind and solar uses more land with less energy and there are dangers such as endangered birds getting killed by windmills and solar panels have dangerous chemicals.

A smart energy policy involves using nuclear/atomic energy, hydroelectric dams (though we have maximized on that in the U.S.) and geothermal. We need to update our nuclear powerplants with the new reactors, perfect the Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor (Thorium replacing Uranium) and the Small Modular Reactors (SMR).
People often think windmill and solar panels are green, but windmill and solar panels have environmental dangers as wind and solar uses more land with less energy and there are dangers such as endangered birds getting killed by windmills and solar panels have dangerous chemicals.

A smart energy policy involves using nuclear/atomic energy, hydroelectric dams (though we have maximized on that in the U.S.) and geothermal. We need to update our nuclear powerplants with the new reactors, perfect the Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor (Thorium replacing Uranium) and the Small Modular Reactors (SMR).
Nuclear isn’t a renewable energy source, and unfortunately the type of breeder reactors needed to process spent fuel are also a significant concern for nuclear proliferation. Oh yes, and then there’s the disposal of spent fuel if you’re not going to reprocess it. And finally, there’s the sheer cost of building and operating nuclear reactors, and to that you have to add what you do with them once they’ve passed their operation lifespan.

Every form of energy production is going to have ill side effects, but this stinks of grossly exaggerating the risks of renewable energy and grossly minimizing the problems with nuclear.

The fact is that the universe pummels us with gigawatts of energy every second in many different forms; wind, hydro, tidal, solar, and while they will have their environmental cost, that cost is going to be a lot less than hydrocarbons or the long term disposal of spent nuclear fuel.
 
Nuclear isn’t a renewable energy source, and unfortunately the type of breeder reactors needed to process spent fuel are also a significant concern for nuclear proliferation. Oh yes, and then there’s the disposal of spent fuel if you’re not going to reprocess it. And finally, there’s the sheer cost of building and operating nuclear reactors, and to that you have to add what you do with them once they’ve passed their operation lifespan.
Nope, the thorium MSR reactors mentioned above pose virtually no risk for nuclear proliferation. They are ideal for meeting the needs of the developing world doing a massive build out of coal generators.

Actual cost experience shows nuclear is competitive and can become much more so as more reactors are built. MSR designs will significantly improve on the safety of current reactors.
No nuclear reactor can be made proliferation proof, but MSRs have some significant advantages for proliferation resistance. First, the waste from MSRs is not useful for use in nuclear weapons since MSRs fission almost all actinides. Second, MSRs can use up existing stockpiles of nuclear waste from conventional reactors as well as existing stockpiles of plutonium, making these materials unavailable for use in nuclear weapons.
 
Last edited:
the thorium MSR reactors mentioned above pose virtually no risk for nuclear proliferation. They are ideal for meeting the needs of the developing world doing a massive build out of coal generators.

Actual cost experience shows nuclear is competitive and can become much more so as more reactors are built. MSR designs will significantly improve on the safety of current reactors.
Thorium MSR reactors have a lot of advantages:
A 2015 independent review of the LFTR concept by the Electric Power Research Institute deemed it a “potentially transformational technology for meeting future energy needs in the face of uncertain market, policy, and regulatory constraints.”
YET, it will take a long time before we have a commercial MSR reactor.

From: A forgotten war technology could safely power Earth for millions of years. Here’s why we aren’t using it
If thorium reactors are so great, what’s the holdup?
It basically boils down to this: “The science is easy. The engineering is hard.”

Petti and Gougar see three barriers to powering civilization with commercial thorium LFTRs.
  1. Molten salt is a health hazard
  2. Engineering new reactors takes a long time and costs billions
  3. LFTRs create weapons-grade material (but it’s complicated)
There’s still a long road to the Thorium Age
Addressing all of the niggling details, according to current government estimates, might take until 2050 to fully realize a commercial LFTR or other type of thorium molten-salt breeder reactor.

Similarly arduous timescales are true of other “generation four” nuclear reactors, which is why they, too, aren’t yet powering US homes and businesses.

Long-established nuclear-energy companies aren’t interested in overturning decades of “business as usual” to gamble on a technology that’s radically different from anything in their portfolios. After all, the LFTR may work but end up being outcompeted on price for the energy it generates.

So instead, most companies are riffing on current LWR and related designs to improve efficiency, safety, and the tortuously slow speed of licensing a reactor.
 
Last edited:
A 2015 independent review of the LFTR concept by the Electric Power Research Institute deemed it a “potentially transformational technology for meeting future energy needs in the face of uncertain market, policy, and regulatory constraints.”

YET, apparently, it will take a long time before we have a commercial MSR reactor.

From: A forgotten war technology could safely power Earth for millions of years. Here’s why we aren’t using it
Yes it needs basic investment in R&D for it to go commercial with confidence, this is an investment ideal for the US Govt. If we don’t do it, other countries will.

Though there are unknowns which need research, it has been demonstrated to work without much babysitting (original small reactor ran for years). Can’t see how it would lose on cost given that the raw material is less expensive as well as the construction since you don’t need the large high pressure containment facility. We just need more data on using molten salt as the medium. I expect many small problems need attention before commercialization.
 
I am 100% against nuclear power. SMRs are not the answer. Storing alternative energy safely is doable. Storing tons of spent nuclear fuel rods in water-filled tanks is a bad idea. A few billion dollars has already been spent on how to dispose of them safely - without harming the environment. It’s cheaper just to build more storage tanks.

Go to youtube and type in SolarReserve Africa

And type solarreserve.com into any search engine to see how it works. Then type in Three Mile Island and Chernobyl disaster. The worst that that can happen with a Solar Reserve station is the leakage of molten salt.
 
Thorium - the great secret that was known for some time but is only being mentioned recently. I’ll have to look into Fluoride which was added to the drinking water in the United States in 1945 but did not come into wide scale use until 1960. It was meant to prevent tooth decay. Go ahead. Look it up. I really doubt an LFTR is a new development. It is based on old technology.
 
Solar panel compositions are changing. Organics exist. I am tired of being misdirected and told lies.


Coal in Germany has no future.


Regarding wind turbines. Sound canceling technologies exist. Regarding infrasound, specifically, this is an engineering problem that can be solved.
 
40.png
niceatheist:
Nuclear isn’t a renewable energy source, and unfortunately the type of breeder reactors needed to process spent fuel are also a significant concern for nuclear proliferation. Oh yes, and then there’s the disposal of spent fuel if you’re not going to reprocess it. And finally, there’s the sheer cost of building and operating nuclear reactors, and to that you have to add what you do with them once they’ve passed their operation lifespan.
Nope, the thorium MSR reactors mentioned above pose virtually no risk for nuclear proliferation. They are ideal for meeting the needs of the developing world doing a massive build out of coal generators.

Actual cost experience shows nuclear is competitive and can become much more so as more reactors are built. MSR designs will significantly improve on the safety of current reactors.
No nuclear reactor can be made proliferation proof, but MSRs have some significant advantages for proliferation resistance. First, the waste from MSRs is not useful for use in nuclear weapons since MSRs fission almost all actinides. Second, MSRs can use up existing stockpiles of nuclear waste from conventional reactors as well as existing stockpiles of plutonium, making these materials unavailable for use in nuclear weapons.
It’s a largely untested technology so let’s see what the first test installations show. In the meantime, nuclear and fossil fuels aren’t the only sources of energy
 
I am 100% against nuclear power. SMRs are not the answer. Storing alternative energy safely is doable. Storing tons of spent nuclear fuel rods in water-filled tanks is a bad idea. A few billion dollars has already been spent on how to dispose of them safely - without harming the environment. It’s cheaper just to build more storage tanks.

Go to youtube and type in SolarReserve Africa

And type solarreserve.com into any search engine to see how it works. Then type in Three Mile Island and Chernobyl disaster. The worst that that can happen with a Solar Reserve station is the leakage of molten salt.
I think you are battling 1970’s nuclear technology and not what we are proposing here. 3 Mile Island and Chernobyl have no relevance to Thorium MSR reactors. Thorium MSR reactors actually have much more in common with your Solar Reserve station that also uses molten salt for heat collection and transfer.

A Thorium MSR reactor will effectively work as a garbage disposal and chew through our stockpiles of nuclear waste. Those dangerous spent rods will be used as fuel yet again.
 
Last edited:
This topic/thread just popped up “by itself” or something.

I think they are still tweaking the Forum.

Anyway, the original electric power nuclear reactor technology is based on scaling up the reactor designs used for submarine propulsion.

Canada, with the CANDU design, and France with their own designs based on American designs, have radically advanced the mechanical design of nuclear power reactors.

In addition, as Theo520 posted, the Thorium MSR reactors are totally different.

It is important to study the physics and chemistry.

Read Ed Heiserodt’s book, “Underexposed - What If Radiation Is Actually Good for You?”

The city of Hiroshima has demonstrated how recovery from disaster can be achieved.

And Three Mile Island and Chernobyl demonstrate how you need to do the reading.

Start with Heiserodt’s book.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top