Why won't Carter debate his book?

  • Thread starter Thread starter estesbob
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why is it incumbent on Mr Carter to debate Mr Dershowitz? Authors are not required to debate their books, and their refusal to do so means nothing.
Well, not nothing. It means something. But it is common for those who they refuse to debate to challenge them on it, and I think that is what Dershowitz is doing.
Nobody makes a big deal of someone refusing to debate David Duke, so why does Mr Dershowitz deserve that privilege?
You are equating David Duke with a renowned legal mind? That is not exactly accurate. I am no fan of Mr Dershowitz’s liberal views, but I have found that he is a good orator and knows a lot about the topic of Mr Carter’s book.
Mr Carter is a strong defender of international law, while Mr Dershowitz defends targeted assassinations which, under international law, are considered war crimes. I really see no point to any debate between the two.
Sorry, I do.
 
Why is it incumbent on Mr Carter to debate Mr Dershowitz? Authors are not required to debate their books, and their refusal to do so means nothing.

Nobody makes a big deal of someone refusing to debate David Duke, so why does Mr Dershowitz deserve that privelege?

Mr Carter is a strong defender of international law, while Mr Dershowitz defends targeted assassinations which, under international law, are considered war crimes. I really see no point to any debate between the two.
It is not incumbent for him to debate. Howver it is interesting that he is unable to defend it.
 
You are equating David Duke with a renowned legal mind?
No, I am equating two sophists. One happens to be a political outcast (Duke) and the other (Dershowitz) is in Harvard.
40.png
gilliam:
I have found that he is a good orator and knows a lot about the topic of Mr Carter’s book.
Maybe so, but it doesn’t explain why Mr Dershowitz feels compelled to demand Mr Carter debate him. Just because Jimmy Carter doesn’t want to debate Mr Dershowitz doesn’t mean Mr Carter doesn’t want a healthy debate/discussion of the issues raised in the book. Nobody appointed Alan Dershowitz THE EXPERT on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
 
Well, he quite possibly knows more than Carter does on the subject.
As Carter knows, I’ve been to Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza, many times – certainly more times than Carter has been there – and I’ve written three books dealing with the subject of Middle Eastern history, politics, and the peace process. The real reason Carter won’t debate me is that I would correct his factual errors. It’s not that I know too little; it’s that I know too much.
Do you doubt his statement backing up his expertise? Other than Carter’s dismissal of him, do you have any other reputable sources who say he doesn’t know what he is talking about?

I would be interested to see a debate between the two of them, but I don’t think Carter is secure enough in his knowledge or debating skills to accept the challenge.
No, I am equating two sophists. One happens to be a political outcast (Duke) and the other (Dershowitz) is in Harvard.

Maybe so, but it doesn’t explain why Mr Dershowitz feels compelled to demand Mr Carter debate him. Just because Jimmy Carter doesn’t want to debate Mr Dershowitz doesn’t mean Mr Carter doesn’t want a healthy debate/discussion of the issues raised in the book. Nobody appointed Alan Dershowitz THE EXPERT on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
 
Do you doubt his statement backing up his expertise? Other than Carter’s dismissal of him, do you have any other reputable sources who say he doesn’t know what he is talking about?
I don’t think I ever questioned Mr Dershowitz’s expertise or claimed he didn’t know what he’s talking about.

Mr Dershowitz has his world view, which is pretty much that Israel is justified in whatever it does because Israel does it, and Mr Carter has his, which is obviously a different view. As a Catholic, I am much more comfortable with Mr Carter’s view than Mr Dershowitz’s view.
 
I don’t think I ever questioned Mr Dershowitz’s expertise or claimed he didn’t know what he’s talking about.

Mr Dershowitz has his world view, which is pretty much that Israel is justified in whatever it does because Israel does it, …
I have not found that to be the case.
…and Mr Carter has his, which is obviously a different view. As a Catholic, I am much more comfortable with Mr Carter’s view than Mr Dershowitz’s view As a Catholic, I am much more comfortable with Mr Carter’s view than Mr Dershowitz’s view.
What does being a Catholic have to do with President Carter debating Mr. Dershowitz?
 
What does your “comfort” with one side of an argument have to do with a good debate? Do you prefer to just sit in the comfort of listening to people who agree with you, or do you like to hear a good debate of the issues? I would assume the latter, since you participate in this Forum.

If you don’t question Mr. Dershowitz’s expertise, then why do you think Carter doesn’t want to debate him? Are Carter’s viewpoints defensible? If not, why do you agree with them?
I don’t think I ever questioned Mr Dershowitz’s expertise or claimed he didn’t know what he’s talking about.

Mr Dershowitz has his world view, which is pretty much that Israel is justified in whatever it does because Israel does it, and Mr Carter has his, which is obviously a different view. As a Catholic, I am much more comfortable with Mr Carter’s view than Mr Dershowitz’s view.
 
No, I am equating two sophists. One happens to be a political outcast (Duke) and the other (Dershowitz) is in Harvard.
That, my dear sir, is your opinion. I think it is an insult to equate a renowned legal scholar with the ex-leader of the KKK, with all the baggage that comes with that equation. And I know you know the baggage is there and you are selecting this equation deliberately in an attempt to taint Mr Dershowitz.
Maybe so, but it doesn’t explain why Mr Dershowitz feels compelled to demand Mr Carter debate him. Just because Jimmy Carter doesn’t want to debate Mr Dershowitz doesn’t mean Mr Carter doesn’t want a healthy debate/discussion of the issues raised in the book. Nobody appointed Alan Dershowitz THE EXPERT on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Well, to be fair to Mr. Dershowitz, President Carter said he didn’t want to debate Mr. Dershowitz because Mr Dershowitz didn’t know anything about the topic. That is, IMHO, obviously not the case.
 
What does your “comfort” with one side of an argument have to do with a good debate? Do you prefer to just sit in the comfort of listening to people who agree with you, or do you like to hear a good debate of the issues? I would assume the latter, since you participate in this Forum.
Yes, but it doesn’t mean that there aren’t viewpoints that are closer to the truth than others.
If you don’t question Mr. Dershowitz’s expertise, then why do you think Carter doesn’t want to debate him?
Because he’s got other things to do? Why is there this assumed obligation for Jimmy Carter to have a debate with this one specific person?
Are Carter’s viewpoints defensible?
Of course they are. Why on earth would he write a controversial book espouding a viewpoint that he can’t defend himself?

Personally, I don’t think using the word ‘apartheid’ is especially helpful to describe the situation in Israel/Palestine, for various reasons. But it is certainly an arguable point of view - and I find his description of what is going on, whatever specific words he uses to describe it, to be realistic and compelling.

Mike
 
Mike,

I can’t say it better than Derschowitz, so I won’t…
Carter’s refusal to debate wouldn’t be so strange if it weren’t for the fact that he claims that he wrote the book precisely so as to start debate over the issue of the Israel-Palestine peace process. If that were really true, Carter would be thrilled to have the opportunity to debate. Authors should be accountable for their ideas and their facts. Books shouldn’t be like chapel, delivered from on high and believed on faith.
The argument that he has “other things to do” doesn’t make any sense. Debate would help sell his book, since his arguments are so defensible, right?
Yes, but it doesn’t mean that there aren’t viewpoints that are closer to the truth than others.

Because he’s got other things to do? Why is there this assumed obligation for Jimmy Carter to have a debate with this one specific person?

Of course they are. Why on earth would he write a controversial book espouding a viewpoint that he can’t defend himself?

Personally, I don’t think using the word ‘apartheid’ is especially helpful to describe the situation in Israel/Palestine, for various reasons. But it is certainly an arguable point of view - and I find his description of what is going on, whatever specific words he uses to describe it, to be realistic and compelling.

Mike
 
The argument that he has “other things to do” doesn’t make any sense. Debate would help sell his book, since his arguments are so defensible, right?
Debate in general, yes. A debate with Dershowitz - perhaps, perhaps not. I still don’t see why Jimmy Carter has this requirement to debate with this one specific person just because this person wants him to.

Mike
 
Debate in general, yes. A debate with Dershowitz - perhaps, perhaps not. I still don’t see why Jimmy Carter has this requirement to debate with this one specific person just because this person wants him to.

Mike
Who said it is a requirement for Carter to debate an expert with the opposite viewpoint? It is the courageous thing to do if you believe your viewpoint is defensable, but it is certainly not a requirement.
 
Who said it is a requirement for Carter to debate an expert with the opposite viewpoint? It is the courageous thing to do if you believe your viewpoint is defensable, but it is certainly not a requirement.
The thread is titled ‘Why won’t Carter debate his book?’ not ‘Why won’t Carter debate his book with me?’ Mr Dershowitz obviously feels there is some obligation on Mr Carter to debate specifically with him. As far as I can see, Mr Carter is debating his book with various articles, and of course published it in the first place. He’s just not debating with Mr Dershowitz.

Mike
 
The thread is titled ‘Why won’t Carter debate his book?’ not ‘Why won’t Carter debate his book with me?’ Mr Dershowitz obviously feels there is some obligation on Mr Carter to debate specifically with him. As far as I can see, Mr Carter is debating his book with various articles, and of course published it in the first place. He’s just not debating with Mr Dershowitz.

Mike
  1. The title of a thread has to match the article which it references. The article is written by Dershowitz, and it discusses Carter’s refusal to debate him. So, it seems to me that the thread is very much about Carter’s refusal to debate Dershowitz.
  2. An article is not a debate. Carter doesn’t appear confident enough to debate. He is more comfortable discussing his book with sycophants.
 
  1. The title of a thread has to match the article which it references. The article is written by Dershowitz, and it discusses Carter’s refusal to debate him. So, it seems to me that the thread is very much about Carter’s refusal to debate Dershowitz.
Yes, but I think we differ as to whether this is Carter’s or Dershowitz’s problem 😛
  1. An article is not a debate. Carter doesn’t appear confident enough to debate. He is more comfortable discussing his book with sycophants.
I’m not sure I agree. I don’t think we can draw many conclusions at all from his refusal to debate with just one man.

Anyway, I’m bowing out of this conversation here, as I need to get a reasonable sleep before travelling tomorrow. Merry Christmas 🙂

Mike
 
Yes, but I think we differ as to whether this is Carter’s or Dershowitz’s problem 😛
I don’t think it’s anyone’s “problem.” I just would like to see a good debate on the issue by two supposed experts from each side. I guess that is too much to expect.
 
I don’t think I ever questioned Mr Dershowitz’s expertise or claimed he didn’t know what he’s talking about.

Mr Dershowitz has his world view, which is pretty much that Israel is justified in whatever it does because Israel does it, and Mr Carter has his, which is obviously a different view. As a Catholic, I am much more comfortable with Mr Carter’s view than Mr Dershowitz’s view.
I hope you are not equating Mr Carters hatred of Israel and support of murderers and terrorists with Catholocism.
 
I hope you are not equating Mr Carters hatred of Israel and support of murderers and terrorists with Catholocism.
Mr Carter neither hates Israel nor supports murderers and terrorists. I don’t know where you’re getting this.

If you can find any public statements by Mr Carter to the effect that he really does “hate” Israel or that he “supports” murderers and terrorists, I’d love to see them. Shouldn’t be too hard to find if they exist.
 
  1. An article is not a debate. Carter doesn’t appear confident enough to debate. He is more comfortable discussing his book with sycophants.
Maybe Jimmy Carter just doesn’t want to get into the mud with Dershowitz.

Read Dershowitz’s attack piece. He persoanlly attacks Mr Carter as a “hypocrite” and a “bully”. He also refers to certain reviews of Mr Carter’s book calling it “moronic”, “anti-historical” and “riddled with errors and bias”. It’s a safe bet that Mr Dershowitz shares that opinion. I don’t know what good can be served by Mr Carter paying any attention whatsoever to Mr Dershowitz.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top