Why won't Carter debate his book?

  • Thread starter Thread starter estesbob
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe this is your confusion
No confusion whatsoever…my comment was directly in response to your comment:
I don’t know what good can be served by Mr Carter paying any attention whatsoever to Mr Dershowitz.
So, I asked what good can be served by any of us paying attention to Carter. A question you haven’t been able to answer btw. 😉

It does not mean I am not interested to hear from both of them. I think it would be an interesting debate. However, I’m pretty sure Dershowitz would win the debate, which is probably why Carter won’t take the challenge.
 
I haven’t seen that anywhere either, but it seems obvious. If you can’t smear him one way or the other, you’re going to have to consider that he may be right. For some strange reason, it is taboo (in America) to even ask the question, “hey, is Israel handling that Palestinian situation fairly?” let alone declare that they aren’t. As Carter said, these are fair subjects hotly debated everywhere (including Israel) but not here.

I propose Deshowitz debates An American jew who agrees with Carter (yes, they exist) and better yet, an Israeli citizen who agrees with Carter. But I get the feeling he never would, because bringing down an ex-president and Nobel prize winner would bring him more of the attention he craves.
So are you of the opinion that Carter is incpable of defending his own book? Do you really beleivethat these subjects are not hotly debated in America?? I see no evdecne of that but if its true, why? Is it ,as carter imlplies , because a Jewish Cabal contols the media and the Govt?
 
Bob

Have you thought through the problems associated with an ex-president in such issues? One side claims this is anti Semitic then we hear the U.S. President is straining to put Israel’s issues above U.S. citizens due to the threat of war. So, the ex-President is publicly explaining how to weaken the U.S. President via his experience with these issues. So the Palestinians use this information to flare up the issue which the current and next U.S. President have to deal with. It is not anti-Semite, it about the U.S minding the U.S.

By the way who is going to explain the “lack of strain” on the U.S. President to a U.S. President? You would either have to have a second U.S. President or at least a senior staffer.

Years ago Dwight David Eisenhower a U.S. President and former career military officer warned of the Defense Contractors undermining the U.S. Presidency, which was a brave warning. For which he would have to pay dearly. This was and act of honor. Today the same is happening again.
 
So are you of the opinion that Carter is incpable of defending his own book?
I believe Carter is perfectly capable of defending his book. It’s just that there is no need for him to engage a marginal figure like Alan Dershowitz.
40.png
estesbob:
Do you really beleivethat these subjects are not hotly debated in America??
Congress does occasionally take up divisive hot topics like abortion, partial birth abortion, and stem cell research. They even debate the merits of foreign aid to such-and-such countries.

I’m eagerly awaiting the next Congressional debate on whether Israel should receive the amount of aid it does. Also, that very public discussion of Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians is something to look forward to, as well.

Funny, but I guess I’ve missed recent past debates on these topics.
40.png
estesbob:
I see no evdecne of that but if its true, why? Is it ,as carter imlplies , because a Jewish Cabal contols the media and the Govt?
There is no “Jewish Cabal”. Many American Jews, as well as many Israelis, oppose what America and the Likud bloc are doing.
 
I believe Carter is perfectly capable of defending his book. It’s just that there is no need for him to engage a marginal figure like Alan Dershowitz.
Then why does he refuse to defend his book other than to take ad hominen attacks on those who crtiicize it?
Congress does occasionally take up divisive hot topics like abortion, partial birth abortion, and stem cell research. They even debate the merits of foreign aid to such-and-such countries.

I’m eagerly awaiting the next Congressional debate on whether Israel should receive the amount of aid it does. Also, that very public discussion of Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians is something to look forward to, as well.

Funny, but I guess I’ve missed recent past debates on these topics.
They debate it in every congress when they authorize aid to Israel. In addition one is hard pressed to find a Middle East Studies dept in any University that includes a supporter of israel. Of course i guess we culd carry on the debate like they do in Eurpope. Constant villification in the Press. Banning of Israeli prfofessors from speaking at Universities or conferences, systematic vanalism of Jewish Synagogues and Cemetries and the occasional kidnapping and torturing to death of Jewsih Students.
There is no “Jewish Cabal”. Many American Jews, as well as many Israelis, oppose what America and the Likud bloc are doing.
Tell that to Carter.

It is interesting that on one hand you tell us there is no Cabal but on the other hand tell us the deabte is stifled. Why is that?
 
Bob

Years ago Dwight David Eisenhower a U.S. President and former career military officer warned of the Defense Contractors undermining the U.S. Presidency, which was a brave warning. For which he would have to pay dearly. This was and act of honor. Today the same is happening again.
What happened to Eisenhower?
 
WARNING

This thread is wandering off topic. The topic is:

Why won’t Carter debate his book?
 
[EDIT: This is a repost…cleaned up for accuracy]
Texas Roofer:
*Maybe this is your confusion *
No confusion whatsoever…my comment was directly in response to gnjsdad’s comment (my apologies, for attributing it to you initially):
40.png
gnjsdad:
I don’t know what good can be served by Mr Carter paying any attention whatsoever to Mr Dershowitz.
So, I asked what good can be served by any of us paying attention to Carter.

It does not mean I am not interested to hear from both of them. I think it would be an interesting debate. However, I’m pretty sure Dershowitz would win the debate, which is probably why Carter won’t take the challenge.
 
Why do you assume Dershowitz would smear Carter, instead of debating him with facts? I don’t see any evidence that he would. He is very knowledgable about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Debating someone other than Carter about Carter’s book wouldn’t be fair to Carter - the other person may misrepresent what Carter intended.
I haven’t seen that anywhere either, but it seems obvious. If you can’t smear him one way or the other, you’re going to have to consider that he may be right. For some strange reason, it is taboo (in America) to even ask the question, “hey, is Israel handling that Palestinian situation fairly?” let alone declare that they aren’t. As Carter said, these are fair subjects hotly debated everywhere (including Israel) but not here.

I propose Deshowitz debates An American jew who agrees with Carter (yes, they exist) and better yet, an Israeli citizen who agrees with Carter. But I get the feeling he never would, because bringing down an ex-president and Nobel prize winner would bring him more of the attention he craves.
 
Why do you assume Dershowitz would smear Carter, instead of debating him with facts?
No assumption is necessary. I read what Dershowitz wrote and what he quoted from another person. The smearing is already done.
 
No assumption is necessary. I read what Dershowitz wrote and what he quoted from another person. The smearing is already done.
Can you provide a quote and source, because I haven’t seen smearing done by Dershowitz.
 
Can you provide a quote and source, because I haven’t seen smearing done by Dershowitz.
Go to post #1. Click on the link so neatly provided!👍
Begin to read, then count the number of words until you get to HYPOCRITE.

He then quote others’ words just as I said, MORONIC, LAUGHABLE, etc.

He is characterized as BEMOANING and “HE BLUSTERED”
“HE’S A BULLY”

I believe all of these fall under the heading: AD HOMINEM ATTACKS.

As a Harvard Law professor, Dershowitz should know this.

I could be wrong, but I call that smearing
 
So, you think Carter can’t handle someone calling him a hypocrite, a bully, saying he blustered or bemoaned? Okay. 😛

None of those are smears (an unsubstantiated charge or accusation), and none of them are calling him anti-semitic. You said both of those were obvious objectives of Dershowitz.

They are not obvious to me.
Go to post #1. Click on the link so neatly provided!👍
Begin to read, then count the number of words until you get to HYPOCRITE.

He then quote others’ words just as I said, MORONIC, LAUGHABLE, etc.

He is characterized as BEMOANING and “HE BLUSTERED”
“HE’S A BULLY”

I believe all of these fall under the heading: AD HOMINEM ATTACKS.

As a Harvard Law professor, Dershowitz should know this.

I could be wrong, but I call that smearing
 
What might the role be … of truth … and of Political Correctness … in Carter’s refusal to debate his book?

How do those two things … truth … and Political Correctness … manifest themselves not only with respect to Middle East policy as initiated by Carter’s presidency, but also in terms of how they impact the way Catholics should view the way Middle East policy is carried out today … in Iraq, in Afghanistan, with respect to India (south Asia) and Pakistan… and with respect to some of the religio-political movements such as Wahabism, and the Taliban, … and al Qaeda … and the differences in birth rates in Europe between “Christians” and “Muslims”?

It’s all of a piece.
 
Can you provide a quote and source, because I haven’t seen smearing done by Dershowitz.
You don’t appear to have read my post.😦

I quoted Dershowitz’s name-calling. But wait…

Maybe when Jimmy Carter is called a “bully” and a “hypocrite”, that’s not a smear.
 
You don’t appear to have read my post.😦

I quoted Dershowitz’s name-calling. But wait…

Maybe when Jimmy Carter is called a “bully” and a “hypocrite”, that’s not a smear.
Apparently, you didn’t read my last post. 😛 🙂

A smear is an “unsubstantiated charge or accusation” - not name calling. Personally, I think being called a bully or hypocrite is pretty mild. If Carter can’t handle that, then I understand why he is cowering in a corner, afraid to debate.
 
Is it ,as carter imlplies , because a Jewish Cabal contols the media and the Govt?
I haven’t read the book yet, but I’d be very surprised if the term “Jewish cabal” appears in it. If it did, we’d have heard about it by now.
 
Apparently, you didn’t read my last post. 😛 🙂

A smear is an “unsubstantiated charge or accusation” - not name calling. Personally, I think being called a bully or hypocrite is pretty mild. If Carter can’t handle that, then I understand why he is cowering in a corner, afraid to debate.
How about “moronic”?, “anti-historical”?

I have to chuckle at your characterization of Carter as “cowering in a corner” because he refuses to debate the likes of Dershowitz. As if Dershowitz embodied a standard anyone should follow…
 
None of those are smears (an unsubstantiated charge or accusation)
Ah…that’s a smear. Then maybe Dershowitz is just name calling. Again, it’s what we’ve come to expect, but it’s still disappointing from a Harvard Law Professor.

So I guess the real “smears” were the things I pointed out in post #79 where Carter was accused of encouraging terrorism and also, by innuendo, declared mentally ill.

That’s some varsity smearing!👍
and none of them are calling him anti-semitic. You said both of those were obvious objectives of Dershowitz.
They are not obvious to me.
I think you’re mixing me up with some others around here. I don’t recall ever using the words anti-semitic, or naming any objectives of Dershowitz, except for one, he wants more media time. That is is only goal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top