Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So if you are in the 1% (which I disagree w/, most sources say that is only w/perfect use) you and your husband will think that all those months/years w/ all that sex was worth your death? Even if you knew you could prevent it w/ abstaining? I guess sex just isn’t that important to us then. :-/
Well don’t get me wrong, we’d be as careful as humanely possible, that’s for sure.

But yes, I hold sex with my husband to a very high esteem. It’s a renewal of our wedding vows and it’s a physical, spiritual, emotional way of giving ourselves to each other entirely. Yes, to me that is worth the very small risk. 👍

I’m a newly wed (a little over a year) so it’s still a fascinating, wonderful thing to me.
 
Haha. I’m a romantic I guess. Or maybe I’m just madly in love with my husband. 🙂

I’d rather take a 1% chance that my life will be in danger rather than not be intimate with my husband for the rest of my life.
I guess this is part of trusting God.

We shouldn’t have anymore children, I have a higher risk for miscarriage or a preemie. Plus other health issues. We don’t abstain completely, and actually this month abandoned the method on a fertile day. :whistle:

Although I’ll probably be nervous until AF comes or not, I figure if God wants a baby, then His will be done. He’ll give me the stregnth to accept what ever comes.
 
As someone who was in that situation when we were early in our marriage (we had been married fewer than 5 years), my husband loved me too much to take that 1% chance of my death from pregnancy. We were not Catholic then, we did not use any form of ABC, so we abstained for a few years, then we went to conservative NFP.
I can understand his way of thinking, and my husband would feel the same way, I’m sure. I guess I’d have to convince him and make sure he knows how incredibly important it is to me.
 
Well don’t get me wrong, we’d be as careful as humanely possible, that’s for sure.

But yes, I hold sex with my husband to a very high esteem. It’s a renewal of our wedding vows and it’s a physical, spiritual, emotional way of giving ourselves to each other entirely. Yes, to me that is worth the very small risk. 👍

I’m a newly wed (a little over a year) so it’s still a fascinating, wonderful thing to me.
  1. So you are willing to take an IMMORAL risk and use artificial birth control and risk your immortal soul and that of your husband, but not take a MORAL risk and use NFP?
  2. If a couple is using artificial birth control with full knowledge of it’s sinfulness and full consent of the will, they have cut themself off from the Grace of God and are probably not renewing their sacramental wedding vows.
 
I guess this is part of trusting God.

We shouldn’t have anymore children, I have a higher risk for miscarriage or a preemie. Plus other health issues. We don’t abstain completely, and actually this month abandoned the method on a fertile day. :whistle:

Although I’ll probably be nervous until AF comes or not, I figure if God wants a baby, then His will be done. He’ll give me the stregnth to accept what ever comes.
Yes… this is the trust. If you take the risk, you trust in God’s will. If you cannot take the risk, you don’t.
 
Ok, I’ll bite: where did that one come from?
The way God designed marriage is that we are called to that vocation, we prepare and enter a valid marriage. We then have sexual relations and lovingly accept children.

When we have a serious reason to delay having children, or a serious reason to space children, we abstain from relations. When abstaining will cause one of the partners to sin (masturbation or adultery), we have recourse to using the God-designed cycles of the female reproductive system to determine when we are infertile and may take recourse of using those times to have sex.

NFP is not the default normal state of marriage, it is only used when there is something wrong that prevents us from welcoming a child at this time.
 
I don’t think you have to have a discussion monthly…just that you are fertile once a month so it seems like a good time to discuss it. I think that the more often you discuss it the better. In the interest of full disclosure we don’t use NFP, we have decided that there are very few reasons we would avoid and we haven’t reached them.
I think that they’re “discussing” it one way or another if they’re avoiding during their fertile times…but to sit down and have a discernment discussion isn’t something I’d consider necessary. I mean, the most fertile time for a woman is when they have to abstain. If it’s not important to them to not get pregnant, they’re more likely to “cheat” and risk pregnancy. If they’re adamant about avoiding, especially when she want it most, there must be a good reason…and real-life doesn’t always work on a monthly basis. Again, the Church doesn’t require Catholics to actively try to get pregnant, or to have a certain amount of kids. They only require that there be no physical or chemical barriers to interfere with the unitive property, and to accept any life that God sends their way…they don’t have to try and they can continue to avoid.
 
The way God designed marriage is that we are called to that vocation, we prepare and enter a valid marriage. We then have sexual relations and lovingly accept children.

When we have a serious reason to delay having children, or a serious reason to space children, we abstain from relations. When abstaining will cause one of the partners to sin (masturbation or adultery), we have recourse to using the God-designed cycles of the female reproductive system to determine when we are infertile and may take recourse of using those times to have sex.

NFP is not the default normal state of marriage, it is only used when there is something wrong that prevents us from welcoming a child at this time.
Yup. 👍
 
I think that they’re “discussing” it one way or another if they’re avoiding during their fertile times…but to sit down and have a discernment discussion isn’t something I’d consider necessary. I mean, the most fertile time for a woman is when they have to abstain. If it’s not important to them to not get pregnant, they’re more likely to “cheat” and risk pregnancy. If they’re adamant about avoiding, especially when she want it most, there must be a good reason…and real-life doesn’t always work on a monthly basis. Again, the Church doesn’t require Catholics to actively try to get pregnant, or to have a certain amount of kids. They only require that there be no physical or chemical barriers to interfere with the unitive property, and to accept any life that God sends their way…they don’t have to try and they can continue to avoid.
(emphasis mine)

They can only to continue to avoid pregnancy if they have a just/serious reason.
 
Haha. I’m a romantic I guess. Or maybe I’m just madly in love with my husband. 🙂

I’d rather take a 1% chance that my life will be in danger rather than not be intimate with my husband for the rest of my life.
Maybe I might change my mind someday Debora, but right now this second, I’m thinking that if a pregnancy were truly a danger to my life, I wouldn’t be using NFP or ABCs. But I can totally understand your point of view as well. I can’t see a couple not being intimate for that long unless the reason was very very serious, like death.
 
Maybe I might change my mind someday Debora, but right now this second, I’m thinking that if a pregnancy were truly a danger to my life, I wouldn’t be using NFP or ABCs. But I can totally understand your point of view as well. I can’t see a couple not being intimate for that long unless the reason was very very serious, like death.
Yeah, I think everyone here would agree with that. Complete abstinence should only be used in the MOST extreme circumstances, like death. Or if NFP has been determined to be unreliable and the couple has a just/serious reason to avoid.
 
So if you are in the 1% (which I disagree w/, most sources say that is only w/perfect use) you and your husband will think that all those months/years w/ all that sex was worth your death? Even if you knew you could prevent it w/ abstaining? I guess sex just isn’t that important to us then. :-/
OR, that the thought of a 1% chance of a potential complication that might cause illness and/or death isn’t as important as sharing the marital embrace with one’s spouse is to others? Everyone’s different and even their health status is different. One’s point of view could be based on the degree health threat involved as well.
 
(emphasis mine)

They can only to continue to avoid pregnancy if they have a just/serious reason.
Which can only be determined by each individual family according to their indivual situation. The Church doesn’t require Catholics to have a predetermined set of children, or a minimum or maximum amount of children. They just require one be ‘open to life’ and accept any life that results from the marriage. They don’t require actively trying to become pregnant either.
 
OR, that the thought of a 1% chance of a potential complication that might cause illness and/or death isn’t as important as sharing the marital embrace with one’s spouse is to others? Everyone’s different and even their health status is different. One’s point of view could be based on the degree health threat involved as well.
There is also the unborn child’s life to consider.
 
Which can only be determined by each individual family according to their indivual situation. The Church doesn’t require Catholics to have a predetermined set of children, or a minimum or maximum amount of children. They just require one be ‘open to life’ and accept any life that results from the marriage. They don’t require actively trying to become pregnant either.
No one has ever said that the Church does teach this. Only that NFP/abstinence can only be used with a serious/just reason.

Not using NFP doesn’t mean “actively trying” it just means… maybe it will, maybe it won’t. It means we have no serious reason to avoid pregnancy at this time and we are leaving the rest up to God.
 
They don’t require actively trying to become pregnant either.
If by “actively trying” do you mean fertility drugs or charting to only have relations during the fertile time, then, correct.

If by “actively trying” you mean to have sexual relations, well, as a married couple we can mutually agree to abstain (and prayerfully do so, see St Paul on that one). If one of the partners struggles with abstaining, it is sinful to refuse the marital debt.
 
What would you recommend for people that have serious reasons and NFP does not work for them.
I would highly recommend they work with doctors and NFP specialists to determine WHY NFP doesn’t work. Is it a hormone deficiency? Would weight/loss or gain help? Taking a supplement?

If all of these are exhausted, complete abstinence is the only other moral option, as outlined by the Church.
 
I don’t understand what that means…?
If two people engage is sex knowing that if pregnancy results there is a 100% chance of serious complications that would result in death… they also need to consider the life of the baby that would be conceived.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top