Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The reason is because the teachings of the Church are a matter of faith, and are more abstract without physical consequences that compare to the civil laws that govern people. If you steal, and get caught, you will have to defend yourself in a court of law, and most likely will be fined and/or jailed. There are no physical and immediate consequences to going on birth control because they are legal and acceptable in society. The Church says it is wrong, and you will be punished for it later and all that is abstract and removed from many people’s reality. So I have a hard time relating to your analogy. But maybe it will help someone else 🙂
So if they don’t get caught it is moral?
 
So if a couple is struggling with incredible financial strain and is in debt up to their ears, they are in the clear to steal money to solve that problem? By your thinking above the problem that couple is having is at least in part the moral choice they made not to steal, right? I believe financial problems is up near being the number one reason for divorce and has an even greater threat to marriage than lack of sexual intimacy. If a person can avoid sexual morals in the name of saving a marriage why not other morals that might prevent an even greater threat to a marriage?
By that analogy, if someone is in financial trouble and ran out of all options for help - because there are indeed places and people to turn to - they can go steal. So, not being able to be intimate with one’s spouse, not having someone to turn to, it is OK to go have an affair? Doesn’t make sense, does it?

Not everything is morally equivalent.
 
The reason is because the teachings of the Church are a matter of faith, and are more abstract without physical consequences that compare to the civil laws that govern people. If you steal, and get caught, you will have to defend yourself in a court of law, and most likely will be fined and/or jailed. There are no physical and immediate consequences to going on birth control because they are legal and acceptable in society. The Church says it is wrong, and you will be punished for it later and all that is abstract and removed from many people’s reality. So I have a hard time relating to your analogy. But maybe it will help someone else 🙂
Haha I would be more scared of God than I would of the law 😉 Plus the law at times penalizes us for doing what God tells us is right. Maybe not so much in the U.S but definitely in other parts of the World. The law is completely relativistic.
 
The reason is because the teachings of the Church are a matter of faith, and are more abstract without physical consequences that compare to the civil laws that govern people. If you steal, and get caught, you will have to defend yourself in a court of law, and most likely will be fined and/or jailed. There are no physical and immediate consequences to going on birth control because they are legal and acceptable in society. The Church says it is wrong, and you will be punished for it later and all that is abstract and removed from many people’s reality. So I have a hard time relating to your analogy. But maybe it will help someone else 🙂
Civil law and consequences are, unfortunately, not always built around objective truth.

The government could decide tomorrow that stealing is legal. They have already made murder legal through abortion.

God has been pretty clear about both- “Thou shall not steal.” and the exhaustive teachings of Christ’s Bride, the Church, on married sexuality. The ultimate consequence is that both stealing and artificial contraception are objectively mortally sinful and merit Hell. It’s a reasonable analogy.
 
I keep wondering, what if a couple who was infertile tried using NFP to CONCEIVE and was unable to?
They are frustrated and hurt.
Obviously, the NFP is to blame here, right? What? No? It’s the infertility? gasp
That’s a whole other ball of wax. Many people turn to fertility treatments and IVF, which is against Church teaching as well, and yes, they are angry at the Church for that teaching. So yeah, it goes both ways…they’re not angry with the Church for NFP. They’re angry with the Church for imposing it on them and feel like they are being held emotionally hostage with the threat of hellfire and damnation. Again, it’s not your stumbling block, so I totally understand your perspective. But it is a stumbling block for many …
Well, then they should be mad at God about the fact that NFP didn’t work for them! After all, they were promised that they could use it to conceive in their pre-cana classes!
I don’t think they’re mad at God, but they do get mad at the Church.
Or… maybe they should discover WHY they are infertile?
Maybe if they discover there is nothing they can do about their infertility, they should accept that cross and move forward with other moral options?
Or would you suggest that, because they were told that NFP would help them conceive that the Church is at fault here? That they should look into other, immoral options like IVF?
That’s generally what non-Catholics do, yes… practicing Catholics wouldn’t consider it, no. I thought about it before I happened upon this forum, and then discovered it was forbidden by the Church. I don’t believe in the teaching, I don’t agree with it. And in fact, I think it’s bogus. But I have enough faith in the Church to put the thoughts of IVF out of my mind because I choose to remain Catholic. No, I’m not mad at God for the teaching. But the Church annoys me with their rules and laws and regulations. I feel the Church is more about rules and laws than about loving God, and notion that the more one obeys those laws, the more they love God. But those are the rules, and as long as I choose to be Catholic, I’ll do my best to follow them. So IVF was taken off the list of things to accomplish …
 
How is saying “I understand NFP can be hard” dishonest?

People who claim to be Catholic and post on a Catholic forum and encourage others to sin should be quiet.
But I disagree that Searching is encouraging others to sin. It looks like he’s encouraging people (by his living example) to follow the rules of the Church despite hating the rules. And I think that’s a good thing. Also, this is a discussion forum. Those who disagree with your aren’t going to be quiet, they’re going to discuss their perspective and then you will yours. Being quiet wouldn’t be a discussion board. That would be a closed forum where something is posted, and then no one would have an opportunity to share their thoughts, views, struggles, etc.
 
But I disagree that Searching is encouraging others to sin. It looks like she’s encouraging people (by her living example) to follow the rules of the Church despite hating the rules. And I think that’s a good thing. Also, this is a discussion forum. Those who disagree with your aren’t going to be quiet, they’re going to discuss their perspective and then you will yours. Being quiet wouldn’t be a discussion board. That would be a closed forum where something is posted, and then no one would have an opportunity to share their thoughts, views, struggles, etc.
There is a big difference between “I am struggling with understanding this particular teaching the the Church… can we discuss these issues?” and “Well I think the Church is wrong on X, Y, and Z. These teachings are bogus. Couples should pray and decide for themselves”
 
How is saying “I understand NFP can be hard” dishonest?

People who claim to be Catholic and post on a Catholic forum and encourage others to sin should be quiet.
Again, SILENCE with those who disagree. Off with our heads!

Oh, I am quite Catholic. Just because I disagree with and struggle does not change that. Disagreeing and struggling and questioning is not encouraging others to sin.

So only those who are perfectly aligned with everything are Catholic?

Saying only that NFP can be hard is dishonest if that is all that is said. Purposely avoiding discussing why, and especially with combined with church teachings on sex, and shrugging off those who do have problems, is wrong.

I can guarantee you that when we did finally hear about NFP and chose to use it, it was no big deal, because we did not know about church teachings on sex. Nothing was said. We engaged in sexual intimacy in other ways; we are married; never questioned it; never had questions of conscience. That only arose when someone told us about the CCC and what it said about sex. My wife and I disagree, but we follow it to the letter, no matter the impact, and there are and have been. Discussing that is not leading others to sin.

Telling those who disagree and question to be quiet because we are leading others to sin is wrong.
 
By that analogy, if someone is in financial trouble and ran out of all options for help - because there are indeed places and people to turn to - they can go steal. So, not being able to be intimate with one’s spouse, not having someone to turn to, it is OK to go have an affair? Doesn’t make sense, does it?

Not everything is morally equivalent.
Exactly it doesn’t. It doesn’t make sense that an affair would be morally acceptable to prevent a divorce anymore than it does to say other sexual alternatives outside of intercourse would be allowed to save a marriage.

Morals are not if, then statements. Culpability and the graveness of an action can be if, then statements but the moral itself is not.
 
He has said that the Church should not tell us that sex needs to end w/ climax in the wife. He has alluded that people should have the right to pray about what is right for them and then engage in possibly immoral sex. How is that not scandalous?
Because that’s exactly how he feels about it. And notice, despite telling us exactly how he feels about it, he’s still following those rules. He’s not saying: go out and buy contraceptives and condoms and go at it kids. He’s saying: this sucks, I hate it, I hate feeling like I have to follow all these stupid outdated rules, I feel like I should have more autonomy, but I’m doing it anyway. That’s not scandalous, that’s part of life. He is praying about it and doing what is right for him…and choosing to suffer for it. He’s not the only one struggling with this teaching, and he’s not the only one following the teaching despite being angry about it. That’s not scandalous.
 
That’s a whole other ball of wax. Many people turn to fertility treatments and IVF, which is against Church teaching as well, and yes, they are angry at the Church for that teaching. So yeah, it goes both ways…they’re not angry with the Church for NFP. They’re angry with the Church for imposing it on them and feel like they are being held emotionally hostage with the threat of hellfire and damnation. Again, it’s not your stumbling block, so I totally understand your perspective. But it is a stumbling block for many …

I don’t think they’re mad at God, but they do get mad at the Church.

That’s generally what non-Catholics do, yes… practicing Catholics wouldn’t consider it, no. I thought about it before I happened upon this forum, and then discovered it was forbidden by the Church. I don’t believe in the teaching, I don’t agree with it. And in fact, I think it’s bogus. But I have enough faith in the Church to put the thoughts of IVF out of my mind because I choose to remain Catholic. No, I’m not mad at God for the teaching. But the Church annoys me with their rules and laws and regulations. I feel the Church is more about rules and laws than about loving God, and notion that the more one obeys those laws, the more they love God. But those are the rules, and as long as I choose to be Catholic, I’ll do my best to follow them. So IVF was taken off the list of things to accomplish …
Okay, so you are struggling to conform your will to the teachings of the Church. That’s understandable and normal. Do you pray for it? Do you research WHY the Church teaches what it does about both conjugal sex and IVF? Do you work towards understanding the teachings?

That’s what we are supposed to do. No one said you have to have 100% understanding of all the Church’s teachings. Everyone has said, you cannot choose sin.
 
Haha I would be more scared of God than I would of the law 😉 Plus the law at times penalizes us for doing what God tells us is right. Maybe not so much in the U.S but definitely in other parts of the World. The law is completely relativistic.
And that’s what drives you 🙂 Not everyone is the same. Others aren’t driven that way. The rules of the Church are more abstract to them, and the consequences far removed.
 
Again, SILENCE with those who disagree. Off with our heads!

Oh, I am quite Catholic. Just because I disagree with and struggle does not change that. Disagreeing and struggling and questioning is not encouraging others to sin.

So only those who are perfectly aligned with everything are Catholic?

Saying only that NFP can be hard is dishonest if that is all that is said. Purposely avoiding discussing why, and especially with combined with church teachings on sex, and shrugging off those who do have problems, is wrong.

I can guarantee you that when we did finally hear about NFP and chose to use it, it was no big deal, because we did not know about church teachings on sex. Nothing was said. We engaged in sexual intimacy in other ways; we are married; never questioned it; never had questions of conscience. That only arose when someone told us about the CCC and what it said about sex. My wife and I disagree, but we follow it to the letter, no matter the impact, and there are and have been. Discussing that is not leading others to sin.

Telling those who disagree and question to be quiet because we are leading others to sin is wrong.
You did not come on here saying “I am struggling and questioning”. You can on here saying " I completely disagree with this. The Church is wrong. Couples can engage in other forms of sexual acts if they want to."

There is a vaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaast difference. One is acceptable. The other is not.
 
There is a big difference between “I am struggling with understanding this particular teaching the the Church… can we discuss these issues?” and “Well I think the Church is wrong on X, Y, and Z. These teachings are bogus. Couples should pray and decide for themselves”
You forgot about the part where he’s actually following the teachings, depsite hating doing so. There’s nothing special about following the rules when one is totally on board with them. That’s not a struggle, and that’s not a burden. That’s easy. Following rules one doesn’t agree with is hard. That’s where the real sacrifices are. It’s not a sacrifice to follow rules you totally buy into.
 
And that’s what drives you 🙂 Not everyone is the same. Others aren’t driven that way. The rules of the Church are more abstract to them, and the consequences far removed.
The Church’s ‘rules’ are God’s ‘rules’. The idea of eternal damnation drives a lot of people. It’s called imperfect contrition.
 
And that’s what drives you 🙂 Not everyone is the same. Others aren’t driven that way. The rules of the Church are more abstract to them, and the consequences far removed.
Haha well that is the problem that needs to be addressed then. Doing something out of fear from God is not the ideal at all. The hope would be we follow the moral code because we see how it has our best interests at heart, and because we trust God to take care of us when it doesn’t appear to do so. Obviously this isn’t always the case and having the fear of God to fall back on in those tough times is needed. Doing something purely out of fear of God though always means a rough ride and a lot of suffering.
 
You forgot about the part where she’s actually following the teachings, depsite hating doing so. There’s nothing special about following the rules when one is totally on board with them. That’s not a struggle, and that’s not a burden. That’s easy. Following rules one doesn’t agree with is hard. That’s where the real sacrifices are. It’s not a sacrifice to follow rules you totally buy into.
I didn’t forget that part. And everyone struggles with one or another teaching of the Church. It’s not like people were just magically able to understand everything.
 
My wife and I disagree, but we follow it to the letter, no matter the impact, and there are and have been. Discussing that is not leading others to sin.
:doh2: I’m sorry! I didn’t know you were a HE. I will respond to posts accordingly. 😊
 
Because that’s exactly how she feels about it. And notice, despite telling us exactly how she feels about it, she’s still following those rules. She’s not saying: go out and buy contraceptives and condoms and go at it kids. She’s saying: this sucks, I hate it, I hate feeling like I have to follow all these stupid outdated rules, I feel like I should have more autonomy, but I’m doing it anyway. That’s not scandalous, that’s part of life. She is praying about it and doing what is right for her…and choosing to suffer for it. She’s not the only one struggling with this teaching, and she’s not the only one following the teaching despite being angry about it. That’s not scandalous.
Just realized that you and I have been referring to searching as a “she” but clearly they are a “he”.

I think the scandal comes in how he is relating his hardships. In having the extreme anger be the primary thing showing in his posts it is breeding hostility. It is extremely commendable to follow the teaching without having the understanding but then the person should be trying to gain the understanding. Less “I hate the Church’s teaching but I do it anyway but it makes me angry but I do t but it sucks”.and more “I don’t understand or agree w/ this teaching but I am following it because that is what Christ would want. I’m also seeking to get a better understanding.” Do you see the difference?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top