You miss the point. We are asking Mary to help us by asking her to intercede for us with her son Our Lord.
John 19:26-27 "When Jesus saw his mother, and the disciple whom he loved standing near, he said to his mother, “Woman, behold, your son!” Then he said to the disciple, “Behold, your mother!” You seem to have a lot of doubts, and that is OK. Just put all the other things aside and focus on the Eucharist.
God bless,
Brendan
Brendan,
you keep telling me I miss the point. I am telling you about my experience as a Catholic who might have converted too fast. I don’t know. The problem remains: what I am going to do now? I have done all the studying I can and heard every argument, and my feeling of unease increases.
You tell me to just remain where I am and focus on the Eucharist. That is what I have been doing until now, although, let us face it, it is not a lasting solution, and it is not fair to me nor to the Catholics in my parish. I sense a great peace when I sit with Jesus. But communially speaking, I have only felt the unity and peace when I was with people who shared my faith and focus.
Can you understand that you can not admonish a person into believing something they do no’t believe?
You quote a passage from Scripture, and read a whole huge meaning into the fact that John was asked to take care of Mary after Jesus’ death and resurrection. The church has elevated this passage into a symbol of such force that all of us must treat the passage more strongly than any fundamentalist ever would. Growing up as a Protestant I never ever of my own mind, came to the comclusion based on those verses, that Mary was my mother too.
Nowhere does the Church tell me that I have to have to believe in the apparitions at Lourdes or that I have to pray the rosary or make consecrations to Mary etc.
I have no issues with you liking to go to Lourdes, or that someone get’s a healing from Jesus after having asked Mary to pray for him. What I take issue with is that I practically am not left in peace if I say, I do not wish to focus on Mary, pray the rosary or deal with apparitions. I would like to keep my faith-directed language (words like “hope, sweetness, salvation, mediator” etc.) focused on the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit where I believe they belong, and get my main inspiration from Scripture instead of from “messages”.
You imply that I exaggerate when I say I feel pressure to conform. All I can say is how would you like it if every Sunday at your parish songs were sung that did not express your thoughts or feelings about something, or all your parish friends would seek to persuade you to have a certain kind of devotion, that you didn’t feel at home with. And some would even imply that the Lord was displeased with you if you did not have that same spirituality. as them. That is the greatest peasure you can put on a Christian person. You make them scared that God is not pleased with them because of their honest thoughts, and it is a horrible place for the person who must live with this kind of shaming. You can say it is not pressure. But it does create a strong sense of estrangement.
You can believe that Lourdes is Scriptural. I do not really know what you mean by “scriptural”. When I say I have a hard time seeing the connection between present day apparitions of Mary and the Gospels of Jesus, it is because I see no examples in Scripture of apparitions initiated by saints that had already crossed over and where such attention is given to the apparition, the place and the saint as a source of healing and hope. People say they follow Jesus and are led to Jesus through Mary. I can not deny that, if that is their experience, but I always wonder why then are they mentioning the name of Mary so much. Why do they seek her before they seek Jesus, why do they - through their own words - seem to have more hope in her help than in his?
I guess it is a problem of proportion. I have met Catholics who were so engaged with marian apparitions and other mystical litterature, that they didn’t know anymore when they quoted Scripture and when they quoted some saints from a private revelation.
You seem to think that Jesus does not unify himself with Protestants, that he is not their aim, and that he is not truly present in the assemblies that praise him.
He is the aim. And you can find no where where I say otherwise. However, disciples of Jesus has many valid needs and God knows that. I do think that a lot of Evangelical Pentecostal persons and churches seem more focused on Christ, and on the Holy Spirit as a living Person. Catholics are preoccupied with so many other things than those main Persons, and following their words and example from Scripture.
Maybe you think I am just a weak person looking for worldly comfort. You know what, I do not mind. I admit it… I do not like having to invite sick people to go to Protestant lay people in order to get healed in the name of Jesus, because I cannot find a single Catholic in a huge surrounding that seems to have the gift of healing that the Bible speaks of. I do not like to have to go to Protestants when I could really use a word of prophesy. I do need the community and the joy and the evangelization in such places.
I need to hear the simple Gospel preached without layers of stuff. I need Catholic leaders to explain why Jesus did all these healings and asked the disciples to do so, when we do not do it today. I need an explanation as to where the people with prophetic ministry have gone, and why they are not allowed to speak in the parishes.
I have many questions and doubts and it is growing bigger and bigger inside of me. So you can say: put a lid on and focus on the Eucharist. But even if I worship Jesus in solitude an empty church building I am still a human being with a mind and a heart.