Catholic identity crisis

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaisyNJesus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I pose simple questions.

Are these Penetcostals investigated by a commission, group of peers, or expected to present objective evidence such as doctor’s reports etc when they claim a miracle occured?

If not how do you know they aren’t simply lying?
 
Yet you are OK with miracles that occur as a result of a Pentecostal lay minister laying on hands?

And Mary does not cause these miracles herself, she intervenes for us. In effect she prays for us to Our Lord (her son) who then acts. It sometimes seems to me that many protestants seem to have no issue with asking a living person to pray to Our Lord for them, but take issue when the saints are asked to do likewise. They seem to have no issue accepting miracles that seem to occur through the intercession modern day evangelical pastors and charismatic lay-people, but seem to take issue when miracles occur through the intercession of the saints.

Yes other things are important, but compared to the enormity of what is the Eucharist they do pale into mere tools. The Holy sacrifice at Calvary is the very centre of our Faith and it dwarfs everything else in our Faith, in Christianity, in the whole world. How can everything else in our Faith and in this world not pale into insignificance compared to the very physical presence of Our Lord in the Eucharist?

The Eucharist IS the source and summit of all Christian life, not community, not charismatic gifts, not even scripture, but the Eucharist.
👍

I would not feel comfortable in a charismatic setting because it seems too close to protestants. I believe it came out of protestantism. If someone asked me that is what I would say however I would not feel the need to try and dissuade others from such a thing for as you stated earlier it is a big Church with room for many as long as it is approved by the Church. So I wonder why some Catholics feel the need to come on a Catholic forum and question the devotion to the Blessed Mother that the Church has.
 
My wife is a devout Catholic involved with the Charismatic Renewal. We attend different parishes since I prefer Latin Mass. We are moving to Florida and, for the first time in years, we will likely attend the same Catholic parish near our home. If anything, I may recite Latin prayers during Holy Mass while everyone else recites in English.
 
I have experienced spiritual manifestations found in the Charismatic Renewal, I found them very inspiring, and edifying. I was a pioneer in the Renewal, by God’s calling. But I would never exchange what I have in my Catholic Faith. for all the Charismatic experience and power in the world. It made me love my Faith even more. But I did learn something very important, that people need a personal encounter with Jesus, a real experience, a touch of the Divine to make their Faith come alive. When the Apostles encountered Jesus on the road to Emmaus, they didn’t recognize Him, after He left the them, they said "Didn’t we feel our hearts burning within us, when Jesus spoke They were so over-joyed that they couldn’t help but talk about Him to everyone This is what happens
to us when we have this encounter, we can’t help talking about it, and a lot of people who don,t understand what has taking place actually get turned off, actually they have never been turned on. I know what I have I pray for the grace of final perseverance, like St.Paul, who said I fought the good fight, and now there is a crown awaiting for me, (to be united with my Lord. We need our Pentecost, and our Magnificat, like Mary. If you believe in the Gospel, Mary prophesied that the world will call Her blessed because of what God did to her, where is this prophesy fulfilled, where? It is true there are some innocent over pious faithful, and the Church reminds them that devotion to her is only justified if it leads to Jesus. As for me, she is my spiritual mother that will always keep faithful to her Son. Jesus gave her to us when He said to St.John, before Jesus died “Son behold thy mother, and mother behold thy son” Thats why we Catholics love Mary, she suffered in union with Her Son Jesus. You simply don’t understand, and you need to grow in understanding. We pray that you receive this “Enlightenment” Jesus is truly present in the Eucharist, I know.
 
I pose simple questions.

Are these Penetcostals investigated by a commission, group of peers, or expected to present objective evidence such as doctor’s reports etc when they claim a miracle occured?

If not how do you know they aren’t simply lying?
It surprises me that your approach to this is to simply suspect brother Christians of lying.
All I can say is that the people who told me about the dead being raised were worthy to be believed. Much more so than those who never do anything but talk.
They are not stupid that they would not know a corpse from a living person.

I have heard such testimonies the last few years from different countries in the world where people who suffer a lot for the sake of the Gospel and preach it (in Africa and China etc.) see huge miracles.

But I have also heard a story like this very close to my home. A Pentecostal father aised his son back to life again - after a deadly accident that had completely destroyed the little boy - through persistent and trusting supplication for about half an hour.

I believe the Western world with its intellectualism and philosophy has made us into sceptics.

The minister Heidi Baker, whom I mentioned earlier, has also seen people raised from the dead. At least five children, who were prayed over by simple African pastors who didn’t know that they were not supposed to pray for such things apparantly. I have met Mrs. Baker and would say she is one of the greatest missionaries alive today because she follows the example of Christ. The word anointing has a clear meaning even when you read her books.

Another testimony I could mention is the famous convert from Islam to Christianity, Gulshan Esther, who wrote her testimony book called “The Torn Veil”. She tells not only about her complete healing from being a cripple after a vision of Jesus Christ, but also how she actually raises her sister back to life. Again there is no reason I would insist on doubting testimonies which are so clearly in line with the Gospels. Jesus told his disciples to do these things, just like he told Peter to step out on the water, which also might sound silly or unprovable for a modern western ear.

Now its amazing to me that you much rather assume that such testimonies are lies, than that you would willingly trust the word of Jesus himself to his disciples:
“Heal the sick, raise up the dead, clean the lepers, cast out demons! You have been given it for free, give it for free”. (Matthew 10: 7-8 )

I think we can learn a great deal about faith from other parts of the Body.

Daisy
 
👍

I would not feel comfortable in a charismatic setting because it seems too close to protestants. I believe it came out of protestantism. If someone asked me that is what I would say however I would not feel the need to try and dissuade others from such a thing for as you stated earlier it is a big Church with room for many as long as it is approved by the Church. So I wonder why some Catholics feel the need to come on a Catholic forum and question the devotion to the Blessed Mother that the Church has.
Johnny, in fact I think you are right. The Catholics did experience revival through the preaching and healing of Evangelicals, and became hungry for the Holy Spirit and his work, which is what the charismatic renewal is all about.

One book where you can read about this is called “A man called Mr. Pentecost” by David duPlessis, an ardent anti-Catholic who was called by God to tell the Catholics about the many gifts of the Holy Spirit. DuPlessis was not asked to tell Catholics to leave the Church. He was very humbled and had God taught him love for and unity with Catholics. His book is an amazing testimony which has the capacity to create a longing in every heart for more of the life in the Spirit, that some people actually have. The book was an eye opener for me.

Now, Catholics always say the New Testament is a Catholic book, written and understood by the Church itself. Well, the New Testament is extremely charismatic. Just read the Gospel of Matthew. I have lost count of all the times where Jesus is said to have: healed the sick, cast out demons, cured the leper, raised the dead, “healed everyone”, “healed everyone”, “healed them all” (!), and having thereby fulfilled the prophesy “it was our sicknesses he carried” (this is clearly written with reference to physical healing, and not only spiritual), and sending out disciples to do all these same things, saying: “these signs will follow those who believe, they will cast out demons, heal the sick, etc.”

A huge percentage of the New Testament is about these healings and mighty deeds, which were a natural and integrated part of preaching the Kingdom, and manifesting it within the early Church. Also the miracles were signs to confirm what was being said by the disciples.

It seems you will build a whole set of teachings about Mary and the saints based on one or two vague verses in the whole Bible, but you choose to ignore the these long and striking passages about the charismatic nature of Christian evangelisation.
Why is that?
 
I have experienced spiritual manifestations found in the Charismatic Renewal, I found them very inspiring, and edifying. I was a pioneer in the Renewal, by God’s calling. But I would never exchange what I have in my Catholic Faith. for all the Charismatic experience and power in the world. It made me love my Faith even more. But I did learn something very important, that people need a personal encounter with Jesus, a real experience, a touch of the Divine to make their Faith come alive. When the Apostles encountered Jesus on the road to Emmaus, they didn’t recognize Him, after He left the them, they said "Didn’t we feel our hearts burning within us, when Jesus spoke They were so over-joyed that they couldn’t help but talk about Him to everyone This is what happens
to us when we have this encounter, we can’t help talking about it, and a lot of people who don,t understand what has taking place actually get turned off, actually they have never been turned on. I know what I have I pray for the grace of final perseverance, like St.Paul, who said I fought the good fight, and now there is a crown awaiting for me, (to be united with my Lord. We need our Pentecost, and our Magnificat, like Mary. If you believe in the Gospel, Mary prophesied that the world will call Her blessed because of what God did to her, where is this prophesy fulfilled, where? It is true there are some innocent over pious faithful, and the Church reminds them that devotion to her is only justified if it leads to Jesus. As for me, she is my spiritual mother that will always keep faithful to her Son. Jesus gave her to us when He said to St.John, before Jesus died “Son behold thy mother, and mother behold thy son” Thats why we Catholics love Mary, she suffered in union with Her Son Jesus. You simply don’t understand, and you need to grow in understanding. We pray that you receive this “Enlightenment” Jesus is truly present in the Eucharist, I know.
You have now entered into a monolog. It seems you are debating with a person of your own imagination, with all due respect, and you are very patronizing.

I am aware that Mary was a disciple, given a huge and special grace to be his mother, and that she followed Jesus and stood under the cross.
I am also aware that Jesus is the sole mediator between God and man and that he alone carried all the sin of the world up on the cross and accomplished the mission which only he could, being the Messiah, fully man and fully god.

Mary suffered as a human mother and I am sure that her suffering was one more pain for Jesus to bear. I am aware of Mary’s great piety and her election by God, and that she is a role model for all the faithful. I am also a believer that she is the new Eve, which the early fathers wrote about without much other ado.

But Christ is the saviour. I know you agree with this. But you seem to disregard my actual concerns about marian devotions where Mary is called “our salvation, our life, our hope, refuge of sinners” etc. Some people seem to hope and trust in her before Jesus - just read some threads on these very fora, where people say they think their prayers are unworthy and need an an advocate. Some Catholics are taught that Mary is more accesible than Jesus, more understanding. I am amazed that you do not find this troubling at all. Or have I misunderstood you?.

I have not told anyone to choose between Catholicism or the charismatic life. It is rather my feeling that I am asked to do this by some of my fellow Catholics.
In my view the authentic Christian must accept the very real element of the charismatic, just as surely as we were asked to imitate Christ’s life. We must accept and imitate the passages about the Holy Spirits actions, and actualize them as readily as we actualize the Eucharist, because we believe in the words in the Gospel, not just a selected few.

Peace. and please, do really read what I say before you answer again.
Daisy
 
It surprises me that your approach to this is to simply suspect brother Christians of lying.
All I can say is that the people who told me about the dead being raised were worthy to be believed. Much more so than those who never do anything but talk.
They are not stupid that they would not know a corpse from a living person.

I have heard such testimonies the last few years from different countries in the world where people who suffer a lot for the sake of the Gospel and preach it (in Africa and China etc.) see huge miracles.

But I have also heard a story like this very close to my home. A Pentecostal father aised his son back to life again - after a deadly accident that had completely destroyed the little boy - through persistent and trusting supplication for about half an hour.

I believe the Western world with its intellectualism and philosophy has made us into sceptics.

The minister Heidi Baker, whom I mentioned earlier, has also seen people raised from the dead. At least five children, who were prayed over by simple African pastors who didn’t know that they were not supposed to pray for such things apparantly. I have met Mrs. Baker and would say she is one of the greatest missionaries alive today because she follows the example of Christ. The word anointing has a clear meaning even when you read her books.

Another testimony I could mention is the famous convert from Islam to Christianity, Gulshan Esther, who wrote her testimony book called “The Torn Veil”. She tells not only about her complete healing from being a cripple after a vision of Jesus Christ, but also how she actually raises her sister back to life. Again there is no reason I would insist on doubting testimonies which are so clearly in line with the Gospels. Jesus told his disciples to do these things, just like he told Peter to step out on the water, which also might sound silly or unprovable for a modern western ear.

Now its amazing to me that you much rather assume that such testimonies are lies, than that you would willingly trust the word of Jesus himself to his disciples:
“Heal the sick, raise up the dead, clean the lepers, cast out demons! You have been given it for free, give it for free”. (Matthew 10: 7-8 )

I think we can learn a great deal about faith from other parts of the Body.

Daisy
 
Daisy,

It seems to me that you are prepared to accept as true, miracles that seem to occur as a result of protestant pastors and lay-people laying on hands, but earlier you outright rejected the thousands of miracles that occur at Lourdes through the intercession of Our Blessed Lady. Is Hedi Baker in a better position to intercede for us than the Mary the Mother of God?

As to us learning things from other Christian denominations, yes we can as individuals learn things from other individuals, whatever their religion or denomination, but we need to remember that there is only one true Church, and we ought to place our trust in the Church that Christ Himself created while on Earth, rather than in other Christian denominations that are created by man.

I don’t mean to insult you, but you do seem to give the impression that you have quite a lot of issues with the Church, to the point where you will deny miracles that happen as a result of Catholic prayer to Our Lady, but readily accept miracles that happen through protestant laypeople. It’s almost as if you think God dopes not operate within the Catholic Church. Do you think He just comes to reside in the Eucharist in the Catholic Church, whereas all His power through miracles etc. operates only through protestant preachers? I don’t mean to insult you, but that is how it is coming across in what you have written on here.

God bless,

Brendan
 
It surprises me that your approach to this is to simply suspect brother Christians of lying.
All I can say is that the people who told me about the dead being raised were worthy to be believed. Much more so than those who never do anything but talk.
They are not stupid that they would not know a corpse from a living person.

I have heard such testimonies the last few years from different countries in the world where people who suffer a lot for the sake of the Gospel and preach it (in Africa and China etc.) see huge miracles.

But I have also heard a story like this very close to my home. A Pentecostal father aised his son back to life again - after a deadly accident that had completely destroyed the little boy - through persistent and trusting supplication for about half an hour.

I believe the Western world with its intellectualism and philosophy has made us into sceptics.

The minister Heidi Baker, whom I mentioned earlier, has also seen people raised from the dead. At least five children, who were prayed over by simple African pastors who didn’t know that they were not supposed to pray for such things apparantly. I have met Mrs. Baker and would say she is one of the greatest missionaries alive today because she follows the example of Christ. The word anointing has a clear meaning even when you read her books.

Another testimony I could mention is the famous convert from Islam to Christianity, Gulshan Esther, who wrote her testimony book called “The Torn Veil”. She tells not only about her complete healing from being a cripple after a vision of Jesus Christ, but also how she actually raises her sister back to life. Again there is no reason I would insist on doubting testimonies which are so clearly in line with the Gospels. Jesus told his disciples to do these things, just like he told Peter to step out on the water, which also might sound silly or unprovable for a modern western ear.

Now its amazing to me that you much rather assume that such testimonies are lies, than that you would willingly trust the word of Jesus himself to his disciples:
“Heal the sick, raise up the dead, clean the lepers, cast out demons! You have been given it for free, give it for free”. (Matthew 10: 7-8 )

I think we can learn a great deal about faith from other parts of the Body.

Daisy
The problem is there are many people every year in the Catholic church who claim to be visionaries, perform miracles, or claim something miraculous is occuring, but once the Church comes and investigates they are exposed as frauds.

People like attention, people like to feel “special” or different or better than everyone else. People like to feel “chosen.” And of course people like fame and people like money.

I’m not saying this is always the motive, I’m not saying there are no authentic miracles. We know, though, that these temptations are so common place that claims of miraculous occurences really need to be investigated from a good “sceptical believer.”

Bear in mind Hindus make such claims of miracles often, some have even claimed to be the reincarnation of Jesus Christ. We must be sceptical.
 
You say you believe in the Gospel, and you didn’t answer my question. Mary in her humility made a prediction, that all generation would call her “Blessed” because of what Christ did to her, what generation, the Pentecostals, the Protestants, and many others? Read my statements. I do read yours and I do understand, but you don’t completely understand mine.

Did you read the statements made by David J. Du Plessis a Pentecostal minister? I am at a disadvantage because I don’t have a copy of the printed statement. But just like you I have no reason to doubt the words of some Catholic priest who talked to him. His statement went to the effect like “What Son wouldn’t honor, and love His mother and so on…” Do you honor Mary, she wasn’t just another Mother, she was free of all sin, a perfect Ark of the Covenant , a holy body free fom sin for her Son Jesus, God-man. It was her blood He shed, and the body that came from her body. She was chosen by the Father to be the Mother of His Son. Mary became the New Eve, and she is the one “Who will be the one to crush the Head of Satan” Through the power of Her Son, Jesus defeated Satan completely, and she will share in the the success of that battle. Please pay attention, There is only one Savior, the Son of God. But even we share in His triumph, every Christian has a very real battle with Satan and his co-horts, by the power merited for us by Jesus. Mary was at the Top of the list as a perfect Christian, there is so much you don’t know.

When a person is convinced or not convinced, reason more than often fails to bridge the gap between knowing and not knowing. Especially when we are convinced we are right. This is a spiritual condition that only God can cure, St.Paul had this condition, and we all have it to some degree, so pray and petition God that if there is something we don’t understand enlighten us so that we can know God’s truth, and not just ours. This condition is called “self-righteousness” not “God-righteousness” It is a serious human fault that has the power to destroy, and cause much human suffering, ask St.Paul, and if we could, ask those that passed away who caused heresy in the Church.because they thought they were right, and see the results.
 
Daisy,
My experience is different than yours. I was raised in the Baptist church, but I felt drawn to the Catholic Church since childhood.

I still have a seed of the Baptist Church in me. It was a big part of my childhood. Mainly, it gave me a wonderful appreciate of the scriptures. And as I started attending the Catholic Church, I saw how beautifully biblical the Mass is.

I don’t read Baptist perspectives. I feel like I learned that as a child. When I read religious material, it is almost always Catholic.

I can’t comment on whether this person can work miracles. I just don’t know.

I pray that you find your spiritual home here with the Catholic Church. There are so many miracles in our faith. Learn more, and I don’t think you will be disappointed.

May the Holy Spirit guide you to truth.
 
It is strange that I mentioned that the Church warned some innocent pious people about devotion to Mary, that this devotion can only be justified if it leads to Jesus Christ. That didn’t seem to clarify anything for you. Also Jesus said that “More blessed are those who have not seen, and yet believe” I would thing that as much as you know, that this should encourage you to understand spiritual growth, eating meat. I spent most of my life believing without seeing, and so have many, many others. Then Jesus revealed what I believed, and I was so happy that I took His Word for it, long before He should me the proof. I knew it pleased Him more than if He showed me. I am no ones judge, and we do the best we can. But if I back down from what my Faith taught me, then I become a liar, no witness at all.

I know a Catholic woman, a very good friend. She had her own charismatic experiences, and because she didn’ have a good understanding of Mary, she began criticizing Catholic devotion to her, and started thinking like you. I warned her she was wrong. I never knew if she changed her mind because she died shortly after. Her daughter was the of the same opinion, and she left the church. I noticed both were very strong in their opinions. I knew what was wrong and I even told her, and she couldn’t understand, because it was a spiritual blindness. God confirmed this for me, about myself, He healed me.
 
It is strange that I mentioned that the Church warned some innocent pious people about devotion to Mary, that this devotion can only be justified if it leads to Jesus Christ. That didn’t seem to clarify anything for you. Also Jesus said that “More blessed are those who have not seen, and yet believe” I would thing that as much as you know, that this should encourage you to understand spiritual growth, eating meat. I spent most of my life believing without seeing, and so have many, many others. Then Jesus revealed what I believed, and I was so happy that I took His Word for it, long before He should me the proof. I knew it pleased Him more than if He showed me. I am no ones judge, and we do the best we can. But if I back down from what my Faith taught me, then I become a liar, no witness at all.

I know a Catholic woman, a very good friend. She had her own charismatic experiences, and because she didn’ have a good understanding of Mary, she began criticizing Catholic devotion to her, and started thinking like you. I warned her she was wrong. I never knew if she changed her mind because she died shortly after. Her daughter was the of the same opinion, and she left the church. I noticed both were very strong in their opinions. I knew what was wrong and I even told her, and she couldn’t understand, because it was a spiritual blindness. God confirmed this for me, about myself, He healed me.
Mary always points to Jesus. When the shepherds came to see baby Jesus, Mary and Joseph let them behold their son – thus pointing to Jesus. At the marriage feast in Cana, Mary told the servants, “Do whatever He tells you.”

When she followed her Son to the Cross, Jesus told His mother that John was her new son. And by extension, he gave his Mother to all believers.
 
For the sake of clarification on the Church teaching I quote from the Documents of Vatican Council ll concerning devotion , to Mary, the Mother of God, Jesus

The sacred synod teaches this Catholic Doctrine advisedly and at the same time admonishes all the sons of the church that cult, especially the liturgical cult, of the Blessed Virgin,be generously fostered , and that the practices and exercises of devotion toward her, recommended by the teaching authority of the Church in the course of centuries be highly esteemed, and that those decrees, which were given in the early days regarding cult images of Christ, the Blessed Mother and the Saints, be religiously observed. BUT IT STRONGLY URGES theologians, and preachers of the Word of God to be careful to refrain as much from all false exaggeration as from too summary an attitude in considering the special dignity of the Mother of God.

Following the study of Sacred Scripture, the Fathers, the doctors and liturgy of the Church under the guidance of the Church’s magisterium let them rightly illustrate the duties and privileges of the Blessed Virgin WHICH ALWAYS REFER TO CHRIST the source of all truth, sanctity and devotion. Let them carefully refrain from whatever might by word or deed lead the separated brethern or any other whatsoever into error about the true doctrine of the Church. Let the faithful remember moreover that true devotion consists neither in sterile or transitory affection, nor in certain vain credulity but proceeds from true faith, by which we are led to recognize the excellence of the Mother of God, and we are moved to a filial love towards our mother and to the imitation of her virtues.
 
What I do find very troubling is when people start hoping to obtain more mercy and help from a creature than from Jesus.
You miss the point. We are asking Mary to help us by asking her to intercede for us with her son Our Lord.

It seems to me that many protestants have real issues with us asking the saints to pray for us and for out intentions, but have no problem asking a protestant lay-person to pray for a sick relative etc…

We are a Church, not just of the living, but also of the dead. The saints in Heaven are part of our Church today, asking a saint to intercede for us is asking a current member of our Church, who happens to reside in Heaven, to pray for us for whatever intention we request.

And among the saints in Heaven, Mary is not simply another saint, she is our mother, and the mother of our saviour. How many people on Earth turn to their own earthly mothers for help when in difficulty? Why then is it an issue when by turning to Mary, as we are simply obeying one of the last things Christ told us

John 19:26-27 “When Jesus saw his mother, and the disciple whom he loved standing near, he said to his mother, “Woman, behold, your son!” Then he said to the disciple, “Behold, your mother!” And from that hour the disciple took her to his own home.”

Why then do many protestants seem to take issue when Catholics actually treat Mary as our Mother in Heaven? Why when we turn to our Mother for help is this treated with suspicion? What is wrong with asking your mother to intercede on your behalf with your Father?

God is our Father, Mary is our Mother. That is scriptural and is something that protestants feel uncomfortable with (just as they take issue with Peter being the rock upon which the Christ’s Church was built and that he was given the powers to bind and loose).
Only after I started really asking myself about these expressions and all these Marian apparitions that I felt were quite odd in light of the Gospel, did I have to distance myself.
Marian apparitions are thoroughly investigated by the Church for many years, before being approved. There is nothing unscriptural at all about them.
But then I immediately ran into this subtle pressure to conform against my judgement and my conscience in obedience to the Church.
I have never seen anyone put under such pressure, subtle or otherwise. Perhaps it is the fact that people simply express their own views when you challenge them? Perhaps it is the fact that strong Marian devotion represents the mainstream within the Catholic faithful and you feel uncomfortable about being out on a limb when compared to most Catholics? II very much doubt that anyone is forcing you to pray the Rosary. Perhaps the lack of acceptance comes from you towards those who have string Marian devotions, than the other way round?

.
A very pious Priest once told me that we shall not say: “which is more important, the inspired Word of God or the Eucharist. Both are essential and equal”.
Church teaching is that “the Eucharist is the source and summit of the Christian life”.

The Eucharist IS the centre of our Christian faith, that is Church teaching.
You think that because of the Eucharist everything else is of little importance.
I never said that, so don’t put words into my mouth. I said that all other things pale into insignificant compared to the Eucharist. Yes other things are incredibly important, but the importance of the Eucharist dwarfs them all. It is through the Sacrifice at Calvary that our sins were forgiven, the Mass is Calvary (in unbloody form) taking place before our very eyes.

Yes other things are very important, but nothing, nothing that is happening, has or has ever happened in this world is as important as the Sacrifice of Calvary.
I think precisely because of what we believe about the Eucharist all the other things become hugely important too. How do you think that a place where there is no joy, preaching, community, no power of the Spirit, can convince people that we have the true Presence of Christ more than all the others?
I agree with you in that 👍 but all these other things - joy, preaching, community, etc. are mere tools to direct people towards what is truly important, the Eucharist. When things like joy and community become aims in themselves, then that is when we really have to worry.

You seem to have a lot of doubts, and that is OK. Just put all the other things aside and focus on the Eucharist.

God bless,

Brendan
 
You miss the point. We are asking Mary to help us by asking her to intercede for us with her son Our Lord.

John 19:26-27 "When Jesus saw his mother, and the disciple whom he loved standing near, he said to his mother, “Woman, behold, your son!” Then he said to the disciple, “Behold, your mother!” You seem to have a lot of doubts, and that is OK. Just put all the other things aside and focus on the Eucharist.

God bless,

Brendan
Brendan,

you keep telling me I miss the point. I am telling you about my experience as a Catholic who might have converted too fast. I don’t know. The problem remains: what I am going to do now? I have done all the studying I can and heard every argument, and my feeling of unease increases.

You tell me to just remain where I am and focus on the Eucharist. That is what I have been doing until now, although, let us face it, it is not a lasting solution, and it is not fair to me nor to the Catholics in my parish. I sense a great peace when I sit with Jesus. But communially speaking, I have only felt the unity and peace when I was with people who shared my faith and focus.

Can you understand that you can not admonish a person into believing something they do no’t believe?

You quote a passage from Scripture, and read a whole huge meaning into the fact that John was asked to take care of Mary after Jesus’ death and resurrection. The church has elevated this passage into a symbol of such force that all of us must treat the passage more strongly than any fundamentalist ever would. Growing up as a Protestant I never ever of my own mind, came to the comclusion based on those verses, that Mary was my mother too.

Nowhere does the Church tell me that I have to have to believe in the apparitions at Lourdes or that I have to pray the rosary or make consecrations to Mary etc.

I have no issues with you liking to go to Lourdes, or that someone get’s a healing from Jesus after having asked Mary to pray for him. What I take issue with is that I practically am not left in peace if I say, I do not wish to focus on Mary, pray the rosary or deal with apparitions. I would like to keep my faith-directed language (words like “hope, sweetness, salvation, mediator” etc.) focused on the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit where I believe they belong, and get my main inspiration from Scripture instead of from “messages”.

You imply that I exaggerate when I say I feel pressure to conform. All I can say is how would you like it if every Sunday at your parish songs were sung that did not express your thoughts or feelings about something, or all your parish friends would seek to persuade you to have a certain kind of devotion, that you didn’t feel at home with. And some would even imply that the Lord was displeased with you if you did not have that same spirituality. as them. That is the greatest peasure you can put on a Christian person. You make them scared that God is not pleased with them because of their honest thoughts, and it is a horrible place for the person who must live with this kind of shaming. You can say it is not pressure. But it does create a strong sense of estrangement.

You can believe that Lourdes is Scriptural. I do not really know what you mean by “scriptural”. When I say I have a hard time seeing the connection between present day apparitions of Mary and the Gospels of Jesus, it is because I see no examples in Scripture of apparitions initiated by saints that had already crossed over and where such attention is given to the apparition, the place and the saint as a source of healing and hope. People say they follow Jesus and are led to Jesus through Mary. I can not deny that, if that is their experience, but I always wonder why then are they mentioning the name of Mary so much. Why do they seek her before they seek Jesus, why do they - through their own words - seem to have more hope in her help than in his?

I guess it is a problem of proportion. I have met Catholics who were so engaged with marian apparitions and other mystical litterature, that they didn’t know anymore when they quoted Scripture and when they quoted some saints from a private revelation.

You seem to think that Jesus does not unify himself with Protestants, that he is not their aim, and that he is not truly present in the assemblies that praise him.

He is the aim. And you can find no where where I say otherwise. However, disciples of Jesus has many valid needs and God knows that. I do think that a lot of Evangelical Pentecostal persons and churches seem more focused on Christ, and on the Holy Spirit as a living Person. Catholics are preoccupied with so many other things than those main Persons, and following their words and example from Scripture.

Maybe you think I am just a weak person looking for worldly comfort. You know what, I do not mind. I admit it… I do not like having to invite sick people to go to Protestant lay people in order to get healed in the name of Jesus, because I cannot find a single Catholic in a huge surrounding that seems to have the gift of healing that the Bible speaks of. I do not like to have to go to Protestants when I could really use a word of prophesy. I do need the community and the joy and the evangelization in such places.
I need to hear the simple Gospel preached without layers of stuff. I need Catholic leaders to explain why Jesus did all these healings and asked the disciples to do so, when we do not do it today. I need an explanation as to where the people with prophetic ministry have gone, and why they are not allowed to speak in the parishes.

I have many questions and doubts and it is growing bigger and bigger inside of me. So you can say: put a lid on and focus on the Eucharist. But even if I worship Jesus in solitude an empty church building I am still a human being with a mind and a heart.
 
The problem is there are many people every year in the Catholic church who claim to be visionaries, perform miracles, or claim something miraculous is occuring, but once the Church comes and investigates they are exposed as frauds.

People like attention, people like to feel “special” or different or better than everyone else. People like to feel “chosen.” And of course people like fame and people like money.

I’m not saying this is always the motive, I’m not saying there are no authentic miracles. We know, though, that these temptations are so common place that claims of miraculous occurences really need to be investigated from a good “sceptical believer.”

Bear in mind Hindus make such claims of miracles often, some have even claimed to be the reincarnation of Jesus Christ. We must be sceptical.
This is what I find so odd. There are people in this world who are firm believers in the Gospel, who hope for everything from Jesus and believe that he is the same today, yesterday and always. These people pray for healings, they cast out demons, they even raise the dead… all in the name of Jesus, giving him the glory and honour alone.

And yet your first thought is to disaprove and doubt their testimonies because they are not Catholics.
Look at the Gospels and you will see what Jesus said and did. You will see how he preached and served. People do this, they have him and the Bible as their sole example for everything and you doubt their sincerety.

These are nothing like Hinduists.
It is interesting, there are many Protestants who believe the Catholics have a dead and powerless faith, weakend further by part idolatry. In fact I understand the Evangelicals more when they doubt that we are primarily led by the Holy Spirit.

There are doctors everywhere that verify miracles.
In my vicinity there are severel recent examples of people who were healed from brain cancer during the laying on of hands by normal lay-evangelicals who have this gift from the Holy Spirit. They pray in the name of Jesus, they focus on what he has done on the cross, and people get healed in numbers, which is verified by medical doctors, brain specialists etc.
I do not live in the African bush where there are no doctors or in the middle ages where science was not as evolved…

youtube.com/watch?v=o49nkDyoPN0 I post to you an example where you can be a critic or a believer. Up to you
 
Daisy,
My experience is different than yours. I was raised in the Baptist church, but I felt drawn to the Catholic Church since childhood.

I still have a seed of the Baptist Church in me. It was a big part of my childhood. Mainly, it gave me a wonderful appreciate of the scriptures. And as I started attending the Catholic Church, I saw how beautifully biblical the Mass is.

I don’t read Baptist perspectives. I feel like I learned that as a child. When I read religious material, it is almost always Catholic.

I can’t comment on whether this person can work miracles. I just don’t know.

I pray that you find your spiritual home here with the Catholic Church. There are so many miracles in our faith. Learn more, and I don’t think you will be disappointed.

May the Holy Spirit guide you to truth.
Dear sister,

I do read the books from other Christian traditions as well as the Catholic tradition. Why should I not? I have so many books. I liked the saint litterature as well, but I could relate much more readily to the Evangelical Pentecostal testimonies than to the ascetic, somewhat elitist saint litterature about the greatness of suffering, celibacy and morification.
I was very amazed by all this when it was still new to me, but now I do not like to read it much. I feel more inspired by books like “The Hiding Place” by Corrie ten Boom, “The Knife and the Switchblade” by David Wilkerson, “A man called Mr. pentecost” by David duPlessis etc. etc.
I did read a real good book by Catholic sr. Briege McKenna about her healing ministry in the Catholic Church. That was a good book, and it comforted me.

Honestly it was only after I became a Catholic that I encountered all these awesome testimony books from the Evangelical world. It has been a great richness but also created a longing to be with these brothers and sisters that walk in this Kingdom Life, and to learn from them. And as you see it does create some difficulty for me and some conflicting ideas.

I have read extremely much Catholic stuff, I used to live like a hermit almost, and also studied quite a lot of theology, moral theology, catechism, council writings etc. It was amazing and rich and beautiful to get into all that. But when I open the books by the Pentecostals, I say, this is the life of Jesus, and that is what is real. And these people are the ones I want to be like, because they are like Jesus, and I understand what they say and do.

I can not understand that it was holy and pious that Therese of Lisieux suffered greatly because she was tormented, gievn lousy food, and lived in a cold cell.
I do not desire to be a great moral theologist or a philosopher that knows every teaching in the Church. I simply wish I had a faith like these evangelical people.
Like Soren Kierkegaard once wrote “The true humility will not be satisfied with the left hand, but will demand the right”. That is the childlike faith that I see in for example Heidi Baker, which is a faith I have not seen much among Catholics. I wish I had, really.

The more good Catholics ridicule the Pentecostals and say we don’t need what they have, the more hollow I think it sounds. because we do need what they have. We are not yet angels in heaven. The people that called upon Jesus did really call for him to heal them. He did not belittle their prayer.

tell me, are you as a former Baptist never wondering about the language used in some marian devotions, like when Catholics call her their “hope, their life, their salvation” and such?
It seems that some people make good converts like you, and others are always stuck in the culture and faith which they thought they could leave behind.
I know both kinds. I know I am not alone with my struggles.
Can you share more thoughts with me?

Daisy
 
This is what I find so odd. There are people in this world who are firm believers in the Gospel, who hope for everything from Jesus and believe that he is the same today, yesterday and always. These people pray for healings, they cast out demons, they even raise the dead… all in the name of Jesus, giving him the glory and honour alone.

And yet your first thought is to disaprove and doubt their testimonies because they are not Catholics.
Look at the Gospels and you will see what Jesus said and did. You will see how he preached and served. People do this, they have him and the Bible as their sole example for everything and you doubt their sincerety.

These are nothing like Hinduists.
It is interesting, there are many Protestants who believe the Catholics have a dead and powerless faith, weakend further by part idolatry. In fact I understand the Evangelicals more when they doubt that we are primarily led by the Holy Spirit.

There are doctors everywhere that verify miracles.
In my vicinity there are severel recent examples of people who were healed from brain cancer during the laying on of hands by normal lay-evangelicals who have this gift from the Holy Spirit. They pray in the name of Jesus, they focus on what he has done on the cross, and people get healed in numbers, which is verified by medical doctors, brain specialists etc.
I do not live in the African bush where there are no doctors or in the middle ages where science was not as evolved…

youtube.com/watch?v=o49nkDyoPN0 I post to you an example where you can be a critic or a believer. Up to you
There was once a priest in the eastern part of the US of A that laid hands on people and had some healings. And I have heard of others as well from time to time. So the church does have this.

We also have a evangelical catholic services which seem to be what you are wanting but they are in the larger cities.

You did mention the passage of Jesus on the cross and that this seemed to be made over more than it deserved…in reference to Mary’s part in our life. And that from the evangelical viewpoint this was not seen. But then on the other hand, catholics believe when Jesus said “this is” my body and “this is” my blood, they saw it for what it was. Yet the evangelicals did not see what was clearly said by Jesus.

I can understand that you miss your evangelical way of praying because this has become a part of you over the years. And it is difficult just to part company suddenly with a way of thinking. It just takes time to break in like a new pair of shoes.

I can also empathized with you because if I had to go to a catholic church where the litergy was so modern that it made me feel out of place, I would have a hard time with that, not to say that I would leave, but I would not like it one bit.

Try to avoid the subject of Mary for the time being because you have so much more going on right now in your spiritual life. I honestly think Mary would not want you upset over her either. Even tho I feel very close to Mary, I don’t pray to her specifically that often. Even tho I pray the rosary, it is about Jesus that I am thinking of when praying it. So someday if and when you feel the need to have a relationship with Mary, then do so. Otherwise the prayers you say to Jesus who is at the Father’s right is a very powerful and good way to pray. And that is Mary’s intention anyway that you have this close bond of unity with him.

May God bless and keep you. May God’s face shine on you. May God be kind to you and give you peace.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top