Catholic shift gives Democrats big boost

  • Thread starter Thread starter meno
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If people aren’t dumb, and it is the Church that is getting dumber, what do you mean exactly by dumb? I don’t understand.
The way I take this “dumbing down” is the same as watering down…example

embarrasement and outrage of abortion
abortion legal
more people accepting it
because some accept it others do and change their mind
people publicize they have had abortions, telling others it is ok

These steps that have had happened is the “dumbing down” of the issue or making the issue not as important.

I guess you are trying to tell us that you did not know that.
 
The first thing that has to happen is for pro lifers (and i am sure very good Catholic) such as yourself to stop making the feeble excuses for the democratic party. (as well as any republican who will vote for a pro choice republican)
Whoa! Hold on. I voted for a pro-life democrat, whose record was not as corrupted as the pro-life republican. I don’t have to make any excuses to you, my church, or my God.

I think the first thing that has to happen is that people need to renounce the infallibility of the Republican Party. Which I said many posts ago and this repeating is becoming pointless.
Don’t you realize that many Catholics who are not that deep in their faith are easily influenced and when they see people such as yourself make these excuses they “in their hearts and minds” do not think the abortion issue is a priority. Your arguments do just that, make the abortion issue not a priority.
You greatly overestimate my ability to influence people. :o

First, I don’t even see what I’m doing his as an argument. Second, my “argument” was simply asking you what is part two of the plan? What do you do after overturning that one decision?
You have no plan. If anything, that shows a lack of priority on your behalf.
Two questions I need to ask you,
Each time I reply to your questions, I ask you questions also.
You have yet to answer. How long do you think I will let you get away with that?

So you tell me I am making an impression on other Catholics. I tell you the same. As a former teacher of adolescents, teenagers, and young adults, I can tell you what most young people think of most of the pro-life activists: they run the other direction when they see them. Face it, you’ve got a lot of folks acting as bad as PETA!

To sum up for those who are SO MUCH holier than me and seem to be not actually reading my posts and seeing what you want to see. You are painting me as some sort of pro-choice, rationalizer. Save that energy for when you actually find one.

I did not vote pro-death. I did not influence anyone to do so.
I believe life starts at conception, or “human life” or whatever distinction you want to make.
I just returned from mass with communion, and I have nothing to prove about my faith to you or anyone here.
43 million babies died, and one of them was mine. And there was nothing I could do about it.
 
If people aren’t dumb, and it is the Church that is getting dumber, what do you mean exactly by dumb? I don’t understand.
You werent dumb but you did go against the clear teaching of the Church. You have told us in the past that you have always voted staright Democrat so it appears that the war is the just the latest rationalization for supportng pro-abortion canidates. To be fair I know you dont think of it in thise terms-you just vote for Democrats and the fact they are pro-abortion is irelevant to you. Paty all.

You have always, it appears, put yor politics ahead of your fatih. That is your decision to make. What perplexes me is your continued insistence that is compatible with Catholic Teachings.
 
?

So you tell me I am making an impression on other Catholics. I tell you the same. As a former teacher of adolescents, teenagers, and young adults, I can tell you what most young people think of most of the pro-life activists: they run the other direction when they see them. Face it, you’ve got a lot of folks acting as bad as PETA!

To sum up for those who are SO MUCH holier than me and seem to be not actually reading my posts and seeing what you want to see. You are painting me as some sort of pro-choice, rationalizer. Save that energy for when you actually find one.

I.
So opposing the killing of our children is a 'holier than thou" attitude?? And you were teaching our youth? When they expressed revulsion for pro-life advocates did you take the time to tell them how important the cause they were involved in was? Or did you just roll your eyes and mutter about them being “holier than thou”? Are you, BTW, involved in the pro-life ministry?

If you voted for pro-abortion canidates you are aiding and abetting the killing of our children. No matter how you try to rationalize it, no matter how “right” you feel with God and the Church it does not change that fact.
 
Whoa! Hold on. I voted for a pro-life democrat, whose record was not as corrupted as the pro-life republican. I don’t have to make any excuses to you, my church, or my God.

I think the first thing that has to happen is that people need to renounce the infallibility of the Republican Party. Which I said many posts ago and this repeating is becoming pointless.

You greatly overestimate my ability to influence people. :o

First, I don’t even see what I’m doing his as an argument. Second, my “argument” was simply asking you what is part two of the plan? What do you do after overturning that one decision?
You have no plan. If anything, that shows a lack of priority on your behalf.

Each time I reply to your questions, I ask you questions also.
You have yet to answer. How long do you think I will let you get away with that?

So you tell me I am making an impression on other Catholics. I tell you the same. As a former teacher of adolescents, teenagers, and young adults, I can tell you what most young people think of most of the pro-life activists: they run the other direction when they see them. Face it, you’ve got a lot of folks acting as bad as PETA!

To sum up for those who are SO MUCH holier than me and seem to be not actually reading my posts and seeing what you want to see. You are painting me as some sort of pro-choice, rationalizer. Save that energy for when you actually find one.

I did not vote pro-death. I did not influence anyone to do so.
I believe life starts at conception, or “human life” or whatever distinction you want to make.
I just returned from mass with communion, and I have nothing to prove about my faith to you or anyone here.
43 million babies died, and one of them was mine. And there was nothing I could do about it.
I certainly do have a plan, winning the hearts and minds of others, which is your plan # 1. I am very vocal with websites and host and built a website with my brothers for a friend of mine, who has been on the radio station here Deacon John Beckman. The website is catholicchristians.com.

You are very wrong about your influence, and if you look throughout my posts, I do not vote for the politician, I vote pro life. I sent a message to the republican that was running as govenor in my state that I nor anyone that I could convince would vote for a prochoice republican. In every case, I would vote for a pro life democrat over a pro choice republican. You twisted and made up where I have ever said or implied the infallability of the republican party. I have consistantly said that I believe that most of the politicians in both parties will sell their souls for power.

If you vote for a person who is pro choice and very vocal about it, you do vote pro death.

We have to take a united stance on the abortion issue and say, if you are pro choice we will not vote for you. Perhaps it will be losing a voice for a short period of time, but if a strong message is not sent, it will only continue to erode.

There are a very very few pro life activists that act badly. I am not sure what you mean there.
 
So opposing the killing of our children is a 'holier than thou" attitude??
Read what I wrote Bob - you know all the smug holier than thou posts about OTHER POSTERS. That comment was explicitly aimed at this thread. No one else .
And you were teaching our youth? When they expressed revulsion for pro-life advocates did you take the time to tell them how important the cause they were involved in was? Or did you just roll your eyes and mutter about them being “holier than thou”? Are you, BTW, involved in the pro-life ministry?
Ok Bob - you have it your way. I was evil then and I’m evil now. Now you can move on to other things, like telling me I’m killing people…oh wait, here it comes.
If you voted for pro-abortion canidates…
You didn’t read what I said.
…you are aiding and abetting the killing of our children. No matter how you try to rationalize it, no matter how “right” you feel with God and the Church it does not change that fact.
You didn’t read what I said. Here is what I said:
You are painting me as some sort of pro-choice, rationalizer. Save that energy for when you actually find one.
I’ve seen this in every thread you participate in bob. It ain’t helping anyone.
 
You werent dumb but you did go against the clear teaching of the Church.
To vote GOP?
You have told us in the past that you have always voted staright Democrat so it appears that the war is the just the latest rationalization for supportng pro-abortion canidates.
I would have voted for the Republicans if they were anti-war, regardless of my past Democratic affiliation. I consider the War an utter disaster.
You have always, it appears, put yor politics ahead of your fatih.
As have you, it seems to me. I can’t even conceive a scenario where you would vote other than Republican, no matter how they would change. You seem, for better or worse, a true-believing diehard Republican, which I suppose, is okay.
 
To vote GOP?

I would have voted for the Republicans if they were anti-war, regardless of my past Democratic affiliation. I consider the War an utter disaster.

As have you, it seems to me. I can’t even conceive a scenario where you would vote other than Republican, no matter how they would change. You seem, for better or worse, a true-believing diehard Republican, which I suppose, is okay.
The war an utter disaster considering another disaster of over 43 million babies killed?

A couple of sidenotes on the war though, Sadaam was responsible for over 900,000 deaths. The number of dead U.S. is so tragic, but so many fewer than any other war AND much less that the suburbs in our country.

I agree the war is tragic, but not even close to over 43 million deaths.
 
To vote GOP?

I would have voted for the Republicans if they were anti-war, regardless of my past Democratic affiliation. I consider the War an utter disaster.

As have you, it seems to me. I can’t even conceive a scenario where you would vote other than Republican, no matter how they would change. You seem, for better or worse, a true-believing diehard Republican, which I suppose, is okay.
I voted against Kay Bailey Hutchinson and Rick Perry in last week’s election. Both Republicans.
 
The war an utter disaster considering another disaster of over 43 million babies killed?
I agree the war is tragic, but not even close to over 43 million deaths.
The war has gone on for some three years. Have there been 43 mil abortions in the US in that time frame? It seems an awfully high number.

But, I judge the war in terms beyond the number of US casualties. Can anyone with a straight face say that we won both the war and the peace? Have we any plan for getting out of that quagmire?

I’m not saying this to reopen any arguments about the war, but it seems to me that you are just comparing numbers, whereas I and millions of Americans, including a majority of Catholics, have had enough with Mr. Bush’s handling of the catastrophe and apparent cluelessness as to how to extract ourselves honorably from Iraq.

And, there were no small number of conservatives who had it with the expansion of the government and the tremendous spending by the government under the Republicans. And many of those traditional conservatives were Catholics.

I could not see how all were to have to accept all the Republicans were doing just for the sake of crumbs tossed to them regarding pro-life issues. Not to say that you were wrong to vote Republican, just that so many Catholics said “enough!”
 
If you vote for a person who is pro choice and very vocal about it, you do vote pro death.
Yes, and here I agree with you. Any very vocal pro-abortion politician should not receive our votes.
 
The war has gone on for some three years. Have there been 43 mil abortions in the US in that time frame? It seems an awfully high number.

But, I judge the war in terms beyond the number of US casualties. Can anyone with a straight face say that we won both the war and the peace? Have we any plan for getting out of that quagmire?

I’m not saying this to reopen any arguments about the war, but it seems to me that you are just comparing numbers, whereas I and millions of Americans, including a majority of Catholics, have had enough with Mr. Bush’s handling of the catastrophe and apparent cluelessness as to how to extract ourselves honorably from Iraq.

And, there were no small number of conservatives who had it with the expansion of the government and the tremendous spending by the government under the Republicans. And many of those traditional conservatives were Catholics.

I could not see how all were to have to accept all the Republicans were doing just for the sake of crumbs tossed to them regarding pro-life issues. Not to say that you were wrong to vote Republican, just that so many Catholics said “enough!”
Come on, stop the twisting, I did not say that there were over 43 million in 3 years time.

I can say that I tend to believe the republican side of the issues because of their stance as a party on the pro life issue. There are certainly bad apples in both parties. With all of the media hype and “spins” of the facts by both parties, how in the world does anyone know what to believe. I tend to believe mostly the ones that have taken the stance as pro life. I may even agree that the best politician would be a democrat pro life one, one who has not sold their soul for power.

The only argument the democrats have for abortion is that is part of a womans body and they have the right to choose. Doesn’t matter that the real word for it is murder.

I do not take a politicians word for things, but do research the issues. I can make a well researched argument for most of them. Arguments can be made for all of the points you bring up on what is best for people. I again admit that I am biased on what I look for because I find it hard to believe anything a politician that is pro choice says, only because it gets them elected.

The fact that cannot be disputed is the democrat politicians are mostly pro choice and republican politicians are mostly pro life. And I use mostly in a very loose way…a better word to replace it would overwhelmingly.

You are believing politicians and an entire party who believe that murder is ok, as long as it gets them votes. I don’t think there is a debate that abortion is murder in this thread, but perhaps I am wrong.
 
If people aren’t dumb, and it is the Church that is getting dumber, what do you mean exactly by dumb? I don’t understand.
Have you no knowledge of priests (and other Catholics) tell Catholics that it is allright to support those in favor of abortion, ot to practice birth control, etc. I did not say the CHURCH was getting dumber, I said there is a dumbing down of the church. There is a big difference. Sorry I did not say it in a way you could understand.
 
Originally Posted by max37 forums.catholic-questions.org/images/buttons_cad/viewpost.gif
*Whoa! Hold on. I voted for a pro-life democrat, whose record was not as corrupted as the pro-life republican. I don’t have to make any excuses to you, my church, or my God.
I think the first thing that has to happen is that people need to renounce the infallibility of the Republican Party. Which I said many posts ago and this repeating is becoming pointless.
You greatly overestimate my ability to influence people. :o
First, I don’t even see what I’m doing his as an argument. Second, my “argument” was simply asking you what is part two of the plan? What do you do after overturning that one decision?
You have no plan. If anything, that shows a lack of priority on your behalf.
Each time I reply to your questions, I ask you questions also.
You have yet to answer. How long do you think I will let you get away with that?
So you tell me I am making an impression on other Catholics. I tell you the same. As a former teacher of adolescents, teenagers, and young adults, I can tell you what most young people think of most of the pro-life activists: they run the other direction when they see them. Face it, you’ve got a lot of folks acting as bad as PETA!
To sum up for those who are SO MUCH holier than me and seem to be not actually reading my posts and seeing what you want to see. You are painting me as some sort of pro-choice, rationalizer. Save that energy for when you actually find one.
I did not vote pro-death. I did not influence anyone to do so.
I believe life starts at conception, or “human life” or whatever distinction you want to make.
I just returned from mass with communion, and I have nothing to prove about my faith to you or anyone here.
43 million babies died, and one of them was mine. And there was nothing I could do about it.*
The first and most important issue is life:

Casey says he is pro-life. +
Santorum says he is pro life. +

Both men ran on a pro-life platform. Casey’s win allowed the pro-choice far left Democrats to take over the Senate. Thus a vote for Casey was a vote against life.

Sometimes we need to make choices for the big picture. In this case all things did not turn out equal.
 
The first and most important issue is life:

Casey says he is pro-life. +
Santorum says he is pro life. +

Both men ran on a pro-life platform. Casey’s win allowed the pro-choice far left Democrats to take over the Senate. Thus a vote for Casey was a vote against life.

Sometimes we need to make choices for the big picture. In this case all things did not turn out equal.
I am not sure that I agree with all of your post. I certainly do that the most important issue is life, but that Casey was elected may send a message to the democrats that being pro life and sticking to your guns is a good thing, instead of selling your soul for power (as so many so called Catholic politicians have done). That may mean more in the bigger picture.
 
I guess when we get to where ever we spend eternity we can tell the children that were killed and those that killed them that a protest vote was ok. That the babies killed because of these votes was for a good cause. That limiting power of a few was a good thing.

We the People need to get control of the courts and take those that break the laws to court and not sacrifice more children for the “cause”.
 
I guess when we get to where ever we spend eternity we can tell the children that were killed and those that killed them that a protest vote was ok. That the babies killed because of these votes was for a good cause. That limiting power of a few was a good thing.

We the People need to get control of the courts and take those that break the laws to court and not sacrifice more children for the “cause”.
If you read through my previous posts you can see that I couldnt agree more.
 
I was being sarcastic. I never would want to explain why I killed a child so I could have more etc.

We have no rights at the expense of others.
 
I’m awaiting you to point out what these policies are. Of course the church emphasizes social justice What they don’t do is endorse the approach to social justice embodied by either political party. Is your opinion that the Democratic Party is better on social issues ithan the Republican Party. I disagree with that opinion but the point is the church has taken no side on this. Contrast that to the direct opposition to the teachings of the Church that are found the Democratic Party party platform,

Once again I ask you to post this link to where the Church has condemned any policy of the Republican Party.
Republicans support the death penalty, the Church does not.

That is one.
 
Republicans support the death penalty, the Church does not.

That is one.
I did a search on the death penalty on the web, then on the political platform of the Republicans and Democrats.

democrats.org/pdfs/2004platform.pdf
gop.com/media/2004platform.pdf

Democratic platform makes no mention of capital punishment
Republican platform makes 1 mention of it and says that it is up to the states. (i think most of us here disagree with that view)

Much of the search results show in Iowa that Republicans are for and democrats against.

In Illinois where I live, the republican Ryan commuted all death penalty sentences to life.

We know that Bush is for it, but I cannot say that I have seen the views of too many democrats. On the surface it seems like more republicans are for the death penalty but I cannot see where the blanket statement that this poster made about republicans are for the death penalty is true

On the other hand if you notice in the party platform,

The democrats say “we stand proudly behind a womans right to choose” and promote public funding of abortion

The republicans mention 12 times in their platform that they are against abortion and public funding of abortions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top