Gun violence - lest we forget

  • Thread starter Thread starter YourNameHere
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Um, no.

I’m allowed to own whatever type of vehicle I want. I can own a dump truck if I want. And in reality, I don’t have to register it, if I am keeping on private property. It doesn’t need tags, other than to be on a public road.
 
Um, no.

I’m allowed to own whatever type of vehicle I want. I can own a dump truck if I want. And in reality, I don’t have to register it, if I am keeping on private property. It doesn’t need tags, other than to be on a public road.
As I said, minor technical details. Irrelevant to the question at hand. Of course, as long as you want the criminals to have guns, try to create more obstacles.
 
Last edited:
Such a simple solution for all the problems!! I can visualize all the law abiding citizens to swarm to the official gun-licensing offices, carrying their weapons in a wheel-barrow. (Or maybe they would change their names to “Clyde Barrow” and “Bonnie Parker”.) And we could open a hunting season for them. 😉

Any objections?
As I said, minor technical details. Irrelevant to the question at hand.
(Quoted before the edit)
They are not minor technical details. They are at the heart of the matter.

Stopping law abiding citizens from owning weapons, will not stop criminals from having guns. Making law abiding citizens, criminals, will also not do anything to stop actual criminals from having guns.
 
40.png
meltzerboy2:
Terrible as the Wounded Knee Massacre was, how many times did this kind of gun violence by the government happen since 1890? And how many times have the mass shootings by individuals continued to happen in more recent years? Therefore, which poses a bigger threat in our present-day society?
The very fact that the framers of the American constitution considered it such a significant concern that they felt it necessary to establish protection of the right to arms.
The issue is how many times it happened at all. Tens of millions of civilians in the twentieth century.
In 2 sentences you’ve managed to completely distort the intent of the framers and completely distort the facts of world history.

The framers intent was the welfare of the American people. Not an unregulated schmozzle the results of which makes America the most deadly gun violence nation in the western world. Who can possibly believe that.

And the history of ‘democide’ has never been related to civilian gun ownership. That’s the madeup history of the US gun lobby. ‘Democides’ are the aftermath of people losing a voice and choice in who is ruling them.
 
Why are to stooping so low? You keep trying to imply that law abiding citizens are the reason for mass shooting. What you want to do is make law abiding citizen criminals. By doing so it will stop mass killings. You dont want a discussion you want to lecture.
 
Why are to stooping so low? You keep trying to imply that law abiding citizens are the reason for mass shooting.
I did not imply or tried to imply anything. I suggest you read what I actually wrote. And then a conversation could take place.
 
In 2 sentences you’ve managed to completely distort the intent of the framers and completely distort the facts of world history.

The framers intent was the welfare of the American people. Not an unregulated schmozzle the results of which makes America the most deadly gun violence nation in the western world. Who can possibly believe that.
I don’t think I said the word “schmozzle”.
Of course the framers did not intend people to
Improperly use firearms to hurt innocent people. And of the 100 million plus gun owners, only a fraction of a fraction of a percent do.
And the history of ‘democide’ has never been related to civilian gun ownership.
Correct. It is often related to the lack of civilian gun ownership. It is precisely why tyrants work to disarm the people.
Democides’ are the aftermath of people losing a voice and choice in who is ruling them.
Democides are the result of both. Governments deny the people their voice and the means to defend themselves.
 
Last edited:
Of course, as long as you want the criminals to have guns, try to create more obstacles
The ones who seem satisfied with criminals having illegal firearms are the progressive politicians who have run America’s largest cities for half a century and seem quite content with the entire situation on the “other side “ of their cities.
They even fought against the law abiding having the ability to defend themselves until Heller and MacDonald.
 
Last edited:
The ones who seem satisfied with criminals having illegal firearms are the progressive politicians who have run America’s largest cities for half a century and seem quite content with the entire situation on the “other side “ of their cities.
Baloney. I gave a detailed analysis about preserving the rights of the law-abiding citizens and a process to decrease the access to firearms from criminals. And also the method to decrease the drug related turf- wars.
I will not reply to this thread anymore.
 
Last edited:
Baloney. I gave a detailed analysis about preserving the rights of the law-abiding citizens and a process to decrease the access to firearms from criminals. And also the method to decrease the drug related turf- wars.
Great. But unless you are one of those big city government officials I was talking about, I wasn’t talking about you.
 
Great. But unless you are one of those big city government officials I was talking about, I wasn’t talking about you.
This was a hypothetical conversation about the possible ways and means to decrease violence, either gun related or otherwise - while also preserving the rights of the law-biding citizens.
 
40.png
JonNC:
Great. But unless you are one of those big city government officials I was talking about, I wasn’t talking about you.
This was a hypothetical conversation about the possible ways and means to decrease violence, either gun related or otherwise - while also preserving the rights of the law-biding citizens.
And progressives involved in these big cities have no interest
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
And there are millions and millions of non-incidents of people who did not die because of anarchy. That is what you are arguing for by suggesting that governments should not be armed.
I’m not arguing against government having guns. I’m arguing against only government having guns. It would be idiotic for government not to have guns. It is dangerous for citizens not to have guns.
A government that is constantly challenged by armed citizens can never be at peace.

You say you are not for anarchy, but that’s exactly what you will get if the government is subjected to armed resistance. The proper way to resist the government is by civil representation and by petitioning the government. According to Catholic teaching, all authority comes from God. People who stockpile weapons against the day when they need to fight their own government are not acknowledging that authority. And before you bring up monarchy or any such nonsense, the belief about authority coming ultimately from God applies to all forms of government, including a constitutional republic.
 
A government that is constantly challenged by armed citizens can never be at peace.
That’s what happened at the founding. Do you believe they were wrong?
When has that happened in America since?
You say you are not for anarchy, but that’s exactly what you will get if the government is subjected to armed resistance.
Was there anarchy after the revolution?
Is there any reason in your view that permits the people to armed resistance against their government?
The proper way to resist the government is by civil representation and by petitioning the government.
And that is what happens here all of the time. Who has said it should be different.
People who stockpile weapons against the day when they need to fight their own government are not acknowledging that authority.
So the founders were wrong to defend the stockpile arms at Concord?
And before you bring up monarchy or any such nonsense, the belief about authority coming ultimately from God applies to all forms of government, including a constitutional republic.
God grants rights to the people, who grant limited powers to government. So yes, through the people, government authority comes from God.
 
There is running our big cities. When is the last time Chicago, Detroit, Philadelphia, Baltimore has a conservative as mayor?
Who cares? Obviously the candidates do not resonate with the voters.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top