Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
fbl9 and BaptistGuy, your conversation about the bread that’s the Body of Christ, and the wine that’s his Blood, made me think about this Carholic statement: the Eucharist is the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Christ.

As a Catholic I’m embarrassed to admit my ignorance (lack of good catechesis) again, because I don’t know why does the CC believe this. Why does it believe that the piece of bread is not only his Body, but also the other 3 things (Blood, Soul, Divinity)? Also, why is the cup of wine not only his Blood, but the other 3 things as well (Body, Soul, Divinity)?

However, I think this is why BG feels like he would not bow down and worship a piece of bread or a cup of wine, while we Catholics have no problem doing it. Because for us, that cup of wine is not only the Blood of Christ, but also his Body, Soul, and Divinity.

I remember now when I dated a girl from the Reformed (Calvinist) Church - this is roughly the same as the Presbyterian Church. Her mother was actually Catholic, and she used to attend the CC every now and then. So, we attended a Sunday Mass in the CC, and I remember, she kept sitting on a chair while I (and other Catholics) kneeled during the consecration of the Eucharist. To be honest, I must admit it made me feel very uncomfortable that she wouldn’t kneel before the Eucharist. :o But of course, she wasn’t trying to offend Jesus Christ by not kneeling - she was a religious girl who revered Christ. It’s only that the Eucharist didn’t mean the same thing to her as to us Catholics.

I guess in an interdenominational relationship or marriage, there can occur awkward moments like this.

I never attended service in a Protestant Church, so I don’t know how I would feel there, or would I ever risk offending the sensibilities of our Protestant brethren. I did attend the Eastern Orthodox Divine Liturgy many times, and here were some things that I found unexpected at first, but I did follow their customs and had no moral problem following them:
  1. They go up to Holy Icons depicting Mary with baby Jesus, they bow before these Icons, and kiss the Icons.
This same custom exists in the Eastern Catholic Churches. Holy Icons in both the EO and Eastern Catholic Churches have been associated with many miracles, the miraculous exuding of myrrh (an oily substance), miraculous renewal of old and faded Icons, and miraculous cures for sick people praying before the Icons or anointing themselves with the myrrh exuding from the Icons. The picture next to my screen name is one of a such Icon, the miraculous Icon of Soufanieh.
  1. They kiss the hands of their priests and bishops.
I don’t know whether Eastern Catholics do it, but EO do it regularly. I had no problem kissing the hand of an Eastern Orthodox priest. They are consecrated hands, they perform the miracle of turning the bread and wine into the Eucharist.
 
I think keeping our brotherly love for each other is key.
I completely agree. And truth is also important. Hopefully I did not give the impression that I was hostile toward the Baptist church - I am not. However, being around southern baptists, I often find myself having to defend Catholicism against baseless myths, which can be frustrating. I happen to like the pastor of this particular church (Champion Forest Baptist Church in Houston), and I enjoy the amount of time he spends explicating scripture, which is something I don’t experience on a regular basis during Mass.
 
jm,

They had one thing we did not, they actually saw Jesus and his Disciples, and did not need scripture the way we do. Sola scriptura obviously would not apply to those who could just go and ask Jesus, or Paul when Christ had ascended. This does bring up an interesting consideration, what of all the converts who merely had a meeting with Christ as he passed by, and never saw him again? They never had any of the sacraments, or traditions we have.
Actually, they did - they went to Mass (which they called “the breaking of the bread and the prayers” - the word “Mass” itself was not yet in use) and they certainly gathered together for worship on a regular basis. There were no “lone ranger” Christians, back then.
Like Jesus, many likely continued the Jewish traditions.
Well, until the Apostles told them to discontinue those practices, in Acts 15, right?
With that consideration, how much importance can we reasonably place on many of the modern positions/practices that exclude others (I specifically am thinking of denying communion to a Christian who is not Catholic, but am not limiting it to that, other rites such as the Last Rite for example.)
It is not about “excluding others” - it is you who have removed yourself out from under the authority of our priests, so as not to have to obey their commands or believe what they teach - but in doing this, our priests now no longer have any authority to give you Holy Communion or Last Rites, or indeed, any other Sacraments or any other favours or services that they normally give to those under their care. You have rejected him from being your Shepherd, and taken another shepherd for yourself - a Protestant preacher, or yourself, or someone else - therefore, why should he feed you with the food that is to be fed to his own sheep? Or bind up your wounds as if you were his own sheep? When you have rejected him, by means of being a member or participant in the Protestant Reformation.
While humorous, you miss my point. Think back to the concern of the ECF, they did not want people to splinter, and say “I follow Paul”, or “I follow Apollo”, etc. I doubt they wanted people to say “We would all be Catholics in communion with the Bishop of Rome.”.
Well, Peter was not yet in Rome, but they certainly did want all of the converts to be in full communion with the Apostles (see Acts 15, and indeed every passage of the New Testament that speaks about how to deal with dissenters), whose leader was Peter, as appointed by Christ, as we see recorded in John 21:15-19 - “feed my sheep.” Jesus appointed Peter to be the Chief Shepherd of the Church, and when he came to Rome and was crucified, his office was taken by Linus (the Bishop of Rome), who in his own turn acted as Chief Shepherd of the Church. That lineage remains unbroken to this very day, and it is now Pope Benedict XVI who occupies that office.
I really think they wanted people to say “We follow Jesus”.
And how better to do so, than by being a member of the Church that Jesus actually founded on earth? 🙂
As to Christ ans original sin, the answer their is simple. Christ, unlike Mary, Christ, unlike you and I, was Divine. It was Christ who was fit to be a sacrifice for all our sins, and conquer death, nobodoy else.
👍 I agree.
On Baptism, you mention John 3:5. You will not find argument from me, Baptism is important. In the Baptist circles I have always worshiped in, Baptism was important as a public declaration of faith. This ties in with John 3:5, but also when Christ said that those who denied him on Earth would be denied by Him to His Father. Is this not part of it for Catholics as well? Also, you mentioned Baptism as removing sin, where is this idea from?
I Peter 3:18-22

For Christ also hath once suffered for sins, the just for the unjust, that he might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh, but quickened by the Spirit:

By which also he went and preached unto the spirits in prison;

Which sometime were disobedient, when once the longsuffering of God waited in the days of Noah, while the ark was a preparing, wherein few, that is, eight souls were saved by water.

The like figure whereunto [even] baptism doth also now save us (not the putting away of the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience toward God,) by the resurrection of Jesus Christ:

Who is gone into heaven, and is on the right hand of God; angels and authorities and powers being made subject unto him.
Also, if Baptism does remove sin, then why have a Confessor?
Because Baptism only takes away existing sin - it doesn’t take away future sins. The Sacrament of Reconciliation is for the removal of sins committed after baptism. We can only be baptized once in our lives, but we can go to Confession as often as we need to, in order to restore our original Baptismal innocence.

Also, just to pre-empt a common argument, the phrase “not the putting away of the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience toward God” does not signify that there is no water, but rather, it signifies that the ceremony of baptism (which includes water, as Jesus commands in John 3:5) is not meant to be a bath - Catechumens should still bathe normally before coming to the water of Baptism - the water acts in the Sacrament to cleanse our souls; not our bodies.
 
Praying to dead people is where I couldn’t quite go along.
I would have issues with praying to dead people, too. Our belief in the Catholic faith is that those who go to Heaven are more fully alive than they have ever been before, and that they have received eternal life in Christ, which is how it is that they can pray for us to Him with the certainty of being answered.
If a Jew accepted Christ, I don’t see why they would not be allowed to observe the passover for example.
Well, the reason would be that Jesus is the Lamb of Passover, for Christians. The bread and wine of the Eucharist is our Paschal feast. The reason we don’t sacrifice a lamb or celebrate the Jewish passover is because the Mass is already our Christian Passover, and we consume the flesh and blood of the Lamb of God who was sacrificed once and for all for our sins, rather than the flesh of an ordinary lamb whose death on the Altar can only save us from sin for one year.
 
We do not ask the prayers of dead people either.😉
regarding that bread; perhaps your understanding of transubstantiation is flawed.
Remember the flesh is of no avail is this matter.
We see bread, taste bread. That bread is also subject to time degradation just like shelf bread. The quailties we define bread by are the same as that of that bread. These qualities are not the substance of bread. By faith the substance of that bread is Christ Himself, completely Christ ; flesh, bone, blood, and spirit.
The body of Christ.
amen
To BaptistGuy and flb9,

I just wanted to add that Catholics ask the saints in heaven to pray for them because they are very much alive in heaven. At mass all the angels and saints come down to be with us at the holy sacrifice of the mass. At mass we are all entering into Calvary, Jesus’ suffering, dying, and resurrection! It is a mystery and a miracle! And Jesus is really and truly present on on the altar when the priest (in the role of Christ) calls down the Holy Spirit and by the consecration ( when the priest says “This is my body”) the transubstantiation of the bread and wine become the body, blood, soul and divinity of Jesus Christ.

The real presence of Christ by the power of His word and the Holy Spirit. The priest pronounces these words, but their power and grace are God’s.

Christ told His apostles to Do this in memory of me. See John 6.

Many disciples were present when Jesus said, “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink the blood, you have no life in you; he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day. For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed. He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him.”

But many did not believe Jesus and left so He asked his apostles if they would go away too? Simon Peter then answered him, “Lord to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life; and we have believed and come to know, that you are the Holy One of God”

The Early Church Fathers did exactly this in fact if you study the Early mass it has the same parts of the mass as we have today. The prayers of Thanksgiving, the offertory, the consecration, Holy communion, and the blessing. Awesome!
 
piper.
Christ promised to be with us forever. the Eucharist is a fulfilment of that promise.
sbg stated he agreed with the Church’s teaching regarding transubstantiation, he also beleives, to my understanding of what he has posted, that communion in the Catholic Church is the same as his.
If one claims to beleive in a real presence would it not be logical that they would worship Christ if He was really there. People will never understand the unity we share as long as they preach a Christ that is divided.
 
piper.
Christ promised to be with us forever. the Eucharist is a fulfilment of that promise.
sbg stated he agreed with the Church’s teaching regarding transubstantiation, he also beleives, to my understanding of what he has posted, that communion in the Catholic Church is the same as his.
If one claims to beleive in a real presence would it not be logical that they would worship Christ if He was really there. People will never understand the unity we share as long as they preach a Christ that is divided.
:doh2: fbl9, do you mean the verse below (Matthew 28: 20), the last verse of Matthew’s Gospel?

"And behold, I am with you always, until the end of the age."

Yeah, it makes sense that the Eucharist is the fulfillment of Christ’s promise. Although he ascended into Heaven, he still remains with us in the form of the Eucharist, and we can visit him and worship him in every single Catholic church (as well as other Apostolic Churches that have the Eucharist). I am reminded of an old hymn we used to sing in my childhood and still sing to this day in my native town’s church, it goes something like this: “Although we can’t grasp it [Christ’s real presence in the Eucharist] with our intellect, we can grasp it with our faith.” Btw, as much as I like modern praise and worship songs originating in Evangelical Protestant circles, and being sung in our Catholic churches as well, the old Catholic hymns often deal with much more and teach us more, see the hymn about the Eucharist for an example.

Also, I am reminded of Christ’s words somewhere in the Gospels where he says something like this (paraphrased): **“If you won’t eat the flesh and won’t drink the blood of the Son of Man, you won’t have life in you.” **

These words of Christ are indeed consistent with the idea that he is fully present in the Eucharist, i.e. “Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity”, as the CC teaches. If the bread was only his body, and the wine was only his blood, without Christ being fully present in them, I don’t see how he could have claimed that he is with us always until the end of the age, and that his flesh and blood give us life.

Regarding the CC limiting Communion to only Catholics and members of those apostolic Churches that have a valid apostolic succession and therefore a valid Eucharist (such as Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox - Syriac and Armenian, and Polish National), my understanding is that this is certainly not because the CC is trying to be mean, or divisive, with our Protestant and non-Christian brethren.

The reason is simply this: you must understand what the Eucharist is according to the Catholic Church, you must believe that Christ is fully present in the Eucharist (his Real Presence in the Eucharist), and you must partake worthily in the Eucharist (i.e. you should be in the state of grace, or else if you have committed serious sins, you must go to Confession before going to Communion). However, with our Protestant and non-Christian brethren, they either belong to Churches that are agnostic about the Eucharist, or outright reject the Catholic understanding of it. In addition, they do not practice the sacrament of Confession, which would also necessitate a priest or bishop with valid apostolic succession, to act in persona Christi and absolve one’s sins (in accord with Christ’s words to the Apostles recorded in the Gospels, “whose sins you forgive they will be forgiven, whose sins you retain they will be retained”).

Most importantly, everybody is invited to become a member of the Catholic Church, to believe in the Eucharist as the CC believes in it, and to take advantage of the sacrament of Confession before going to Holy Communion. Thus, as I see it, the CC is not mean or divisive, because the path to becoming Catholic and fully participating in the Sacraments is offered to everyone, to every single person regardless of whether they are currently Protestants, non-Christians, agnostics, atheists, or whatever.
 
See John 6.

Many disciples were present when Jesus said, “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink the blood, you have no life in you; he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day. For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed. He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him.”
Thanks for this quote. To my mind, it supports the view that the totality of what Christ is, i.e. Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity, happens to be present in the Eucharist. The Eucharist is not like the flesh and blood of a deceased person whose soul left the person’s body. In such a deceased person’s cadaver, the flesh and blood are present but the soul is no longer present. However, Christ says, “He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him.” That only makes sense if Christ is fully present and gives himself totally to us with the Eucharist, i.e. he gives not his soul-less cadaver to us, but rather the fullness of his living self, Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity. We will have eternal life in us if we eat/drink the Eucharist, because the Eucharist is Christ himself, fully alive, as opposed to a lifeless cadaver separated from its soul.

This also explains the Catholics worshipping the Eucharist. We can bow down, we can fall on our knees before the Eucharist, because we believe that the living God is present, the Son is present who is the second person of the Holy Trinity. Emmanuel = “God with us”. The prophecy says that the maiden will bear a son whose name will be Emmanuel, “God with us”. And we Catholics believe that this is literally true with the Eucharist, that God is literally with us in the Eucharist. So, we bow down before the Eucharist and worship him.
 
Piper, Also the fact that the others could not believe what he was saying was true so they left.
He was not saying that communion was just a symbol or something, but that 'he who eats his flesh and drinks his blood will abide in me and I in him." We receive Jesus all of Him. And we become more like Him every time we receive Him.
 
I appreciate the continued responses. I have been busy, and haven’t gotten to respond much. I do still read the posts.
 
I appreciate the continued responses. I have been busy, and haven’t gotten to respond much. I do still read the posts.
👍 thanks for letting us know you are still here.
to me the doctrines of the Church are are made in a reflection of who Jesus is.
 
I’m in a remarkably similar situation to SBG and this thread was exactly what I was looking for here on the forums!

To share my story:

I’m another Protestant man from the Deep South dating a Catholic woman. Like SBG, I grew up in an area where virtually everyone, whether they actually go to church or not, identifies as some type of Evangelical Christian. I was never raised to be anti-Catholic, but I never thought much about them either. After all, there was only one Catholic church in our town and dozens and dozens of Protestant ones.

I’ve been blessed to grow up in a very Christian environment. I was raised in a Presbyterian Church, but I went to a school run by the Churches of Christ. If you don’t know anything about the CoC, they are a group that has a 100% literal approach to the Bible, and are so strict in their interpretations that they look down on most other Evangelical groups (such as Baptists) as being too liberal. We had Bible classes every day at school, and we also had daily chapel for about a half hour before lunch. There were some negatives to growing up in an environment like this, but one positive side was that I learned much more about the Bible than most young people, and the basics of Christian life (worship, prayer, Bible study, charity, forgiveness) are still important to me as an adult. I know I’m a Protestant Christian, but I’m reluctant to take on any specific label because my beliefs are still changing as I learn more and more about the Bible and church history.

I’ve been dating my Catholic girlfriend for a little over a year. She is originally from an area where almost everyone is Catholic, and Evangelical Protestants are considered unusual. It’s great to find someone I can go to church (or mass) with, but we’re realistic about the fact that our religious differences, and a lack of understanding about those differences, could be a problem if we decide to make a move toward marriage. (You should have seen my face when she explained to me what a May Crowning was! :D) We don’t want to get engaged before we make some kind of workable decision that we’ll both be happy with.

We’re both trying to approach the issue with a spirit of humility and open-mindedness, but educating one another on what we believe and why is very challenging. My search for information brought me to Catholic Forums, and this awesome thread!

I’m sure I’ll have some good questions for y’all in a while, (and some more opinions to share from the Protestant point of view) but for now I’ve learned a lot by reading the posts.

Thanks, everybody!
 
I’m in a remarkably similar situation to SBG and this thread was exactly what I was looking for here on the forums!

To share my story:

I’m another Protestant man from the Deep South dating a Catholic woman. Like SBG, I grew up in an area where virtually everyone, whether they actually go to church or not, identifies as some type of Evangelical Christian. I was never raised to be anti-Catholic, but I never thought much about them either. After all, there was only one Catholic church in our town and dozens and dozens of Protestant ones.

I’ve been blessed to grow up in a very Christian environment. I was raised in a Presbyterian Church, but I went to a school run by the Churches of Christ. If you don’t know anything about the CoC, they are a group that has a 100% literal approach to the Bible, and are so strict in their interpretations that they look down on most other Evangelical groups (such as Baptists) as being too liberal. We had Bible classes every day at school, and we also had daily chapel for about a half hour before lunch. There were some negatives to growing up in an environment like this, but one positive side was that I learned much more about the Bible than most young people, and the basics of Christian life (worship, prayer, Bible study, charity, forgiveness) are still important to me as an adult. I know I’m a Protestant Christian, but I’m reluctant to take on any specific label because my beliefs are still changing as I learn more and more about the Bible and church history.

I’ve been dating my Catholic girlfriend for a little over a year. She is originally from an area where almost everyone is Catholic, and Evangelical Protestants are considered unusual. It’s great to find someone I can go to church (or mass) with, but we’re realistic about the fact that our religious differences, and a lack of understanding about those differences, could be a problem if we decide to make a move toward marriage. (You should have seen my face when she explained to me what a May Crowning was! :D) We don’t want to get engaged before we make some kind of workable decision that we’ll both be happy with.

We’re both trying to approach the issue with a spirit of humility and open-mindedness, but educating one another on what we believe and why is very challenging. My search for information brought me to Catholic Forums, and this awesome thread!

I’m sure I’ll have some good questions for y’all in a while, (and some more opinions to share from the Protestant point of view) but for now I’ve learned a lot by reading the posts.

Thanks, everybody!
Hi Red, welcome.
Glad to have you with us.Hope to hear back from you later.
 
I’m in a remarkably similar situation to SBG and this thread was exactly what I was looking for here on the forums!

We’re both trying to approach the issue with a spirit of humility and open-mindedness, but educating one another on what we believe and why is very challenging.
Welcome to CAF, Red! :tiphat:

An interdenominational relationship between a serious Christian man like you and your Catholic gf does have its challenges, but your shared commitment to Christ and moral foundation constitute a huge bonus in this secular world, where so many people no longer care about God and his commandments to us. A spirit of humility and mutual respect for each other’s churches/faith communities is crucial, without that you wouldn’t make it very far.

I would also like to recommend this website to you - maintained by a Catholic couple, musicians who come from Evangelical and Presbyterian backgrounds, and who started their website to answer some questions from their Evangelical friends:

davidmacd.com/catholic/index2.htm

Here’s a quote from their homepage:

We love praising Jesus with anyone who has had a personal encounter with him. Sometimes our Evangelical friends ask us sincere questions like: Are Catholics Christian?..Is the Catholic Church Bible based?..Why are you guys so into Mary?.. Isn’t Jesus about relationship and not religion?..Don’t Catholics think they can work their way into heaven? … and so on.

Some Evangelicals are surprised to learn that the Catholic Mass is allBible, that the Rosary is a meditation on the life of Jesus, and that we have an Altar Call at every Mass (Communion). Our Evangelical friends see that we’ve surrendered to Jesus and say we are “born again.” Some have trouble reconciling the life they see in us with what they’ve been told about the Catholic Church.

There are not over a hundred people in the United States who hate the Catholic Church. There are millions, however, who hate what they wrongly believe to be the Catholic Church, which is, of course, quite a different thing. (Bishop Fulton Sheen)

Never in western civilization, have Christians faced such persecution for trying to defend the unborn, the sanctity of marriage, and protect our teens from the media’s normalization of sex, drugs, and violence. We fear the worst is to come. Christians have got to cooperate like never before, and it will be easier if we understand each other.

Here we lay Catholicism at the feet of our Evangelical friends. We are not trying to gloss over differences but our hope is that all Christians will love one another as He has loved us (Jn 13:34). We are not apologists. We are simply a Catholic couple responding to Jesus’ prayer **“that they may all be one, as you Father, are in me and I am in you.” **(Jn 17:21) “Let us not give up meeting together… let us encourage one another.” (Heb 10:25), “Wherever two or three are gathered in my name, I am there among them.” (Mat 18:20).​

I hope I piqued your interest! 🙂

Here’s a non-exhaustive list of topics discussed on the website, the site is very accessible, easy to read. It’s not meant for experts with doctorates in theology, it’s more for the average Christian brother and sister:

Mass
Saints
Statues in Church
Bible Catholics?
Faith vs. Works
Born Again/Baptism
Eucharist
Pope
Mary
Why Purgatory?
Why the Early Church Fathers?
Indulgences
Catholic Timeline 20-500 A.D.
Inquisition
Priests Forgive - Called Father?
 
Thanks to both of y’all for the warm welcome and the great resources.

L,

I’ll be sure to visit that website in the future, and I’ve already got the “Catholicism for Dummies” book on hold at my local library.

I was interested in studying religion and seeking answers before I even met my girlfriend, and so I’ve already read certain early church works like the letters of Ignatius, the Didache, 1st Clement, the epistle of Polycarp, and stuff like that. I’ve got a leg up on some other people in that area, but I still have a long way to go.

One anecdote you might find funny:

The first time I attended mass with my girlfriend, I didn’t know about the bells that ring during the preparation of the Eucharist. When I heard them ringing, I looked at my girlfriend and said under my breath “I can’t believe someone left their cell phone on.” That’s one of those learning moments.
 
Hi BaptistGuy,

I am a devoted Catholic woman who is dating a devoted Baptist Christian, and it is NOT easy! There are so many clashes. I invited him to church once and he told me he didn’t want to go again because “there was pagan worship”. As a devoted Catholic, going to mass every Sunday is a big part of my life, and when the person that you love most refuses to go, you feel this scratch in your heart and it burns…and the worst part is that you cannot see this ‘scratch’ to cure it, you can only feel it. Before you get into this relationship, please think about it. How are you going to raise your children? What is the best for your children?. I do not discourage you from learn about Catholicm because I have learned so many wonderful things about the Catholic Church that I have tried to share with him. Unless both of you are willing to be open-minded and not close-minded like the farisees–who believed theirs was the only right way to get to heaven, the relationship will not work. An interfaith relationship requires great love and great respect coming from both sides. You must not be waiting for her to convert and she must not be waiting for you to convert or else you will never be happy.
 
Thanks to both of y’all for the warm welcome and the great resources.

L,

I’ll be sure to visit that website in the future, and I’ve already got the “Catholicism for Dummies” book on hold at my local library.

I was interested in studying religion and seeking answers before I even met my girlfriend, and so I’ve already read certain early church works like the letters of Ignatius, the Didache, 1st Clement, the epistle of Polycarp, and stuff like that. I’ve got a leg up on some other people in that area, but I still have a long way to go.

One anecdote you might find funny:

The first time I attended mass with my girlfriend, I didn’t know about the bells that ring during the preparation of the Eucharist. When I heard them ringing, I looked at my girlfriend and said under my breath “I can’t believe someone left their cell phone on.” That’s one of those learning moments.
That’s funny.
May i ask if you have found, in your readings, items that you don’t agree with?
 
That’s funny.
May i ask if you have found, in your readings, items that you don’t agree with?
It’s hard to say that I’ve found anything I “don’t agree with” so far, because I’ve mostly read documents like the epistles of Ignatius and 1st Clement. I’m already interested in the early Christian writings for a couple of reasons. First, I work as a history teacher and arguments from historical documents and physical evidence are naturally very effective with me. Second, I decided a few years ago that it makes sense to try and interpret the Bible in light of what the Christians who were nearest to the time of the apostles thought it meant. To me, someone like Polycarp, who actually knew John the Apostle, would logically be a good source for trying to understand apostolic teaching.

I’m sure you can guess some of the things about Catholicism that seem strange to me or make me uneasy, but I don’t want to react out of ignorance. I’ve always been annoyed by people who start political or religious arguments over mistaken ideas about what the other person believes rather than the other person’s actual position. I’ll be more open to questioning when I have a better understanding of what I’m asking about.

I know some things from my church that I *miss *when I go to Catholic Church. I miss the music I’ve grown up with that has such a strong emotional connection to me. I miss the style of preaching that I’m used to. (But maybe my girlfriend’s church just has priests who aren’t very expressive during the homily?) I don’t like sticking out when I can’t go up to receive Eucharist, even though I understand why I can’t. I miss some of the times of silent prayer that I’m used to. I also miss calling out prayer requests, updates and praises from the congregation, although I also miss that when I attend any church where the size of the congregation makes doing so impractical.

Right now I’m wondering what I can do to try and help my girlfriend understand the teachings and church culture that I grew up with. It’s odd how hard it is to teach something that’s so ingrained in who you are.
 
wait, catholics don’t support organ donation? doesnt it save lives?
According to Catholic teaching on bioethics, it is not sinful to treat a disease, even if it leads to sterility as an unintended or “secondary” consequence. Are you interested in bioethical issues, BaptistGuy? I mean contraception, abortion, euthanasia, in vitro fertilization, organ donation, the use of cell lines from aborted babies, etc.
 
Oops, TLC, I listed the one thing that’s not intrinsically evil, among a bunch of intrinsic evils, thus creating confusion. :o

The CC is OK with organ donation, within certain ethical guidelines. The procedure can be abused and abuses are rampant, but that’s another story.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top