moving on to Islam

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bloved
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t understand the question.

-MontChevalier
Chevalier;8263444]I don’t understand the question.

-MontChevalier
What is the “difference in the protestant and Catholic view of Islam”, and how is such a disagreement–if one can be shown to exist–relevant here?
Hello to you both sorry for not responding but have been busy.

I maybe see how my question is not understood and i should have qualified my question better.

In my experience of sharing directly with protestants they hold that Allah Mulims seek is satan.
My words in the prior post were un fair as i asserted that this view is protestant. If i have offended any one i am very sorry.

The Contrast to this is Catholics according to their church teaching hold that Mulsims seek the same G-d they worship.

I asked the question as given the change in religion from Protestant to Catholic in the light of my experience seems huge.

So you may be able to help me where does one find a credible source of protestant beliefs?

Peace and blessings Howie
 
With regard to the bolded bit, this is pure ignorance. Early Islam allowed women to do many things which weren’t allowed in the West even until recently. They still can and could inititate a divorce, go to university and school, become doctors, own their own money and work for themselves, own a business and travel abroad freely.
Peace and blessings,
what you say here about rights is of truth. I dont hate people of the Islamic religion so dont seek to argue with you of be derogative to Islamic religion. I know of women who convert and are happy.
I personally dont understand how they want to after reading the Quran given that men in paradise are given two wives but have other “created beings” for their pleasure.
Paradise in the Quran looks to me like a place designed to satisfy Arabic men of days of old.

No disrespect to an sister who has chosen Islamic religion, just my objective view.
Similarly, there are literally a 1001 reasons why women in particular convert to Islam, and one of the reasons I’ve heard is much to do with the lackings of Christianity as they saw it.
I agree but that does not speak for the Islamic religion but against the convert or Christianity.

Pray well and stay well
 
Posted by Kouyate on another forum regarding attempts to create “Sharia Zones” in U.K. cities. “Sharia”, isn’t that a “moslem” thing?
Sharia law in my experience of listening to Muslims is held and excepted very differently.
Some parts are wanted and others are not.
This makes sense given
  1. the Quran was a document expressed to people in specific circumstances and its guidance changes to suit different events. So it stands to reason different sharia would apply in different places at different times. Unlike the books of the Torah and injeel that each in their own right show G-ds guidance as constant and un changing
  2. The followers of Mohamed (pbuh) are to split into 73 sects with only one going to paradise. So it stands to reason of 73 sharia offerings only one could be correct but subject to point one.
  3. Most importantly most Muslims i have met that are pro sharia have no idea how it would apply, they simply mean they want G-ds law here. So maybe like Christians they understand G-d is not about democracy and is about kingdom. Christians some understand democracy is allowed for a time by His / Her / Its grace.
Any points here made on behalf of religions are from various sources ie reading and direct discussions, i dont state them as facts and welcome any un bias source for corrections.

G-d is most merciful, may His mercy be on all He wills
 
So Hosemonkey,

If Islam is a false, deceptive religion how do you know Christianity isn’t the false, deceptive product of early, power-hungry disciples?

The OP isn’t converting to Islam, by the way.
I think you raise an important point, none of us really know what went on so long ago, we are at best left with some writings and some oral traditions.

I think from the writing’s the disciples had some power understanding faults asking “who is greatest of us” clues this but as we read on we see they were poorly treated, imprisoned and still stood for what they knew of the truth. thats a big clue.

But in defences of Mohamed (pbuh) what some posted here is much like i read of the Quran, if read in true order all seems very pious until chapter 2 the 87th chapter of the “revelation” then the justice becomes important.
I also agree there are things that i dont understand as of G-d but i am not native Arabic speaking nor was i there.
i know from the torah and injeel me not being native speaking, aramic / palio hebrew or greek i dont really understand the all as pure of G-d.

Add to this your important point of not really knowing the past, its best i approach such topics in humility and leave lording for me with my G-d and for others our G-d, their god, gods or men as it maybe.

Oh BTW if you see and know G-ds goodness anywhere dont be humble even if you find it in the sinner or their creed. Truth is truth even when satan tries to vail it.
Glorify G-d where you see, its not about us.

“i will be who i will be”, you have free will to choose who you see
 
I have answered your question. That you do not seem to be able to understand it is not my problem. For you to raise such a question smacks of disloyalty, or perhaps that you are not convinced of the truth of the faith that you claim. I think the latter.
I am not sure but think the other poster is a Catholic and dont know your religion.
You maybe un aware Catholics believe Muslims and them selves both seek to adore the One same G-d.
In addition to that they had a council back in the 60s that encouraged kindness even with non Christian religions to encourage dialogue rather than shutting it down.
So while i cant say for sure they look like Catholic in attitude to me.
Hope this may help you discussion, if i am way off, sorry just trying to build pace for better discussion.

Pray well and stay well
 
Rubbish. It’s clear that you tried to divert the central matter and make a cop-out because you realised my original question was raised as a trap. You’re too scared to lose.
Forum rules prohibit setting out to trap some one i think. Have a read of them as i am not the best reader as you may owe an apology.
Regardless to the rules it is not our best behaviour of love.

IMO for Muslims (at least to 87th chapter revealed) and Christians alike are not out to be winners but are out to glorify G-d. Its not about us. The truth “wins” the discussion.
Bless ya
 
Peace and blessings,
And some of these ‘happy converts’ as you call them cant wait till they get back to their original religion. 75% in fact when they find out what the real islam is and not the watered down version of islam.
councilofexmuslims.com/index.php?topic=4198.0
It would not be a fact as you stated but a claim via your link. No one would be able to gather such a statistic from a global perspective.
That is because they need support groups, as women in islam are treated rather poorly.
There are several passages suggesting women are beneath men, not as smart as men, can be beaten by their husband, more women in hell than men etc. Of course you are going to need a support group dealing with issues, and many others like these!
Unless you are spending a lot of time at your Mosque this would be what you sumise based on your understanding.
While i don’t get to participate in the womens group here where i live they seem very happy. The support here between the women is at times in support of contacts for employment as many new Muslim sisters come from out of town.
I dont see how this says women and men are equal, however, there is an abundance of text showing how women are less superior than man.
My opinion of text would be similar to yours expressed here but it is easy to confuse equal and same. Also i think many in Christian history interpreted scripture as Men are superior to women. The Catholic church where i live still has prohibits (or at least is not open to) women form the ordained priesthood.

May g-d bless and guide you and yours
 
And some of these ‘happy converts’ as you call them cant wait till they get back to their original religion. 75% in fact when they find out what the real islam is and not the watered down version of islam.
councilofexmuslims.com/index.php?topic=4198.0
And a large minority will stay, and you can’t ignore a large number like that.
That is because they need support groups, as women in islam are treated rather poorly.
There are several passages suggesting women are beneath men, not as smart as men, can be beaten by their husband, more women in hell than men etc. Of course you are going to need a support group dealing with issues, and many others like these!
These type of support groups exist because Islam teaches segregation of genders, and especially for certain issues (such as marriage issues, pregnancy and children, hijab and the like) it is considered proper to ask another woman only. It is also a useful source of faith support for women. It can also be the only time those women have to socialize, as Islam forbids mixed socializing between those who are ghayr mahraam (non-relatives)

And this is no different to many other religions. My local Orthodox synagogue has a women-only prayer group and other women-only events, My last church had a women-only meeting, which I used to help in running along with a women’s prayer team and other things.
Why are you comparing the west against a religion? The ‘west’ isnt a Christian religion the last time i checked, however, Catholicism is a religion, and I will compare islam with that.
Catholics do dress modestly, in fact, i myself dress modestly.
Here is what the bible says:
1 tim 9 Similarly, women are to wear suitable clothes and to be dressed quietly and modestly, without braided hair or gold and jewellery or expensive clothes;
10 their adornment is to do the good works that are proper for women who claim to be religious.
Whilst you may personally follow modesty rules, there are plenty of Christians who do not. Indeed, modesty in dress and action is something that is RARELY discussed in any church now, and it’s something I only really thought about when I read the Qur’an and made Muslim friends.
Ive been to Egypt, and i can assure you, women are not respected, they are harrassed on a daily basis, in saudi, they cant drive, cant go out without a male relative, have to sit in the back of shops etc, do you call that respecting women?? And i wont even start on how the taliban treat women!
These are cultural rather than Islamic. Different Islamic cultures have different ways of working and you’re imposing YOUR cultural values upon them.

As for Saudi women, I’ve often come across Saudi women saying the’re HAPPY to live in the way they do and that they don’t wish for this to change. But things ARE changing in Saudi, including a campaign to allow women to drive, something supported by more liberal Saudi scholars.
And Christianity doesnt teach this??? Have you been locked in a cupboard???
Eph 6 1 Children, be obedient to your parents in the Lord – that is what uprightness demands.
2 The first commandment that has a promise attached to it is: Honour your father and your mother,
3 and the promise is: so that you may have long life and prosper in the land.
4 And parents, never drive your children to resentment but bring them up with correction and advice inspired by the Lord.
A LOT of Christians of all denominations simply don’t follow this. It’s what the Bible says, but whether it is followed is another matter.
I dont see how this says women and men are equal, however, there is an abundance of text showing how women are less superior than man. Refer to the link above. 😉
I don’t have a Qurán to hand, but I"ll find the verses I’m actually thinking of and post them.
Yes it is.
:Let’s flip this over: there’s probably a Muslim message forum where a Muslim poster is saying exactly the same things about Christianity as you are saying about Islam.
 
:Let’s flip this over: there’s probably a Muslim message forum where a Muslim poster is saying exactly the same things about Christianity as you are saying about Islam.
Cant exactly remember the last time a Christian ran into a mosque and blew himself up, honor killed his daughters or his wife, but Ill go do a quick search to see what I cant come up with.
 
Cant exactly remember the last time a Christian ran into a mosque and blew himself up, honor killed his daughters or his wife, but Ill go do a quick search to see what I cant come up with.
There have been plenty of attacks by Christians on innocent civilians including the bombings of abortion clinics. Anders Brevik claimed to be a Christian and has killed 78 innocent people.

As to the stuff about wives and children, I can cite one case: Irish Catholic Ireland in the past. Women were expected to marry and stay with often abusive husbands, who in turn often beat and ill-treated their wives and children. If I were to look, there’s likely a few murder charges on the books where this was the case.
 
Yes I know I was being ironic. Of course there have been cases where Christians have caused violence. But trying to compare the ethnic/moral code to that of Islam is silly. There are cases of crazed Christians, but I havent found anything in Christianity in a whole that amounts to compulsory Jihad that we Muslims were taught.

And yes, I know ‘Blah blah not all Muslims are bad terrorists etc’. I know this. I am friends with many of my Muslim friends who dont care one way or another that I converted. Doesnt change what is in the Quran… it only changes the fact that they choose to be cafeteria Muslims and pick and choose what they want to obey and not obey.
 
Can we stop making this thread about the general merits of Islam vis-a-vis Christianity or anything else and bring it back to trying to help the OP with her situation? This arguing and jockeying for position is not helping anybody.
 
My dearest friend from highschool is turning to Islam. These last few years I have been busy and had to change our friendship because I work and now have a family. She called me a few days ago and invited me to her conversion. I admit I know little about islam but it scared me and I don’t know what to tell her. She is married to a catholic man his facebook page shows he is angry at her and is afraid for his kids.:confused: what do I say at this point?
It may be worthwhile asking her why she’s turning to Islam and why she does not embrace the Catholic Church. Nine out of ten times the reason why people do not accept Catholic doctrines is due to their lack of knowledge or misunderstanding regarding them…

God bless,
 
Call a priest, let he talk to her… thats what they do to muslims that want to become chrisitan
 
Call a priest, let he talk to her… thats what they do to muslims that want to become chrisitan
True? when you say “they” i assume you mean Muslims, so when a Muslim wants to become a Christian Muslims call a priest.

In that light if you are trying to say do as they do should she not call an Imam?

And i guess your advice is based upon this process works for Muslims in stopping conversions, if thats so it would reflect priests are not good at helping.
 
My dearest friend from highschool is turning to Islam. These last few years I have been busy and had to change our friendship because I work and now have a family. She called me a few days ago and invited me to her conversion. I admit I know little about islam but it scared me and I don’t know what to tell her. She is married to a catholic man his facebook page shows he is angry at her and is afraid for his kids.:confused: what do I say at this point?
This person will return to the one, true catholic church when the Warning comes to pass. Of this I am sure.
 
Wow, I’m shocked at the intolerance I see here. We do live in a country that has freedom of religion, I might remind some people. And everybody’s journey to God is unique and might take a different path than your own.
Are you only going to choose friends and love people and support those who think and do exactly as you do?
That doesn’t sound so Christian to me.
If I were you, I’d be a good friend and go to her conversion. If you had a friend who was running in a political party different than the one you voted for, and she won, and she invited you to her celebration party…you wouldn’t go?
Even tho she’s of a different party, you still care about her and want to support her path to be close to God, even if it veers from yours. Or do you want to punish someone just because they are different than you?
And why are you so afraid of this religion? People are often afraid of what they don’t know or because they listen to rumor.
The former Cat Stevens, who wrote some of the most beautiful, loving, heartfelt songs in the world follows the Islamic faith…and he’s one of the most peaceful, kindest, God-loving souls I’ve ever met in my life.
Go to your friend’s conversion. And show her how a God-loving person truly behaves in this world, with the people they love. xoxox
I would argue that faith isn’t really comparable to politics. I’m with you on remaining friends with the convert to Islam and loving her sincerely. Going to the victory celebration for a friend of a different political party will perhaps entail feelings of disappointment, even resentment or humiliation. But attending the conversion ceremony of a friend to another faith will likely signal to others one’s adherence to indifferentism and relativism (“It doesn’t really matter, whether to me or in general, what you believe, since all religions are ultimately the same”).

Islam certainly has some good elements, but has other aspects–such as the denial of the trinity and the incarnation–that a Christian should condone neither in word nor in action. No one should even be given to think that a Christian encourages or affirms their decision to depart the faith.

Souls are at stake here, not merely personal pride. Christianity and Islam cannot both be true at once; the two are mutually incompatible. Faith deals with what will happen in eternity, which is unalterable after death; politics deals with what happens in the present, which is ephemeral and can change at the next election.

To truly love someone is to tell them with honesty what may hurt them now but will benefit them in the long run. Friends don’t let friends drive drunk.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top