Pope suggests Trump: not Christian

  • Thread starter Thread starter ringil
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I wont decide if Trump is a Christian or not…thats IMO for God to decide. What Pope Francis has said according to the translations is that if you support building a separation wall and if you support the deportation of Mexicans then you are not a Christian. This is nothing to due with wealth and everything to do with common courtesy which is a major element in Christianity. Donald Trump lacks common courtesy wrt how trump speaks about minorities…and I think this is why the Pope is calling out Trump.
Marco Rubio isn’t the Vicar of Christ; however, I can read Marco’s words and wonder if Cuba got a bad deal.

It is very troubling if this deal enriched Cuba’s dictators who are accused of some of the worse things and where citizens flee the country over the rough seas. They are the poor too? Is there some difference I’m missing?

2014:
Rubio calls out pope on Cuba
Sen. Marco Rubio, a Catholic, criticized Pope Francis on Wednesday after the pontiff played a key role in helping the United States and Cuba forge an agreement that resulted in the release of American Alan Gross from Cuba.
Rubio said he would “ask His Holiness to take up the cause of freedom and democracy.”
The Florida Republican said he didn’t criticize Francis’ personal appeals to help facilitate Gross’ release, but was speaking in response to the White House’s announcement about talks to normalize relations with Cuba after a nearly 50-year embargo with the country.
The pope played a pivotal role through personal appeals to President Barack Obama and Cuban President Raul Castro to help the two countries forge an agreement for the release of Gross, Obama announced on Wednesday.
 
Yes. He is aligning himself with the elites who want cheap labor.

Exploit the immigrants and deny working class Americans fair wages.

The Hb1 visa program is rampant with fraud too.

The elites want cheap labor and support global warming issues as they will make money from it.

This is so sad that the Pope does not see he is being played.
Danny , I would say building bridges is a bilateral effort somehow in general.
It takes both sides and a possibility to go both ways.
What do you think ?
 
. My concern now and going way back is that this Pope keeps saying things that are confusing to the faithful
Only problem is that he’s not confusing the faithful he’s only confusing politically conservative American Catholics no one else seems to have a problem with the Holy Father
 
When it came to the gays Pope Francis infamously said “Who am I to judge?” When it comes to Trump he is “not Christian.” Does anyone else see a problem with this? I am not a Trump supporter. In fact, I hate politics. My concern now and going way back is that this Pope keeps saying things that are confusing to the faithful, and the fact that he should be shepherding the flock, not becoming involved with the affairs and the politics of the day. And if Benedict hadn’t resigned for whatever reason I wouldn’t be feeling this way right now. So yes, I am not happy with the latest developments
So the pope said “Who am I to judge?” about people who are born gay and want to have a semblance of a normal life. He then said that people who stress walls instead of bridges are not Christian. How are these conflated. They seem like two entirely different concepts. Do you have a problem with bishops telling us who to vote for, but not the pope? I don’t get what you don’t get.
 
I wish the Pope hadn’t gotten involved, because his comments will provide fuel for the Trump machine like nothing else has. It’ll surely propel Trump to the top of S. Carolina, where anti-Catholic sentiment is strong.

I’m not sure I wholly agree with the Pope, however, because a sovereign nation has a responsibility to protect its citizens.

However, I love it that all the conservative Republican “Catholics” are probably gnashing their teeth right now.

At this point, if Trump utters a single disparaging word about the Holy Father, I’ll vote for the Democratic candidate if Trump becomes the nominee.

And I’ll repeat what I stated in another thread: My support for Francis grows stronger every day. Thank God he is our Holy Father.
 
But here is what I don’t understand. You are insisting that the Pope didn’t necessarily condemn Trump. He was talking about some theoretical person who “only thinks about building a wall and not bridges.” and according to you, the Pope is not talking about Trump.

So why are you insisting now that since this is such an important moral issue, we must listen to the Pope and not Trump? What does Trump advocate that the Pope condemns? I thought there was no conflict between the two people.
Literally, the wall.
 
When it came to the gays Pope Francis infamously said “Who am I to judge?” When it comes to Trump he is “not Christian.” Does anyone else see a problem with this? I am not a Trump supporter. In fact, I hate politics. My concern now and going way back is that this Pope keeps saying things that are confusing to the faithful, and the fact that he should be shepherding the flock, not becoming involved with the affairs and the politics of the day. And if Benedict hadn’t resigned for whatever reason I wouldn’t be feeling this way right now. So yes, I am not happy with the latest developments
I wonder, did you ever read what the Pope said about gays? He was saying that if he meets a gay person who has good will and he is trying to live a Christian life (which includes continency and chastity) who was he to judge. He was saying the tendency is not the issue. That is 100% in-line with Catholic teachings. Many gay people do live chaste lives.

As for the Pope and Trump–the Pope’s actual words are not being talked about or posted. He said (paraphrased) that if a person thinks ONLY of building walls, and does not think of building bridges, he is not behaving as a Christian. He never said Trump is not a Christian, and in fact he said that since he did not have the details, he was giving Trump the benefit of the doubt. He also said he would not try to tell people how to vote.

Sadly, both the media, and Trump, have once against taken the Pope’s words and perverted them to their own purposes.
 
The problem is how Trump speaks about Mexicans, migrants, refugees, immigrants and Muslims for example…Calling on a ban of Muslims traveling to the USA…and calling for 12 million so called illegals(many of whom are nice good working people) to be deported is probably why the Pope is speaking up…not to mention the Pope is in Mexico and I think maybe the Pope while speaking to Mexicans saw in these Mexicans loving king and wonderful Christians. So the Pope is not at all going against security, but rather…very clearly saying that intolerance has nothing to do with Christianity.

I’m not into politics much btw…I care about people and I will look for leaders who preach tolerance and strength . . GWB said clearly … Islam is peace and those AQ terrorists do not represent Islam. GWB also said it is not the American way to discriminant against others. It is not the American way to deport 12 million people…many of whom are illegals but are still very good productive citizens… There are just as many criminals in that 12 million illegals as there are criminals percentage wise wrt the 300+ million Americans. Trump should take lines from GWB…after all GWB stood up with the firefighters in the after math of 9/11 unifying the country(Muslims, Atheists, Jews and Christians and more) against terrorism.
When "W’ whispered into into Nancy Pelosi’s ear, on the occasion of Mc Cain trying to weigh in on the financial meltdown of 2008, "Miss me yet?’, he must have been prescient
 
When it came to the gays Pope Francis infamously said “Who am I to judge?” When it comes to Trump he is “not Christian.” Does anyone else see a problem with this? I am not a Trump supporter. In fact, I hate politics. My concern now and going way back is that this Pope keeps saying things that are confusing to the faithful, and the fact that he should be shepherding the flock, not becoming involved with the affairs and the politics of the day. And if Benedict hadn’t resigned for whatever reason I wouldn’t be feeling this way right now. So yes, I am not happy with the latest developments
Yes i understand what you are saying. A lot of Catholics are genuinely asking the same questions.

There is an agnostic right wing journalist in Australia named Andrew Bolt who suggested that when the pope speaks in this way he loses half his audience and most of his authority.

Andrew Bolt is an agnostic who, in general, is friendly towards the church. For example, in the last few days he strongly supported Cardinal Pell when the Leftist media here decided to mount a disgusting and untrue attack on him.

blogs.news.com.au/heraldsun/andrewbolt/index.php/heraldsun/comments/column_crucifying_pell/

blogs.news.com.au/heraldsun/andrewbolt/index.php/heraldsun/comments/how_dare_the_abc_interview_peter_fox_to_damn_george_pell/

blogs.news.com.au/heraldsun/andrewbolt/index.php/heraldsun/comments/this_political_pope_attacks_trump_as_a_non_christian/
 
Hannity had a great debate between a priest and the son of the late Jerry Falwel.

Final take - this will be worth 3 - 4 points in SC for Trump and the Pope needs to apologize to Trump. Unless he is ready to start calling out other individual politicians by name.
 
But here is what I don’t understand. You are insisting that the Pope didn’t necessarily condemn Trump. He was talking about some theoretical person who “only thinks about building a wall and not bridges.” and according to you, the Pope is not talking about Trump.

So why are you insisting now that since this is such an important moral issue, we must listen to the Pope and not Trump? What does Trump advocate that the Pope condemns? I thought there was no conflict between the two people.
Trump should not have seen a conflict since the Pope’s words, when taken in their full context, do not condemn a person who is trying to build bridges to those most in need. If Trump plans to build those bridges, then he can assume the Pope’s words do not apply to him, but if Trump has no intention on building any bridges of help, then yes the Pope’s words apply to him.

It is clear the Pope was trying to speak to all people and all politicians, as he often does. He wants people to consider the pain and suffering those being locked out.
 
The Catholic Church is looked at by some as helping to lead the charge of immigration, some Catholics themselves may see that.

I don’t know if the Church has been involved in Sanctuary Cities, etc. but I’d think some could interpret the involvement already as being a bit political so this is the blow back potentially of some of that and now we hear Trump and the media are perverting the Pontiff’s words. It started somewhere long before Trump. He’s not at fault for the ensuing scrum.

:dts:
 
Literally, the wall.
You know ,Good Tidings , in my mind and in my heart I am right now holding some American persons who are.going through hardships and I wonder if these persons would have anything ,any skill or knowledge that could give them a job in Mexico.
And viceversa.
In other words there is usually that niche that can help both ways.
You know your society best and I am not Mexican but oftrn times I.wonder the same with surrounding countries and not necessarily super elaborate skills ,but what might be helpful .
Just a thought and a question if you ever thought of this.
 
You just seemed surprised in this instance. I’m just saying you shouldn’t be surprised. We have instances of liberals placing more importance on their political ideology than on the teachings of Jesus.
And now the conservatives are doing that very thing.
 
Hannity had a great debate between a priest and the son of the late Jerry Falwel.

Final take - this will be worth 3 - 4 points in SC for Trump and the Pope needs to apologize to Trump. Unless he is ready to start calling out other individual politicians by name.
Hannity attacks the Church a lot. There is close to nothing I’d trust from him regarding the faith.

The Pope said nothing but Gospel truth and he never once said Trump was not a Christian–fact. Sometimes, what the Vicar of Christ has to say will cause pain and controversy.

I wonder, if Jesus had made the same comments as Pope Francis, would people go away from Him as they did 2,000 years ago?
 
Only problem is that he’s not confusing the faithful he’s only confusing politically conservative American Catholics no one else seems to have a problem with the Holy Father
I think there is a diffrence between having personal distain with the Pope and disagreeing with him strongly on a political issue, an area where I think most Americans on this Forum would agree he is not a policy expert in. I would include Trump in here as well.
 
“No leader, especially a religious leader, should have the right to question another man’s religion or faith,” Donald Trump

For me looking in on this issue I consider this statement by Trump to be another example of his hypocrisy.

Just last week he questioned Ted Cruz’s Christianity.

“How can Ted Cruz be an Evangelical Christian when he lies so much and is so dishonest?” Donald Trump thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/presidential-races/269238-trump-how-is-cruz-christian-when-he-lies-so-much

For a man who is running for the office of POTUS, who states that no leader should question another man’s religion or faith. I just can’t take Trump’s criticism of our Pope with any amount of seriousness especially after Trump blatantly question the faith of another man.
 
I think there is a diffrence between having personal distain with the Pope and disagreeing with him strongly on a political issue, an area where I think most Americans on this Forum would agree he is not a policy expert in. I would include Trump in here as well.
Except this topic touches three major rails: politics, morals, and faith.

Regarding faith and morals, I’ll side with pope Francis (the Vicar of Christ) every time.
 
Only problem is that he’s not confusing the faithful he’s only confusing politically conservative American Catholics no one else seems to have a problem with the Holy Father
Planned Parenthood are hardly a conservative organisation, they criticised Pope Francis after his speech to Congress.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top