Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If by “actively trying” do you mean fertility drugs or charting to only have relations during the fertile time, then, correct.

If by “actively trying” you mean to have sexual relations, well, as a married couple we can mutually agree to abstain (and prayerfully do so, see St Paul on that one). If one of the partners struggles with abstaining, it is sinful to refuse the marital debt.
No, by “actively trying”, I mean having sex during a fertile time. The Church does not require Catholics to actively try to conceive.

If one of the partners struggles with abstaining, it is not always sinful to refuse the marital embrace. For example, it would be sinful (a call to responsible parenthood) to try and pressure one’s spouse to share the marital embrace during a fertile time if one of the parents is sick, under undue stress, having financial difficulty, emotionally unable to parent another child etc. And I mean that for both the mother or the father. If one of the partners struggles with abstaining, and his/her spouse has good reason for abstaining, then the one who is struggling better decide what is important: sex or their spouse. It works both ways.
 
I would highly recommend they work with doctors and NFP specialists to determine WHY NFP doesn’t work. Is it a hormone deficiency? Would weight/loss or gain help? Taking a supplement?

If all of these are exhausted, complete abstinence is the only other moral option, as outlined by the Church.
The issue is that almost no priest is going to tell you that at the marriage preparation.
I would really like to find out how many can** honestly** claim they understood it that way before marriage.
 
The issue is that almost no priest is going to tell you that at the marriage preparation.
I would really like to find out how many can** honestly** claim they understood it that way before marriage.
In the end it doesn’t matter. If you know it NOW then you have to follow the teachings of the Church.
 
If two people engage is sex knowing that if pregnancy results there is a 100% chance of serious complications that would result in death… they also need to consider the life of the baby that would be conceived.
I’m not sure if I understand what you’re saying. My grandmother had seven miscarriages before she had my mom, and almost died to have my mom…are you saying those who are known to have difficult pregnancies should not try to have them anymore? Because I think that those are decisions for individual couples to make…just like using NFP to avoid.
 
The issue is that almost no priest is going to tell you that at the marriage preparation.
I would really like to find out how many can** honestly** claim they understood it that way before marriage.
Do you think that all of us are lying??? Or are you looking only for an answer that you want? Because I believe 3 of us have said yes.
 
Do you think that all of us are lying??? Or are you looking only for an answer that you want? Because I believe 3 of us have said yes.
And the other thing is, it’s not like we’re talking about a bad sales contract here where you didn’t understand the terms before you signed on the dotted line. We are talking about a sacramental covenant.
 
No, by “actively trying”, I mean having sex during a fertile time. The Church does not require Catholics to actively try to conceive.

If one of the partners struggles with abstaining, it is not always sinful to refuse the marital embrace. For example, it would be sinful (a call to responsible parenthood) to try and pressure one’s spouse to share the marital embrace during a fertile time if one of the parents is sick, under undue stress, having financial difficulty, emotionally unable to parent another child etc. And I mean that for both the mother or the father. If one of the partners struggles with abstaining, and his/her spouse has good reason for abstaining, then the one who is struggling better decide what is important: sex or their spouse. It works both ways.
There are limits to when it is morally permissable to refuse the debt.

Good outlines on the Church teachings with regard to the marriage debt can be found at Vatican.va - we went through them in a recent thread, let me find it.
 
Do you think that all of us are lying??? Or are you looking only for an answer that you want? Because I believe 3 of us have said yes.
I think that you’re not acknowledging that other people may have different experiences than you. For example, I had never heard of NFP despite attending Catholic grammar school, Catholic high school, Catholic college and Catholic unversity. It was given a short paragraph mention in my nusing text book. I never knew about NFP until I came to CAF. And when I did find out about it via NFP, all these folks were singing its praises. It didn’t take long to learn that all wasn’t rosy and that many people struggled with it, hated it and said it was destroying their marriage…not only that, as a nurse, I’ve tried to counsel people against ABCs purefly for the side effects and risks and found that no one IRL has even heard of NFP (and those who said they did were describing the old rythmn method) and refused to even hear about it. so no, I don’t think you’re lying. You’re just not understanding that others have different experiences as you. I totally believe Jaaanosik didn’t know what she was agreeing to when she got married in the Church. It’s typical…
 
There are limits to when it is morally permissable to refuse the debt.

Good outlines on the Church teachings with regard to the marriage debt can be found at Vatican.va - we went through them in a recent thread, let me find it.
I would agree with that, but there are limits to having to give it upon ‘demand’ too. When Catholics get married, they become one, and they have “responsiubilities” but they don’t leave their dignity at the door either. They don’t become blow-up dolls, nor do they become pacifiers. They are still people who need to be respected, and not abused, by their spouse. NFP should be discussed and agreed to. However, when one is not in agreement, they’re not always the right one. They’re not always the wrong one either. But they’re not always in their right to demand upon request - either one.
 
I think that you’re not acknowledging that other people may have different experiences than you. For example, I had never heard of NFP despite attending Catholic grammar school, Catholic high school, Catholic college and Catholic unversity. It was given a short paragraph mention in my nusing text book. I never knew about NFP until I came to CAF. And when I did find out about it via NFP, all these folks were singing its praises. It didn’t take long to learn that all wasn’t rosy and that many people struggled with it, hated it and said it was destroying their marriage…not only that, as a nurse, I’ve tried to counsel people against ABCs purefly for the side effects and risks and found that no one IRL has even heard of NFP (and those who said they did were describing the old rythmn method) and refused to even hear about it. so no, I don’t think you’re lying. You’re just not understanding that others have different experiences as you. I totally believe Jaaanosik didn’t know what she was agreeing to when she got married in the Church. It’s typical…
Well not to be argumentative, but I haven’t said anything about what anyone else knew or didn’t. Aside from people should know before marriage that sex=babies and the only moral means of avoiding pregnancy are periodic or permanent abstinence.
 
  1. So you are willing to take an IMMORAL risk and use artificial birth control and risk your immortal soul and that of your husband, but not take a MORAL risk and use NFP?
  2. If a couple is using artificial birth control with full knowledge of it’s sinfulness and full consent of the will, they have cut themself off from the Grace of God and are probably not renewing their sacramental wedding vows.
I didn’t mention anything about artificial birth control. The method of birth control a couple uses is between them and God. Where’s this coming from?
 
Well not to be argumentative, but I haven’t said anything about what anyone else knew or didn’t. Aside from people should know before marriage that sex=babies and the only moral means of avoiding pregnancy are periodic or permanent abstinence.
Well, in the post of yours that I replied to, was in response to this:
Originally Posted by Jaaanosik
The issue is that almost no priest is going to tell you that at the marriage preparation.
I would really like to find out how many can honestly claim they understood it that way before marriage.
To which you replied:
Originally Posted by Jea9
Do you think that all of us are lying??? Or are you looking only for an answer that you want? Because I believe 3 of us have said yes.
My point was, no I don’t think you’re lying. I think you and the other two did know and understand fully well what Jaaanosik didn’t understand fully well. But I think also that you don’t realize that there are many many like Jaaanosik, who don’t know what they’re getting into before they do it…She, like many, are not prepared for NFP because too many people are jazzing it up instead of being honest about it. So it’s no small wonder that she’s shocked by it all…yes, we can all do the math: sex = potential pregnancy, each and every time. However, not many count on the hardship of NFP. That’s not a secret…
 
Haha! I hear ya sister! 😃
I am confused by your posts. Have you abandoned NFP for an immoral contraception? That’s persona you don’t have to answer, but you’ve stated that you are willing to take a 1% risk so that you can have sex w/ your spouse. Why not then chart what you can, look for answers as to why NFP hasn’t worked and abandon the rest to God?
 
Well don’t get me wrong, we’d be as careful as humanely possible, that’s for sure.

But yes, I hold sex with my husband to a very high esteem. It’s a renewal of our wedding vows and it’s a physical, spiritual, emotional way of giving ourselves to each other entirely. Yes, to me that is worth the very small risk. 👍

I’m a newly wed (a little over a year) so it’s still a fascinating, wonderful thing to me.
And I hope that never changes for you :hug1:
 
the thought of a 1% chance of a potential complication that might cause illness and/or death isn’t as important as sharing the marital embrace with one’s spouse
That’s how I feel about it.
 
There are limits to when it is morally permissable to refuse the debt.

Good outlines on the Church teachings with regard to the marriage debt can be found at Vatican.va - we went through them in a recent thread, let me find it.
Cannot put my hands on my copy of Jone.

Here are a few other bits of reading…

1 Cor 7:3-6

The husband should fulfill his duty toward his wife, and likewise the wife toward her husband. A wife does not have authority over her own body, but rather her husband, and similarly a husband does not have authority over his own body, but rather his wife. Do not deprive each other, except perhaps by mutual consent for a time, to be free for prayer, but then return to one another, so that Satan may not tempt you through your lack of self-control.

ewtn.com/library/marriage/mormar.txt

ccel.org/ccel/aquinas/summa.XP_Q64.html

Casti Connubii, Dec. 31, 1930:
25. By this same love it is necessary that all the other rights and duties of the marriage state be regulated as the words of the Apostle: “Let the husband render the debt to the wife, and the wife also in like manner to the husband,”[28] express not only a law of justice but of charity.


vatican.va/holy_father/pi…nnubii_en.html

Can. 1134 From a valid marriage there arises between the spouses a bond which by its nature is perpetual and exclusive. Moreover, a special sacrament strengthens and, as it were, consecrates the spouses in a Christian marriage for the duties and dignity of their state.

Can. 1135 Each spouse has an equal duty and right to those things which belong to the partnership of conjugal life.
 
Lookouts,
Welcome to CAF! I hope you haven’t been run off from so many harsh answers. One thing to really remember right now is that contraception doesn’t take away the risk. It will give a false sense of security. As my wise father says, “Everyone has faith. Some people have faith in the highway system. They will continue driving with the faith that the road in front is complete.”

Your wife has been lied to by our current culture. This way of thinking is very new as a mainstream thought. The embrace of contraception was because of eugenics. It is a long a windy history, but if you are ever interested in more information, I am happy to share the resources. They would absolutely overwhelm this thread. Suffice to say that abstinence has always been considered normal until the 20th century. And before the 20th century, couples actually stayed married. Please don’t let your wife’s current panic shoot your marriage in the foot.

My husband and I have to abstain a LOT. It has very little to do with our fertility. Even though I have absolutely wonky fertility, my charts are very easy to interpret. I know my body. Believe me, my secular friends who have finally made the leap from condoms and charting, to NFP only, are very thankful. The fertility awareness method does work, but it really sucks for your marriage. Condoms don’t unite.

Our abstinence has everything to do with my bad health. The very reason we have been called to our small family, is the reason we are called to a lot abstinence. I was bed-bound again today. I live with chronic pain. To have relations with my husband takes all of the energy of running a marathon. As I typed that last sentence, my 7 year old walked up and asked why we missed indoor gym today. (Playing in the church gym each week is important in bad weather.) It isn’t because I can’t have another baby. It is because of my health.

In a nutshell: your wife is placing blame. Our culture tells her that she should be able to have sex without consequences. Even she doesn’t believe that. What she is really upset at is her health problems (and maybe yours as well, I don’t know). But having to abstain is an easy target for her anger. If you had say, broken your pelvis, like my dear friend’s husband did 3 months ago, she would not be saying, “well, now we can’t have SEX!” She would be worrying about how to help you recover. But after a few months, she might start to resent that she can’t have sex. But all the resentment in the world will not heal a broken pelvis.

She has health problems. From what you have said, her health problem has worry built right in. A condom will not calm her fears. It will just give her a false sense of calm. The question you have been asked is a legitimate one. Is she going to feel better when the man-made design fails? Will your marriage survive with her leaning on the created instead of the Creator?

NFP is just a name that has been given to this set of observing signs. Sex with a condom is empty sex. Literally, empty. Needing a barrier from your spouse doesn’t bring you closer. Our world’s staggering divorce rate has proven that. You will find all of these couples telling you, “We use condoms and we are happily married.” But those who have *really *been married for 50 years call bull on that. It has been shown across all religious beliefs, condoms do NOT contribute to a happy marriage. My secular friends who use NFP are the ones who have stayed married. My Catholic friends and family (and all other religions) who contracept are the ones crashing and burning.

Please look really carefully. The Church is old and wise. Believe HER. Don’t believe our very young culture. You wouldn’t take marital advice from a teenager. Our protestant brethren are only 500 years old. They embraced contraception, just like they have embraced every other form of divide among themselves.

Tell your wife that you love her too much to feed that fear. Remind her over and over that this won’t be FOREVER. I promise that it won’t. My parents, married 47 years, promise that it won’t. Your baby will get older. He or she WILL! It will get better. Don’t kill your marriage in the long term for what really amounts to a short term problem. Her fertility can be interpreted. I PROMISE. I have not failed at interpreting a chart yet. Even other people’s charts. If there is a chart anomaly, I have had it. Double patches, pre-shift spikes and post shift dips, even in one cycle. That one was funny.

God is so good! I can promise that if you are faithful to Him, He will deliver! As we have entered the years where we are called to abstain every fertile cycle, possibly until menopause, my cycles are easy as can be. Charting my fertility has helped me fix my health problems. Please seek out really great medical help in your local area. It is worth it!! Love your wife through this time of abstinence. It will bring you closer. If it doesn’t, then your marriage needs other intervention.

It has been said by those wiser than I, “Abstinence isn’t the problem, but it does clarify the problem.” (Paraphrased from quite a few wonderful popes.) I believe the Vicars of Jesus, not any random person on a Catholic bulletin board.
 
If one has a good reason to avoid a conception, the spouse shouldn’t be demanding the marital embrace. It’s that simple. There’s a woman going through that now on the family life forum: her life would be in danger with an additional pregnancy and her husband keeps demanding sex from her, and that’s wrong. He does not have the right to the marital embrace when her life is in danger. Likewise, a wife doesn’t have the right to demand sex of her over-burdened, stressed-out husband who is worrying day to day about supporting his family. Becoming married creates one-ness, not a transition to blow up doll…
 
Well, in the post of yours that I replied to, was in response to this:

To which you replied:

My point was, no I don’t think you’re lying. I think you and the other two did know and understand fully well what Jaaanosik didn’t understand fully well. But I think also that you don’t realize that there are many many like Jaaanosik, who don’t know what they’re getting into before they do it…She, like many, are not prepared for NFP because too many people are jazzing it up instead of being honest about it. So it’s no small wonder that she’s shocked by it all…yes, we can all do the math: sex = potential pregnancy, each and every time. However, not many count on the hardship of NFP. That’s not a secret…
Sorry I am responding on my phone and so formatting is difficult. My response was regarding that poster’s use of bold the word “honestly”. As though those of us that have responded were not responding honestly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top