Mel Gibson a Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DL82
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Wikipedia? WIKIPEDIA?

Thing is, if Mel was baptized a Catholic, which appears to be the case according to Biography.com
Mel Gibson Biography (1956-)
Actor, director, producer. Born on January 3, 1956, in Peekskill, New York. Gibson was the sixth of 11 children born to Hutton and Ann Gibson, who were Roman Catholics of Irish descent. Shortly after the onset of the Vietnam War, Hutton Gibson relocated his family to Australia for fear that his sons would be drafted into battle. Mel spent the remainder of his childhood in Sydney, where he attended an all-boys Catholic high school.
then he is still a Catholic. . . whether he has ‘affliliated’ with a group in non communion or not. . .
 
Would you care to post any documentation regarding your comment that “…several of the cast were porn stars?”?
I can but it would not be appropriate to post such here.
I will give an example though and you can do the search yourself. MONICA BELLUCCI played Mary Magdalene. She starred in a movied called ‘Irreversible’. It was so hard core that folks walked out of the cannes fim festival upon viewing it.
 
Wikipedia? WIKIPEDIA?

Thing is, if Mel was baptized a Catholic, which appears to be the case according to Biography.com

then he is still a Catholic. . . whether he has ‘affliliated’ with a group in non communion or not. . .
The man started his own church you do the math.
 
Mel Gibson is a hypocrite. He claims to be such a good Catholic; but did you ever see some of the movies he has acted in? The hypocrisy. I can not forgive him for Lethal Weapon 2. Also, he is an anglophobe and an anti-Semite (remember the drunken outburst?). Furthermore, “The Passion of the Christ” promotes sado-masochism. This is just my opinion, and you are free to disagree. [Edited by Moderator]
 
Mel Gibson is a hypocrite. He claims to be such a good Catholic; but did you ever see some of the movies he has acted in? The hypocrisy. I can not forgive him for Lethal Weapon 2. Also, he is an anglophobe and an anti-Semite (remember the drunken outburst?). Furthermore, “The Passion of the Christ” promotes sado-masochism. This is just my opinion, and you are free to disagree. [Edited by Moderator]
The thing about Mel is he claims Catholicism then does the opposite in his work and life.
 
The man started his own church you do the math.
Excuse me. With respect, this is not ‘The Church of Mel Gibson’ and his followers the Gibsonites.

In so far as Church law is concerned, Mr. Gibson is a baptized Catholic and a Catholic he remains. Whether he is a Catholic who is practicing his Catholicism in communion with Rome may be doubtful; whether he is a ‘good’ person or a “good” Catholic is between him and God. . .

Actually there are as many canon lawyers out there who say that even a formal oral or written abjuration of the faith is still not enough to make the person ‘not Catholic’ as there are those who say that a person ‘could’ formally renounce his faith. And I have found remarkably little evidence of any given person actually ‘saying’ or ‘performing’ a ‘formal abjuraton’. I believe that those not in full communion with Rome who consider themselves traditionalists are schismatic, which means Mr. Gibson may be a Catholic in schism. . .but he is still Catholic.
 
Does the sacrament of Penance remove the sin of adultery? Do you know for fact that Mel never found contrition for his sins?

There is not one of us that has not committed a mortal sin in our lifetimes. This is why we have a Savior.
The thing is, since his sin was public, and it was as we are talking about his movies which all can see, then he has to publicly apologise for those sins. Also have you or has anyone heard him recant his opinion about him denying the validity of the Novus Ordo Mass?
 
Excuse me. With respect, this is not ‘The Church of Mel Gibson’ and his followers the Gibsonites.

In so far as Church law is concerned, Mr. Gibson is a baptized Catholic and a Catholic he remains. Whether he is a Catholic who is practicing his Catholicism in communion with Rome may be doubtful; whether he is a ‘good’ person or a “good” Catholic is between him and God. . .

Actually there are as many canon lawyers out there who say that even a formal oral or written abjuration of the faith is still not enough to make the person ‘not Catholic’ as there are those who say that a person ‘could’ formally renounce his faith. And I have found remarkably little evidence of any given person actually ‘saying’ or ‘performing’ a ‘formal abjuraton’. I believe that those not in full communion with Rome who consider themselves traditionalists are schismatic, which means Mr. Gibson may be a Catholic in schism. . .but he is still Catholic.
Personally I don’t care what he is one way or the other.
 
Excuse me. With respect, this is not ‘The Church of Mel Gibson’ and his followers the Gibsonites.

In so far as Church law is concerned, Mr. Gibson is a baptized Catholic and a Catholic he remains. Whether he is a Catholic who is practicing his Catholicism in communion with Rome may be doubtful; whether he is a ‘good’ person or a “good” Catholic is between him and God. . .

Actually there are as many canon lawyers out there who say that even a formal oral or written abjuration of the faith is still not enough to make the person ‘not Catholic’ as there are those who say that a person ‘could’ formally renounce his faith. And I have found remarkably little evidence of any given person actually ‘saying’ or ‘performing’ a ‘formal abjuraton’. I believe that those not in full communion with Rome who consider themselves traditionalists are schismatic, which means Mr. Gibson may be a Catholic in schism. . .but he is still Catholic.
Personally I don’t care what he is one way or the other.
 
Pope John Paul 2 received Mel as one of his flock prior to the release of “The Passion.” Were he a schismatic, and a celebrity figure worldwide, the personal encounter with His Holiness would never had taken place.

Mel Gibson is as Catholic as you or I, no doubt about it.
The Holy Father meets with far worse people than Mel but that doesn’t change who they are. E.g. Bill Clinton (at least 3 or 4 times)
 
You may disagree if you wish your choice. I have heard him talk way to many times. I have heard him talk about his faith as well. He still did it for the money and has more or less said that in interviews since. As far as the movie goes the King of Kings did more for me than the passion ever could. Contrary to your experiences most folks I know didn’t much care for it either. Folks get more into glorifiying mel here and his movie then Christ IMHO. btw did you know several of the cast were porn stars ? didn’t think so.
Mel has appeared on the Catholic TV network EWTN a number of times. He had a sort of fireside chat with Raymond Arooyo for the full length of the one-hour show…more than one occasion.

The conversations were principally about the Faith and never was Mel in contradiction with the Faith. He is a devout Catholic who has found his spiritual connect with the Church.

Mel Gibson is the consumate family man and has always fought for the unborn in one way or another.

As for the LA Diocese headed by Archbishop Mahoney well, that’s is for YOUR spiritual instincts to discern whether or not the Archbishop is a true shepard.

We are warned by Our Lord in the end times there will be false prophets…sooner or later some will recognize a “false shepard” when he shows himself.

The Holy Spirit infuses us with the wisdom to see. All we have to do is just ask for the Light.
 
The thing is, since his sin was public, and it was as we are talking about his movies which all can see, then he has to publicly apologise for those sins. Also have you or has anyone heard him recant his opinion about him denying the validity of the Novus Ordo Mass?
I’ll agree with one aspect of your “public apology” requirement. The only “public apology” to my mind is the sin of ABORTION as a public endorser of that heinous sin. There must also be “public restitution” for such a great sin.

The only apology for Mel’s sins belong in the confessional and no place else.

As for the Novus Ordo, I yearn for the day when the Mass is returned to us in the form of Traditional Mass. God was glorified in the Mass prior to the Novus Ordo in such a way that the spirit was moved in a most mysterious way.

I attend my local Novus Ordo parish but that does not mean it is as gratifying spiritually as the Traditional Mass. I hold on with great hope that the Church will drift back to the fullness of the former when Catholic songs were the only songs. Songs to Our Lady are a rarity and only on her feast day might we hear a song in tribute to her. I miss that too.

Jesus also warns there will be a “falling away” and laments on His return will He “find any faith left?”

Mel Gibson measures up quite well for his catholicity. He was unmercifully persecuted for bringing Our Lord’s passion in that graphic film.

The majority of the film’s depictions are from our Blessed Ann Catherine Emerich’s visions…and I am OK with that too.
 
The Holy Father meets with far worse people than Mel but that doesn’t change who they are. E.g. Bill Clinton (at least 3 or 4 times)
True, the Holy Father met with the Clintons and other heads of State…but these are all diplomatic sessions since the Vatican is is City/State entity. The pope meets with Red China. Korea et al and his primary concern in those meetings is to appeal for the freedom of his flock in those atheistic countries.

Mel Gibson’s one-on-one with the Successor to Peter was for matters of faith and as a shepard to one of his flock.

Two entirely separate incidences. So separate they are worlds apart.
 
I can but it would not be appropriate to post such here.
I will give an example though and you can do the search yourself. MONICA BELLUCCI played Mary Magdalene. She starred in a movied called ‘Irreversible’. It was so hard core that folks walked out of the cannes fim festival upon viewing it.
I can recall the occasion of the woman caught in adultery and the woman (Mary Magdelein) whose sins of impurity were so vast she shed her repentant tears on the Savior’s feet; then dried his feet with her hair.

Strangely, MONICA BELLUCCI played Magdalein. From what I read in subsequent stories following the Passion, Miss Belucci has rediscovered her faith and is a new mother.

Christ often uses people who live dissolute lives to be his messengers. St. Augustine is a prime example of a complete turnaround.

There was a story (can’t remember his name, sorry) of a Jewish abortion doctor who found Christ, converted and now travels everywhere denouncing abortion and works for pro-life causes with all his energy. I think his first name was “Nathan?”

God often chooses the most UNLIKELY people to make Himself known to the world.
 
Mel has appeared on the Catholic TV network EWTN a number of times. He had a sort of fireside chat with Raymond Arooyo for the full length of the one-hour show…more than one occasion.

The conversations were principally about the Faith and never was Mel in contradiction with the Faith. He is a devout Catholic who has found his spiritual connect with the Church.

Mel Gibson is the consumate family man and has always fought for the unborn in one way or another.

As for the LA Diocese headed by Archbishop Mahoney well, that’s is for YOUR spiritual instincts to discern whether or not the Archbishop is a true shepard.

We are warned by Our Lord in the end times there will be false prophets…sooner or later some will recognize a “false shepard” when he shows himself.

The Holy Spirit infuses us with the wisdom to see. All we have to do is just ask for the Light.
You contradict yourself in one breath saying how great Mel is because he appeared on a Catholic program and I guess that means we should support him but in the same breath you have nothing kind to say about the Archbishop. To me that is a problem because though you might have some legit complaints about the Archbishop he still has the authority and at the same time you ignore a lot of issues in regards to Mel which are quite questionable to say the least. I never stated once Mel isn’t Catholic but he is not a good example of any Catholic I wish to emulate.

Personally I think way to many glorify Mel and most simply because of a movie he made. If you wish to see him in a good light go for it but he is not in communion with Rome. He makes no secret of it though apparently many here don’t realize that for whatever reasons.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top